New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

bevel up plane/retailer question

Posts

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#51

David Barnett

Uh... maybe not

David Barnett

"All LV planes I listed are LA but I can chose from BU or BD."

Rule of thumb:

If it's LA it's BU.

If it's BU it's LA, but... it could be functioning at a higher cutting angle with a steeper bevel on the blade, but it's still bevel up.

You said you have a low angle block plane. See the bevel? If the sole of the plane is down, that is, resting on the wood you're planing, the bevel is facing upwards, hence bevel up.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#52

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Part of this becomes knowledge informed by practice, Ray. LN talks about their low angle planes being "bedded at 12�," but really only mentions the bevel on the jointer plane, where they mention "...the blade mounted bevel up at 12�..."

If you take a plane iron and hold it at 12� from horizontal, you'll immediately find that the bevel HAS to be up, or it won't touch the wood.

Lee Valley ran into a problem that they solved with confusing terminology: they offer two subtly different smoothing planes, each with its iron bedded at 12�. To distinguish them, they call one low angle and the other bevel up; but both phrases, as descriptive phrases, apply to both planes.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#53

It's NOT "apples and oranges"

Larry Williams

The exact same phenomena is happening in both woodworking and in metal working. Metal, wood and a lot of other things are viscoelastic and deform ahead of a cutting edge then, after the edge passes, what wasn't cut away springs back. The big difference is that you're much more unlikely to experience sudden catastrophic failure of materials or tooling as a result of inadequate clearance when woodworking.

An example would be turning round aluminum stock to a shoulder with an AR style bit. You'll be taking shavings just like a plane unless you don't have enough relief angle on your bit. A heavy cut without enough relief the aluminum in returning from its viscoelastic deflection will be rubbing on the flank (the area behind the cutting edge) of the bit and things go South in a hurry. If you have the right geometry and your just turned cylinder is exactly say .050" oversize, you might advance your tool bit exactly .050" for the final cut. If you do and you're working to close tolerances, you'll find you are still over sized. That's because the metal is deflecting away from the shear and springing back after the cut.

You can experience basically the same thing with wood but most people don't work wood to those tolerances. One example is to set a plane for a fine shaving of about .001" in hard maple then use that same plane at the same setting in poplar. It won't plane the poplar because the poplar will deflect completely away from the blade before it shears. Set the same plane for a .001" shaving in poplar and it'd be a good idea to eat your Wheaties before you use it in hard maple.

There are a lot of variables when dealing with viscoelastic deflection. The type and specific kind of material, how acute the cutting edge, how heavy the cut are some examples. A 40� bedded strike block plane with a 25� bevel angle on the iron taking a light cut requires less clearance than a 55� bedded bench plane with a 30� bevel on the iron taking a relatively moderate cut. One thing you can count on is that finish quality and edge life suffer any time there isn't enough clearance.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#54

Re: Uh... maybe not

ray

So....out of the box, LN LA planes are considered BU?

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#55

From the Lie-Nielsen site: *LINK*

Bruce, a MN Galoot

"This is an outstanding plane. The low angle blade set with the bevel up "

this quote comes from


here

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#56

David Barnett

A picture might help *LINK*

David Barnett

If you go to the Lie-Nielsen website and look at the diagram for each of the LA planes (under Block Planes), you'll see the bevel on each plane blade points upward and is bedded at 12�. Look at one of the Bench Plane diagrams and you'll see the bevel points downward while the blade is bedded (supported) on its frog at a higher (usual) 45� angle.

On a low angle plane, if you put the blade in with the bevel facing downwards, the cutting edge wouldn't touch the wood through the sole of the plane, which is why LA planes are BU.

So yes, a Lie-Nielsen LA plane is a bevel up plane.


LA is BU

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#57

Re: A picture might help

ray

Your comment about the cutting edge not coming into contact with the wood helped a lot. Thanks.

It just seemed strange (and therefore it confused me) when I saw that LN didn't use the term BU at all on their LA planes and LV did on some LA planes and not on others.

What the heck, in a world where 60 1/2 is a much smaller plane than a number 5....just accept and learn.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#58

Re:Order of magnitude thing

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I would also be interested to know, who gets paid among participants in this thread and board. Larry makes planes, and everyone knows about that, but what about the others. Is anyone getting money or gear for floating around the web or otherwise promoting woodworking or tools?

