We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Aluminum plates are readily available for faceting laps, 8" diameter is most common, but 6" is also available. Usually a 1/2" hole. Many cutting laps are just a steel disk on one of these plates, I've popped the steel off and cleaned up the aluminum to use as a backing plate before. I probably have a few around if you'd like to mess around with this.
I bought and was about to try mylar as a substrate when I realized there was nothing left for me to improve. So I quit the quest to find a more convenient/effective substrate.
********Again, the screaming limitation of using cheap loose diamonds is that you are limited to using only one size due to carry over and contamination of the next substrate(see above discussion). If someone wants to do useful research , explore a way to remove this limitation. *********
So, the next logical step in thinking is to decide where is the most effective place to use cheap loose diamonds. I concluded it was the last step in sharpening, namely 1 micron. (If there is a reason to go smaller in practical woodworking I haven't found it.) Steel glides effortlessly over cast iron charged with 1 micron diamond and a bit of WD 40. On everything else I tried the steel does NOT glide effortlessly over the substrate using 1 micron diamond. So, that was the end of the story for me. I have enough issues with free-hand honing without grabby substrates to contend with.
Diamond embeds and cuts rapidly in hard plastic, soft metals, wood, and probably lots of stuff. The counter top installers rounded over my granite (actually gneiss) tops with an angle grinder and a rubber wheel charged with 100 micron diamond. Took but seconds. These applications may be useful for your grinding needs, but they aren't for mine.
Diamond cuts so fast the powered honing doesn't make any sense to me. You all should know how lazy I am and quick to use a power tool when I can. So when I say powered honing isn't necessary, take notice. It does not take long to grind the hollow out of a hollow ground tool hand honing on a 1 micron cast iron plate. It would take seconds with a powered device, too fast for my control.
I have charged aluminum cylinders with 30 micron diamond powder and had at concave surfaces such as gouges. Mounted in a drill press they cut rapidly, vastly more so than hand held slips.
These are the easiest shapes to find in stock almost anywhere that sells cast iron. Rounds (cylinders) are continuously cast in all sorts of large sizes and a disk can be simply sliced off the stock cylinder pieces. It was rectangles that we had trouble finding because rectangles of a small size can not be continuously cast. They must be poured/cast or sawed from larger sizes.
How hard would it be to cast one's own rectangles? The raw material is readily available from any junk yard. What would it take to melt the material, and in what?
I was thinking of use as a plate for psa mylar that he was talking about rather than direct charging, I just forgot to write that part down - working nights this week my head isn't really functioning efficiently
Iron pours are becoming a big thing at larger blacksmith gatherings and even at some of the community colleges that offer metal working instruction.If you want things cast those are the places I`d look first.
Why cast at all when there`s so much cast around in close to ideal form already?
What size piece do you want? I`ve been collecting cast tables from WWing machines thrown away at the dump for a while now.I finally have some tooling that`ll cut it with decent results.A diamond saw blade in a worm drive skillsaw works as good for cast as it does for stone counter tops.Ironic eh,diamond cutting something for diamond.
"These are the easiest shapes to find in stock almost anywhere that sells cast iron. Rounds (cylinders) are continuously cast in all sorts of large sizes and a disk can be simply sliced off the stock cylinder pieces."
I like rounds for lapping and they're easily got and now I know why round is cheaper than other cast iron stock. MSC sells 6" x 1" circles for $22.22 each. As I recall, they cost $6 or $8 each when I bought mine (long ago, heh).
I made my first laps the old way, ground them (they came fairly rough), then hand scraped them, checking with prussian blue against a surface plate, and lastly, lapping them against one another in sequence to final tolerance. I did two sets this way and it was a thoroughly enjoyable cabin fever project for the long New England winter.
Probably better to buy them, have them Blanchard ground and then lap them to spec by hand, though, as it'll save a buttload of time and effort. Anyway, that's one way to get some laps for not a lot of money.
As for rectangles, I don't know about remelting and casting iron into lap-sized rectangles, but it sounds like fun.
MSC sells cast iron rectangles in a convenient 3" x 1" x 36" size for $122.27 each, which would yield three nice laps of 12" length -- six if you use both sides, pretty good at that price considering what the shorter Harris laps went for way back. My homemade rectangular laps are 3/4" thick. That extra 1/4" wouldn't hurt a bit.
What a fun vacation! A great area of the United States to be in and "diamond mining" too! I made many pieces of jewelry with them. People couldn't believe that i got them myself.
