We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
"Melting diamonds in glass would be a waste of diamonds. Only those exposed at the surface would be doing anything useful. Better to "melt" them in a thin layer of metal on a flat steel plate (AKA diamond "stones")".
You betcha! One only needs a thin layer of glass with suspended diamond fused to a thicker core. As a substrate, lead crystal works well for loose grit or paste. A block of well-annealed and flattened Gaffer 45% lead crystal holds and presents the diamond beautifully. Nice and heavy, too. Next time I cast some Gaffer frit I'll make you a block to try. Considering all the lead in it, it's probably a good idea to wash one's hands following a heavy session of swarf making and don't use vinegar or other acids to clean it. But heck, Romans used lead as a tasty sweetener -- defrutum was the Splenda of the ancient world.
You're right -- they are steel. Whether they are carbon steel I don't know.
But does it matter much whether they are steel or cast iron? Kanaban used with either carborundum powder or diamond paste will result in the abrasive particles embedding in the plate. I would imagine that cast iron will behave quite similarly. What advantage would cast iron have in this situation?
Who did a lecture about how fast a kimberlite pipe would have to erupt in order to move the diamonds from a stable P-T regime to the surface without having them revert to graphite. It was mind bogglingly impossible, and of course the moral of the lecture was that there was something missing from the equation - and 20 years later I can't remember what it was
These days I honestly think that the allure of diamonds is more generations of successful marketing than rarity. They're still rare, but I don't believe as rare as really good ruby or sapphire, and definitely not as rare as decent emerald. Aesthetically, I too prefer just about any good colored stone to diamond. I like opals, but frankly find their grading to be too arbitrary to really take seriously.
Funny, I had no idea John McPhee was an earth science writer until just last week when my wife remarked on this gap in my geological education (we're both geologists though neither of us work in that field any more). Serves me right for taking all the technical stuff I guess. I'd started reading one of his other books (the one about shipping) last month and found it rather hard to follow.
Plates made of crystalline stone tend to just grind up the diamond between the tool and the plate as there's little pore space in which the diamonds can accumulate. Though hard, diamonds are fairly brittle and do crush fairly easily.
I tried it with a spare black "granite" tile, figuring that was about the softest and most porous crystalline rock to try. It works, but you have to recharge more frequently than really seems right. I would hesitate to use anything as dense as a black arkansas stone.
It would be interesting though if you tried it Bill - I've never used diamond on cast iron, so have no basis for comparison. I've used diamond on copper laps a lot, but that's usually coarse stuff like 600 grit. The granite didn't work well compared to that, but may be fine compared to cast iron.
I have a friend with a fairly complete machine shop, I might suggest he make some plates and post them for sale. Any thoughts on a good size for a test batch? He has a gift for finding free material, so I'm assuming he could come up with some iron to try out.
"But does it matter much whether they are steel or cast iron?"
Very much so, in my opinion.
"I would imagine that cast iron will behave quite similarly. What advantage would cast iron have in this situation?"
Well, it has much to do with grain fineness and evenness, stability, steel's tendency to work harden when flattening, cast iron's ability to be flattened to astounding tolerances and ease of maintaining its flatness, and the evenly-distributed physically-available graphite content. Last but not least, the collective experience of thousands of machinists since the first great English iron surface and lapping plates were hand scraped that arguably made possible the Industrial Revolution bears witness to cast iron's superiority.
Anecdotally and more recently: "A couple of years ago I thought I'd give the poor old plate a well earned rest and salvaged a nice mild steel plate. It was horrible to use, as the tool and the powder dug into it. I was amazed that the cast iron was so much better. To find out more, I looked up my Machinery's Handbook and found that the best lapping plates are made from cast iron. It seems it was just dumb luck that I used cast iron. All this makes me wonder why more people don't use cast iron for their plates."
Is supposed to be in it's crystalline structure, which IIRC, is a non-homogeneous latticework of soft and hard material. The diamond sticks to and is embedded in the soft stuff, the hard keeps it flat under localized pressure (which can be high when doing something like polishing rock). Steel is much more homogeneous, and while it may work, it's not likely to work as well.
There's a guy who developed an alloy polishing lap that works similarly to cast iron, though is much softer. Cast iron really only polishes hard stone nicely, the alloy was developed for softer stones. For our purposes, cast iron's main advantage is it's fairly easy to find big flat pieces for cheap, at least for now. I would consider using copper also, maybe some un-etched pcb material glued to a board. No idea if the copper would be thick enough, but it might be worth a try.
"I would consider using copper also, maybe some un-etched pcb material glued to a board. No idea if the copper would be thick enough, but it might be worth a try."
Copper's going to be horrible! Oh well, just a thought.
Works ok on the coarse grits, but probably that's due to the coarseness of the grit holding the blade up away from the soft metal substrate. I've only used it on a blade a couple times, need for coarse lapping is rare.
