Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Help with ideas

Posts

Help with ideas

#1

Help with ideas

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi All,

Maybe the illuminati gathered here can help me out of the corner I have painted myself into. Please pardon the photos....

Here is a satinwood wall cabinet I'm about ready to steel wool and wax. It'll hold a small jewelry collection for my wife. Door projects outward in a mild V shape. Interior fittings to be decided--I have glass shelves for it, but they'll likely not be used. Here it is:


Behind that bottom rail is a tray:


Here is a closeup of the tray:


Here's my problem. All through this project I figured I would get some inspiration about what kind of pull to put on the tray. The inspiration still ain't arrived. There is a special problem--the front of the tray is nearly flush against the bottom rail with the door closed. There is maybe 5/32" max. of room for the pull in front of the tray's front face.

All help and ideas appreciated!

Wiley

Re: Help with ideas

#2

Re: Help with ideas

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Wiley

The obvious design for the pull (whether flat- or rounded stock) is one that follows/parallels the outline of the front. in other words, creates a "V". It is not evident what you plan on the outside (for the door), or whether you intend to use a spring instead of a pull. But if you use a pull, say in a strongly contrasting wood (e.g. Ebony), then you could repeat the shape/wood on the inside for continuity.

Here is the thing: once you have the pull in place on the drawer face, then mortice the rear of the door to receive it. That way there can be a pull with greater projection than you have allowed.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Help with ideas

#3

Re: Help with ideas

chuckbeck in cent il

My first instinct is to put two teardrop shaped reliefs about the distance your thumb and third finger would want to reach into it together.

chuckbeck

Re: Help with ideas

#4

I was thinking the same thing

John in NM

Something symmetrical around the V that is kind of wide and flat to tie in with the drawer dimension. My initial thought was to cut a dovetail across the V, and insert a contrasting spline, then hollow the ends of the spline for finger grabs.

Spline would be flush with the drawer face at the V, and the door would have to be relieved to accommodate the ends that stick out from the drawer face.

But I'd definitely mock it up first, just in case it looked really funny :D

Of course you could use an old bent framing nail, with claw gouges just below the head, if you wanted to stir things up a bit :D

Re: Help with ideas

#5

drill a round bottom hole ...

Ian (in Sydney, Australia)

That drawer front looks deep enough for a round bottom hole.

Excavate the centre of the front to a depth of about 3/8" or 1/2" and a diameter of about 1-1/4" then place a "normal" small pull made, as Derek suggests, of a contrasting timber, in the cente of the hole.

The hole, while not weakening the drawer, will provide clearance for fingers to grasp the knob.

My mother had a dresser with two banks of drawers with this sort of knob hidden behind close fitting doors.

(if you look at the CMT 1-1/2" bowl and tray router -- cat no. 851.502.11 -- you'll see an example of the profile I'm suggesting)

Maybe a combination of two forstner bits -- 1-1/2" to a depth of ~1/4" then use a 1" bit in the centrte to a total depth of ~3/8". Then hand carve the transition between the two holes.

Re: Help with ideas

#6

Re: I was thinking the same thing

Bob Hackett

I sort of like the way the drawer looks now with it`s clean,subtle V line.

In order to not greatly disturb that look I would think about cutting back the top surface of the drawer front as far as I felt I could get away with(while blending it back into the rest of the front for that uninterrupted look) and then maybe add enough to that top border to form a slight lip.You would have to look to realize there was a way to pull the drawer open but it would keep that clean look and yet offer an extended pull area and a subtle detail and shadow line to the drawer.Hope it`s not too late to incorporate something like that.

If the back is not seen yet accessable then you could also cut some manner of small hole in the back that would allow a finger to push the back of the drawer and open it enough to get a finger over the front.A button in the interior or wood spring in back of the drawer could also be used if you wanted to keep the back intact.

MB

Re: Help with ideas

#7

Re: drill a round bottom hole ...

Tim Caley

What about some type of spring catch where you would push the drawer in to release it and leave the front of the drawer with a clean face if there is enough room in the rear of the cabinet?

Re: Help with ideas

#8

I like this one.

Dan Donaldson

I think the clean look with no pull is great. I would try to find a way to not add anything to the drawer front.

Re: Help with ideas

#9

Re: drill a round bottom hole ...

Bob Macgregor

Great minds run in the same channels!

My first thought, too, was the spring catch idea, if there is room behind (or under?) the drawer for one...

Alternatively, you could wait a bit for Charlie Belden to suggest a more exotic magnetic, or robotic, method of opening the drawer! Or maybe a pneumatic cylinder with hidden activation button... or sound activation ("open sesame")?

