New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

bevel up plane/retailer question

Posts

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#76

interesting you would go there, David

Larry Williams

David,

In part, you wrote, "...I've never looked that close at softwoods, they look better after a 38-40 degree pass of a japanese plane most of the time..." You've hit upon something Don and I sometimes discuss and wonder about.

I don't know if you read my post to Tom in this thread. I wrote:

"...Bill gave the 40� bedded prototype to Don to check out. Set for very light cuts, Don immediately used it on a miter shooting board but it didn't behave properly. It acted as if it was dull and Don felt like he was having to force it into the cuts.

Don took the iron out and found, to his surprise, it was sharp. Don was just starting to wonder what was going on and looked down at the wood he was planing. The surface was burnished and Don knew instantly what was probably the problem...."

40 years ago I had the opportunity to spend seven days wandering around a couple Japanese cities seeing what I could. One of the places I found myself was inside what was obviously a recently completed temple. I didn't know a lot about woodworking at the time but the wood inside the temple attracted both the eye and hand. My impression was that it was pine and had no visible finish but it appeared polished.

In my work I view a burnished surface a problem because it impairs good uniform penetration of adhesives, stains or finishes. If the goal is to leave a burnished surface that will get no finish coating then things may be different. One could use a plane with inhibited clearance to burnish such a "finish" in woods that tend to have a high deflection ahead of the cutting edge. Is this what those 38� bedded Japanese planes are intended to do? I don't know but Don and I sometimes wonder about it. I remember, years ago, reading about Japanese temple builders who would stop and sharpen after each shaving. At the time I dismissed it as just more mystique but that may not be the case.

I am puzzled by your comment about these threads or "arguments" being opportunities to peacock one's knowledge. Is that the way you view this? To me it's been a discussion of some pretty important functional issues around plane performance. It's a learning opportunity. I've learned quite a bit during this thread and gained a much clearer perspective on the knowledge I did have. I really value this, it's what makes following woodworking forums worth the time I invest.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#77

Re: interesting you would go there, David

wilbur

I don't have a good explanation for the "burnishing" that you describe, other than it seems to happen in my shop as well. Like many things, this could be a multifactorial process.

1. Bed angle. I'm not going to pretend like I know anything about this. What I can say is that for a Japanese plane tuned for softwoods, the bevel angle would be around 25�. The bed angle would be 38.65� (inverse tan (8/10), actually). That would leave a clearance angle of 13� or so. I don't know if that has anything to do with the burnishing, but that's the data.

2. Sole configuration. Because of the relieved areas of the sole of a Japanese plane, a given area of wood will see these parts of the plane, in this order: the sole at the front of plane, the sole right in front of the mouth, then the blade. For a western plane, it's different: sole at the front of the blade, then the blade, then the sole at the back of the plane. There may be something to the wood being cut by the plane blade and then not touched by the sole of the plane that contributes to the appearance.

3. Sole configuration, part 2. The sole of a Japanese plane touches the wood only in two narrow strips at the front of the plane and right in front of the mouth. Because of the small area of the touch points, it could be that the wood compresses more during planing compared to a western plane, and that the compression just prior to being cut with the blade contributes to the appearance.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#78

It got away from me

Bob Hackett

When I first saw this post I meant to ask if you had any other pics or links to these Pam.

I`m finding info and pics of them hard to find,especially pics of the side that rides on the work.

These have the potential to be incredibly versatile tools from the looks of it and I`m interested in possibly making my own version of one is why I ask for info.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#79

Re: interesting you would go there, David

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I often prefer to go with a burnished finish, and wish I could get that from planing on end grain, too (so far, sandpaper seems to be the best I can get). So I'm playing around with a slightly new bedding angle/mouth configuration to buy/make a finishing plane version. Also, I think the speed of planing has an added effect. Inomoto-san says go fast.

As to why some people insist on aggressively confronting those who know something and thus display their lack of knowledge befuddles. Why they can't just be polite also befuddles. I mean, if they don't like a conversation, why not just move on? I have noticed a very strong tendency in people to limit others by their own limitations. Perhaps it's the discussion itself in this case, "Oohh, take away the conflict, it's destroying my peace."