As I understand it, kanaban do not by any special virtue excel at flattening backs of Japanese chisels and planes but are adequate for that purpose. Apparently they became popular well before diamond arrived on the scene and worked well enough with the widely available silicon carbide on the relieved backs of Japanese woodworking tools to gain acceptance. For flattening the entire back of a Western plane iron, one needs a certain amount of patience, but it's doable.
The Harris lapping system (iron plates) used 280-grit SiC for lapping backs and touching up nicked edges, and it was damned fast, but their SiC, as described in the Garrett Wade catalog, was sharper and blockier than the norm (back in the '80s). I still have a few ounces of that stuff. Maybe I'll compare it to what I generally use now.
Next time I'm in the surplus store in Albuquerque I'm going to look for some pcb material, they get lots of good stuff from Sandia.
Need an extra 325 lap? I was going to replace my 600 with a new copper lap, and then accidentally charged it with 325, so now I have two. Ten years ago I could have used a spare, but I do so little cutting any more that it's not worth it.
In Bill's article (in the Woodcentral Article section) on loose diamond sharpening he suggests that plexiglass is another substrate that can be used (at least with more course grits) I wonder if anyone, including you Bill, have any further experience with this or other substrates. Thanks -Howard
I gave Plexiglas and at least one other plastic a try and didn't like them. There was a grabby quality to them that made it hard to keep a consistent angle when freehanding and when I used a jig I only pulled the blade toward me to avoid having it dig into the plexi. Since I have cast iron available I didn't spend much time trying to make any of the plastics work better.
I've also had much better experience with gray cast iron than with a steel kanaban and some other surface-ground annealed steel I've tried.
The never-ending search for that perfect polish *LINK*
David Barnett
Plexiglass (acrylic) has fairly wide use as a lapping substrate. While I favor other laps, plexi works for hand sharpening, preparation of scientific specimens for microscopy and spectrographic analysis, and for faceting/polishing gemstones. One drawback of rotating acrylic laps for faceting is the heat generated with diamond. Using a thicker lap helps somewhat but I prefer other choices, other materials. You're not going to generate that kind of heat when hand sharpening, nor would it matter much, so give it a try. It works. I've used it. It feels somewhat erratic and a bit hard to use as smoothly as other lapping substrates.
Other laps and substrate materials I've tried and used with diamond (loose, compound, spray) and/or other abrasives: iron, zinc, tin, copper, acrylic, phenolic, sintered diamond over steel, plated diamond over steel and aluminum, wax, pitch, ceramic (with spray diamond, mylar (Spectra- and Ultra-laps), paper, BATT-laps, recycled remachined hard drive discs, recycled and remachined computer circuit boards (Dyna-Discs), Corian, Nu-Bond laps, cowhide and elk (with cerium oxide), reinforced resin over metal, pelletized epoxy matrix, polycarbonate, nylatron (filled with molybdenum disulfide lubricant powder), urethane, ebonite, canvas, oh... and wood. And I'm not the first to have tried any of them.
My advice? For sharpening, find a couple that work and stick with them. For faceting and polishing gems, keep looking.
For more about honing woodworking tools with plexiglass and diamond:
I suspect that many are using the Arkansas stones in a somewhat different manner than I. I use these stones to polish an edge that is already sharp and needs refinement. A stone that is freshly milled, or one that has been abraded will indeed cut much faster, but there is a corresponding drop in the stone's ability to polish the edge. As the stone is used the quality of the edge improves even as the ability of the stone to actually remove material is reduced. Introducing an abrasive to the surface, especially a really brash abrasive like diamond, will cause the stone to scratch the edge rather than polish. I think those who object is faster cutting would be much happier with a soft Arkansas or a Washita stone, than a Black or Translucent.
The best stuff to put diamond on for sharpening chisels and plane irons is cast iron. End of story. If you-all want to actually use this approach, as opposed to talk about it, just spend the effort to get a chunk of cast iron and carry it to your local machine shop to be turned into something flat and 12" long. Machine shops are not scary places to visit or deal with. Once you-all effortless slide a plane iron free-hand across the plate and watch 80 grit grinder scratches disappear before your eyes you will be left wondering, as I do, why someone isn't selling plates for this purpose. It is so easy free-hand honing on the plates, the steel tool edge sucks flat on the plate, even I can do it. Less time sharpening, more time woodworking.
In my experience, the best utility of diamond paste-powder is for final grinding at the 1 micron level. Anything coarser can best be done with a fixed diamond plate which are readily available. I suggest EZE-lap.com as the best source and you may be able to talk them into offering wholesale price. I make more wood stuff than most of you and it appears my extra-fine fixed diamond plate will last many years for chisel and plane sharpening with no maintenance.
If your needs are other than for practical tool sharpening as part of making stuff, I'm not a source of useful advice.
