New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Tried using diamond paste on stones... *LINK*

Posts

Tried using diamond paste on stones... *LINK*

#1

Tried using diamond paste on stones... *LINK*

John Aniano in Central NJ

A few weeks (months ?) ago, our own Dave Barnett told us all about using diamond paste on sharpening stones - something he found mentioned on page 32 of the Norton catalog on their website (see link below). Yesterday, I flattened the back and sharpened up a tiny Veritas plane blade (the mini shoulder plane). My trusty soft and hard white Arkansas stones, ones I had flattened about a year ago, were the test subjects. I first tried flattening the blade back on the plain soft stone (no diamond) and it worked as it always had - slowly. I then wiped a tiny bit of 1 micron diamond paste on the stone and wow, did it ever cut! Black swarf showed up on the stone in a swipe or two, showing me that lots of material was being removed, and after a few dozen more swipes, the back was almost a mirror finish! Way better than the stone alone, WAY BETTER!! The hard Arkansas stone with the diamond paste wipe was equally amazing - it also cut quite quickly and took only a few more passes to get the back finished. Focusing on the bevel, a few swipes on both stones made the edge shine.

This is a method everyone should try at least once - I'm convinced! Thank you Dave!!

Incidentally, with such a sharp blade the little plane cut well, but was a bit of a pain to hold: I thought the side hole edges could have been better relieved (or eliminated). I'm used to using tiny planes for making bows, but planing a slot in ebony was tough on the fingers- maybe a topic for another day...


Norton Catalog - see pg 32 "Diamond Lapping"

Re: Tried using diamond paste on stones... *LINK*

#2

David Barnett

Pleased as punch this worked for you, John. *LINK*

David Barnett

I sometimes worry that I come off a bit evangelistic. It does work. At any rate, you're in good company, I must say. Amazing how many lurkers WoodCentral must have and how quickly these things disseminate across the internet. We are truly blessed.

Over the years, I've had the good fortune to correspond (on this and other subjects) with art conservators, museum curators and document restorers from Egypt, the Vatican, the Hermitage, the Brit to the Getty. WoodCentral's Sam Simpson introduced me to several incredibly talented restoration professionals and academics throughout the world (my God, he knew everyone, I think), and literally catapulted my contacts and knowledge to levels I barely knew existed.

By the way, I've been pondering a cast glass stone with the feel of quarried Arkansas chert but with the cutting action of friable diamond. I've got the kiln, got the glass frit and got the diamond. But apparently the world's gonna end in 2012AD, so screw it.

Until then, though, the next time I slab and flatten some of my favorite jasper, I'll save a slice for you. I'm serious. That's one awesome final polish with a spritz of spray diamond or a spot of 0.5 micron paste. Adjust those electrons in the valence shell to get the precise cutting action you prefer.


Deglazing Oil Stones -- 10/29/2010

Re: Tried using diamond paste on stones... *LINK*

#3

Re: Tried using diamond paste on stones...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Hip-hip-hooray, I get to use that old black Arkansas for something besides Jack's razors. Many thanks, guys.

Pam

Re: Tried using diamond paste on stones... *LINK*

#4

Re: Tried using diamond paste on stones...

Kevin Adams

Thanks, John. I am also interested in trying this, but just haven't had a chance yet. So you used the 1 micron on both your soft and your hard stones? I was thinking of going a little coarser (3 micron) on the softer stone and use the 1 micron on the hard. I also had a concern about putting any diamond paste on the soft ark and I believe David cautioned on that, too (given it's softer nature). You didn't notice any issues with the soft stone after applying the diamond?

Thanks for the report. I do need to try this now!

Kevin

Re: Tried using diamond paste on stones... *LINK*

#5

Re: Pleased as punch this worked for you, John.

John Aniano in Central NJ

Dave,

As for your idea to embed diamonds into a cast glass block...

In a former life, I was a ceramic engineer! I would guess that the addition of the diamond might, just might, cause the whole glass melt to crystallize as it cools. Something about nucleation sites in a glass melt - I won't bore you with the details I would have to dig out from my old notes. I might be wrong, but often impurities that are not readily soluble in the glass matrix, like I would expect diamond to be, can cause nucleation to occur. This does depend on the rate of cooling, though. Not that nucleation is a bad thing for your purposes, the resulting polishing "stone" would just not be transparent, but milky colored or opaque. It would still grind/polish steel, if the diamonds were truly homogeneously dispersed in the cast glass block.

I look forward to trying the jasper! Again, too bad we only have one year left to try this, but who's counting?...

