Re: New Chain Saw Recommendations ?
Larry Menzel
Shoot...don't screw around, buy a Stihl and be done. MS 291 is versatile, powerful and fast. Last you forever.
FWIW, I bought mine last summer and absolutely love it.
Larry
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: New Chain Saw Recommendations ?
Larry Menzel
Shoot...don't screw around, buy a Stihl and be done. MS 291 is versatile, powerful and fast. Last you forever.
FWIW, I bought mine last summer and absolutely love it.
Larry
Re: count me in on the Stihl 18" Farm Boss
Larry Menzel
And another.
Well Brad, Have you decided yet?
Keith Newton
I'm sure both brands are great saws, so your not likely to go wrong with either. As for grade and size, I think you will be happy with the mid grade. However, I thought I would throw in my two cents. If you bought your other saw new back pin the seventies, this will likely be the last chainsaw that you will ever buy, so here is something to consider.
Chainsaws have a great power to weight ratio, and that seems to be even greater with the more powerful saws. There is a certain amount of stuff necessary to make just the basic saw, without adding that much more to increase the displacement a bit. For instance, you may find a saw in the 2 HP range for ~12#. Then get one more HP for each added pound.
Now, when it comes to using a chainsaw, I don't seem to notice the weight of the saw, until I put a long bar on, and it's not the weight of it so much, as the fact that the extra is so far out in front of the handle that it isn't balanced anymore.
But here is my suggestion. Buy the most powerful motor that is in the range of your budget and needs. The work comes, not from moving the saw to the tree, or even while using the saw, which may be even less work, since it pulls itself into the wood being cut. The real work for me, is holding my body in the position or stance while the cut is going on. The older I get, the stiffer or more painful my joints have become.
Cutting down a tree, then cutting it into manageable pieces is a little like a cross between some weight lifting, with a lot of yoga mixed in. It only takes a moment to lift the saw into position for the next cut, where you hold that position for the duration. That duration can be cut in half by doubling the HP, so that makes the work less over the long haul.
Then on the monitory side. If a bigger more powerful saw cost $200 more, but you prorate that out over ten years, that is only twenty for each year. If you use the shaw about twenty hours each year, that is only one buck per hour, but every time, you have done the cutting twice as fast. That's my rational for getting the better saw anyway, not to mention the pleasure of using a tool that just breezes through the wood with little effort. I think I learned that from watching Tim the Tool Guy. 
One last thing. I like getting really big trees, so would like to have an even bigger more powerful saw, but can't see spending the big bucks to buy a new one. Recently I needed a longer bar, so bought a 32" along with a skip-tooth chain for it. The dealer was trying to tell me that it wouldn't work, but when I pointed out that the 32" bar with skip tooth had exactly the same number of teeth in the cut as a 20" bar with a regular chain, he didn't have anything to counter that. I think it cuts great, so I'm happy with the purchase.
Don't overlook Jonsered, if there's a good dealer.
Chuck Jones - West TN
As has been said the dealer is the deal. That's why I bought a Jonsered the last time. I have had and worn out several Huskys and Stihls and I like them both. The local Husky dealers are useless. The Stihl dealers are okay, but Stihls are just very expensive in the upper end models. I bought the biggest Jonsered made (2166 I think. 71cc) and put a 20" bar on it because of the balancing issue already mentioned. The comparable Stihl is $300 more. I'm happy as a pig in mud.
Jonsered is owned by the same parent company as Husqvarna... and several other brands. Lots of parts are actually interchangeable.
Jonsered and Huskies
Jorge
are built in the same factory, on the very same bench about 6' from each other, using same parts. Why are they phasing out Jonsereds is a mystery to me, it was the favorite of all the pro loggers. It was my first saw and served me well for 18 years, when tried to replace it it was not available anymore, thus the Husky.
Re: Don't overlook Jonsered, if there's a good dea
Roger Chandler
Our Husqvarna dealer is fabulous! They also carry the full Stihl lineup as well as the full Husky line up and service mowers, blowers, tillers, snow throwers, etc.
I guess it really does depend on the people who own the business......are they the kind of folks you want to do business with?
Jonesred made a few models for Husqvarna..........they are good saws!
I don't think Jonsered is being phased out.
Chuck Jones - West TN
I'm not aware that Jonsered is being phased out at all. In fact it seems just the reverse. The brand was recently picked up by Tractor Supply. Of course that bothers me to some extent, in the same way it bothers me when any brand is picked up by a large retailer a la Husqvarna at Lowes.
Prior to the TSC deal Jonsered had very limited distribution around here. My local dealer has carried them for years and still does, but I couldn't have named another dealer nearby. I didn't know they were actually now integrated into the same plants as Husqvarna, but he had told me for years that most of the critical parts are interchangeable.
Husky 346XP w/ 18" bar
Ellis Walentine
Powerful, reliable, not too big or heavy, cuts like a bandit.
Re: Husky 346XP w/ 18" bar
Brad Vietje
Yup -- that's the one. If all goes well, I'll own one in about 2 weeks.
I'm not in a real rush, but 2 weeks is about as long as I want to wait. I have a friend with a bad back who needs some help clearing up a few trees, and if I fuss about too long, he may try to do it himself, or hire someone to do it, and I'll feel like I let him down.
My local dealer gave up the Stihl line because he felt their top end saws were just too expensive for the local market, so he brought in the entire Huksy line this week. Looks like my timing was good this time -- but only time will tell!
Safe spinning,
Brad Vietje
Newbury, VT
Re: Husky 346XP w/ 18" bar
Phillip Medghalchi
Ellis, for the life of me I tried to Google Husky chain saws and I keep getting the Husqvarna 372XP Chainsaw W/18in Bar & Chain for $749. Is this correct or you guys are really talking about the Husky brand that they sell at Home depot.( the tools I meant).
If this is correct I have to move closer to you folks to coem by and borrow your expensive chain saw. I thought that my Sthil chain saw(16") was too much to spend for wood turning purpose. I am y be wrong compared with what yo gys buy for your hobby. 
Re: Husky 346XP w/ 18" bar
Sergio
Husky is, I guess a nick name fir the Huskqvarna.
I have two Shtil saws and once learned how not to choke them they work great.
Re: Husky 346XP w/ 18" bar
Barry Irby
Phillip, I'm pretty sure Husky and Husqvarna are not related. Its true the us laymen call Husqvarna chainsaws "husky's" but they are not actually made by the same companies. The Husky line of tools are made by Stanley (mostly) and are the house brand for Home Depot. They don't make chainsaws. Husqvarna makes a bunch of stuff including sewing machines, buy not the tools and cabinets for Home Depot.
And you are right. Turning can be an expensive hobby. Many hobbies are expensive. Golf and Snow skiing are examples. Turning and woodworking offer the usually unfulfilled illusion that we are going to profit from the hobby by selling our products or at least filling our houses with fine furniture we could never afford. I have built a lot of furniture in my mind. Some of it fabulous.
Well...
Ellis Walentine
Yes, "Husky" is the nickname for Husqvarna equipment and no, I'm not made of money. I think I spent about $350 for my 346XP brand new, but that was a while ago, maybe 8 - 10 years. I saw one on e-Bay recently that's up for grabs at $235 and counting. They don't make that model anymore; it's been replaced by the 550XP, which sells in the low $500 range.
Re: Husky 346XP w/ 18" bar
Phillip Medghalchi
Brad, I think I have to move up there close to you so when the weather gets better we can go out there in all that woodsy area around you and give it a test run on that chain saw. You cut and I turn. 