New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

bevel up plane/retailer question

Posts

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#26

Sounds like an excellent application...

Bob Hackett

For use of "high tech" more wear resistant steels.

When I say more wear resistant I`m talking about steels that are more wear resistant than O1 or W1.Something more along the lines of a HSS or CPM.

These types of irons are readily available for the BU planes as well as the BD ones.

I would think that you could also extend the life of a BU iron between grindings by doing the "ruler trick".Which is pretty much accepted to be viable when using micro bevels on BD irons.Something more than one of the the big names recommends to increase the angle on a BD plane in an effort to tame difficult grain.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#27

Re: The Jury - rejoinder

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

So the jury is still out, eh? Five years in deliberation?

Hi Warren

The reason the jury is still out is that there is no verdict to say BU are flawed by the presence of a wear bevel. As I noted before, there are thousands and thousands of happy users of these planes. If this was a flaw in a motor car component, the manufacturer would have recalled all production. I certainly do not anticipate this happening here.

That there is a wear bevel is one thing. That it interfers with the process of planing is another. And, if it does, the point at which it begins to do so is yet a further important factor. For those that become concerned (notice that I did not use a words like paranoid :)) about the bad wear bevel, then the addition of David Charlesworth's "Ruler Trick" is recommended. I sometimes do so and mostly not, and cannot say that I have seen much difference in the two set ups.

Larry (in his reply here) posted a link to Konrad Sauer's blog and pictures of his block plane blade as "evidence" that his hobby horse rides. I posted a link to Konrad's blog entry on the Australian forum. The reaction there was laughter - not at Konrad, who is held in high esteem, but at the belief that this is a typical experience to planing wood with a bevel up blade. Keep in mind that we (in Australia) have some of the world's most savage wood - pretty, but interlocked, hard and abrasive - and BU planes are given a real going over ... and there is none the hysteria here that I read over the Pond.

Anyway I decided some while ago to complete some research on this area. It is slowly gathering momentum. It involves looking at the wear on BU blades at different bedding angles, along with differing angles of attack. So far I have BU planes with beds of 12 and 25 degrees. Perhaps when this is done the Jury will come in.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#28

Science? 

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

When wood is cut, it deflects ahead of the cutting edge to the point where it can easily be severed by that cutting edge. If I set up a 12� bevel-up plane to have a 55� angle of attack I'd need a 43� bevel. What you're saying is that a 43� knife edge is easier to push into wood than a 30� knife edge? Do the laws of physics change South of the Equator?

BTW, the steeper the angle of attack the more the wood deflects ahead of the cutting edge. The same goes for the angle of the bevel, the more obtuse the cutting edge the greater the deflection. The greater the deflection, the greater the needed clearance angle. This isn't opinion, Derek, it's physics--real science.

I know from experience that I loose clearance if I hone a 55� bevel down plane at 35�. It's very obvious in the performance of the plane. 15� of clearance isn't enough for a 55� cutting angle.

Hi Larry

There are certain points that you overlook that nullify your argument.

Firstly, an important difference between BU and BD planes is the way the blade is bedded. On BU planes the blade is supported by a bed that runs within a millimeter of the back of the cutting edge. On a BD plane the support it is not possible to get this close, and the best it can go is 3 or 4 times the distance.

Of course this also depends on factors such as the thickness of the blade and its projection for depth of cut. In my experience, smoothers tend to take moderate-fine to fine shavings. None of these conditions is likely to tax a BU plane, nor modern, thick-bladed BD planes.

Secondly, are you discussing BU planes generally or BU set up for a high cutting angle? I think that you are confusing the two. But for this discussion I assume that you are referring to the latter. So ... a BU smoother with a 55 degree cutting angle has a 43 degree knife edge. The question is what are the forces on this at 12 degrees ...... versus the 25 or 30 degrees of the bevel on the blade of a BD plane with a bed of 55 degrees? Now I am not a structural engineer, and neither are you, so we should pass this one over to someone suitably qualified. Someone out there?