Thanks,

John

Re: Tried using diamond paste on stones... *LINK*

#6

Re: Tried using diamond paste on stones...

John Aniano in Central NJ

Kevin,

I could only find my tube of 1 micron diamond paste to try that day, so I used it on both stones. I misplaced the other two coarser grits... As for the 1 micron grit on the soft Arkansas stone - I can always re-flatten it if it became too deformed due to it's softness.

I do have to get a tube of the 0.5 micron and lower grit pastes if they are readily available. But then again, for most of the bow making work I do, the edge I get off a 1200 grit diamond stone is often sufficient. Having a sharper edge off of these diamond -charged Arkansas stones will be a real plus and a time saver (not having to get out the 4000 grit waterstone and water, etc.).

John

Re: Tried using diamond paste on stones... *LINK*

#7

Can you melt diamond in glass?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Diamond, it appears, burns in air around 848 deg. Celsius, which is half the temp needed to melt glass (1500 deg. Celsius), although it doesn't melt until 3550 deg. Celsius.

Would there be an issue with the diamond flaring off as the glass was poured?

bill, no kind of engineer

Re: Tried using diamond paste on stones... *LINK*

#8

Re: Can you melt diamond in glass?

John Aniano in Central NJ

Bill,

I would strongly doubt that the diamond particles would vaporize, combust or otherwise disappear. But then again, never having specifically read about or experimented with diamonds in molten glass, all bets are off.

John

Re: Tried using diamond paste on stones... *LINK*

#9

If there were no available oxygen...

John in NM

There would be no problem, though you would have to make sure that they wouldn't turn into graphite - diamonds are metastable at atmospheric pressure.

Re: Tried using diamond paste on stones... *LINK*

#10

Caution!

Bill Tindall

It is rewarding to see sharpening with diamonds catching on......slowly. I recently found May May, professional carver, sharpening her carving tools with diamond.

The problem with using an ARK stone for a substrate is that it is an expensive substrate and the sizes are inconveniently small. Once one gets used to long sweeps across a 12" piece of cast iron it would be hard to settle for anything smaller. BTW, If the diamond is doing its job the stone will never need flattening.

Grinding with loose diamond has one significant limitation. You can only use one grit. Fortunately you did not discover your coarser grits or one of your stone would be compromised.

Ideally the diamond embeds in the substrate where it is immobile as the steel passes across the particles. However, even in cast iron the particles are not permanently embedded and some stick into the scratches in the steel. If one grinds with coarse diamond on one substrate followed by grinding with a smaller diamond on a second substrate, this second substrate will become contaminated with the coarser particles carried over in the steel. This phenomena is not newly discovered by me. I found reference to it in a machinist manual dated in the '40s. So even 60 years ago metal workers knew the advantages of grinding hard steels with diamond. (The manual said that some of the particles embedded in the steel would be removed by swiping the steel over something softer, like copper or aluminum?)

I have solved this problem as follows. I hollow grind on a grinder. One can go directly from this operation to 1 micron on cast iron but I never get the edge perfectly straight off the grinder. So, I follow hollow grinding with "edge straightening" on a 12" long "extra fine" fixed diamond plate. This operation is then followed by honing on cast iron charged with 1 micron diamond....which works just fine for practical woodworking.

By the time I decide to resharper the 1 micron is insufficient to remove enough metal in a reasonable amount of time to grind away the "dead" edge. So, I start with the extra fine plate followed by 1 micron.

Melting diamonds in glass would be a waste of diamonds. Only those exposed at the surface would be doing anything useful. Better to "melt" them in a thin layer of metal on a flat steel plate (AKA diamond "stones").

I remain boggled as to why no one is selling cast iron plates for diamond sharpening. I am in correspondence with a diamond plate manufacturing company about the possibility of offering a fixed diamond plate coated with 1 micron diamond particles to be used for sharpening.

Re: Tried using diamond paste on stones... *LINK*

#11

There's a great line in one of John McPhee's books

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

in which he learns about, as he puts it, the narrow thermodynamic shelf on which diamonds sit, and how easily a temperature change can alter the crystalline structure. He then goes into a lyrical paragraph about diamonds, the symbol of eternal love, and so on - all the DeBeers advertising lines from the last century - and closes with a reference to diamonds "yearning to be fresh pencil lead."

Re: Tried using diamond paste on stones... *LINK*

#12

Never saw the allure

Bob Hackett

The only interest diamonds have ever held for me have been in an industrial sense.I like how they cut stuff.