I'm sorry to be so dense, but looking at the posts I see none (including yours or Bill Houghton's who I think is the moderator) that has an email next to it. I also can't seem to find a way to get to a list of members. Thanks for your help. -Howard
Anyway, I ordered some 1 micron and .25 micron spray from them a while back and just yesterday tried it for the first time on a 2x72 Surgi-Sharp leather belt. Think there is way too much wobble in the belt (probably should have pre-conditioned the belt w/mineral oil or something... but didn't), but man does it work quickly! But it got me thinking... there has to be a better way... so, started searching for ideas last night. Ran across a recent thread @ SMC:
where he used a Worksharp 3K to hone using .5 micron (probably) chrome oxide to power hone/strop with pretty good initial results. He was/is jazzed about it anyway. So last night while trying to go to sleep... still thinking about it... I thought what about using psa mylar on a glass disc... shouldn't be too tough to cobble something like a Worksharp together... and just spray the diamond onto that. Wake up this morning... what about using a cast iron faceplate?... Grizzly has one pretty cheap:
H7821 Cast Iron Face Plate 6" x 1" x 8 TPI - $17.50
...your viewing and posting privileges are thus restricted. I just tested what I can see without a profile, and e-mails don't appear*.
If you establish a profile (see link below for instructions), you should be able to see e-mail addresses. One point not made clear in the instructions: because you've posted before, Wood Central's software will eagerly assume you want to use your same name/e-mail address as your profile name. The trouble is, this skips over the first two steps in establishing a profile - which are critical steps. So you need to delete Wood Central-related cookies (or all of them, if your browser isn't sophisticated enough to let you identify specific cookies) before proceeding.
A profile takes just a couple of minutes to establish.
*While I don't know this for sure, I think this is one of the protections Ellis built into the Wood Central software: online robots don't establish profiles, and this makes it hard/impossible for them to harvest e-mail addresses from Wood Central posts.
I totally agree, all talk on alternates aside, that iron is the best for sharpening woodworking tools by hand. I started with Harris plates but now I favor longer Meehanite (continuously cast grey iron) laps and hones, and more of them for more grit sizes. I also have some 6" x 1" thick rounds that are very useful for flattening (they stay put, too). But they were a pain to come by, even when metals were very cheap, so I'd say it's better to use diamond on something less than iron (at least at first) rather than to not use diamond at all. But that's me.
It won't matter to me personally, it would be nice to see someone offer properly machined laps at reasonable prices. Like you, I'm still somewhat amazed that someone hasn't taken up the gauntlet since Harris Tools quit making them.
"Machine shops are not scary places to visit or deal with."
I will have to say that some machine shops are far more helpful than others when it comes to preparing laps or machining plane sides and soles. Some machinists simply don't have the inclination or patience to work on such projects, so folks may need to shop around a bit -- I've heard about some real disappointments. It's like some veterinarian's are dog vets, some cat vets, and so on. But finding a good machinist is worth the effort.
" ...it appears my extra-fine fixed diamond plate will last many years for chisel and plane sharpening with no maintenance."
I'll second EZE-lap. My 600-grit stone is still going strong well into its second decade. However, when most folks think their stone's lost its mojo, I'm thinking it's finally breaking in.
But stop searching? For some, it's half the fun. For others, it's not even a choice. Why? "Because a fire was in my head."
Although as you've presented it here, I now better appreciate your terminology.
"As the stone is used the quality of the edge improves even as the ability of the stone to actually remove material is reduced."
Perhaps, unless and until it becomes glazed or the presented cutting edges of the quartz crystals become blunted by very hard modern alloy steels for which these stones do not excel.
"Introducing an abrasive to the surface, especially a really brash abrasive like diamond, will cause the stone to scratch the edge rather than polish."
You are correct that diamond will always leave scratches, although if a fine enough mesh diamond is employed, these will be very tiny scratches indeed, so tiny as not to cause surface and edge degradation when used for woodworking. A less aggressive finer-grit Arkansas stone will burnish away some of the obvious scratches left by coarser stones and this will improve cutting performance and edge longevity.
Much depends on the composition, grain and temper of the tool steel being honed, of course, and as you noted last November, Arkansas and Turkey stones are well matched to these less-doped steels. Such steel tools coming off a very fine hard Arkansas stone perform well. No argument.
Similarly, whether or not Beilby flow is real or imagined, stropping with chromium oxide does appear to further smooth and enhance even 1 micron diamond scratches, so I continue to keep a green horse butt bench hone within arms length.
"I think those who object is faster cutting would be much happier with a soft Arkansas or a Washita stone, than a Black or Translucent."
If Arkansas it is to be, than yes. Absolutely. But if faster cutting on harder, more heavily-alloyed steels are what you wish to sharpen, I'd still recommend diamond.
As for charging a hard translucent Arkansas stone with diamond, I certainly wouldn't recommend buying one for that purpose -- the good ones are anything but cheap, to be sure -- but would I charge one I already owned with diamond, especially if I was dissatisfied with its performance for whatever reason? You betcha. I'd probably try to sell it on eBay first, to someone who might better appreciate it's traditional virtues. That said, I still keep mine for freehand honing gravers and some older carving tools.