Hi Tom

I do some pre-production testing for Lee Valley: planes, saws, chisels. Every man and his dog knows that - no secret. But I do it for fun - there is no monetary payment involved. I do get a "free" tool for my time when I am so involved. Never depended on this to stock my workshop. Never been asked to write a review for them. I pay for my website out of my pocket, and write for my amusement and, hopefully, the interest of others.

Of course, if anyone out there would like to put me on their payrole ..... :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#59

Re: A picture might help

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

It just seemed strange (and therefore it confused me) when I saw that LN didn't use the term BU at all on their LA planes...

But they did! Bruce provided the quote, from the first sentence of the third paragraph.

Pam

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#60

"apples and oranges",yet again

Bob Hackett

You used turning an aluminum cylinder as an example so I`ll run with that.

Substitute wood for that aluminum and in order to cut you must rub the bevel(zero clearance angle) to control the cut if you create a clearance angle by lifting the bevel off the surface being cut then you get a catch and ruin the piece.

You could use a scraper to make the cut but then the finish goes out the window.Besides we`re talking about a shearing cut rather than scraping.

Apples and oranges,Larry

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#61

David Barnett

No, more like apples and halibut

David Barnett

Equating planing wood with machining aluminum is stretching (pun intended) viscoelasticity just a bit.

From a particularly well-written Wikipedia entry:

"All materials exhibit some viscoelastic response. In common metals such as steel or aluminum, as well as in quartz, at room temperature and at small strain, the behavior does not deviate much from linear elasticity. Synthetic polymers, wood, and human tissue as well as metals at high temperature display significant viscoelastic effects."

"Whereas elasticity is usually the result of bond stretching along crystallographic planes in an ordered solid, viscosity is the result of the diffusion of atoms or molecules inside an amorphous material."

While amorphous aluminum alloys do exist, they include transition and rare earth metals -- not something likely to end up on my lathe, especially as most also contain significant silica. And last time I looked, regular ol' aluminum's modulus of elasticity was about 10 at 21C, gray cast iron 13.4, and carbon steel around 29. It just doesn't seem all that springy, but what would I know?

Except for wave damping technologies, viscoelastic behavior of conductors at the submicron level, and so on, there's relatively little in the literature about aluminum's viscoelastic deformation arising from tool bit deflection, though it does happen, of course. Machine tool bit relief angles are not about viscoelasticity, though, as I understand it. Really, aluminum's face-centered cubic crystal structure is rather unlike a fibrous, hygroscopic material such as wood. I just don't see machine tool bits as a fit analog for hand tools used in woodworking. But that's just me -- maybe can't wrap my head around it.

Also, you left out a few things in your comparison of a lathe cutting operation to hand planing wood: deflection of both tool and tool assembly, work piece deflection, feed speed, rotation speed, work piece temperature, coolant (if any), and lubricant (if any). Ignoring both the mechanical and tribological factors leaves me dubious -- sins of omission.

But then I'm arguing with a guy who compared steel to tomatoes. Now think if I'd ignored most of the meat (literally) from your post and paraphrased it: too many chickens -- not enough Viagra. Someone might draw the wrong conclusion. :)

"I think modern varieties of steel have a lot in common with modern varieties of tomatoes. The "improvements" have a lot to offer to the supply chain but not so much the end user unless you're fond of the taste and nutritional value of cardboard. When is the last time you saw the white bones of a mature chicken on your plate after a meal of fried chicken? Yeah, technology can make a baby chicken grow faster and you can take Viagra to overcome the effects of the estrogen they feed chickens to make 'em grow. I don't think a lot of the "improvements" necessarily make things better."

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#62

Re: halibut

Larry Williams

"...Also, you left out a few things in your comparison of a lathe cutting operation to hand planing wood: deflection of both tool and tool assembly, work piece deflection, feed speed, rotation speed, work piece temperature, coolant (if any), and lubricant (if any). Ignoring both the mechanical and tribological factors leaves me dubious -- sins of omission. ..."

