Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Help with ideas

Posts

Re: Help with ideas

#26

How about

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Regarding the spring-and-catch method: how about a button on the shelf above the drawer that, when pushed, releases a catch, as per the highly professional mechanical drawing below?


It would need more attention than this: you need to "ramp" the release, so the catch will push it down as the drawer closes. I would also be concerned that a spring pushing from the back could cause the drawer to rack as it attempted to open. Whether two springs, one each side, or a single spring in the center would best prevent this, I'm not sure. Some experimentation might be needed.

You would also need to notch the back of the drawer to permit removal with the latch mechanism in place.

However, you could make the springy part of the catch from a flexible hardwood like oak, then shave it until the springiness was just balanced. One or both parts of the catch could be sheet brass, bent to fit (your hardware store will have hobby brass sheet in multiple thicknesses).

Properly done, this would be something easily released, which would then push the drawer far enough forward to be pulled open.

The button, and the hole in the shelf, need a shoulder, to keep the button from coming out the top - the spring latch keeps it from coming out the bottom.

My initial assumption was that the button would be round (easiest to make), but you could, actually, make it a triangle or a pentagon, shaped in harmony with the front of the shelf.

Boy, it's so much fun to speculate about other people's work...way easier than actually doing the work.

Re: Help with ideas

#27

Re: Help with ideas

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hello Kevin,

Thanks for your comments and questions. I know it's hard to tell very much from these photos. I'll get better photos later, so you can see what's going on. This is a wall cabinet adapted from one that Mr. Krenov shows in The Impractical Cabinetmaker, p. 145. The whole cabinet is quartered Ceylon satinwood that I collected from Gilmer over a period of years. I used a bandsaw for most of the resawing (to get a desired thickness), and everything else is handtools.

Construction. I followed the hints that Krenov shows in his book, but will mention a couple of things that might help someone else. On these cases, you're making a door, and then fitting a box behind it. The door comes first. In making one of these V-shaped doors, it's very helpful to use thick veneer, like 1/4" for the rails, in quartered material. First off, the look of the case calls for straight grain, rather than cathedrals or swirling grain. Veneering quartered wood helps with that. Second, on these v-shaped doors, it is a bear to cut a rebate into solid--I did that on an earlier attempt (http://www.traditionaltools.us/cms/index.php?name=coppermine&file=displayimage&album=69&pos=0), and vowed not to do it again. If you use 1/4" veneer to face the door rails, you can create the rebate as you glue-up. The v-shaped inner core is satinwood, and was roughed out by bandsaw, then planed to accept the veneer. The rest of the case is solid. The main thing I would like to get across is that if anyone is planning one of these pieces, you want to create all rebates by use of thick veneers, in order not to leave yourself a very nasty job of cutting a rebate into a weird-shaped stick.

The only difficult moment making the door is when you're joining those two 1/4" veneer pieces, which are mitered to form the V in front. You want that join to disappear. What you do is save the waste blanks that you cut the inner core of the rails from--those blanks, placed on your shooting board, will let you shoot the correct miters.

The back. In that previous case (see link above), I made a frame-and-panel, then screwed/plugged the panel into rebates in the top, bottom, and sides. I needed this case to be shallow, so to save every smidgen of interior space, I limited the back to a 1/4" of case space. This was done by using a solid 1/4" back (a glueup), with a 1/8" tongue on the front face, and chiselling out a 1/8" groove in top, bottom, and sides, located 1/8" in from the edge. So the back is hardwired in, floating in grooves in the case.

Glass. Nothing wrong with ordinary window glass from your local shop. But on this project, I used lightly textured German glass, offered by Bendheim in New Jersey. I can't recommend Bendheim highly enough. Extremely professional, and they did quite a bit of phone consultation with me to make sure I would be getting what I needed. I appreciated their effort, on both the door glass and the shelf glass.

