Here are my hypothesis, some of which I have validated via experiment:
1.) If you have a strong enough magnet, it will transfer its magnetism to the tool significantly (i.e. enough to be detrimental by my opinion)
2.) If you have the same magnetic attractive force in a smaller piece of steel, its effect is more significant (i.e. restrictive)
3.) The longer the magnetic field is applied, the greater the magnetizing of the tool becomes.
So, if your magnetic strip is strong enough to hold a tool up (suspended against gravity) vs. perhaps leaning on a ledge, it is probably not a great idea to put turning tools in it. Heavy duty magnets transfer their magnetic fields to turning tools extremely quickly (minutes, not hours or days) and the effect is extremely long lasting (hours after 5 minute exposure.)
I would expect that the effect would be even greater if I was to store my tools this way, but I am not willing to magnetize them in the name of science, as I don't own a de-magnetizer.
I think of it as a "wet paint sign". I touched it lightly and it was wet. I'm not going to sit down on it to see if it is all wet, or if it was just wet where I touched
I didn't say that it affected the sharpening. The magnetized tool will pick up & hold fine particles of steel. It is almost impossible to remove them all.
...empiricism for a woodturning discussion, and I will continue to use my magnetic strips as I have for years, and consider this whole scenario to be a non-issue! If it ain't broke,...............!
steve I"m not sure what kind of magnet you used but I didn't have any problems. First I used my magenetizer/demagnetizer to magentize several tools. You could feel the pull down onto the tool rest but I had not trouble whatsoever sliding the tool across the rest or rotating the skew for turning beads or shear scraping with a scraper. I tried thick tools and thin tools and my Robust rest and my Powermatic rest. Same results.
Then I grabbed a quarter size rare earth magnet and stuck it to the top of the tool directly above the rest. Same results only less pull from the magnet so it was easier to pull the tool off the rest.
I do agree that you can get shavings on the tool from grinding but a quick swipe with a brush removes virtually all of it. I'm guessing what's left comes off with the first revolution or two of the wood.
So I stand by my original statement in that I don't think the magnetic tool holders hurt anything. I think they are weaker than the two systems I tried. Still if in doubt at all Lyle's method of the tilting tool rack is what many turners use.
John, It feels to me like there's a 10 lb weight on top of the tool, particularly with detail cuts. I would have figured it would bother you given some of the things you make using light cuts etc. I can tell as soon as it hits the toolrest-student's tools, not mine.
I should have just copied Lyle's post word for word. I agree 100%.
I have to agree with Lyle & John J. I can definitely feel the drag when using a magnetized wood turning tool. It is particularly an issue with skews and spindle gouges for delicate cuts on finials. With bowl gouges the drag isn't as pronounced.
Maybe those who use magnetic tool strips should try a demagnetized tool to compare.
You won't find strong RE magnets in my workshop as they are a potential hazard for any one with an implantable defib or other similar medical device.
I just had to say this, does this mean my metal hip replacement will pull me against the magnetic bar. I don't have any magnets around. I tried the bar and it made my lathe tools pull on the tool rest before I was ready to cut. Never again. Oh, my metal hip part is Titanium.
To pinch Jamie's phrase, it’s not horse puckey or me being a smart alex.
I’m not talking about plates & screws, knee, hip implants etc but medical devices such as pacemakers, implantable defibrillators, neuro-stimulators etc. The cases etc of these implantable medical devices are made of non-ferrous metals so magnets will not stick to the case. However strong magnetic fields may impair their normal function, temporarily disrupt or even disable some device functions (as they are designed to do). The devices may either withhold a life saving appropriate therapy or perhaps inappropriately deliver a therapy from dangerous false over/under sensing of heart rhythms etc. In the case of a friend it may just require a change of underwear as they have a device that controls bowel function (sacral nerve stimulation).
The hazard & risk from strong magnetic fields is sufficient for the medical device manufacturers to caution recipients of these devices to avoid objects, tools, and environments which produce strong electromagnetic fields. Any one with an ICD, implantable cardioverter defibrillator, or a heart pacemaker should heed those warnings.
Small relatively common objects with strong magnetic fields such as a small RE magnet could easily be placed in a pocket near the device or sensing leads. Magnetic tool racks, magnetic bases for lamps etc probably aren’t a high risk in “normal conditions” unless the device comes close to them.