I�m very happy with the cast iron lapping plates I got by buying 1/4� oversized stock from McMaster-Carr. I got the 5 x 24� size and had it Blanchard ground on both sides for about $70. I then cut it into six plates with finished dimensions of 5/16 x 2-1/2 x 8� using a hack saw and considerable patience. That comes to less than $30 each, less that a typical waterstone.
I like the thinner size�in fact I first bought 3/8� stock (1/2� thick in its original bandsawn condition) and decided to go for something lighter and less bulky. My first laps were from Harris Tool and they seemed wider than necessary (at 3�) and very heavy.
Blanchard grinding leaves a distinctive pattern of circular scratches but I�ve found it�s not necessary to remove the scratches to have the lap work well. I did a little work on a coarse waterstone to make sure there weren�t any high points on the cast iron, but very little work was needed.
The lapping plates from Harris Tool were described as ductile cast iron and they have a different feel from the gray cast iron ones I made. I like the gray cast iron better. In use it seems crisper and less gummy for some reason.
My preferred sharpening method is similar to Bill Tindall�s�grinding to remove the old edge, then one grit of diamond at a slightly higher angle to give the cutting edge its sharpness. I have a lapping plate with one side dedicated to 3 micron diamond which I seldom use, the other side dedicated to 1 micron or finer. I find 1 micron to be about right in the tradeoff between cutting speed and final edge quality.
David, thanks for the info... just ordered a couple 6" rounds, thanks to you. Literally today, I found a local distributor for "Dura-Bar", got a quote of ~$65 for a 6" round and ~$85 for an 8 incher. I passed.
I remember talking to someone across town about having something blanchard ground last summer, gonna have to find that # and give them a ring. Hoping it will be just a tad more time after that w/sandpaper on a surface plate. Still kicking around the idea of mounting my new rounds on a faceplate connected to the headstock of an old pole lathe that I have, then running it with a treadmill motor. Just like the idea of that for some reason... Thanks again for the tip(s).
Under $30 per plate is a terrific price. I've tried lapping with plates straight from the Blanchard but prefer smoother, especially for small width chisels, flat gravers, and the like. Scored and otherwise textured laps work, of course, and I routinely use scored laps in gem faceting. I do think that lapping them flatter than they come off the Blanchard (which will get them to .001" or better) is still worth the effort for applications more demanding than sharpening chisels and plane blades.
I personally prefer the thicker plates as it gives me room to curl my two outer fingers underneath the blade I'm flattening. I also like the extra heft of the longer 12" laps but mine don't have to be moved about -- 8" works just fine. The Harris plates were 8".
"The lapping plates from Harris Tool were described as ductile cast iron and they have a different feel from the gray cast iron ones I made. I like the gray cast iron better. In use it seems crisper and less gummy for some reason."
My Harris plates were gray iron rather than ductile, I was told. They were always described as double-annealed and gray cast-iron in all the ad copy and literature from Harris that I've seen. The rep I met from Harris at Garrett Wade (or a ww-ing show from Garrett Wade -- I forget), extolled on the virtues of gray cast iron, from my recollection. Did they change them? I have to wonder.
"My preferred sharpening method is similar to Bill Tindall�s�grinding to remove the old edge, then one grit of diamond at a slightly higher angle to give the cutting edge its sharpness."
Pretty good method, I'd say. I'm kinda in that camp, too. Got my slow-speed 7" Baldor in the mid '90s and just love it. I've also adopted Bill's use of narrow grinding wheels for most work. Excellent results. Thanks, Bill!
As for most sharpening, I use 8000 grit after the hollow grind followed by 14000 -- depends on the steel and the tool. On carving tools and when I'm chiseling something finicky, I'll strop, as well.
My Harris plates were bought on sale through a third-party vendor and the description at that time was ductile iron. Several years later I checked the Harris website and saw their description as gray cast iron, if I recall correctly. I considered ordering another smooth plate to see if it was different, but at the price they were asking I decided against it.
The flatness tolerance was supposed to be .0002" but the smooth plate I got was nowhere near that flat. I was able to get it plenty flat enough using a coarse waterstone but it took a lot of fussing around.
I agree that the Blanchard grind (or any other scored surface) won't be good with narrow tools. I use my lapping plate almost exclusively for plane blades. For chisels I still like waterstones, especially for the harder carbon steel in Japanese blades. That's a combination of steel and stone that's hard to beat.