Lock. I used a Lee Valley full mortise lock. But it turns out, you need a shorter key than what they provided. Or it will look weird. I found a pretty good key on-line (meaning a reasonably short shank), and was able to file the flag down to match the flag on the original key. If anyone needs details on this, just email me and I'll provide a link to that key.

The tray. The tray is formed of 5 thin pieces (1/8" sides and 3/16" front and back). These pieces are dovetailed at four corners, and the whole corral is glued into an 1/8" deep groove chiseled and scratched around the edge of the base. Then a cap is glued on top, and mitered at the corners. The apex of the tray has to come together in front without a visible seam--the front pieces are butted together, and I shaped a thin glue block to reinforce the joint. The cap piece also reinforces that butt-join. In principle, you could dovetail the apex, but then you have a wide ugly join which would have to be molded over--I thought it best to flow the grain across unbroken, and just reinforce the join.

Decent photos later. Thanks for your comments!

Wiley

Re: Help with ideas

#28

Contrasting pull mockup

wilbur

Hi Wiley,

Here's a mockup of what I would do. As nice as the drawer front is, I think that the case might benefit from the addition of a few contrasting elements. It is a jewelry case, after all, so you might as well make it fancy.

I'd add a small drawer pull in the middle that wraps around the V shaped front out of a contrasting wood, such as a dark rosewood or ebony. I'd also add a small lip/overhang to the profile of the drawer pull which will help with opening. Even if the pull is very thin from front to back, a slight lip will make it easy to use. Hopefully the picture will be clear enough.

I also tried having two pulls centered in the middle of each face of the V front drawer front, but I liked the look of this better, myself.

Almost forgot to mention: that's a really beautiful looking case, with or without pulls!

Hope this helps!

Re: Help with ideas

#29

Ellis Walentine

Re: That kind of like what I was thinkng

Ellis Walentine

Yes, I considered the center pull, too, Robin. That wouild be easier to make, too, because you could just gouge the trench across the V and mount the slip vertically. Aesthetically, I still prefer the horizontal pull. OTOH, if you want to solve the equation for ergonomics, you might use two pulls and orient them at about 45�. That is the most natural orientation for the way your thumbs and forefingers would present themselves to the drawer.

Ellis

Re: Help with ideas

#30

Re: Help with ideas

Ace Karner

Perhaps you can add to the back of the drawer as shown and then excavate and use a small pull across the excavation. It could be made to emulate the molding around the drawer and would mirror the mutton on the door.

Forgive the drawing I did it in a hurry just to try to show the concept.


img

Re: Help with ideas

#31

Re: Help with ideas

R.J. Whelan

Wiley,

I had a similar situation several years ago.

I ended up drilling a 1/4" hole in the back side of the drawer front (mine was 1/2" thick) and inserting a magnet. I then made a little turning (like a bottle stopper) and inserting a magnet in it's flat bottom. The little turning sat on the shelf and when I wanted to open the drawer I would bring the two magnets together and pull the drawer out.

Be sure to let us know what you finally end up doing.

RJ

Re: Help with ideas

#32

Re: That kind of like what I was thinkng

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I too generally prefer a horizontal pulls. In general horizontal lines tend to be static and calm and are a reflection of the horizon line which is a grounding line. Vertical lines on the other hand lift the eye in the way a tree or a building on the horizon does. The rare diagonals imply a more dynamic movement and can be extremely effective when used within a design, but they are also more challenging because it creates other design problems.

It had not occurred to me to use a diagonal pull and it is an interesting idea ergonomically. Design wise I think it would lead to an animistic feel that if followed through would reflect back to the likes of the post modernist designs of the Memphis Design group. As fun as that could be I am pretty sure it is pretty far from Wiley�s intent.

One of my long standing criticisms of Krenovian inspired design is the tendency to get seduced by the beauty of the material and overlook the beauty of the design. Some craftsmen get so enamored by the beauty of the grain in a board that becomes the focus of the entire piece. While this can work it is difficult to do and it is a rare design that allows this and is also a beautiful design. I would look to some of Nakashima�s work to illustrate this and on the opposite side of the coin I would point to Sam Maloof's work. By that I mean to point out that Sam often used extremely beautiful boards in his work but the design was the focus of his work and the wood was a vehicle to get that across.

