Re: Science?
joel moskowitz
"I have just measured the unsupported length of blade on a LV BU Smoother and LN #4 1/2 (with a 50 degree frog), both for equivalent smoothing cuts. The BUS measured 4mm. The #4 1/2 measured 8.5mm. In other words, the BD plane had a little over twice the unsupported blade than the BU plane. Both blades are 3/16" thick, both made from A2. And I should also mention that the #4 1/2's blade was bevelled at about 28-29 degrees. The unsupported length would increase if the bevel was 25 degrees. Does any of this really matter on planes such as these? I very much doubt it - we are playing with numbers here."
Look at the force vectors and the forces where the metal bends. It's a straight mechanical engineering problem. This is why really good mitre planes have tiny mouths both in front and behind the cutting edge.
"The early BU planes were made in grey cast iron, which is fragile compared to modern ductile iron. The Stanley #62 and #164 had a reputation for the mouth chipping easily. My own Stanley #62 has a lost bedding at the rear of the mouth. "
Early Mitre planes were made with steel soles. the STanley 62 and 164 are junk by comparison. Really not worthy of consideration. And certainly not in production by the time the Infill had converted to BD smoothers.
"(This does not appear to have affected its performance much, using a thicker LN blade). It was not until LN, then LV, began marketing these planes in ductile iron, and with thick blades, that they were rediscovered. I cannot see how you can conclude that BD planes were favoured over BU planes for serious traditional work because of their absence on the market. "
Because they were. Large English mitre planes are pretty common from before the 1850 period. They were used for smoothing tough boards and many survive with handles cobbled onto them. However once (starting in the 1830's with Panel planes and moving to smoothers by the late 1840's) infill smoothers appeared large mitre planes basically vanish from the market and small ones appear for specialist work only. Stanley doesn't enter into it until way to late in the market.
"Surely their absence was because their constructional demands placed them at a disadvantage?"
None of the modern BU planes I have used work nearly as well as the better condition Mitre planes I have (other then their ergonomics are far better). You can support the blade better with steel than with cast iron.
"Let me make this clear: I am not trying to make a case for BU planes over BD planes. I am simply trying to point out that meaningful conclusions need to be based on objective information, rather than subjective impressions .... which leads us to the next point ..."
"But Larry's math is correct.
Not actually Larry's math, but that of his brother. Have you done the math as well?"
Yip - (My degree is in mechanical engineering - but this calculation for force vectors is grade one physics.) I also have the means and have done plenty of comparisons.
"It is not that simple (says I the Non-mathematician. My 6 years of Research Maths Stats at university do not count here
). It all depends on what you are examining, that is, what conditions you are including in your calculations."
It is that simple.
"I have passed this on to a friend of mine, Bob, who is both a woodworker and the Head of Department of Applied Physics at one of our local universities. I involved him in a similar project once before, this being when I needed to calculate the amount of steel to be removed when camber blades with different primary bevel thicknesses (interestingly, aslo a project inspired by Larry arguing that a BU plane could not be used in the same way as a typical BD jack. Link: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/WoodworkTechniques/TheSecretToCamberinBUPlaneBlades.html)
The question I posed Bob was this:
The issue is BU versus BD planes and the forces required to push them. Which plane causes the user to experience most/least resistance when pusing one?"
That's not the question I am answering. My question is for a given iron which plane has better blade support and less blade chatter for a given depth of cut.
Larry's point - which is correct but far harder to calculate takes into account clearance angles on the wood and wood deflection. He's right here - no question about it (empirical evidence confirms that) but as I said with harder more brittle woods, with less deflection, a BU plane will work better.
Interestingly enough I accidentally did an experiment many years ago before I understood how important clearance angles were. Almost all mitre planes are bedded at 20 degrees. I thought wouldn't a lower angle mitre plane work even better on eng grain. We built two chariot planes to test this. One at 20 degrees another I think at 15 or 18 ( don't remember). The lower angle plane worked far worst. It was the clearance angles that killed it.
"The situation:
"a BU smoother with a 55 degree cutting angle has a 43 degree knife edge. The question is what are the forces on this at 12 degrees ...... versus the 25 or 30 degrees of the bevel on the blade of a BD plane with a bed of 55 degrees? "
I think that I will also ask him to calculate vectors for (1) holding tote angle constant, and (2) the differences when using Stanley/LN angles on the BD and LV tote angles on the BU.
I shall pass on these results when they are available.
Regards from Perth
Derek