Okay, the picayune waltz it is. If you haven't noticed, this is a hand tool woodworking forum. Several paragraphs about feeds, speeds, coatings, coolants and the rest most likely wouldn't be read by anyone even if they cared. The reality is that you know exactly what I'm talking about and those with no machine shop experience have a pretty good idea. Not bad for four words: "heavy cut", "inadequate clearance."

I did appreciate your pointing me to the Wikipedia article and it is well written. Like most things well written pretty important concepts can lurk in one or two easy to miss sentences. Did you happen to read far enough to see these two?

"Purely elastic materials do not dissipate energy (heat) when a load is applied, then removed[1]. However, a viscoelastic substance loses energy when a load is applied, then removed."

It's a pretty important concept for machinists and hand tool woodworkers alike. One example for a machinist is where to apply coolant. If heat is from friction it would be best to apply coolant directly behind an end mill. If it's from viscoelastic compression of metal it's best to apply coolant in front of an end mill.

You know David, rather than flash around fifty cent words like "tribology" it's better to get it out from under the raincoat and do something useful with it. You could use it explain that the dulling wear woodworkers are likely to experience on edge tools is from adhesive wear not abrasive wear. You could also use it to explain that while heat has little effect on abrasive wear it's a major catalyst to adhesive wear. The more you compress the wood ahead of your cutting edge the more heat you generate and the faster the tool dulls. Oh my, are we back to viscoelasticity again? I think we just might be.

It also brings us back to your propensity to buy into technological Darwinism again. Where technological "improvements" are always better. Oh no! Are we back to tomatoes and steel again? I guess that's where this adhesive wear stuff might lead. If one looks at the properties of A-2 steel (the improved modern high production variety) vs. O-1 steel (the heirloom variety) one will find that the resistance to adhesive wear is virtually identical between the two. The much touted wear resistance of A-2 shows up under resistance to abrasive wear. So, unless one lives on the bottom of the planet where trees grow upside down and the sand runs into them, the one place a woodworker is likely experience this "improved" wear resistance is when honing their tools. I think I'll stick with the heirloom variety of steel. That goes for tomatoes too, I don't much care for the cardboard taste, texture and nutritional value of the "improved" modern variety.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#63

Re: From the Lie-Nielsen site:

ray

Bruce,

Thanks for the help. I did make it to the tool show in Medina, but I didn't feel as if I was knowledgeable enough to make a wise purchase. I plan to buy a new LA Smoother or Jack plane fairly soon and try my luck later on a used Jointer, etc.

I am finding that this adventure is as good as I thought it would be.

Thanks again,

Ray

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#64

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)

David Barnett

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#65

Re: halibut... but... but...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

OK, but do you agree that heirloom tomatoes are superior? :)

Pam, who thinks you read really expensive books :)

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#66

David Barnett

Re: halibut... but... but... *LINK*

David Barnett

"Okay, the picayune waltz it is. If you haven't noticed, this is a hand tool woodworking forum."

Nothing picayune about it. Firstly, I have noticed this is a hand tool woodworking forum. I further noticed that you introduced an over-simplified (in my estimation) machine analogy to explain how a hand tool blade edge cuts and wears. Which was my point. It's simply not analagous. Machining operations offer neither an apt nor robust explanation of what's happening to a plane blade edge under stress. In my opinion. So again, I have noticed this is a hand tools forum, which is why I felt your explanation was stretching it, so to speak, so tried to explain why.

"Several paragraphs about feeds, speeds, coatings, coolants and the rest most likely wouldn't be read by anyone even if they cared."

That would have been one paragraph, Larry, and more precisely, one sentence -- and again, the only reason for bringing up those factors was to point out the shortcomings in your example. In my opinion. As for who reads these posts and who cares? I do. You do.

"The reality is that you know exactly what I'm talking about and those with no machine shop experience have a pretty good idea."

Yes, I do know what you're talking about, and because I don't think it's a fair nor a complete analogy, I critiqued it. I'm not saying I think otherwise for mischief or aggrandizement, but because I truly don't believe that what happens with a shouldering cut as you described adequately supports that it's also what happens at the cutting edge of a hand plane.

Granted, you've thought about, experimented with, and know one hell of a lot more about what happens at the cutting edge of a hand plane blade than just about anyone. I freely admit I may be entirely wrong. And that's okay. But your arguments fail to overcome what I think, and saying my reasons and arguments are picayune or not germane to hand tools (again, especially as you introduced the machinery comparison), does little to convince me otherwise.

