I am considering making a rack, either portable or wall mounted, using a "pool cue rack" type design on a slight recline using an inexpensive HF magnetic tool bar to keep the tools in an upright position. I know this might magnetize the tools slightly, but am wondering if that slight amount of magnetism would have much effect in use?
Hi Joe, the only downside I can see is that it might cause the steel you grind off when sharpening to stick to the gouge, which might embed in your turning causing problems with iron staining and perhaps the longevity of your cutting edge.
I tried that once that bar magnetic gave me trouble big time on smaller tools;turning between centers. The tools also eat steel wool for lunch. Works for others, not me.
I have use magnetic strips for years with very few problems. Beware of the HF strips...at the least the ones they put on sale for about $8 ... go ahead and buy a good one ($12 or so) from Rockler, Hartville, etc.
The HF are just not strong enough.
The only problem I have had is with flat tools (scrapers, Sorby multi tip, etc) where there is a lot of contact with the tool rest. Parting tools or other used on edge are not a problem. Round tool only contact for 1/100 (?) of an inch so it is not a problem if they get a little magnetized.
You can get grinding residue but it wipes off easily. The residue could get imbedded in the wood but most blown away with the chips. More likely to get the bits of burr imbedded.
Good quality spring clips work well for heavy flat items.
Hi Joe -- I keep several large scrapers on a magnetic rack and I have sometimes found that they have picked up enough magnetism to "drag" on the tool rest when I use them. I just demagnetize them with an open-loop soldering iron or such, which eliminates the problem plenty quick.
I like the caps on "never". I agree totally, Its a hassle I don't want to deal with. I would never use magnets for turning tools. The calipers or attachments might be OK but even they can be problematic. When you build your tool rack, put the tools on a slight angle with the handle in a shallow hole (Forestner bit) and the cutting tip into a notch. The angle needs to be tilted back enough so that if you bump the rack, or a tool in It, that they do not fall out of the rack and hurt you. My rack is tilted 15-20 degrees back.
Can you explain why I'm curious. I keep a seldom used skew that I sharpen at a 25 degree angle on my magnetic strip. I cant say I see any negative results. It sharpens fine, holds an edge reasonably well considering its high carbon steel a d I dont have any trouble sharpening it. Perhaps I'm oveooking something and I'm always willing to learn.
Here's one of my tool carousels. This one is on a lazy susan bearing, and the tools are captured by the top ring. Some don't like the tools facing upward, by I was trained to never place a tool on its cutting edge. I can grab a tool, and immediately go to work with the tools in this orientation. Maybe this will give you an idea.
Don't know if the question why was addressed to me, but I will respond. All the above reasons apply. Some have stated the problems with solutions. I would rather prevent the problems rather than put a band aide on it. The problems seem small but are a significant nuisance over a long time. I don't want the hassle. The tools will get magnetized. A magnetized tool will have drag on the tool rest and attract debris or other tools in its path. As soon as I start using a students tool when Im traveling that has been stored in a magnet strip I can feel it immediately on the tool rest. I choose to stay away from magnets. Im a control freak. I want and use tools with fingertip light touch control. I don't have a grip at all while turning. My tool does all the work and I just gently guide it. My techniques don't work with magnetized tools.
Thanks Lyle. Was t directed at anyone in particular just wondering. Obviously I haven't had problems. A magnetized tool does stick to the tool rest lightly when I lift it but I can't feel drag when I slide it
Nice looking rack Keith. I'm a Klutz knowing myself I would stick my hand on top and slice some skin. I have shelves on most my lathes and take out what I'm going to use as I need them. On my Long bed Vicmark I just set them on the end when I'm production turning. Seems like many have their good and not so good ways of keeping tools at hand.
... old magnetic knife holders in use for many years and have never seen any semblance of tools becoming magnetized. I don't believe HSS alloys become magnetized as much as old carbon steels, and my old knife holders may not be as field strong as the HF strips which I have never used. My tools don't even attract grinding dust from CBN wheels, so I believe there's a bit of urban legend associated with magnetized HSS tools. I've used magnetized tools and degaussing coils for many years in my precision electronic and camera repair business.
Interesting thought Jamie. I still have my magnetized/demagnetized from my camera repair days. When I get home Friday I will try and magnetize a few tools and see not only if they doagnetize but how they are attracted to the tool rest
I have used magnet bars to hold a wide range of different turning tools for at least 15 years, and can attest that some of the tools, particularly the flat tools (e.g. skews, scrapers) with more physical contact with the magnet bars, do become mildly magnetic over time. Tools that are round in cross section, while still being held by the magnet bar, do not get nearly as magnetized as the 'flat' tools. In my experience, the key word is mildly.
