Well, well... might's well end the year with some spirited debate and fireworks
I need a new chain saw, and I have not been up on current models for a number of years. Here's the background:
* I have used an old McCulloch 610 saw that's so old it has a manual oiler button (mid-70's ?), which still runs great, but I need a new bar for it and have not been able to find one.
* I also have an old Stihl 210 Electric saw with a 20" bar that's an impressive beast, and still works great. I use this inside the barn.
* My son, who worked for a tree service years ago, has a much newer Husqvarna (not sure of the model number), which I have used, and liked a lot.
I've been under the impression for years that Husky & Stihl are among the very best saws, but Husky makes so many different models, and I have not figured out what their numbering system (system???) means. 455 ? 460? 372? Is there logic here about engine displacement, horse power, or series/design details that I could learn to decipher? Pro vs hobby quality level?
I want a rugged and reliable saw with a 16" - 18" bar; I find the 20" only needed with really large trees, and even then, a little careful planning and smarts will allow pretty big trees to be felled with a 16" bar. And, I've got a friend with a 36" bar if I get into trouble.
Suggestions? Favorites? Models to avoid? Off-brands like Echo? Let the fun begin!
My current saw is a Husky 455. I don't know what the numbers mean either. I looked at a stihl really hard but it was twice as expensive and I had my last Husky for 15 years and a lot of use. In fact it still runs after a short trip to the repairman. I needed a saw immediately and the other Husky died and I was afraid it would need something serious so I just bought a new one. Then I took it in for repair and it was fairly inexpensive so I fixed it and us it for back up. I've never had trouble with either one of them.
I ran crews of sawyers (and saws) years ago, and became a solid Stihl man. That said, Husky's are always a good bet. If I were to choose and buy today, I would base my decision upon the local dealership, more than upon the brand.
In my town, the Husky dealer displays a lot of garden tools, has a big pretty showroom, and has located on a main drag. My Stihl dealership is in a "barn-like" building, off the main drag, and his showroom is predominately saws.....
I think my Stihl Dealer knows more about Huskies than my Husky dealer does!
Thank you. I'm also checking with a local shop in Northern VT called Chainsawr: www.chainsawr.com.
My son says he really liked the Husky 346 the best -- newer ones have the XP suffix. He has the 455, because he needed a new saw when he returned from Iraq and wanted to go help out with Hurricane Irene clean-up, and his local dealer didn't have a 346 in stock. He doesn't like the newer ones as much as the older ones -- he feels they were better made about 5 years ago, with better components. Maybe that's the Poulan/Home Depot influence?
I'm keeping an eye out for a used/rebuilt 346 fer sher.
Either a Stihl or Husky would be a good choice. One question to consider along with the purchase is service/repair availability near you. I have had my Stihl 362 for a long time with almost no issues and during my fire career we used nothing but Stihl saws. When I upgrade it will also be to another Stihl. Good luck and use your safety gear.
I love those shabbier "man cave" type dealers in any field. They are not about glitz, bright lights and marketing, but about service and knowing what they do from top to bottom. And -- they usually know how to fix just about anything, while some of the shiny factory authorized places are all about selling you parts... and parts, and more parts. Glad you found/went to the better shop !
I use chainsaws quite a bit for roughout.com. I use Husky primarily since their availability and the local service center. They also sell stihl but they recommend husky. The XP designation has been around a long time and is the professional line. I use a 372xp the most with a 24" bar. I have access to two of these saws. For bigger logs it is a 395xp with a 32", 36" or 42" bar depending on task at hand. I also use a 350xp with 16" bar for smaller stuff. I use a 350 (non XP model) for trimming branches and stuff around the house. Once you use the XP series you'll wonder why you ever used the rancher or non XP models. More torque and power in my opinion. I just learned something from my dealer. Store your saw with the choke out so air can't get to the gas as easy. Good luck with your decision. Both brands are very good and I think the available service center should be the deciding factor.
More than once I've heard that models sold at the big box stores are made specifically for them, which suggests they may not be to the same standards and tolerances as models sold at power equipment stores.
The most important variable is who provides the best service in your area.
Up to ten years ago all my saws were Stihl. When we moved they slowly went to family members and were replaced with Husqvarna due to the excellent service our local small engine dealer provides.
My two favorite saws are the 562XP and 550XP which is their current XP generation. The latter is used 95% of the time w/ a 16" bar.
I brought both saws to a local class to up my sawyer certification and while the rest of the students brought larger saws they all ended up using my 550.
The instructor who uses Dolmar for his daily work at first was skeptical until he tried it and then used it for most of the day's demos and exercises.
My neighbor and and another buddy who both cut over 50 cord a year (I only cut 20-30) tried my saws and replaced theirs within a couple months.
Can you tell I really like these saws? They cost more but are worth every penny if you cut a lot of wood or think you will down the road.
That being the case, if the best service shop in the area sold a different brand I would go with what they recommended.
I bought a Stihl 290 with a 20" bar in 1989. It is still running. It has gotten me through 4-5 ice and other bad storms. A couple of years Stihl had their 310 on sale so I bough one of them. Both the saws have had only regular service and a new chain once in a while.
The other thing I did was buy one of the 3 in 1 files. They are expensive but worth every cent.
If I was going to buy a new saw tomorrow it would be a Stihl.
I have two Stihls. One I bought in 1989 and it has served me well. It's been through a couple of ice storms and couple of bad hurricanes. All I have ever done to it is get a tune up every year and keep the chain sharp.