"Like most things well written pretty important concepts can lurk in one or two easy to miss sentences. Did you happen to read far enough to see these two?"

Yeah, I sure did. I'm a big fan of Roderic Lakes, who wrote much of what appears in that article. I first encountered his work in the 1980s when I was helping a NASA biophysicist develop bioelectric technologies for combating bone loss in low to zero gravity environments. Rod Lakes probably knows more about what biomechanically happens in bones than anyone else on the planet, and just about everything else bioelastic, bioplastic, and viscoelastic, which is why I mentioned that Wikipedia article was particularly well-written.

A couple real page-turners (hey, I used to live for this stuff):

Saha, S. and Lakes, R. S., "A non-invasive technique for detecting stress waves in bone using the piezoelectric effect," IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering , BME-24, 508-512, (1977).

Lakes, R. S., Yoon, H. S. and Katz, J. L., "Slow compressional wave propagation in wet human and bovine cortical bone", Science, 220 513-515, (1983).

And all the rest: http://tinyurl.com/PublicationsRodLakes



Now I don't have much skin in this game, have no real interest beyond wanting to know more about what's happening when I use one hand tool or another, and mostly want to have fun exploring these issues. And yes, I do enjoy arguing my way to new learnings. And who better to learn from than you?

Actually, I would love to abandon my perceptions and convictions if given a clear and compelling refutation, the same as I love losing a chess match to a superior opponent. I'm right about enough to be satisfied that I can think some things through, but secure enough to get most things wrong most of the time, and yet find it all thoroughly enjoyable. So I do apologize for my dilettantish proddings and prodigious verbiage, but hey, that's me.

While you've said nothing to prompt my sudden self-explanation, nothing unreasonable nor personally provocative -- in fact, some of your points are fair, well-described and deserve scrutiny -- I did want to let you know I'm not intentionally wasting your time or disrespecting your knowledge and accomplishments. I currently have had more time to spend here these last few weeks, but that won't last. Also, the occasional emoticon cannot do justice to the unceasing jovial countenance that accompanies my mercurial musings.

As for tribology, why that one only cost me fifteen cents when I got it. Damned inflation. Besides, who can pass up a word that shares ancestry with tribadism? As for the raincoat thing, that's fair, considering I posted this only last week:

"It's never too tough to tempt a guy who wears a trenchcoat and cut-off trouser legs tied below the knee to exhibit his proud possession. Wait for it. ... ... Ta-Daaa!"

I guess Bob Hackett just brings out the best in me. Onward.

"You could use it explain that the dulling wear woodworkers are likely to experience on edge tools is from adhesive wear not abrasive wear. You could also use it to explain that while heat has little effect on abrasive wear it's a major catalyst to adhesive wear. The more you compress the wood ahead of your cutting edge the more heat you generate and the faster the tool dulls."

There you go. That's what sends the tingle up my spine. Those dancing sparks at the edges of blades and arrises of gems draw me like a moth to a flame. I'll want to say more on that later, but for now, I'm pretty sure I've said enough.


Viscoelastic Materials - Roderic Lakes

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#67

David Barnett

Book$

David Barnett

Yes.

And you have no idea.

(My apologies for removing the linked-to post, but as you no doubt discovered, I bungled the URL -- duh!)

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#68

That was intended to reply to David's post below

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#69

Re: Book$

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

No problem, except for the momentary utter confusion. Not the first time today. :)

Pam

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#70

David Barnett

Oops! Bad URL. Fixed.

David Barnett

My apologies for the above deleted post, but I bungled the URL for the linked book and so re-posted the same document with the correction (my edit time had expired).

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#71

David Barnett

Mea culpa! Mea culpa! 

David Barnett

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#72

The adventure is just beginning

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"I am finding that this adventure is as good as I thought it would be."

Oh, and it's just beginning. Even though it's all fundamentally simple (I say this in the face of the discussion here about bevel up vs. bevel down planes), there are just so many new things to learn, and, because much of it is developed skill and muscle memory, finding how elegantly hand tools can work has just layers and layers of adventures and exciting moments.

