interesting you would go there, David
Larry Williams
David,
In part, you wrote, "...I've never looked that close at softwoods, they look better after a 38-40 degree pass of a japanese plane most of the time..." You've hit upon something Don and I sometimes discuss and wonder about.
I don't know if you read my post to Tom in this thread. I wrote:
"...Bill gave the 40� bedded prototype to Don to check out. Set for very light cuts, Don immediately used it on a miter shooting board but it didn't behave properly. It acted as if it was dull and Don felt like he was having to force it into the cuts. Don took the iron out and found, to his surprise, it was sharp. Don was just starting to wonder what was going on and looked down at the wood he was planing. The surface was burnished and Don knew instantly what was probably the problem...."
40 years ago I had the opportunity to spend seven days wandering around a couple Japanese cities seeing what I could. One of the places I found myself was inside what was obviously a recently completed temple. I didn't know a lot about woodworking at the time but the wood inside the temple attracted both the eye and hand. My impression was that it was pine and had no visible finish but it appeared polished.
In my work I view a burnished surface a problem because it impairs good uniform penetration of adhesives, stains or finishes. If the goal is to leave a burnished surface that will get no finish coating then things may be different. One could use a plane with inhibited clearance to burnish such a "finish" in woods that tend to have a high deflection ahead of the cutting edge. Is this what those 38� bedded Japanese planes are intended to do? I don't know but Don and I sometimes wonder about it. I remember, years ago, reading about Japanese temple builders who would stop and sharpen after each shaving. At the time I dismissed it as just more mystique but that may not be the case.
I am puzzled by your comment about these threads or "arguments" being opportunities to peacock one's knowledge. Is that the way you view this? To me it's been a discussion of some pretty important functional issues around plane performance. It's a learning opportunity. I've learned quite a bit during this thread and gained a much clearer perspective on the knowledge I did have. I really value this, it's what makes following woodworking forums worth the time I invest.