Oh, and Leonard Lee would dispute your conclusion about 15 degrees being necessary for the clearance angle. As you know he wrote that this was about 7 degrees ("The Complete Guide to Sharpening"). Are you saying that the wear bevel on a BU plane approaches 5 degrees? Yikes! :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#29

Re: Science? 

joel moskowitz

"Firstly, an important difference between BU and BD planes is the way the blade is bedded. On BU planes the blade is supported by a bed that runs within a millimeter of the back of the cutting edge. On a BD plane the support it is not possible to get this close, and the best it can go is 3 or 4 times the distance. "

This isn't correct. On a bevel up plane the blade is supported only a few millimeters away but at that point the blade section is very small. On a BD plane the support is much further way but the iron is thicker and the bending moment on the blade puts force directly into the blade and keeps it solid. In both designs proper contact between blade and bed is very important.

While you can attribute the lack of adoption of BU planes in wooden style to the weakness of the bed, in the metal world once BD infill planes were invented large mitre planes nearly vanished from production. MY conclusion is that for serious traditional work BD was favored. There is also a vast range of performance in mitre planes.

Modern BU planes are far superior in construction and the heavier irons, with much less flexible blades (A2, D2 & etc) bend less in use and help improve performance. But Larry's math is correct. Interestedly the wood defection in normal hardwoods is far more than tropical woods and material like ebony and ivory. After BD infill planes were invented mitre planes became smaller and were almost exclusively marketed (although obviously others bought them) to piano makers and instrument makers who were planing ebony and ivory and rosewood. In your neck of the wood I bet some of those super hard Austrailian woods plane really well with a BU plane.

ps - I collect mitre planes, I have used most of the BU models on the market, they all feel like I'm dragging a cart through mud. To me a high angle BD plane definiely is harder to push than a 45 degree one is - but both feel less draggy than a BU plane. I won't argue that people don't like them - people do -- but I think it's more a factor of really top quality manufacture than an inherently better design.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#30

Re: Let me get this straight

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

While I really like my LN LA Jack, I have noticed that it stops cutting well much sooner than my other planes, most of them wooden and bevel down. I thought that maybe it had an A2 blade, but nothing in the LN description says one way or the other. I also thought maybe it was the scary sharp method that I typically use for the few (as in 2) western metal planes I have, perhaps it was being dubbed? But maybe it's the wear on the back. Very interesting.

Thanks,

Pam

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#31

Re: Science? 

Larry Williams

"Firstly, an important difference between BU and BD planes is the way the blade is bedded. On BU planes the blade is supported by a bed that runs within a millimeter of the back of the cutting edge. On a BD plane the support it is not possible to get this close, and the best it can go is 3 or 4 times the distance..."

The cutting edge of a bevel-down plane is backed up by hardened steel of the rest of the iron. That of a bevel-up plane is backed up by a little bit of air, springing back wood fibers and cast iron which has more give than steel. The force on the cutting edge is directly opposite the direction of the plane's movement. The edge of a plane iron is essentially a triangular section of steel with the force applied to just one corner. In a bevel-down plane that force puts that corner in compression and in a bevel-up in tension. Ask any engineer or physicist which is stronger. I'll guarantee compression wins every time.

"Secondly, are you discussing BU planes generally or BU set up for a high cutting angle? I think that you are confusing the two. But for this discussion I assume that you are referring to the latter. So ... a BU smoother with a 55 degree cutting angle has a 43 degree knife edge. The question is what are the forces on this at 12 degrees ...... versus the 25 or 30 degrees of the bevel on the blade of a BD plane with a bed of 55 degrees? Now I am not a structural engineer, and neither are you, so we should pass this one over to someone suitably qualified. Someone out there?"

Well Derek, I've discussed this very thing with my brother who went to MIT to get his PhD in physics after graduating first in his class from Colorado School of Mines. You may not have heard of Mines but I'm sure there are a lot of people here who have. My brother assured me my thinking was correct on this and offered to work out the equations to prove it. I turned down the offer, I just wanted to know if I was on the right track. I'm sure he has better things to do than help me play tag on woodworking forums.

