Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Magnetic turning tool rack

Posts

Re: Magnetic turning tool rack

#51

Seems familiar *LINK*

clay foster

Arguing with an engineer is like wrestling with a pig in the mud. After a while you realize the pig really likes it.


Sock and a shoe

Re: Magnetic turning tool rack

#52

Brad Vietje

Four Thumbs up, Clay !   

Brad Vietje

I only have 2, but I 'm still seeing double from laughing so hard!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Magnetic turning tool rack

#53

Re: Seems familiar

Mike Potts

LOL....hard to believe this thread, has gone on for 6 days,

keep it safe

Mike

Re: Magnetic turning tool rack

#54

Steven Antonucci

I'll take the top 3 engineering school anyday

Steven antonucci

Like Yogi Berra said

"You can't teach him something he doesn't already know."

Feel free to disagree.

S

Re: Magnetic turning tool rack

#55

Re: I'll take the top 3 engineering school anyday

Barry L Elder

This all sounds like it could be the Army Corps of Useless Engineers discussing/arguing how to waste lots of $$$$$$$$$ :D

Re: Magnetic turning tool rack

#56

Re: Magnetic turning tool rack--Tool Rest!

John Lucas

That's true Dennis but in the case of John Jordan Lyle Jamieson Jamie Donaldson and myself, we all keep our tool rests spotless and slick as can be. Something I learned from John J a long time ago

Re: Magnetic turning tool rack

#57

Steven Antonucci

Facts vs. Opinions

steven antonucci

The truth is that I don't really care if anyone changes their mind, but it really comes down to representing opinions as facts. My opinion changed as a result of this discussion, but the facts have not.

Here is a picture I shot 5 minutes ago of the tool that I magnetized a week ago with a 5 minute exposure to a 1" disc magnet. I don't know how it compares to a magnetic tool bar in strength (in factual, measurable magnetic terms), but it was only in place for an instant and a week later, the tool is still magnetized enough to hold up a 1 1/2" flat washer.


So, in summary, using a magnetic tool rack will absolutely transfer magnetism to your tool. {fact} For me, the effect is enough to warrant not using a magnetic rack {opinion}

To suggest that there is no effect...{erroneous}

And remember, I started on the side of the argument that it was negligible...

S

Re: Magnetic turning tool rack

#58

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Magnetic turning tool rack--Tool Rest!

Dennis in Southern Oregon

I am sure you do John and I try to also. My point is that any experiments intended to determine whether tool magnetism is a problem need to be carried out with a smooth clean tool rest. Otherwise, the effects of roughness will tend to swamp out any effect magnetism. There were comments earlier that the effect of magnetism seemed larger for skews and small tools. This would be consistent with roughness of the tool rest.

Re: Magnetic turning tool rack

#59

Re: Magnetic turning tool rack

Phillip Medghalchi

Has anyone noticed that Joe Pack Started this on 1/6/15 and after this many replies/comments he didn't even reply to all the comments. He probably wonders what in the world he started. :\

Re: Magnetic turning tool rack

#60

Fact vs Opinion - Remanence & coercivity are real.

Geoff Whaling

The effect was not larger with small tools just more noticeable, as it affected my ability to finesse cuts. Yes, I do keep the surface of my tool rest in very good condition. I also use RE skews with the RE on both long & short points even my Thompsons have been customized.

Opinion – why introduce a “problem” ? If magnetic tool racks & other devices like magnetic bases on lamps cause residual magnetism in tools – why use them? Conversely if you do use them and do not experience problems then why change?

Fact - Residual magnetism (remanence) is real.

Fact - Coercivity is real.

Fact - Ferrous tools rests & ferrous tools will attract if one or the other is magnetized.

Opinion - Is the residual magnetic force strong enough to affect tool movement? We seem to have many opinions on this Question.

Facts - The additional friction caused by a magnetized tool will depend upon many factors largely dependent upon tool rest design; maintenance; tool & tool rest steel grades / alloys, their coercivity; the tool manufacturing process; the duration of exposure to a magnetic field; structure of the magnetic field; etc. Tool manufacturing processes have been proven to influence coercivity i.e. hot rolled vs cold rolled - reduces up to half the max. remanence.

Fact / Opinion - the coercivity & remanence of tool steel alloy / grades may vary considerably. Higher alloy steels may have significantly higher coercivity than low alloy steels. The interaction of two or more sources of remanence may be at work – magnetic - tool rack; lamp base; bracket for DE ports; tool/parts caddy on headstock; drawing clamp; magnetic everything …..