Getting back to Wiley's design he has used the vertical grain of the wood as a design element and repeated that with not only the vertical mullion in the door but also the overall vertical orientation of the cabinet. And while the beauty of the wood is focused on it is not the sole design element. Another focal point such as a pull could make the piece more dynamic, giving your eye a reason to roam over the piece and then settle back down. By dynamic I don't mean to imply a since of movement as it could be a calming and grounding element but one that pulls your eye as it wanders over the rest of your cabinet, a detail that would give your eye a place to pause and rest and then wander away from only to return. These are the things that make a viewer come back. This is not to imply that the design would be lacking with out a pull. As it is it is a beautiful design and not lacking or wanting for anything.

Re: Help with ideas

#33

Thanks, Wiley...

Kevin Adams

for explaining the "v". You sure did a nice job with the joint as it does disappear. Maybe it's my knack for making things harder than they have to be or my past time in the Pacific NW and being exposed to their beautiful, native bentwood boxes, but I wonder if simply kerfing the back of the wood would allow the v joint? However, that would be a delicate operation and would not help you with making the rebates as you describe.

Btw, I didn't know you owned a bandsaw...how large and any other tailed apprentices in that small shop?

Would love to see finished photos when you get there. And what a wonderful community of folks here with the diveristy of great ideas!

Take care,

Kevin

Re: Help with ideas

#34

Re: Help with ideas

Sgian Dubh

I know this won't help you now Wiley, but I've never forgotten something said at a lecture by Rupert Williamson (a well known furniture maker here in the UK) presented to my year group of furniture students many years ago.

I'm paraphrasing but he said something like, "Always remember, you need to design your furniture from the handles back if you don't want them look like an afterthought." You may find this maxim useful in the future-- I know I have over the years. Slainte.

Re: Help with ideas

#35

Re: Thanks, Wiley...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Kevin,

I have a few powertools in a small outbuilding. The only one I use anymore is the bandsaw, and occasionally drill press. Bandsaw is a small INCA, 3/4HP, 6" capacity. Been kicking myself for years that I didn't at least get the 10" one, but it seemed like so much money at the time.

On making the V rails.....It's simple to work totally in the solid, and rough out the whole rail on a bandsaw. That's what I did on the double door cabinet linked in a post above. Start with 8/4 or 10/4 solid; use an 8-10 degree wedge as an auxiliary fence and saw the front faces--that's the appearance part of the V. Then put those newly-sawn faces against the fence and saw the interior angle on the back--ordinary caution will keep you from overcutting in back, allowing for bandsaw blade creep. Cutting the rails totally from solid leaves no seam on the front, so that result of the operation is good.

But here's the problem....You now have two rails with swirling grain. In fact, you won't know what it will look like til you make the bandsaw cuts--then you own whatever it is. The swirling grain looks kinda cool right off the saw, but when the project goes together, it doesn't have the calm look that you made the case for in the first place. The second problem you mentioned: You now have to cut a deep rebate on the interior edge of that V-shaped block, to take the door glass. There is a way to do this on a router table--IF you don't mind making a 1/4" x 1/2" climb cut on a router. But with handtools, that rebate is a bear. What I did on that first double-door cabinet was to use a Japanese azebiki (panel saw) to saw out the entire rebate; then nibbled out the interior apex with a chisel, and cleaned up with a chisel plane. The problem of course is that you're sawing into a stop--that dogleg interior apex of the V. Anyway, it's a goat rodeo (to avoid a less polite term) that I won't repeat.