"...Oh, and Leonard Lee would dispute your conclusion about 15 degrees being necessary for the clearance angle. As you know he wrote that this was about 7 degrees ("The Complete Guide to Sharpening"). Are you saying that the wear bevel on a BU plane approaches 5 degrees? Yikes!"

I have Lee's book in front of me. I've asked you at least three times for a direct quote that says what you're saying. I've yet to get a response. Don't just post a link to an excerpt, give me the quote.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#32

Re: Science? 

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

On a bevel up plane the blade is supported only a few millimeters away but at that point the blade section is very small. On a BD plane the support is much further way but the iron is thicker and the bending moment on the blade puts force directly into the blade and keeps it solid. In both designs proper contact between blade and bed is very important.

Hi Joel

I have just measured the unsupported length of blade on a LV BU Smoother and LN #4 1/2 (with a 50 degree frog), both for equivalent smoothing cuts. The BUS measured 4mm. The #4 1/2 measured 8.5mm. In other words, the BD plane had a little over twice the unsupported blade than the BU plane. Both blades are 3/16" thick, both made from A2. And I should also mention that the #4 1/2's blade was bevelled at about 28-29 degrees. The unsupported length would increase if the bevel was 25 degrees. Does any of this really matter on planes such as these? I very much doubt it - we are playing with numbers here.

While you can attribute the lack of adoption of BU planes in wooden style to the weakness of the bed, in the metal world once BD infill planes were invented large mitre planes nearly vanished from production. MY conclusion is that for serious traditional work BD was favored. There is also a vast range of performance in mitre planes.

Modern BU planes are far superior in construction and the heavier irons, with much less flexible blades (A2, D2 & etc) bend less in use and help improve performance.

The early BU planes were made in grey cast iron, which is fragile compared to modern ductile iron. The Stanley #62 and #164 had a reputation for the mouth chipping easily. My own Stanley #62 has a lost bedding at the rear of the mouth. (This does not appear to have affected its performance much, using a thicker LN blade). It was not until LN, then LV, began marketing these planes in ductile iron, and with thick blades, that they were rediscovered. I cannot see how you can conclude that BD planes were favoured over BU planes for serious traditional work because of their absence on the market. Surely their absence was because their constructional demands placed them at a disadvantage?

Let me make this clear: I am not trying to make a case for BU planes over BD planes. I am simply trying to point out that meaningful conclusions need to be based on objective information, rather than subjective impressions .... which leads us to the next point ...

But Larry's math is correct.

Not actually Larry's math, but that of his brother. Have you done the math as well?

It is not that simple (says I the Non-mathematician. My 6 years of Research Maths Stats at university do not count here :)). It all depends on what you are examining, that is, what conditions you are including in your calculations.

I have passed this on to a friend of mine, Bob, who is both a woodworker and the Head of Department of Applied Physics at one of our local universities. I involved him in a similar project once before, this being when I needed to calculate the amount of steel to be removed when camber blades with different primary bevel thicknesses (interestingly, aslo a project inspired by Larry arguing that a BU plane could not be used in the same way as a typical BD jack. Link: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/WoodworkTechniques/TheSecretToCamberinBUPlaneBlades.html)

The question I posed Bob was this:

The issue is BU versus BD planes and the forces required to push them. Which plane causes the user to experience most/least resistance when pusing one?

The situation:

"a BU smoother with a 55 degree cutting angle has a 43 degree knife edge. The question is what are the forces on this at 12 degrees ...... versus the 25 or 30 degrees of the bevel on the blade of a BD plane with a bed of 55 degrees? "

I think that I will also ask him to calculate vectors for (1) holding tote angle constant, and (2) the differences when using Stanley/LN angles on the BD and LV tote angles on the BU.

I shall pass on these results when they are available.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#33

Re: Science? 

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I have Lee's book in front of me. I've asked you at least three times for a direct quote that says what you're saying. I've yet to get a response. Don't just post a link to an excerpt, give me the quote.