Whatever the reason, I've been enjoying this; but would feel a lot better if Barnett would admit that heirloom tomatoes are superior. :)

Pam

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#80

David Barnett

Oh, but they ARE superior.

David Barnett

Far superior. Happy, now? Actually, I love heirloom tomatoes. In my growing zone it's pretty hard to get much yield, although I may try those cherry Everglades wild tomatoes. In South Florida, tomatoes are usually grown through the winter. The summer humidity and heat is hell on heirlooms.

I'm jealous of the variety some people can grow. At $4 a box for grape tomatoes, I'm gonna have to make some banks of LED grow lights and just do it.

"Oohh, take away the conflict, it's destroying my peace."

I come from a family of kitchen table polemicists who'll argue over who gets the last sausage and why. I'm the largest in the family. By far.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#81

Re: It got away from me *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

The bottom is shaped much like a spoon plane or bearing scraper; but it's got a hollow/ura in there and the angles are different within the same tool. I've attached a link showing Tasai's (excellent blacksmith) version. If you do a search on "yari kanna" you'll find some more.

To make one, I'd start with a bearing scraper and refine. Yari kanna are very expensive tools, so if you email me your address I'd be happy to send you a small version to examine, even use if you're so inclined (but please don't sharpen); but I would want it back in fairly short order.

Pam


Tasai yari kanna

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#82

Hooray!

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

There's a farmer here who grows them and supplies my coop. They should start coming in any day now.

I love a good argument/discussion, too; but have been discouraged by society, so I'm probably a bit dull by now. (:

Pam

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#83

David Barnett

Re: Hooray!

David Barnett

I know what you mean. I enjoy it, too, even when I'm bested. One can argue tenaciously and passionately while being entirely polite and respectful. It's unfortunate that others often take things personally. I'll often throw in the towel to spare an opponent in duress. It's also important to allow that others are not always so well equipped for spontaneous argument and never assume they're wrong because of it.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#84

Come to Maine

Bob Hackett

Folks will sit and passionately discuss things at length up here and if we can`t come to an agreement then we have been known to grab a passerby and each give a brief synopsis of our best argument then let the stranger decide.If they can`t make up their mind then they are invited to toss a coin and it can be decided that way.

Nobody in their right mind would choose a greenhouse tomato from the grocery store over an heirloom tomato from anyone`s yard.I would rather eat my tomato hornworms than a big box tomato.

Many folks are surprised to find that tomatoes come in various shapes and colors can range from black to yellow.

Fried green tomatoes and green tomato pickles are another thing that`s wonderful to introduce folks to. :)

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#85

Re: It got away from me

Bob Hackett

Thank you very much Pam for the offer but I have already used a small leaf knife at the Center for Furniture Craftsmanship in Rockport and that`s what got me going down this path.

I also saw a fellow who did low relief carving using a cross between a spear plane and a crooked knife with a rather long handle for both quickly wasting material from the background of a carving and doing fine finish work with superb control.

I`ve experimented with bearing scrapers and they have too much of a scraping action and are too thick to do what I want.I felt a flatter tool would work far better and even went to far as to grind a boot knife(double edged dagger) flat on one side as an experiment,it got me closer but still not all I`d like it to be. I`m at the point now where I needed to collect more pics/info before I forge out some of my tool steel for another go at it.I need to make 2,my brother wants one of course.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#86

Re: Come to Maine

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I love Maine, in the summer, have spent many a week roaming through the forests on a motorcycle. But winter? No, thank you. Besides, I can talk with you here. :)

Pam

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#87

Re: It got away from me

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

The two bearing scrapers I've got (purely by accident, they came with some large ebay lots of chisels) are the right basic shape; and for sure the tuning for planing would be extensive. But as nearly as I can tell, it could be had by removing metal. Then the question would be what type of steel these scrapers are made from.

Good luck with this.

Pam

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#88

I'll see your winter and raise anything you've got

Bruce, a MN Galoot

(having lived in North Dakota and Minnesota most of my life)

BUT


the idea of tomatoes starting to come in now is a bit more than I can bear!!