Yeah, Duro-Bar is pricey and I wouldn't even know which of their gray irons would be the most suitable.
If you decide to go the sandpaper route, choose a sandpaper that resists stretching and deformation and make sure it's glued evenly with the thinnest film of adhesive you can achieve. Even with precautions you may get some edge dubbing, although if it's kept minimal that'll be fine. You should lightly chamfer the edge, anyway, so you don't cut yourself when using the lap.
If it tests reasonably even off your surface plate (Dykem, prussian blue, etc.), and it probably will, then it's ready for sharpening. You don't even have to remove all the blanchard marks.
However, in the unlikely event you're not satisfied with its flatness, just want to refine your technique or OCD suddenly kicks in, consider hand scraping with a machinist's scraper; homemade from an old file is just fine. This goes faster than you might think and I used to find it a relaxing way to spend the evening. But then I'll occasionally facet a gem to competition standards for the pure fun of it.
If you mount it to your lathe, I'd suggest fairly low rpms, at least until you know it's balanced and secure. Rotary lapping works, even horizontally. Concentric circles, a progressive spiral, radial grooves all work for swarf removal. Hand laps are most often grooved with squares or diamonds.
Like they say on Myth Busters- "Don't Do It, Ever"!
Presuming your Blanchard grinding is equivalent to what we have had done there is no practical room for improvement. Further diddling runs the risk of leaving them less flat and/or embedded with contaminating grits. It is not a practical problem if only 99% of the plate is touching the chisel edge because the plate is "only" flat to 0.001" or it has some deep scratches.
If the goal is something other than getting a chisel sharp for getting on with making stuff then ignore my advice for it may not be relevant to your needs.
Note that Elliot is a professional woodworker and while I am not, I do spend a lot of time making stuff. We have each independently arrived at the same place for how to best use diamond abrasives and what stuff is needed to use them. If your goals are practical this is a good place to start.
Someone recently commented that it made them want to pound their head whist reading about other's approach to sharpening. At the time I didn't understand; now I want to pound my head.
There is utterly no need for steps 2,3 and 4 and oil is not the lube to use on a fixed diamond plate. Where does this stuff come from!?!
Like I once said, you have to be different to get published. Not best or even better, just different.
Posting something like that after giving all that fine advice about sharpening with links to sources for diamonds and various backing materials is just not right.
You may very well be a genius but if you are then you`re an evil genius.
Thanks for hooking us,reeling us in and then clubbing us once you have us in the boat there Cap`n Dave.
... you oughta see how he makes the donuts!" moment, Bob?
"You are a very bad man!"
Qui, moi?
Well, you got me. I was sorta holding that back, keeping it in mind, saving and savoring it, letting it ripen. It's all timing.
Hey, sharpening is where you can really bring out the esoterica, the elitely mandarin, the perverse personal methodological idiosyncratica:
"Then I strop the incannel bevel with a monocrystalline-diamond-charged-mummified-onyx-handled-baby-tapir's-snout that's been soaked in vintage Mazola oil used only once to deep-fry lark's tongues preserved in aspic."
That sort of thing.
"Thanks for hooking us,reeling us in and then clubbing us once you have us in the boat there Cap`n Dave."
I know someone who has one and he likes it, but for flattening the backs of chisels and plane irons, not fine honing. The swarf channels are quite wide to accommodate coarser SiC grit, which isn't a bad thing, but he does prefer and now has a smooth plate for finer honing up to 1 micron. One can, and he does use a broad range of grits on a single stone, which is a common practice with widely grooved laps and silicon carbide -- not with diamond, of course.
I particularly like the generous thickness of this lap. At 1 1/8" there's adequate clearance for chisel handles and for the fingers to support the tool during lapping. It's not cheap, no, but it's not overly expensive for what it is and what it does. Interesting design, although I do prefer a tighter, shallower diaper pattern.
Very well, Bill, your research is well taken. Now where to get this cast iron plate. I've called 3 machine shops here in Peoria (home office for Caterpiller) and none had any of this though one had a small piece of ductile iron which I don't think is suitable). Thanks for you input in all; this has been a great thread. Tom.
If you can't find gray iron scrap on SW Adams, there's no more left in Peoria. Take a hunk of something that looks like it wants to become a lap to your machine shop. Better still, drive on down 24 to Illini Foundry in Bartonville. They'll know what you're talking about, Tom.