There are so many other more interesting rocks out there starting with Opals and moving thru the spectrum of colors from amethyst to Rainbow Obsidian.

I just never saw why diamonds were such a big deal and am glad my wife feels the same way.She`d rather have a natural enhydo Herkimer Diamond than a fancy faceted thing from DeBeers.Give her a cabochon of Moonstone,Labradorite or Pietersite if you want to impress her.

Somebody help me pick David up off the floor please!?

Re: Tried using diamond paste on stones... *LINK*

#13

Re: Caution!

Howard Pollack

Bill- I've been in the process of experimenting with your method (outlined in the Articles section of this forum) of diamond sharpening, using both plexiglass and the back of a groved cast iron lapping plate that I picked up off of ebay. So far the method seems very promising to me. One advantage is that it gets around the bucket of water and ongoing flattening issues that pertain to waterstones. I'd love to find a source for cast iron plates, say 3"x12", but I've not been able to find one yet. If you know of how to get those plates I'd love to know. Also I'd be most interested in the one micron plate you're talking about. Thanks for your efforts. -Howard

Re: Tried using diamond paste on stones... *LINK*

#14

Re:Herkimer diamonds.. slightly OT

George in snowy Lowell, Mich.

Bob,

Your mention of the diamonds reminded me of the time in the 70's when I drove from Michigan to Herkimer. NY. I broke open boulders and "mined" a double handful of the unique "diamonds". What a great adventure! Later I found out that my ancestors lived near there before going to fun filled Lowell,Mich.

George

Re: Tried using diamond paste on stones... *LINK*

#15

Re: source for cast iron plate

George in snowy Lowell, Mich.

Howard,

I bought a 1" x 3 or 4"" x 36 " piece from Mc Master Carr. I cut it in half to 18" pieces and have a piece I would like to get rid of. If interested email me.

George

Re: Tried using diamond paste on stones... *LINK*

#16

Re: source for cast iron plate

Howard Pollack

I'd love to send you that email, but I can't figure out how to find an email address or private message on this forum... -Howard

Re: Tried using diamond paste on stones... *LINK*

#17

Re: source for cast iron plate

George in snowy Lowell, Mich.

Howard

I thought my address was on the posting.

agap015@aol.com

George

Re: Tried using diamond paste on stones... *LINK*

#18

like these.....

Bill Tindall

collected in 1968 at the heyday of finding big pockets of crystals. White foam is 1 1/4" square. I grew up near the location


Re: Tried using diamond paste on stones... *LINK*

#19

David Barnett

OT - devitrification, nucleation - longish & techy

David Barnett

John,

"I would guess that the addition of the diamond might, just might, cause the whole glass melt to crystallize as it cools. Something about nucleation sites in a glass melt. ... I might be wrong, but often impurities that are not readily soluble in the glass matrix, like I would expect diamond to be, can cause nucleation to occur. This does depend on the rate of cooling, though."


You do know your stuff. Thanks for discussing this.

Fortunately, I'm quite familiar with devitrification and the strategies for its avoidance. As for the nucleation, defeating that has to occur in pretty much the same steps and in the same firing schedule.

As an art glass caster, I routinely crash my kiln from fusing temperatures to the annealing range, which avoids most of the problem, something I can do on a small scale that would be unfeasible for industrial producers. Rather hard on the firebricks and the moulds, of course, but moulds are usually single-fire, so no big deal as long as they don't crack before the glass chills. At least the door refractory is alumino-silicate fibre.

For fusers, some devit may still occur, which appears as a scummy crust. Some opt for additives, others cold-work it away as best they can. As a caster, I must avoid it altogether -- extensive cold working would remove detail. Also, my work is generally much thicker but may vary widely within the same piece, and flows into the moulds rather than merely slumping so the annealing/cooling profiles demand a very different firing schedule from sheet glass fusing.

While you're correct that inclusions would precipitate crystallization (glass artists tend to call it devit) at batching and blowing temperatures, the max temps for fusing glass frits, often finely ground to a powdered stage in p�te de verre, allow longer soaks at lower temperatures which lets inclusions to remain suspended. It's more the total amount of heat work over time, as you know, than max temperature reached. So it may be possible to fuse a layer incorporating the suspended diamond to the thicker core, minimize the migration of the diamond, and anneal (or re-anneal) into a solid block. As long as the COE (coefficient of expansion) of both layers is dead-on equal, there should be little problem.

As I do this in PDV (my passion) all the time, it should present no problems to me. All my soda-lime frits are tested Bullseye COE 90, Uroboros 96, or Gaffer 45% Pb crystal at COE 92.