Hi Larry

It is a simple matter to read the text from the on-line link I have supplied to you on all these occasions: http://books.google.com.au/books?id=CtkWaJw5iXkC&pg=PA16&lpg=PA16&dq=leonard+lee+clearance+angle&source=bl&ots=TzrKNKIaSA&sig=sTEek-H9jRE7gtAIppQyshOJ32g&hl=en&ei=TJdgTfCAEsvXccHUmPQJ&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=1&ved=0CBUQ6AEwAA#v=onepage&q&f=false

To help, here are a few quotes:

"I am not going to enter the fray by making a flat declaration that any particular angle is best because there are too many other variables at play". (page 15)

"In many woods this lowered bevel angle (LL is referring to a blade with a 20 degree bevel) and reduced springback leaves more than enough clearance at 12 degrees". (page 16).

How do we get the the 7 degrees I mentioned? This is easy to extrapolate ..

On page 17 LL described adding a 5 degree backbevel to aid edge strength when using a low 20 degree bevel.

"You will find that you can easily live with this reduced clearance angle on woods that have little springback (any dense, finegrained hardwood). But on these woods you may have to beef up the basic bevel a bit to retain your edge ... With a good blade on softwoods with a light cut you will probably find that you can sneak a few more degrees off the primary bevel onto the back bevel, keeping the total included angle at the edge the same but further lowering your cutting angle". (pp 16-17)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#34

Re: Science? 

joel moskowitz

"I have just measured the unsupported length of blade on a LV BU Smoother and LN #4 1/2 (with a 50 degree frog), both for equivalent smoothing cuts. The BUS measured 4mm. The #4 1/2 measured 8.5mm. In other words, the BD plane had a little over twice the unsupported blade than the BU plane. Both blades are 3/16" thick, both made from A2. And I should also mention that the #4 1/2's blade was bevelled at about 28-29 degrees. The unsupported length would increase if the bevel was 25 degrees. Does any of this really matter on planes such as these? I very much doubt it - we are playing with numbers here."

Look at the force vectors and the forces where the metal bends. It's a straight mechanical engineering problem. This is why really good mitre planes have tiny mouths both in front and behind the cutting edge.

"The early BU planes were made in grey cast iron, which is fragile compared to modern ductile iron. The Stanley #62 and #164 had a reputation for the mouth chipping easily. My own Stanley #62 has a lost bedding at the rear of the mouth. "

Early Mitre planes were made with steel soles. the STanley 62 and 164 are junk by comparison. Really not worthy of consideration. And certainly not in production by the time the Infill had converted to BD smoothers.

"(This does not appear to have affected its performance much, using a thicker LN blade). It was not until LN, then LV, began marketing these planes in ductile iron, and with thick blades, that they were rediscovered. I cannot see how you can conclude that BD planes were favoured over BU planes for serious traditional work because of their absence on the market. "

Because they were. Large English mitre planes are pretty common from before the 1850 period. They were used for smoothing tough boards and many survive with handles cobbled onto them. However once (starting in the 1830's with Panel planes and moving to smoothers by the late 1840's) infill smoothers appeared large mitre planes basically vanish from the market and small ones appear for specialist work only. Stanley doesn't enter into it until way to late in the market.

"Surely their absence was because their constructional demands placed them at a disadvantage?"

None of the modern BU planes I have used work nearly as well as the better condition Mitre planes I have (other then their ergonomics are far better). You can support the blade better with steel than with cast iron.

"Let me make this clear: I am not trying to make a case for BU planes over BD planes. I am simply trying to point out that meaningful conclusions need to be based on objective information, rather than subjective impressions .... which leads us to the next point ..."

"But Larry's math is correct.

Not actually Larry's math, but that of his brother. Have you done the math as well?"

Yip - (My degree is in mechanical engineering - but this calculation for force vectors is grade one physics.) I also have the means and have done plenty of comparisons.

"It is not that simple (says I the Non-mathematician. My 6 years of Research Maths Stats at university do not count here :)). It all depends on what you are examining, that is, what conditions you are including in your calculations."

It is that simple.

"I have passed this on to a friend of mine, Bob, who is both a woodworker and the Head of Department of Applied Physics at one of our local universities. I involved him in a similar project once before, this being when I needed to calculate the amount of steel to be removed when camber blades with different primary bevel thicknesses (interestingly, aslo a project inspired by Larry arguing that a BU plane could not be used in the same way as a typical BD jack. Link: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/WoodworkTechniques/TheSecretToCamberinBUPlaneBlades.html)

The question I posed Bob was this:

The issue is BU versus BD planes and the forces required to push them. Which plane causes the user to experience most/least resistance when pusing one?"