BOB

Re: Help with ideas

#10

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Help with ideas

Stephen Shepherd

I'm cheap so I would probably put a couple of straps of leather (maybe lizard or something exotic, how about stingray) in recesses in the top edge of the drawer and let them hang down in front.

They would be only visible when the door is open.

You could also do some sort of folding handle like a hinge with holes on one side to attach to the drawer. The little hinge/handle would fold out for gripping and opening the door. Folds flush when not in use.

Stephen

Re: Help with ideas

#11

Re: Help with ideas

Kevin Adams

Hi Wiley,

I just want to comment on the piece itself...it's really stunning. The door detail is just wonderful and I remember when you were asking questions about installing the glass. I know you don't have much (if any) power tools, so presuming this was made "at the bench" makes it even more special. Is it all solid wood or any veneer, specifically the v-shape? What is the back? Maybe some more photos when you're done will answer my questions.

Thanks for sharing.

Kevin

Re: Help with ideas

#12

Re: Help with ideas

darin

It's a jewelry case so I think it should have a pull ring. Something along the lines of hardware used on Japanese cases but much finer, hammered with a silver or gold finish. I am not sure how I would work it into the V front but making a flat spot for the pull mounted on a plate would work.

darin

Re: Help with ideas

#13

Re: Help with ideas

John Aniano in central NJ

Wiley,

I envision a pair of small, rectangular, shallow "knobs" of ebony, one centered on each side of the "v". From your images, the rectangles might be 5/16" high x 1-1/4" wide, with a small taper in the cross-section to them front to back to have a hand-hold. The rectangles would accentuate the "v" shape without going overboard and making them actual "v"'s. I like Derek's idea of recessing the cabinet door to accommodate knobs, but if you didn't have to, that might be the better way to go, and not have to alter the near-finished door.

Other than that, it is a nice, very nice project!

John

Re: Help with ideas

#14

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Help with ideas - No Pull!

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

No pull, per se. Just drill the two flat bottomed (forstner bit?) holes about an inch or so on either side of the apex of the drawer front. Then, the drawer can be opened by putting thumb and finger into the holes, pinching for grip, and opening the door. Simple, and no extra hardware required.

Jim D.

Re: Help with ideas

#15

Second effort

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Wiley

Firstly, let me say that you have build a beautiful cabinet. It has wonderful flowing lines and a restful, uncluttered feel, and I really would not wish to disturb this with a pull. Even when you asked for a pull and I was responding to this request, I was thinking to myself that the drawer front does not suit a pull. The drawer front should remain clutter-free. It just needs a spring loaded catch, which is what I mentioned should also be on the door.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Help with ideas

#16

Turn it into studio art . . .

CJ in MPLS

pound a couple of nails into the door and drawer. While I am joking, part of me likes that kind of thing.

Your cabinet is a good candidate for this kind of nuttiness as it is gorgeous and the ugliness of a nail would be an interesting contrast. One of the reasons I like some modern art is that I know the artist is perfectly capable of making something that is highly regarded in a more traditional sense, but they chose not to for the purpose of making a statement or exploring some odd approach that intrigues them. By way of example, a nail in your cabinet would likely be viewed as artistic, a nail in some of my work would be looked upon with pity. ;)

But since the nail has been done before, I'd vote for spring catches and no pulls.

CJ

Re: Help with ideas

#17

Ellis Walentine

Re: Help with ideas

Ellis Walentine

Nice cabinet, Wiley! I like the idea of excavating two little hemispherical or elliptical trenches and routing (with hand tools of course :) a slot across each, and then gluing a slip of ebony or other contrasting wood into the slot. You could leave the slip just proud by 1/16" or so.

Ellis

Re: Help with ideas

#18

Re: Help with ideas *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I like this idea. If making one is too much, Lee Valley (and, no doubt, others) offers ring pulls in steel and brass.

There are also ring pulls that fold flat into a plate. Maybe I'm just obsessing about marine hardware right now, because I'm in contact with a company to try to find a piece of bronze or brass hardware that will serve as the eye for a bronze hook I've got for my back gate - but there's some cool stuff out there, and not too expensive at that. I've got no affiliation with the company at the link below, except they're patiently answering my questions. Good prices, although they use Yahoo shipping, which is a bit pricey. Again, Lee Valley and other cabinet hardware catalogs offer this kind of thing, too.

Let me add my comment to those who have drooled over the design. Very nice work.


One example of a ring pull

Re: Help with ideas

#19

Say Bill...

Bob Hackett

Any chance of posting a drawing of what you had in mind for that gate?