Forgot to mention that I have a cousin who lives in Austin. I might have to visit her one of these days, especially if they have tomatoes at this time of year.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#89

Re: I'll see your winter and raise anything you've

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

They're not here yet, had a bad freeze a month ago, but I do expect them very soon. It gets dicey growing stuff in the summer.

If you get down here, let's go out somewhere, please yell.

Pam

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#90

it's easy

Larry Williams

Wilbur,

If you want to increase the burnished look, simply hone your iron to a more obtuse bevel angle. Edge life will suffer but you can get more burnishing. While each different wood will require a different bevel angle to get the maximum burnishing, I'm sure you could quickly learn to control it with just a little experimentation.

While bevel-up fans seem to relish the shiny burnished look, I want something different. To me, a well planed surface will have a dull appearance. Each pore will be open with all the cell walls intact and cleanly cut. I think this is the ideal surface; it promotes the best and most uniform absorbtion of adhesives, stains or finishes.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#91

Tell us more, Pam

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I see bearing scrapers from time to time in my travels, but I've never consider their possible use in woodworking. I'd be interested in hearing how the shape of a spear (or leaf? Seems like both words are used) plane differs from that of a bearing scraper.

I followed the link in your earlier post, and, indeed, the resemblance to the general shape of a bearing scraper is pretty strong. I don't know what steel a bearing scraper is made from, nor what the temper is, but I would expect pretty good steel and fairly hard temper - after all, it is designed to scrape metal.

I want to get one (or two...) before they show up in one of Chris Schwarz' blogs as a new repurposed tool, causing the prices shoot up :D

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#92

Clarity

Warren in Lancaster, PA

What I am after is a clean look with great clarity and yes, cell walls cleanly cut and intact. There is no problem planing cleanly like this with a 42 degree cutting angle. If there is burnishing, it comes from the sole of the plane, and I think a beech sole may give a slightly nicer surface than steel. With high angle planing or with scraping one gets a more dull and cloudy appearance. It is also somewhat more abusive to the edge to plane at higher angles because there is more of a shear force on the edge, more likely to experience "chipping or rolling"

When we use a chisel, we also like to cut at the lowest possible angle for a clean clear cut. If we use a chisel to scrape (the thought gives me the shivers) we can easily duplicate that dull and cloudy look.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#93

You already know at least as much as I do.   *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX


Bearing scraper

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#94

Re: Clarity

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yeah, and while we're at it, can we please have a bit more clarity about terms such as obtuse, acute, steep, and all things referring to angles, bevels, bedding angles, etc.? (Larry, this isn't meant for you so much; but I'd expect you to have a good handle on how these angles should be measured and labeled.)

For example, how exactly do you measure the angle of a bevel? I'd use a protractor with its base parallel to the back of an edge and an arm extending from the base to the angle readings. I'd move that arm to be parallel to the bevel surface and take the reading, and I'd expect that angle to be say, 10� to oh, 35�. Now is that obtuse? 17� is a very gradual slope.

And when someone denotes a 42� cutting angle, what does that mean? Is the protractor placed parallel to the item being cut and the beam moved to parallel the surface closest to that item?

Maybe this should be a separate thread?

Thanks,

Pam

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#95

Re: Tell us more, Pam

Bob Hackett

The primary difference seems to be that a bearing scraper is set up to take a scraping cut and has a rather high bevel angle(closer to 90 than 45).A leaf/spear plane takes a shearing cut and uses a far less steep angle(much less than 45) than a bearing scraper.

Bearing scrapers were usually used to scrape babbitt bearings and while we are talking about a metal we`re talking a metal that is closer to lead in softness than it is to iron in hardness.

I find a lot of cross over uses for both wood and metalworking tools.I use a surprising number to WWing tools for working non-ferrous metals and even cast iron at times.Likewise some of my favorite WWing(especially woodturning) tools have been made from cast off or broken machine tool bits.

