New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

bevel up plane/retailer question

Posts

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#101

Re: Burnishing

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I gave the burnishing idea some thought this weekend. Here is why I think it is wrong. When one planes with a sharp iron at 42-45 degrees the surface has clarity and sheen and feels silky. As the iron dulls over time, all three of these qualities slowly decline. If low clearance was causing burnishing at these angles, one would expect more burnishing as the iron dulled. But instead the silkiness and the clarity are lost.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#102

Re: it's easy

Larry Williams

Wilbur,

Take two pieces of cherry and plane the edge of one with a sharp 30� iron. Take a shaving of maybe five or six thousandths. Plane the second with an iron of about 35� taking about the same shaving. Hold them up to the light together and the second will be reflective. The second one will reflect light and will be burnished.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#103

Re: Burnishing

Larry Williams

Tom,

To get an idea of how much the wood is deflected, take a full length fine shaving on the edge of a board and compare the shaving length to the length of the board. Because the wood was cut when compressed and it doesn't have other wood fibers backing it up, the wood in the shaving doesn't spring back all the way. Your shaving will be quite a bit shorter than the board it came from. If it's a real fine shaving, it'll be wider than the board it came from because the severed fibers tend to expand but it'll still be shorter than the board. Now picture the wood fibers below the level at which they were severed springing back to their original location which will be higher than where the cut happened.

Wood is a porous material. When cleanly cut, it doesn't reflect light.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#104

Re: Burnishing

David Weaver

Warren - I agree with this. I completely forgot about this discussion, but i see it went on.

I don't see how a duller edge creates less burnishing unless there is a claim that the wear on the bevel above the relief is scratching the wood, and I don't see that as realistic.

I have a higher relief angle on my japanese planes than on a bench plane, but it is still a cleaner finish that larry is calling "burnished".

But to the point of the original comment, I go for as much shine as I can get on a planed board - at least on the outside surfaces. If it's in a joint, then nobody does that - why would you? I'm not quite sure how such a discussion is even relevant in the joints other than edge jointed boards, and I've never had them fail...on anything.

I've also never had any issue with finish adherence on anything.

I've not ever made a piece of furniture that didn't at least get wax on it.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#105

Re: Burnishing

Bob Hackett

I was wondering this myself.If burnishing is such a problem with penetration of adhesives then how are the machined wood crowd managing to get by?

Bill Tindal convinced me that an absolutely clean cut which leaves open pores is not what most folks are looking for when they are evaluating potential purchases.Laying a finish on the type of surface Larry seems to favor would scare many buyers off.

Most pro wood finishers recommend filling open pored woods to both speed the finishing process get more uniform looking surface.

If you`re going to use dyes or stains to blend differences between boards or color the finished piece an overly open extremely clean cut surface may be detrimental.

Most WWers I know want a bit of shine to the wood surface prior to finishing.The type of surface Larry is speaking of would have most of the folks I know looking to "improve" it by some means.Burnishing would be one of the ways to do this.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#106

amazing

Larry Williams

"There are no clearance issues--well, viscoelasticity isn't involved--viscoelasticity in wood and metal aren't related--there's no burnishing from lack of clearance--hey, burnishing is a good thing..."

While you're magnifying cutting edges to the nth degree, do you ever think about the properties of the material those tools are supposedly intended to work? Maybe even looking into the bonding properties of finishes and adhesives?

What, pray tell, do you see in these cleanly cut surfaces of red maple that would be reflective?

USFPL photo

Oh, and where did this come from? "I don't see how a duller edge creates less burnishing unless there is a claim that the wear on the bevel above the relief is scratching the wood, and I don't see that as realistic." Have you been taking creative writing classes with Derek?

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#107

Burnishing

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Larry, you were the one who suggested that planing at less than 45 degrees produced burnishing, not David.

My guess is that the magnified sample you picture was not cut at 50 or 55 degrees. When I was in college I had to prepare many wood sections for microscopic analysis, including quite a few Acer rubrum. We used a cutting angle of 41 degrees and got a nice crisp and clean surface as long as the iron was sharp.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#108

Re: amazing

David Weaver

Maybe I misunderstood something from your prior post about burnishing. However, two things

1) I generally don't have endgrain board faces and I can see those cleanly cut tubes on the ends of a board, even if the spots between the tubes are waxy clean looking

2) I have never had a glue joint fail, nor have i had finish release. I've only been woodworking for five years, so I've got time for both of those.

Hasn't there been some literature debunking the myth that a surface can be too smooth to glue? I've just never seen shellac come off of anything, and that is always my base unless I go oil and wax only (which I am also not particularly troubled by).

I would like to see *more* shine so that my finish on ribboned cherry would be even more uniform.

These are just my thoughts. I don't make a blog or sell anything, so I can't get bound up in creating a cited document. The right answer counts to me, at least right in terms of "what do i like and does it matter?". The court history version just isn't something i have any interest in creating.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#109

Re: Burnishing

Larry Williams

"Larry, you were the one who suggested that planing at less than 45 degrees produced burnishing, not David. "

No Warren, I said inadequate clearance leads to burnishing. There's a difference, you know. Anything that increases deflection, like a dull iron, increases the needed clearance.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#110

Maybe I haven`t been doing this correctly

Bob Hackett

I thought I should just sharpen the iron when it dulls,now come to find I should actually be increasing the clearance angle to avoid burnishing when it becomes dull.

How could I have been so wrong for so long?

I`m thinking about rounding up and burning all the things I`ve made now that I understand that the glue and finish I used are headed toward failure.Some of these things are decades old but you never can be too careful.Any second now they could collapse or the finish could explode and send wood shrapnel flying around the room.I don`t think my insurance will cover that sort of thing.

Best to just burn it all and start again after I grind higher relief angles on everything.Shine time`s over,time to banish the burnish demons!

Someone needs to tweet those Japanese temple guys and break the bad news to them.I feel less bad knowing that I had only been wrong for decades while those folks have been doing it wrong for generations.Then again,maybe wood is less elastic in Japan.Maybe they`re using inscrutable wood,that would explain the lack of hardware holding those temples together.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#111

David Barnett

Bob, Bob, Bob...

David Barnett

"Shine time`s over, time to banish the burnish demons!"

... we don't want to suffocate the wood, do we? It has to b r e a t h e, you know. And not just air, mind you, but having been a once-living, growing organic material, it needs to pass orgone, as well. And prana!

To think I used to actually burnish the wood on purpose! And then even add finish! Impede its respiration and energy flow, and it will surely warp, or worse. Ignorant philistines who lack the depth and sensitivity to truly appreciate wood's porosity, ...

Oh wait! Quick! Get the acupuncture needles! Turn up the O2! This maple's gonna code!

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#112

Next thing you know...

Bob Hackett

You`ll be telling me I have to align the horn of my anvil to TRUE north rather than magnetic north and that I`m sacrificing the wrong kind of free range chickens before I begin a new project.

It`s enough that I have to stand hip deep in snow wearing only a loincloth during the new moon because I refuse to shovel a path to that stone altar in the woods.

I mean,a man has to draw the line somewhere!

Wait a minute,tonight`s the new moon isn`t it?

Gotta go,I got free range chickens I gotta catch!