That's not the question I am answering. My question is for a given iron which plane has better blade support and less blade chatter for a given depth of cut.

Larry's point - which is correct but far harder to calculate takes into account clearance angles on the wood and wood deflection. He's right here - no question about it (empirical evidence confirms that) but as I said with harder more brittle woods, with less deflection, a BU plane will work better.

Interestingly enough I accidentally did an experiment many years ago before I understood how important clearance angles were. Almost all mitre planes are bedded at 20 degrees. I thought wouldn't a lower angle mitre plane work even better on eng grain. We built two chariot planes to test this. One at 20 degrees another I think at 15 or 18 ( don't remember). The lower angle plane worked far worst. It was the clearance angles that killed it.

"The situation:

"a BU smoother with a 55 degree cutting angle has a 43 degree knife edge. The question is what are the forces on this at 12 degrees ...... versus the 25 or 30 degrees of the bevel on the blade of a BD plane with a bed of 55 degrees? "

I think that I will also ask him to calculate vectors for (1) holding tote angle constant, and (2) the differences when using Stanley/LN angles on the BD and LV tote angles on the BU.

I shall pass on these results when they are available.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#35

Re: Let me get this straight

Larry Williams

Pam,

Following is an excerpt from Machinery's Handbook about clearance angles in metal working for some metals with single edge tools. In metal working they're called relief angles and I assure you that metals deflect less than wood and tend to stay deformed rather than spring back so much. I've posted it several times in response to Derek's claim that 7� is adequate clearance for planes. He's yet to address this but every machinist lives with these issues every day.

"Relief Angles. --The end relief angle and the side relief angle on single-point cutting tools are usually, though not invariably, made equal to each other. The relief angle under the nose of the tool is a blend of the side and end relief angles.

The size of the relief angles has a pronounced effect on the performance of the cutting tool If the relief angles are too large, the cutting edge will be weakened and in danger of breaking when a heavy cutting load is placed on it by a hard and tough material. On finish cuts, rapid wear of the cutting edge may cause problems with size control on the part. Relief angles that are too small will cause the rate of wear on the flank of the tool below the cutting edge to increase, thereby significantly reducing the tool life. In general, when cutting hard tough materials, the relief angles should be 6 to 8 degrees for high-speed steel tools and 5 to 7 degrees for carbide tools. For medium steels, mild steels, cast iron and other average work the recommended values of the relief angles are 8 to 12 degrees for high-speed steel tools and 5 to 10 degrees for carbides. Ductile materials having a relatively low modulus of elasticity should be cut using larger relief angles. For example, the relief angles recommended for turning copper, brass, bronze, aluminum ferritic malleable iron and similar metals are 12 to 16 degrees for high-speed tools and 8 to 14 degrees for carbides.

Larger relief angles generally tend to produce a better finish on the finish machined surface because less surface of the worn flank of the tool rubs against the work piece. For this reason, single-point thread-cutting tools should be provided with relief angles that are as large as the circumstances will permit. Problems when machining stainless steel may be overcome by increasing the size of the relief angle. The relief angles used should never be smaller than necessary."


Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#36

Re: Science? 

wilbur

This is a fascinating discussion. I do wish that quotes were better delineated on this forum, though. ;)

Regardless of the physics involved in bevel-up/bevel down planes, I don't think anyone disputes the fact that both BD and BU plane blades develop a wear bevel in use. Not that this is what I do, but I remember being told when I first started woodworking that to set up a plane blade, you first work the back of the blade through the last step of your sharpening method of choice. Then you never touch the back again. If you have a bevel up plane, you obviously would have to touch the back of the blade to get rid of the wear bevel. And it seems to me that dealing with the wear bevel is easier if it is on the bevel of the blade instead of the back.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#37

David Barnett

Tool bit geometries for metal

David Barnett

Chip formation in short vs. long materials (short = cast iron, for example), and cutting geometries and relief angles for metalworking tool bits, is rather unlike stresses on thin, wide cutting edges for planing wood. Whereas greater relief may afford better finish cuts when turning or milling metal, especially when cutting long materials, rubbing against wood with a plane iron tends to burnish the finish, which may or may not be desirable.