So you can't get off small particles of steel - what is the problem? Any that can't be removed by wiping them off, or blowing off with compressed air, will be gone in seconds once you put the tool in service at the lathe. I don't understand why this seems to be such a problematic issue that you would "NEVER EVER" do it.
I have sharpened turning tools stored in contact with magnetic strips without incident for years, showing NO reduction in sharpness or turning quality of the edge, even if a few "straggler" filings may have been attached. This does NOTHING to the performance of the tool.
In REALITY, and in practical terms, this is a NON-ISSUE. No theory here, just experience.
So after reading how the "experiments" 1 and 2 were conducted, one can not help but conclude that the conditions that you created in no way replicate the situation of minor secondary magnetism. There could be nothing other than a strong magnetic field induced in the turning tools when a very strong permanent magnet (with accompanying high magnetic flux) remains in contact with the metal tool, particularly full contact with a flat turning tool. (You may have just as well made it into an electromagnet, and switched on 'clamping force' -- it would be the same thing!) What else would you expect? This "worst case scenario" far exceeds ANY real-life relationships with magnetized turning tools, even "strongly" magnetized turning tools. Having direct contact with a strong PERMANENT MAGNET would undoubtedly cause ANY ferrous metal to stick to another ferrous metal while magnetic flux is encountering the metals. A no-brainer situation/conclusion.
I can't see how these "experiments" in any way replicate the real-life situation of storing woodturning tools in racks incorporating magnetic strips. I have THREE tool racks, each having magnetic bars, that I have been using for 15+ years and I am about to build a fourth rack at the new "3rd lathe" station in my shop; you can bet it will have a magnetic strip, simply because of the ease at which tools are picked-up and replaced. (For full disclosure, my tool rack designs also incorporate a "slope back" configuration, so they might be considered a 'hybrid', but they do not have holes, tubes, or slots where the tools need to be fed into to replace them - the magnetic strip works fine to hold them in place.) I remainunconvinced that using a 1" diameter "super magnet" (neodymium or rare earth?) in contact with a ferromagnetic tool even comes close to the actual, practical situation likely to be encountered with typical iron magnets used in magnetic strips meant to hold ferrous tools. Your "experimental" conditions, at least to me, are not valid.
I agree with Jamie, Bill, and others that THERE IS NOPROBLEM, IN MY EXPERIENCE, with using a magnetic strip in my tool racks, and non-valid 'experiments' will not change my opinion or interpretation of this situation, based on 15+ years of real-life use of magnetic strips. You might consider TRYING ONE for a while before dismissing them on speculation,"hypothesis", or non-comparable situations. IMHO, "bad experiments = bad conclusions" fits here.
These two tool racks both use magnetic bars, and have been in continuous use for over 15 years. The small shelf prevents sliding off of the rack and can be a 'landing place' for the bottom of the tool when replacing them; the Lexan sheet behind the "business" ends of the tools prevents the plywood back from getting chewed-up by sharp tool edges when selecting or replacing tools. Each tool can be readily viewed, accessed, and replaced easily and efficiently with one hand without ever having to "thread the needle" of the tool shank into a hole, or drop the shank or handle into a tube. Tools are held securely, safely, and with minimal acquisition of secondary magnetism.
For me, tool magnetism is not a major issue. Period. If you think this is "wet paint" than don't touch. - For MANY turners this is an efficient and useful way to store and use tools with ready access and no impediments to tool selection and replacement. Give it a try, then make some conclusions based on experience!!
