Re: bevel up plane/retailer question
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Can someone provide a list of the possible disadvantes of purchasing a bevel up smoother instead of a traditional #4 smoother plane.
Hi Ray
I use both BU and BD planes, probably equally. I consider there are advantages and disadvantages, which I will try to outline as briefly as possible.
The one generalisation I will make is that BU planes offer the easiest way to obtain cutting angles at the extremes - low and high. Low cutting angles (such as 37 - 40 degrees) are preferred for planing endgrain (e.g. shooting boards) and crossgrain (e.g. when flattening a panel). High- to -very-high cutting angles (50 - 65 degrees) are preferred when planing hardwoods and interlocked grain. BU planes achieve the cutting angle off the blade's bevel, which means that a couple of blades will see you through here.
BD planes rule for me when it comes to sharpening. I prefer to sharpen freehand directly on a hollow grind, and then add a camber to the profile. This is not possible to do on BU blades with high bevel angles (one can do it with low cutting angles however). Basically, one needs to use (high) secondary microbevel on a low primary bevel when sharpening BU plane blades. This is extremely easy to do with a honing guide, but not possible when freehanding. Consequently I use a honing guide with all BU planes.
It is a testament to the exceptional performance and ease of use of BU planes that I use them. My preference would otherwise be a BD woodie, sans adjuster. These I could just removes the blade when it dull, swipe it freehand over a stone, and back to work .... not because I am rushing to meet a deadline; rather because I am single-minded (!) and find the intrusion of sharpening a hassle.
Most of my BD planes have high bed angles. This is where the BD plane achieves its cutting angle. In my experience (which is not necessarily that of others), one of the advantages of BU planes is the low centre of gravity and effort, which makes for easier pushing. Given similar BU- and BD planes with the same cutting angles, the BU plane will be easier to push. Most BD planes, such as the Stanley-type, have a high centre of gravity and effort. There are some advantages to this in turns of developing a sense of the vertical, but that is for another day. To keep the centree of effort low, I prefer BD planes that are razee-shaped or low profile .. such as the HNT Gordon range.

I must emphasise that if you are not going pursue working with hardwoods, etc, then a standard angle plane (45 degrees) will do all that you want it to do. Here I am referring to the common Stanley-style plane.
There are other areas of debate in the BU-BD arena, such as edge holding and blade wear. We could get emotive here, and no doubt someone will raise it. My view is that this is a non-issue.
For someone starting out I consiuder a BU smoother, such as the LV LA Smoother, to be exceptional. It is easy to use, easy to adjust, and will bring a smile to your face since it almost ensures success. Both BU and BD planes have advantages and disadvantages when it comes to setting up a plane...
My re-handled LAS ...

The BU plane does not use a cap iron (chip breaker), which is frankly a pain in the wotsit to adjust on a BD plane. Both LV and LN make adjusters on their BU planes that offer very positive action with minimal backlash. BD Stanley-style planes, even the wonderfully built LNs, have more backlash than BU planes.
BD planes, such as the Stanley-style (not woodies or non-adjuster infills), typically have an easier ability to adjust the blade on-the-fly (since the lever cap is not typically used with as much downforce). This is a useful facility, but note that non-adjuster planes do not appear to be diminished by its absence.

I have done a few reviews on BU planes, generally comparing them against their equivalent BD version.
The first review I did was on a Stanley #62 I restored. I cannot believe that was only 6 1/2 years ago. BU planes have really taken off since then ... http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/Son%20of%20Stan%20or%20LV%20and%20its%20development%20of%20the%20Bevel%20Up%20Jack%20plane..html

Here are a couple of others:
http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/The%20Veritas%20Low%20Angle%20Smoothing%20Plane.html
http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/The%20Veritas%20Lee%20Valley%20Bevel%20Up%20Smoother.html
Regards from Perth
Derek (OK, that wasn't short at all!
)