I really don't see where relief angles for metalworking under power are analogously applicable (especially considering metal cutting theory and praxis is often inseparable from industrial tribologies) to woodworking hand tools even if those angles happen to be numerically the same (7� for carbides, 7� for wood clearance). 7� could arguably be a little on the tight side, though.

As for wear opposite the cutting edge on a bevel up iron, it doesn't take all that long to generate a noticeable difference in finish when viewed under even simple magnification. How this affects engagement of the cutting edge, ease of pushing/pulling the plane or edge longevity, I cannot say. While I do feel my bevel down planes seem to perform more easily and last longer than my bevel ups -- I'm simply not invested in having one outdo the other -- I like using both.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#38

LOL

Larry Williams

I'll give you an A for creativity.

Do me a favor--don't quote me that way.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#39

Clearance angles and wood

Bob Hackett

Call me crazy but I and thousands of other folks rest the backs of our chisels directly on the wood (zero clearance angle) and have no problems cutting pretty much any wood we come across and leaving a smooth surface with this technique.

I have yet to have any of my chisels show any problems with wear bevels creeping up the back either.I`m including my slicks in this statement and they are used in the same manner as a plane would,they do what a plane can`t because of space limitations.

Japanese leaf planes also ride directly on the wood surface and cut wonderful curls just like an iron or wood bodied plane does.

I`m not seeing how the clearance angles needed for machine tool work apply to what we are discussing here on a WWing hantool forum.

Metalworking clearance angles even vary considerably between ferrous and non-ferrous metals.Anyone who has tried to drill bronze,brass or copper with a drill bit sharpened for steel can tell you that thru personal experience.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#40

Re: Clearance angles and wood

Larry Williams

Bob,

I would expect an observant person who does much paring to realize the spring-back is a huge aid in controlling depth of cut. One of my favorite parts of plane making is cutting the toe and heel chamfers on each plane with a chisel. I get four chances to play around with this spring-back on every plane. I have a lot of fun with it.


Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#41

Re: Let me get this straight

TomD

I think I disagree with one part of that, and that is if you are saying one needs a relief angle of 15 degrees. I have a bevel down plane with a relief angle of 5 degrees, cutting angle of 35 degrees, and blade angle of 30 degrees. It is very effective.

That also leads me to believe that the idea of lower cutting angles on BD planes is not correct, as others have suggested. 35 degrees is pretty low.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#42

Re: Let me get this straight

TomD

Larry, with all respect, I don't really see that with woodworking tools. The average 45 degree BD plane has a relief angle of 20 degrees, the aforementioned plane of mine has a relief angle of 5 degrees. It all works. I use the HSS cutters in my mills shapers, and lathes, and all these grind angles make a huge difference in performance, and normally the book angles are correct. So I don't really see a comparison to wood. For one thing the heat created is pretty low.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#43

Re:Order of magnitude thing

TomD

The main thing that is lost so far in this discussion, is quantifying the order of magnitude. There are differences between BU and BD planes, but how many points are there in it. You can have major differences in tool setup that are not going to make a single point of difference in your favour. If this were a sport would you win if you used a BU or a BD, maybe, but I suspect there would not be 1 point out of 100 in it. Meanwhile for Larry's planes, the are many points different, in sole drag, weight/speed, ergonomics, design for specific use, rapidity of turn around in sharpening etc...

Another thing, in this thread is that science is used when someone wants to make a technical argument of high abstraction that for the most part they don't even know the science for. If these were sports shoes, you could get all into the durometer of the rubber, those would be measurable criterion, but if every runner who wore the "superior" shoes ran bad times, and this exact kind of thing happens in the real world all the time, then the shoes are bad. You could call that subjective since you can't take the person out of that equation. But in human performance it is bad science to just overlook the human element.