I have an older (more than 15 years) magnetic strip lathe tool holder that came with my used Woodfast lathe. The holder is very similar in design to the one Rob Wallace posted. If I use the tool holder, the tools become magnetized and stick to the tool rest. Flat tools are 'sticker' than round ones. One of the tools I bought with the lathe is a Robert Sorby skew, 20 inches long, with 9 inches of metal and an 11 inch handle. The skew is 5/16 inch thick at the ferrule and 1/4 inch thick at the cutting end. It is 1 and 1/4 inches wide. With the end of the wooden handle resting on the bottom of the tool holder, the magnetic strip is 4 inches from the cutting edge. Using my 'no lie' fishing scale hooked onto the cutting edge, it takes 27 pounds of force to pull the tool from the magnetic strip. Then resting the end of the wooden handle on a block to use as a fulcrum point, and with the metal resting on a block of wood four inches from the cutting edge, I used my Taylor kitchen scale in the same place as I used the fish scale, to lift the metal off the wooden block. The scale read 300 grams. Next, I slid the banjo out to the side of the lathe, rested the end of the wooden handle on the tail stock to use as a fulcrum point, put the tool rest four inches from the cutting edge and then used the scale to lift the cutting edge from the tool rest as before. To lift the metal and break the magnetic 'stick', the scale read 350 grams, but returned to 300 grams once the tool was off the tool rest. I am glad that some do not have a problem with magnetized tools, but I do. The extra pressure required to start the tool moving can be a problem with some cuts. The tool holder keeps the tools within reach and out of the way, but because of the force needed to release the tool and because of the 'stickiness', I don't use it for all of my tools. Probably not very scientific, but the results do show what I have 'felt' from the tool and tool rest. I would think that the strength of the magnetic tool holder, the tool itself, and the metal in the tool rest would all affect the amount of 'stickiness'. Thanks for reading. John Rubash
Yeah, I was surprised too... and I tried it on an older Sorby scraper (3/4"), most likely with a much more powerful magnet than used in a magnetic strip for tools.
Does the size of the tool magnify the perception of the effort? I think so. On my small skew, it was like I had glued it to the rest. The scraper decidedly had an effect, but I didn't try to cut with either, and I think the subtlety of the cuts with both is different to start.
For Rob and the horsepucky crowd, all I can say is feel free to ignore the effort or minimize it, but it is very real. You make the comment that you've been doing it for 15 years...well, guess what? That's why you don't notice it any more....:)
I will stick to my wooden rack on the back of my tool cart.
I used a rare earth magnet (1 inch diameter that I use in big refer magnets) and noted the cast iron tool rest has much more magnetic attraction than the stainless steel rod edged tool rests I have. I am not using a magnetic strip any more, but wondered if the tool rests were a variable.
Non issue to you. No so to me. Might just be a matter of preference. The same way I don't use steel wool to "sand" any wood projects. Just takes a tiny bit of water or excess humidity to make a (tiny) stain that can't be removed.
My turning tools are mostly laid about on this bench-top or that...no tool rack what ever...so, no magnetic strip or other magnets around. Still, frequently, a magnetized tool with a fuzz-ball of steel wool fragments requires that I stop and deal with that.
0000 steel wool plays an important role in my shop, and the fragments that I cannot see wind up pretty much wherever wood dust goes. It's a minor annoyance.
Im not sure I get your drift. I think Joe was looking for help in storing tools. He has a ton of feedback now and will decide whether he wants to settle for the nuisance of magnetism or build a rack without magnets. I like to hear both sides of an issue. In the turning world we seldom will all agree. We have different reasons for the methods we use.
No one has mentioned yet the role of the tool rest in all of this. Without doubt, the residual magnetism in the tool will attract it to the tool rest to some degree. The consequence of this depends greatly on the condition of the tool rest. A very hard, very smooth tool rest will have a very low coefficient of friction with a hard smooth tool and (based on the the experiments reported here) should add little to the sliding resistance. A rough, pitted, rusted or resin-covered rest will impede tool movement much more for a given magnetic force. Also, dings, pits and scratches in the rest will be more noticeable with small tools and particularly (because of the more-or-less sharp corners) flat skews and scrapers used in a shear scrape mode.
Sorry I guess stuff doesn't come across the way I always want it... There is a lot of good information but if you go back and read all those in favor of magnetic strips does it appear many if any have thrown them away and gone to some other system. The same thing for the don't use them. I doubt if any have decided they will work great and have switched.
The hand tool reference was tongue in cheek to some of their long back and forth threads that also don't seem to change any minds.
I like both sides of the argument, and I actually started on the "wrong" side of it. I conducted my initial test thinking it was a non-issue. I am now firmly on the other side of the argument (I think it is an issue).
So, I guess at least one person did change his position?
It's one thing to say that you are willing to live with the consequences. It is another to not acknowledge the science. Everyone will have difference tolerance for how much is too much, but sooner or later, the line gets crossed.