Living up here in yacht country,I may be able to shop it around to some of my old wooden boat buddies and see if they might know where a fellow could come up with something like that.

Maybe an apprentice down at the Maine Maritime Museum could be talked into tacking something like that on to the next bronze casting project or something.Always worth asking.

MB

Re: Help with ideas

#20

Darrell in Oakville

Re: the key to the solution...

Darrell in Oakville

is in the lock on the side of the case.

My wife's grandfather was a Danish cabinetmaker, and her family has a number of the pieces he made. Two of them have drawers with no pulls. You use the key that unlocks the drawer to pull it open. You get a clean look with just the escutcheon showing on the drawer face.

One more option...

Darrell

Wood Hoarder, Blade Sharpener, and Occasional Tool User

Re: Help with ideas

#21

That kind of like what I was thinkng

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

That is the approach I would take but I would orient the pulls vertically to repeat the vertical divider in the door and the vertical line in the center of the drawer. I might even be tempted to use a single drawer pull in the center.

Re: Help with ideas

#22

Response and request for follow-up

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

WOW! What a group of great ideas! There are several reasonably good ways to go. If anyone comes up with something more, please add it. I would like to reply collectively at this juncture, except to Kevin Adams, which is in the text above.....

1. Recessed pulls. This is a strong idea. I should have mentioned that the drawer front is 3/16" thick, so the recessed pulls would involve adding some meat behind the recesses and encumbering the useful volume. I think the idea would work well, had I planned on it from the beginning, and left enough meat in the drawer front to execute it.

2. Drop pulls. Another strong idea, with or without the drops falling into a shallow recess. The tradeoff is whether to break the grain flow across the front, or not.

3. Pierced front. This seems like the most Krenovian and direct solution. It could be fingerholes, or some sort of lattice pattern. The question is whether this feature is better than the unbroken grain lines.

4. Soft solutions. Steven Shepherd mentioned this. Leather or fabric or knotted rope. Anecdote: I received a gift from Japan once, which came in a paulownia box, and the box was pierced with small holes to allow a silk belt to wrap over and tie the top down onto the box. I found the effect to be stunning. So the idea of threading a kimono tie or similar through the drawer front as a pull is attractive. If done well, it is also a way to 'go with the flow'.

5. Darrell's grandfather's 'key' solution. This is immensely practical, and requires only an escutcheon on each side. Only issue is whether to do anything to the front.

6. Spring and catch. Several folks recommended this, and this is what I would like to try. Because it leaves the grain flow unbroken across the front.

Request for followup help: But I can't figure out an efficient mechanism for doing the spring and catch. Let's say you have a coil spring or a wooden spring mounted at the rear of the box, behind the drawer. Or there could be a pair of wooden springs more toward the front, exerting pressure on each side of the backside of the drawer front. But where is the catch-and-release mechanism? Do you have a mechanical catch like a spring-loaded button right at the foot of the drawer front, which could be pushed down to let the spring push the drawer out? Or is the catch-and-release somehow integrated with the spring itself?

Again, all ideas (and counter ideas too!) are most welcome and needed!

Wiley

Re: Help with ideas

#23

How about this *LINK*

Dan Donaldson

Here is an idea if you can figure out a way to add it either behind, beside, or in the drawer.


Push latch

Re: Help with ideas

#24

Re: Second effort

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I agree with everything you say, with one exception. I think the drawer front looks a little plain and blank, but I love the spring loaded catch with small drawers. So how about some carving on the drawer front, purely decorative?

Pam

Re: Help with ideas

#25

Pin and spring approach

Bob Hackett

I was thinking of a simple spring loaded wood button toward the rear of the case.The button is either pinned or glued to a square sided(so it doesn`t rotate) wood wedge.

Press the button and it pushes the wedge down which pushes the drawer open.

As an alternative,a simple flat wood spring on the back of the drawer to either push the drawer open whenever the door opens or the button/pin in the back of the case could now serve as a catch that pushes into a hole in the drawer back or side (centered in the back would be best).Drop a spring like one from a ball point pen into the hole after you stretch it to be just as long as the hole is deep.

Operation works like so,push drawer in compressing wood spring on drawer back and drop pin in hole.Push pin down into hole in drawer,compressing pen spring in hole and hold pin down.Release drawer,friction holds pin down and drawer locked.

To open drawer,push front of drawer in slightly against wood spring and pin is pushed up by pen spring which pushes pin out of hole in drawer and clear of drawer back.Release drawer and wood spring pushes the drawer open.

Just remember to pull or raise pin before attempting to close drawer or drawer won`t go in all the way and door will not close.

It works more simply than my rather wordy explanation.Hope you get the idea.

MB