I would also be interested to know, who gets paid among participants in this thread and board. Larry makes planes, and everyone knows about that, but what about the others. Is anyone getting money or gear for floating around the web or otherwise promoting woodworking or tools? I briefly did seminars, but not in about 10 years.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#44

My experience is different

Larry Williams

A few years ago, when we developed our strike block plane, Bill built the prototype after several meetings going over the features we wanted. Bill gave the 40� bedded prototype to Don to check out. Set for very light cuts, Don immediately used it on a miter shooting board but it didn't behave properly. It acted as if it was dull and Don felt like he was having to force it into the cuts.

Don took the iron out and found, to his surprise, it was sharp. Don was just starting to wonder what was going on and looked down at the wood he was planing. The surface was burnished and Don knew instantly what was probably the problem. He set the iron down next to one of our grinding templates and found it was ground and honed at 30�.

Don reground and resharpened the iron at 25� and the plane performed as expected. It was also leaving the dull, open-pore, and unburnished surface one wants from a plane. Being a bevel-down plane it had about 10� of clearance with the iron beveled at 30�. That's not enough but 15� of clearance works fine.

BTW, I believe this explains why structurally unsound wooden miter planes that cost three times as much pretty much replaced strike block planes. The early woodworkers were freehand grinding with no tool rest and freehand honing. I'm sure a lot of the old strike block planes didn't work properly because there was really no way to be consistent with such a critical bevel angle.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#45

Re: Clearance angles and wood

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

But if you turn the chisel over (convert it to BD), the cuts are more controllable and produce, at a minimum, far fewer tear out possibilities. I don't know how much this may contribute to the discussion; but something to think about.

Japanese leaf planes also ride directly on the wood surface and cut wonderful curls just like an iron or wood bodied plane does.

Yari kanna do indeed cut wood very nicely in the right hands; but their shape is so complex and compounded, and they're used so free form, I'm not sure how to fit them in this conversation. They're like some combination of planes and scrapers.


Very interesting,

Pam

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#46

Re:Order of magnitude thing

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Is anyone getting money or gear for floating around the web or otherwise promoting woodworking or tools? I briefly did seminars, but not in about 10 years.

I get nothing except some knowledge of interesting methodology.

Pam

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#47

Re: Clearance angles and wood

Bob Hackett

I `m not denying that spring back takes place in WWing.My post didn`t question that.

What I did question was that you need a particular clearance angle in order to effectively cut wood. Zero clearance angle will still cut wood.I also questioned how trying to apply metalworking clearance angles to woodworking worked within this discussion.I believe it is an apples and oranges kind of comparison at best.

Pam,if you flip a chisel over and make a cut with the bevel bearing on the work it still has the same zero clearance angle.The area of the bearing surface becomes smaller but the clearance angle is still zero and the angle of cut remains the same.

The only angle I see changing is the angle at which you are pushing the chisel.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#48

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

ray

A lot of great information and informed opinions in this thread. Thanks to everyone from this rookie.

Specific questions on specific planes:

LN has three planes listed as low angle(none mention BU):

LA Jack

LA Smoothing

LA Jointer

LV lists some BU and some LA:

LA Smooth

BU Smooth

LA Jack

BU Jointer

Are these all BU?

If not, which would be generally better (LA/BU) for someone just getting started and may never have more than 3 planes- ya I know, it is a disease and I will probably be like most of you in a few years.

If they are all BU, why the different labeling?

Thank again...

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#49

Just found one of the answers

ray

I just read Derek Cohen's review of the LV BUS and I think I found the answer to one of my questions- the planes I listed are not all BU.

All LV planes I listed are LA but I can chose from BU or BD. Does it follow then that LN does not offer BU because none are labeled BU?

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#50

Re: Just found one of the answers *LINK*

Bruce, a MN Galoot

In addition to the block planes, LN also makes a low angle jack plane low angle jack plane

http://www.lie-nielsen.com/catalog.php?grp=1247

and

a low angle jointer

http://www.lie-nielsen.com/catalog.php?sku=7_5

(sorry, can't figure out how to embed two urls - you'll have to copy and paste)


low angle jack plane