On the other hand, if you use 1/4" veneer for the front, it's a pretty easy job to bandsaw the core as described above, plane it clean; then glue on the appearance faces with the exact grain you want, and have a perfect rebate in the bargain. The trade off is the seam, but that is doable with care. Krenov shows a good tip on glueup to close the seam: Hammer in a couple of nails at the off-ends of the two veneer pieces; when you miter, miter ever-so-slightly acute; then when you do the glue up, bend those nails in to put positive pressure on those two veneer pieces, so that the appearance miter seam is gluing up with positive pressure on the joint. That way, the veneer pieces can't back up on you, which they would certainly do without the applied pressure from the nails. Krenov shows this in The Impractical Cabinetmaker.

You're so right about all the useful ideas and illustrative graphics that have been brought forward, including some in the past 24 hours which I'll try to respond to.

Wiley

Re: Help with ideas

#36

Re: Help with ideas

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Thanks Richard! Excellent advice, including for others reading this.

I'm not necessarily settling for second best though. I'm coming from the other school, which is that no plan (of mine!) makes it through prototype, and this is my prototype. That likely wouldn't apply to someone of your experience, but I find it true for myself.

What I have done to leave myself some wiggle room is to keep the shelf above the tray in a friction fit for now--I can pull it out if and get tools to any part of the case. And I'm certain I want the tray, rather than two drawers or leave-it-bare. At this point, having seen what the actual project looks like, I'm glad I have options rather than commitment to something decided beforehand. Naturally I would go broke if I applied this thinking whilst trying to make a living at woodworking.

Of all things, I did planning for a living :) . Even then, it was quite often a good strategy to keep options open, rather than committing irrevocably and early to a set strategy. But the same would have been a disastrous (beyond pre-design) in an engineering department preparing plans and specs.

Thanks again!

Wiley

Re: Help with ideas

#37

Re: How about this

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Dan,

I've ordered a couple of those medium ones. Need to seem them. It may be that that a pair could be mortised into the bottom plate of the drawer compartment, from whence they could push on a slot cut into the bottom of the tray. Depends on how much outward force they generate--will they move the tray?

Great idea! You always figure if anyone has it, it'll be LV.

Wiley

Re: Help with ideas

#38

Re: Pin and spring approach

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Two good ideas, especially from the standpoint of keeping the hardware out of view. Only drawback is having to reach to the back of the shelf, and maybe knocking stuff over. Both your ideas though would also work with a button at the front; it's then a problem of making the button look like it belongs.

Much thanks,

Wiley

Re: Help with ideas

#39

Re: How about

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill,

Wonderful drawing!! I like your drawings. They're more detailed than mine.

That idea is very doable, and has the advantage that it could be a very low and unobtrusive button. So it's still on the table.

Much thanks,

Wiley

Re: Help with ideas

#40

Ace and Wilbur

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Thank you both for the great graphics--that was really thoughtful! And helps immensely.

Both ideas are thought-provoking. Ace, I think you're right in that if you're going to have a vertical pull, it's best to locate it on the apex, rather than have one on each side. John of NM I believe made reference to something similar. It also seems that you're right in that if you're going to break the flow of the grain, you want to do it with something that becomes a focal point in itself--not something subtle that tries to blend. The minute you put something vertical in there, then it has to be the main thing, and everything else is in support of it.

On the other hand, Wilbur's horizontal pull is oriented with the grain flow. It strikes me that a horizontal element is going to look more right if it is like a rock in a stream, with the grain flow representing stream flowing around the rock (the pull). In this theory, the pulls would need to have an organic rather than architectural look. Also, if you used pulls on either side, they might be best slightly offset from each other, as you would find rocks in a stream, rather than lined up.

So I kind of like Wilbur's pull as the vertical part of Ace's thought!

Wiley

Re: Help with ideas

#41

Re: Ace and Wilbur

Ace Karner

Nothing wrong with group think to solve a sticky problem. Of course we can never lose sight of the fact that a camel is a horse that was designed by a committee, LOL.

Re: Help with ideas

#42

This has been a lovely discussion

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

a nice change from talking about tools.