Remanence is a measure of how strong a magnetization remains in a material after an externally applied magnetizing force is removed.

Coercivity: is a measure of how permanent a magnet is, ie. what amount of magnetic force it takes to reverse its magnetization. Materials with high coercive force require high magnetizing H fields to become magnetized or demagnetized.

These properties are essential to our modern lives and are also used in steel alloy & carbide tool Quality Control measurements to determine conformance - Cobalt alloyed with carbon behaves like a ferrite; Cobalt alloyed with bi-tungsten carbide, will form a non-magnetic alloy.

High coercivity materials are called magnetically hard materials, and are used to make permanent magnets & find application in electric motors, magnetic recording media (e.g. hard drives, floppy disks, or magnetic tape).

Low coercivity materials are said to be magnetically soft. They are used in transformer and inductor cores, recording heads. microwave devices, and magnetic shielding.

Re: Magnetic turning tool rack

#61

Wow.  Didn't mean to offend.

Joe Pack

Wow, Phillip, I didn't mean to offend. I was more concerned with handling flu at my house (both my wife and myself), a wife with zero voice for going on three weeks and sick grandkids than I was in replying on a discussion board.

I stopped posting, or even reading, the turning forum here for almost a year. Now I remember why.

Re: Magnetic turning tool rack

#62

Bill Blasic

Re: Wow.  Didn't mean to offend.

Bill Blasic

Joe,

Don't let a ham fisted comment take you away from a place where info and learning are abundant.

Re: Magnetic turning tool rack

#63

Mike Stafford

Re: Wow.  Didn't mean to offend.

Mike Stafford

Joe,some people and their inane comments are best left ignored. You are most welcome on WC.

Re: Magnetic turning tool rack

#64

Re: Wow.  Didn't mean to offend.

Cyril Griesbach

Joe, you've been here a long time so stay with us. I, for one, never read Phillip's posts.

Re: Magnetic turning tool rack

#65

Jim Evans

Re: OT Genealogy software

Jim Evans

Ditto

Re: Magnetic turning tool rack

#66

Re: Wow.  Didn't mean to offend.

Phillip Medghalchi

I am not sure what the animosity is about, and what your beef is with me. I just simply was trying to state that Joe must have been surprised how his thread got away from his main qsn. and the controversial answers which were posted.

Anyone has the right to read what they please. I posted what my intentions were.

I do not appreciate calling me out for a comment which was not offensive. If you got something you would like to discuss you can email me, not calling me out here.

Re: Magnetic turning tool rack

#67

All is good.  Let's move on.

Joe Pack

I received a very nice email from Phillip today. After reading his note to me, then re-reading his post here, I can see that his post was not intended in the vein in which I took it. This dust-up is my fault; I should not have posted my reply.

I would be honored to buy Phillip a beverage of his choice if we should ever meet in person.

Re: Magnetic turning tool rack

#68

Thanks, Joe

Barry Irby

I read Phillip's post several times and did not find it Offensive. Actually I looked at the string and was surprised to find he was correct. You had not participated. And you indeed stirred up a long thread. Glad to hear you recovered enough to check on us.

Sorry to hear the flue bug got you and your wife. Hope that's over and you are both healthy again.

Only after I got the flue shot did they announce they had guessed wrong and it might not do me much good.

Thanks for hanging in, we enjoy your expertise here.

Re: Magnetic turning tool rack

#69

Re: All is good.  Let's move on.

Phillip Medghalchi

Joe, I appreciate your courtesy posting this nice wording. Yo do not need to by me a drink. I would be honored to meet you in person and have chat with you.

I can relate to times that when someone is not feeling well to misread or even misunderstand another person's spoken words. When all one's energy is spent trying to recoup from illness the temper and the attention suffers from it.

I remember when I had the back problem I took everyone around me the wrong way and would get agitated very easily.

I am glad all is good and you can see I am the monster some of our dear members here made me to be.

Again, I hope yo get well soon and next few days when weather gets better (I hope at your end of the woods too) you can regain your health.

BTW, one thing that had help me is that I carry a small bottle of Hand sanitizer with me at all times on my Key chain and despite that people think its overkill, I find it that just cleaning my hand as soon as I get into my car is much cheaper than going to the Dr. and finding out that they really do not have answer for your flu or the flu shot is not the right one and etc.

I appreciate this not again. Hope you get to feeling good soon.