If I detect any level of a tool becoming magnetic, I de-magnetize the tool in about 20-30 seconds using a bulk tape eraser, making several random passes across the tool while the tape eraser is energized. You can tell if a tool is magnetized when it picks up steel shavings near the grinder, or on rare occasion, when a tool offers some resistance to movement on a tool rest. After using the bulk tape eraser, perhaps once in 6-8 months (if that) I can detect ZERO magnetism (no metal grinder dust picked up). A simple solution to a minor "problem".
I disagree that summarily dismissing the use of magnet bars to hold turning tools is necessary; from my perspective it isn't a problem. After 15+ years of very active woodturning, I have yet to experience any aspect of acquired magnetism in my turning tools that would rise to any level of concern. For me, this is only a minor issue, if it's an issue at all.
The bulk tape eraser I use as a demagnetizer:
It works quite well for removing any detectable magnetism on the relatively rare occasion that some tools do become slightly magnetic.
Just another perspective on magnet bars and tool racks. I much prefer them to racks designed around loops, holes, tubes, hangers, screw eyes, and anything else that takes time away from selecting, grabbing, using, and replacing a tool efficiently. The second-to-last thing I want to do is have to insert turning tools into holes to replace them in the rack, or place them in PVC tubes, slots, etc. - WAY too inefficient for me. The LAST thing I want to do is reach past the sharpened end of a turning tool (and risk getting cut) because the tool I want is in a poorly designed tool rack. I have seen some pretty bad (and unsafe) tool racks!!
Can you please explain the relationship between magnetism and sharpening a tool "to a fine edge"? I remain curious how you come to the conclusion that slightly magnetized steel sharpens any differently that non-magnetized steel.
I'd like to see actual evidence that this is a problem.
I don't use a magnetic tool rest, but if you were ever a kid, you've probably rubbed two nails together to magnetize them? I have to think that rubbing any tool over the tool rest would eventually begin to magnetize it anyhow?
I have a 1" flat round super magnet that I use to stick things to my tool board. It is way stronger than most of the magnets used in the magnetic strips, so I consider it a "worst case" scenario. When placed on the top of a flat scraper, it was noticeably difficult to move the tool across the tool rest directly below the magnet. The magnet resistance decreased as I moved the magnet further down the length of the scraper handle, and at a few inches away, it was still present, but not what I would consider obvious (you might wax the tool rest or file it... probably not attribute it to magnetism).
The surprising thing that I did not expect was how much residual magnetism would be in the steel AFTER I removed the super magnet. Essentially the area where the magnet had been felt about the same as the magnet at the greatest distance! I have no doubt that the effect would even be more concentrated on smaller tools (shorter and narrower/thinner), and would be even more noticeable.
So, in conclusion, I think it does make a noticeable difference. Perhaps demagnetizers are a way to remove the effect, but depending upon the strength of the magnet in the rack, you might need to do it EVERY TIME you reach for a tool because the magnetizing effect can occur extremely quickly.
Steve wrote, "I have no doubt that the effect would even be more concentrated on smaller tools (shorter and narrower/thinner), and would be even more noticeable. "
Actually, no, I think the opposite should be true. With less of a mass of ferrous metal and a reduced cross-sectional area of the smaller tool intersecting fewer of the magnetic lines of flux from the tool rest, a tool of smaller size and diameter is LESS likely to take on residual magnetism or will do so at a lower level compared to a tool with a larger mass of metal (unless of course you were encouraging it by moving the tool repeatedly in the same orientation to polarize the magnetic dipoles within the metal; e.g. "pulling" the dipole in uniform orientation). The volume and shape of the ferromagnetic material also has something to do with the level of magnetism achievable. I don't think simple ferromagnets "concentrate" just due to smaller size (although magnetic lines can be concentrated using 'cores' in electromagnets), as far as I can remember from my physics classes and what the magnetism lab illustrated over 30 years ago. My assumption is that magnetic properties and laws have not changed since that time.... I forget all of the relationships of B and H fields, Maxwell's equations, etc., so if an engineer or physicist could confirm and explain this better, I can "re-set my magnetism hard-drive" with some confidence.
I did experiment #1 with the hypothesis that magnetizing a tool was a non-issue, only to find out how easily disproved it was. Not only would I not recommend a magnetic strip to hold a tool, I would suggest that any magnet strong enough to old a tool will adversely affect the tool's smoothness across the rest.
Also, same magnet acting on a 1/4" skew renders the skew nearly immobile with the magnet in place. On the scraper, while sticky, the tool could still be moved and the magnet was not able to support the hanging weight of the scraper. The much smaller skew not only hung, but required two hands to be removed.
It was difficult to judge "residual magnetism" qualitatively (experiment #1 vs. #2). Both definitely exhibited enough to be noticed. If I consider the super magnet as a constant source of magnetism, I can says with no doubt that the smaller tool sticks to the rest way, way more than the larger tool. Once the magnet is removed, if the amount of magnetism transfered is the same (I don't know?), the effect should be worse comparatively.
Regardless, the effect is noticeable...and I advise against it...which surprises me, because it surely sounded like an old wives tale.