Re: Help with ideas

#43

Famous last words

wilbur

"It seemed like so much money at the time." This could be the Monday morning quarterback analysis for almost all tool purchases that prove to be not fully satisfactory over time. ;)

Re: Help with ideas

#44

Yeah, but...

Kevin Adams

that Inca is a great small bandsaw.

Wiley, I do have the 10.5" one and it (and a drill press like you) are my last standing power tools. Everything else has been sold off, including my small Inca tablesaw (with tilting table!) and their jointer/planer. I have to admit I have missed the tablesaw a couple of times when I needed to make some quick rips or wanted to do a rough lap joint, but I have managed without it so far. Now, staring at some 2-3" thick beech timbers stacked on the floor does make me miss that 10" jointer/planer...my arms are already protesting what I have in front of me!

Looking forward to seeing what you do with the pull.

Kevin

Re: Help with ideas

#45

Re: Help with ideas

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

This is a beautiful piece and this thread has been very interesting. I have no further drawings or suggestions for handles. I am, however, curious as to the structure and explained use for this cabinet. A jewelry cabinet? With 'glass shelves that probably won't get used'? Really? That would mean there would be space in the big drawer and on one shelf, with a lot of room above it. Is this cabinet meant to display or house just a few pieces of jewelry? Or a few small boxes in the drawer? Then I might view it as a beautiful object of art with a useful drawer. I cannot imagine storing jewelry in the upper section, with no shelves or small drawers. But that may just be me and my take. Otherwise, I love your work, design, wood choice, care in the small details.

Re: Help with ideas

#46

Re: Help with ideas

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hello Joanne,

Thanks for your comments.

I had originally planned this as a display cabinet for stuff that can sit on shelves, and incorporated the bottom tray as a way to get some use out of the dead space behind the lower rail.

But the other day, my wife said that she had some pendants and brooches that she would like to display against a dark background. So we may cover up the entire satinwood back panel with a padded insert covered in gray ultrasuede or Pacific silvercloth or somesuch, suitable for sticking brooches into and hanging necklaces and pendants. The tray may end up with silvercloth in the bottom, and holding hard-to-display items from the same collection. She'll decide--but I'm pretty sure the glass case interior will be fitted out different than I had figured.

I should mention the division of responsibility we have here at home: My wife has final say on everything that happens inside our house and on our grounds, whereas I have much more encompassing authority over matters at the UN, the stimulus, foreign wars, global warming, letters to senators and congressmen, world affairs in general, and getting the garbage out.

Thanks again!

Wiley

Re: Help with ideas

#47

Moses Yoder

responsibilitys

Moses Yoder

When my wife and I got married, it was decided I would make all the major decisions and she could make the minor ones. This has worked out well for the past twenty years; we have not had to make any major decisions.

Re: Help with ideas

#48

Re: responsibilitys

Dan Donaldson

We had a discussion when we got married. I told her that I expected a hot meal on the table and the house all cleaned up when I got home from work. I also expected that she would draw me a bath and get all of my stuff ready for when I got out. Then I asked her who she thought would be getting me dressed and my hair fixed up and everything. She answered "The funeral director". Things changed a bit after that ;)

Re: Help with ideas

#49

Re: This has been a lovely discussion

Rik in WI

I agree. It's very humbling and inspiring to read the wealth of design ideas, and the logic behind them, that have been presented.

Re: Help with ideas

#50

Re: Help with ideas

Marv

Hi Wiley,

Just one more idea....

I think I would think in terms of a small metal or wood button on the left side in the back that would go through a small hole and be pushed in to release a small spring type latch that the drawer when pushed all the way in would catch. The button on the side would only be used when opening the drawer. Or you could go ahead and push the button in so the drawer would more easily latch when closing the drawer. This would allow you to retain the nice clean lines you have on the front of the drawer. The button on the side would only have to be depressed about 1/8", maybe a bit less and could be flush with the side. All you need in the back of the drawer is a small compression spring or even foam rubber will work to push the drawer open just a bit when the button is pushed in.

Marv