After about 35 years of doing this (not full-time - heck, barely part-time some of the time), I feel I'm an intermediate beginner, but enjoying it every time I get a plane, chisel, drawknife, or layout tool in my hands.

I suppose good tennis or badminton players get some of the same rush from a well-played hit, but, when they're done, they've got nothing to show for it but a score on the game.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#73

Re: halibut

David Weaver

I would like to see someone do a wear test in normal woodworking - count strokes, two thousandth shaving - with an A2 iron and with an O1 iron, both the same hardness.

In my experience, the A2 does stay sharp enough to use longer.

Maybe my experience is biased because a lot of O1 irons aren't as hard as the A2 irons I used (one tested at 61.5, and the other 62).

I pushed out several thousand shavings comparing a few A2 irons. Maybe someone else could do A2 vs. high carbon and let us know how it turns out.

Next thing, you'll tell us M2 doesn't last any longer than A2 or O1...I hope that doesn't happen.

When these arguments get into you guys proving who knows more than the other person, I start to fall asleep. I have seen enough where practice doesn't match up with simplified theory to only want to know "what's the answer in practice?"

If the real answer is that O1 is brittle at 62 hardness and A2 is not, and A2 lasts longer because of the hardness, then i still have heard what I want to know...which one can last longer practically?

I've never noticed A2 to be difficult to sharpen on ceramics. M2 is. A2 is not. I would bet I could put a surface on boards with two planes sharpened with a 1 micron ceramic stone - one A2 and one O1, and nobody here could tell the difference in pictures or in person, especially on hardwoods (I've never looked that close at softwoods, they look better after a 38-40 degree pass of a japanese plane most of the time, anyway, but they do take a shine off of a 45 degree plane iron - I just don't remember if A2 makes a difference).

All change isn't bad.

It doesn't mean it's necessary, but it also doesn't mean its bad.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#74

The Judge

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

Hi everyone,

I'm pretty much with Derek on this. One thing I would add is that there are wear bevels on both sides of the plane iron, and both need to get attended to if one wants a truly sharp edge. Read Brent Beach's ("the Judge" here) article on sharpening:

http://www3.telus.net/BrentBeach/Sharpen/bevels.html

In a nutshell, the lower wear bevel (under the iron, irrespective of blade orientation) is shorter than the upper wear bevel. It gets removed by regular sharpening on a BD blade. On a BU blade it takes quite a bit of work to remove it if no back bevels are used (� la Charlesworth ruler trick, Beach goes a bit higher angle). On the other hand, the upper wear bevel does not get removed on a BD blade without a back bevel (but is on a BU blade).

In the end, if we have a blade sharpened at 30 degree, it doesn't matter if it sits BU on a 15 degree bed (such a beast doesn't exist AFAIK, but close enough to 12 degree for the sake of this example) or BD on a 45 degree one. The wood sees exactly the same geometry. But the BU blade needs to get both bevels honed to maintain top performance, whereas one can get away with it more easily with a BD blade if not doing a back bevel (but still the performance won't be as high as it could be).

Bottom line, if you don't want to do back bevels, then stick to BD planes, but your blades won't be as sharp as they should be unless you grind away the upper wear bevel (which gains no speed and wears blades quickly).

As for as the clearance issues Larry mentions, can't argue with his experience, could it be a "feature" of wooden planes? I have no idea, all I can say is that I run 60+ degree angle of attack with ~11 degree clearance on my BU planes with no apparent issue.

Regarding Warren's item #3, IIRC Derek uses a jig because he puts a high angle microbevel on a 25 degree ground blade. If one starts with a 50 degree blade no jig is needed (although I'll admit that it gets harder to freehand at high angles). Derek, could you confirm?

All 4 now,

DC

8 days away from a new plane

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#75

Re: The Judge

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Bottom line, if you don't want to do back bevels, then stick to BD planes, but your blades won't be as sharp as they should be unless you grind away the upper wear bevel (which gains no speed and wears blades quickly).

And who doesn't at least clean up the back of a bd blade when sharpening. Of course, there are those who do the 1" back to the edge is flat enough and never flatten the entire back; but don't they get wire edges when sharpening the bevel? Are these left?

And I'd also have to ask about toothing blades. How are they handled in this universe?

Pam