Re: halibut... but... but... *LINK*
David Barnett
"Okay, the picayune waltz it is. If you haven't noticed, this is a hand tool woodworking forum."
Nothing picayune about it. Firstly, I have noticed this is a hand tool woodworking forum. I further noticed that you introduced an over-simplified (in my estimation) machine analogy to explain how a hand tool blade edge cuts and wears. Which was my point. It's simply not analagous. Machining operations offer neither an apt nor robust explanation of what's happening to a plane blade edge under stress. In my opinion. So again, I have noticed this is a hand tools forum, which is why I felt your explanation was stretching it, so to speak, so tried to explain why.
"Several paragraphs about feeds, speeds, coatings, coolants and the rest most likely wouldn't be read by anyone even if they cared."
That would have been one paragraph, Larry, and more precisely, one sentence -- and again, the only reason for bringing up those factors was to point out the shortcomings in your example. In my opinion. As for who reads these posts and who cares? I do. You do.
"The reality is that you know exactly what I'm talking about and those with no machine shop experience have a pretty good idea."
Yes, I do know what you're talking about, and because I don't think it's a fair nor a complete analogy, I critiqued it. I'm not saying I think otherwise for mischief or aggrandizement, but because I truly don't believe that what happens with a shouldering cut as you described adequately supports that it's also what happens at the cutting edge of a hand plane.
Granted, you've thought about, experimented with, and know one hell of a lot more about what happens at the cutting edge of a hand plane blade than just about anyone. I freely admit I may be entirely wrong. And that's okay. But your arguments fail to overcome what I think, and saying my reasons and arguments are picayune or not germane to hand tools (again, especially as you introduced the machinery comparison), does little to convince me otherwise.
"Like most things well written pretty important concepts can lurk in one or two easy to miss sentences. Did you happen to read far enough to see these two?"
Yeah, I sure did. I'm a big fan of Roderic Lakes, who wrote much of what appears in that article. I first encountered his work in the 1980s when I was helping a NASA biophysicist develop bioelectric technologies for combating bone loss in low to zero gravity environments. Rod Lakes probably knows more about what biomechanically happens in bones than anyone else on the planet, and just about everything else bioelastic, bioplastic, and viscoelastic, which is why I mentioned that Wikipedia article was particularly well-written.
A couple real page-turners (hey, I used to live for this stuff):
Saha, S. and Lakes, R. S., "A non-invasive technique for detecting stress waves in bone using the piezoelectric effect," IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering , BME-24, 508-512, (1977).
Lakes, R. S., Yoon, H. S. and Katz, J. L., "Slow compressional wave propagation in wet human and bovine cortical bone", Science, 220 513-515, (1983).
And all the rest: http://tinyurl.com/PublicationsRodLakes
Now I don't have much skin in this game, have no real interest beyond wanting to know more about what's happening when I use one hand tool or another, and mostly want to have fun exploring these issues. And yes, I do enjoy arguing my way to new learnings. And who better to learn from than you?
Actually, I would love to abandon my perceptions and convictions if given a clear and compelling refutation, the same as I love losing a chess match to a superior opponent. I'm right about enough to be satisfied that I can think some things through, but secure enough to get most things wrong most of the time, and yet find it all thoroughly enjoyable. So I do apologize for my dilettantish proddings and prodigious verbiage, but hey, that's me.
While you've said nothing to prompt my sudden self-explanation, nothing unreasonable nor personally provocative -- in fact, some of your points are fair, well-described and deserve scrutiny -- I did want to let you know I'm not intentionally wasting your time or disrespecting your knowledge and accomplishments. I currently have had more time to spend here these last few weeks, but that won't last. Also, the occasional emoticon cannot do justice to the unceasing jovial countenance that accompanies my mercurial musings.
As for tribology, why that one only cost me fifteen cents when I got it. Damned inflation. Besides, who can pass up a word that shares ancestry with tribadism? As for the raincoat thing, that's fair, considering I posted this only last week:
"It's never too tough to tempt a guy who wears a trenchcoat and cut-off trouser legs tied below the knee to exhibit his proud possession. Wait for it. ... ... Ta-Daaa!"
I guess Bob Hackett just brings out the best in me. Onward.
"You could use it explain that the dulling wear woodworkers are likely to experience on edge tools is from adhesive wear not abrasive wear. You could also use it to explain that while heat has little effect on abrasive wear it's a major catalyst to adhesive wear. The more you compress the wood ahead of your cutting edge the more heat you generate and the faster the tool dulls."
There you go. That's what sends the tingle up my spine. Those dancing sparks at the edges of blades and arrises of gems draw me like a moth to a flame. I'll want to say more on that later, but for now, I'm pretty sure I've said enough.
Viscoelastic Materials - Roderic Lakes