Cecil Pearce used to swear by using hacksaws to cut dovetails in hardwoods.I do my best to balance things out by using my skillsaws and old HD jigsaws/sabersaws to cut steel plate. :D

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#96

Re: Clarity

Warren in Lancaster, PA

"Cutting angle" has been used to denote the angle the wood surface makes with the upper part of the edge. For a Bailey plane with no back bevel, it is the same as the bed angle. For an old "Western" wooden plane with a tapered blade it is about one degree less than the bed angle, and for a Japanese plane, where the iron is tapered in the opposite direction, it is slightly higher than the bed angle. For a block plane, the cutting angle is the bedding angle plus the bevel angle.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#97

Re: it's easy

wilbur

Hi Larry,

If I understand you correctly, you and Don are saying that the low clearance angle leads to the burnishing. How much of a clearance angle do you need to avoid the burnished appearance and get the dull appearance that you are looking for?

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#98

Re: it's easy

Larry Williams

Wilbur,

I should keep a diary like Warren. I could tell you more if I did.

I can say that a Stanley 60 1/2 sharpened to 30� will leave a pure burnished surface in white pine with every pass. I left miles of it in my early years as a carpenter and thought the difference in the finish was just the difference between a hand planed one and the factory finish.

I looked at your blog trying to figure out what woods you might have to experiment with. I couldn't tell much. I'm not even sure which wood Don was using the strike block on when he originally tested it. It was almost certainly beech, cherry, poplar, mahogany or yellow birch. I would think you would easily see the burnishing with your 40� plane and the iron honed a little more than 30� in a wood like poplar. Cherry would show the burnishing better.

I've tried to avoid the burnishing for a lot of years and don't recall ever trying to create it. I was hoping some of your sources would list something like a "polishing plane" and explain things further.

I first really tried seriously experimenting with all the different ways one can set up a Bailey style plane shortly after the oldtools mailing list began. I'm not sure exactly when that was but, at the time, Lie-Nielsen's bench plane line included only the #1 and the #2. A guy named Paul Pedersen and I exchanged a long series of e-mails comparing notes. It was then I discovered I could create a better and more uniform surface that avoided potential problems by avoiding the burnishing.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#99

Re: it's easy

wilbur

Hi Larry,

The woods I have around aren't anything special: cherry, walnut, pine, poplar, white oak.

How would you set up a Bailey plane to avoid the burnished look in those sorts of woods? We can stick with cherry for this discussion.

Re: bevel up plane/retailer question

#100

Re: Burnishing

TomD

"40 years ago I had the opportunity to spend seven days wandering around a couple Japanese cities seeing what I could. One of the places I found myself was inside what was obviously a recently completed temple. I didn't know a lot about woodworking at the time but the wood inside the temple attracted both the eye and hand. My impression was that it was pine and had no visible finish but it appeared polished."

Yeah, that early plane of mine cut pine so one could read the writing in the lightbulb overhead. It created a shaving like cobweb, in pine at least.

"In my work I view a burnished surface a problem because it impairs good uniform penetration of adhesives, stains or finishes. If the goal is to leave a burnished surface that will get no finish coating then things may be different."

I am not sure it is true that a super smooth surface is a problem, first I don't believe it is burnished if by that one means rubbed to a finish, as one might with a piece of bone. My reasons are:

1) planing does not feel any different except within a normal range of difference one feels with different pitches;

2) Surface does not look that different from other well cut surfaces as perhaps one might get with a drawknife under ideal conditions.

3) Burnishing normally takes a lot of fast passes, and one just polishes up the surface, nor a single, potentially slow, pass.

4) I just don't get the idea that there is anything for a tool with a 5 degree or more relief angle to polish, there is no bearing, in the model I have in mind.

5) the shaving released is also very smooth, and it is being immediately released

I'm not buying it, but I am considering it, just not there yet.

"I remember, years ago, reading about Japanese temple builders who would stop and sharpen after each shaving. At the time I dismissed it as just more mystique but that may not be the case."

I don't know if or why people do that. It could make sense in some situations where a wide plane is being used to make a single wide finishing pass. Over a long beam, that could be a situation where there would be a change in blade sharpness. If you were working up a per square foot cost, the cost pf planing with resharpening, would compare well to the cost in the west (speaking non mystically) of planing scraping sanding and then french polishing for a week or year.