Is it a great idea? Probably not. Is it needed? Probably not. Am I curious? Always, so now I'm getting all interested in this again, heh, and I simply must not get derailed. Damned ADD. I do so love this stuff, though. Oh... and please don't feel the need to respond to this unedited verbiage -- I roasted coffee this morning and obviously drank way too much. So much to do. So little time (well... according to Babylonian-Assyrian and Mayan calendricists).

David (who's building an electromelt furnace to batch glass from raw elements).

[tenuous ancillary woodworking content: PDV makes great box top inserts and cabinet pulls]

Re: Tried using diamond paste on stones... *LINK*

#20

why sources of blanks are hard to find

Bill Tindall

I was told that most cast iron "bar stock" is continuously cast and that something as thin as we prefer is impossible to cast. What we did was to buy thicker bar stock and have a machine shop saw it in half, then Blanchard grind one side level. There was economy of scale to this quest as many plates could be ground at one time.

If ARK stones work then there are vastly cheaper sources of "similar" rock, your local kitchen counter store. Ours throws away truck loads of back splash ends, 1 to 6' long, free for the asking. There is very little steel surface bearing on the surface of the rock so I would argue these are level enough, if indeed they are not near perfectly level. Hundreds of varieties of rock are used for counter tops from soft marble to hard quartzite with mineralization from soft calcite through harder feldspar to quartz, the primary component of ARK stones. Some experimentation with this free source should yield something equivalent to ARK stones and in a size more convenient. By equivalent I mean equivalent to embedding diamonds into, not equivalent to used alone. I don't know why ARK stones work where as other rock does not work for honing but I'll bet there is folklore on the topic and perhaps some science. It is hard to imagine that a ceramic equivalent to ARK stones isn't known.

Re: Tried using diamond paste on stones... *LINK*

#21

David Barnett

You might be surprised... *LINK*

David Barnett

... but I'm with you when it comes to most faceted diamonds. They're generally too cold and lifeless (which does have its place, however) when compared to their natural counterparts. A natural rough diamond maccle and many cubes capture the light so it appears to move around within the stone like a living entity, which is what fascinated diamond lovers long before cutting became the thing.

I don't cut diamonds and I rarely use them. I cut color, as they say in the trade, and I not only facet with geometrically precise machines (which does enhance brightness), but I freehand facet (sometimes with curves) and carve, which really lets me play with the light and often enhances color, as well. I go for gems with a more natural and ancient look, which complements the Mycenaean, Hellenic, Etruscan and Egyptian designs and techniques from which I draw my inspiration.

But such stones also look great in hypermodern and minimalist designs, as well, which is my other side. So give me beryl, topaz, sapphire, tourmaline -- I almost forgot tourmaline -- even colored quartz or your favorite feldspars over diamond anyday. And for uncolored faceted stones, I'd rather use white sapphire, silver topaz, or stunning birefringent zircon (a natural stone -- not CZ) as white stones in my designs.

Who cares if diamonds are forever? Bah! As I've said before, if the Babylonian-Assyrian and Mayan calendricists are right, and of course they are, we'll be toast by the end of 2012 AD, anyway.

So, you and who else can pick me up off the floor, Bob? You buddies with Magnus Ver Magn�sson?


Rough, uncut and so many colors

Re: Tried using diamond paste on stones... *LINK*

#22

Would you recommend slate,Bill?

Bob Hackett

The reason I ask is I have quite a few drops of honed finish slate.

All the drops of other counter top stone are polished to a mirror finish and I would think that might impede the diamond taking hold.

I`m using dry 1/2 micron diamond dust BTW.

Re: Tried using diamond paste on stones... *LINK*

#23

Cast iron plates for diamond sharpening

wilbur

These plates do exist. In Japan, cast iron plates called kaneban are used for this purpose. They were originally used with silicon carbide grit, but many people get excellent results using diamond grit paste on them as well. Hida Tool, Japan Woodworker, and Tools for Working Wood all sell them.

Re: Tried using diamond paste on stones... *LINK*

#24

I thought these were carbon steel?

Bill Tindall

Re: Tried using diamond paste on stones... *LINK*

#25

David Barnett

Last I checked...

David Barnett

Wilbur,

... JW and Hida only carried steel flattening plates, which lack the free graphite found in grey cast iron which makes it act rather differently, in my experience. By the way, ductile iron often has cerium oxide and/or magnesium added to diminish graphite formation, which embrittles grey cast iron but helps it do what it does so well when you lap with it.

David