A couple of years ago I picked up a 310 on sale. Thought I would give the old girl a little rest.
I also have one of the 3in1 sharpening tools. Pricey but worth every cent.
Have a husky and an echo. The echo is a limbing saw (12-16 in. bar) and somewhere in the 15-20 year old range and runs great. The husky has already been praised.
if you can get it, a sweet saw. but may be out of production, I have a 455 as well, as the 353 is ancient.
I went around and saw the back room of dealers, the shtill dealer had a pile of saws for repair, the Husky dealer only had a couple, so I went with that and never looked back, The only time my saw went back to the repair shop, (blush) I could not start it, the dealer laugh at me when he opened the gas cap, it was full of oil!. Mea culpa, mea gravisima culpa.
I prefer the 18" bar to the 16", it makes a lot more balanced rig. Have the 20" bar too, just for felling the big ones.
In our town, in the Shenandoah Valley, there are a few loggers around and one servicing dealer that carries the Stihl line and the Husqvarna line up. The servicing mechanic that works on the chainsaws worked for nearly 15 years at the Stihl plant where they make the saws.
He and I were talking one day when I went in to get my snowthrower that was serviced and I noticed a Husky 390 xp there being assembled with bar and chain. He told me that Husqvarna are made heavier in the engine than Stihl, but both are good saws.
I have friend who is a professional logger and cuts for a few lumber mills in Va and WVa. He used to use Stihl exclusively, both big and medium sized pro saws. Back about 5 years ago, he had 3 stihl saws break the crank in the engine. He went to Husqvarna, and now won't look back! That could have just been a bad batch, who knows.
I have a Husqvarna 359 which has been a great saw and cut a lot of wood and still runs like new. Last year I got the 390XP.......man what a powerhouse and it will pull a 36" bar, but I got the 28" bar.........that is enough to manhandle, especially at my age! It will flat eat up a large tree, which is why I got it in the first place.
Brad, I had a 455 Rancher that died. Can't remember what killed it, but at the time I decided that I needed a saw that would stand up to some extended use. I researched it pretty well at the time and the recommendation that I got from all the loggers around here is the saw that I bought. I don't remember pricing, but I think it was more than the other models listed here. The problem that you may have with this is that it is possible it is not made any more. Husky made some modifications made to their saws to better comply with EPA laws and I believe the model I bought did not meet the new standard. I can't imagine the new saws are that much cleaner, but the loggers say that the newer saws that comply just dont have the beef of the older saws. I was able to talk my local dealer into ordering one for me, and there were still some available. Not sure what the XP stands for, but from what others here have posted, maybe a bit more oomph. Downside to my saw is that lugging it through the woods is a chore. It's pretty heavy. Other than that, it runs like a charm as long as you put the gas in the gas side, and the bar oil in the bar oil side. (Don't ask) I just read the rest of Jorge's post and got quite a chuckle as it seems he has done the exact same thing I did recently. I took it to my dealer and he was a bit stumped for about 5 minutes till he felt the gas with his fingers and figured it out. He just laughed and said that happens at least a couple times a week. And I thought I was the only idiot.
Nothing different here as everyone has their favorites and like their lathes as they feel theirs are the best. My only experience with Husky saws is the electric that I bought and was never satisfied with. I did an article on electrics for Woodturning Design Magazine and the Husky was ranked with the Craftsman below the Makita which performed well in comparison to those two. None of the three can compare to the Stihl MSE 220, yes it costs twice as much but it is ten times the saw. I own a Stihl 066, a Farm Boss and a 220. I have no complaints with any of them and have used them for years. I have at least 6 dealers within 25 miles (4 of them within 12 miles) and I know of no Husky dealers (I haven't looked specifically for one, just did there are 2 within that 25 mile area). I do not know this as a fact but my best guess as to a business selling both Husky and Stihl the saw with the best profit margin is the one he is going to push. I know of no dealers here that sell both. From reading all replies above you should be happy with whatever of the two you buy.
I looked at both Husky & Stihl and have been purchasing Stihl. The main reason is service availability and (very important) when I'm rip cutting to make turning blanks from green wood, the Stihl has a much larger discharge chute. (Didn't read all the responses so not sure if this has been touched on - sorry if it has).
You'll always get a lot of good information here, and as usual the W/C community came through with lots of useful information.
From what I've learned here, service is ultra important. Seems Husky has saws at 3 levels -- the homeowner/weekend warrior level; the Rancher level -- more serious quality and heavy-duty; and the Professional, or XP models.
The XP levels have better power-to-weight ratios, better vibration dampening, and better components throughout. Many of the tree service professionals use the 346XP for a very high power/weight ratio, and professional loggers who need larger bars tend more toward the 372XP or larger. Not sure about the larger saws, but the 346 has a magnesium alloy case to make it lighter, and a little more hp per cc. My son says to handle the 346XP and the 455 Rancher and compare how they feel -- I think he wishes he had waited for the first available 346.
Here in Northern Vermont, there is logging everywhere, and probably 50% or more heat with wood, so there is a large customer base (at least per capita), and quite a few experienced dealers. The Chainsawr.com guys are a major service center for loggers and tree services in the area (they are about 35 miles away), and about 7 miles from me in Woodsville, NH is a dealer who is dropping Stihl, and picking up the Husky line starting tomorrow. He found fewer people would buy the more expensive Stihl saws.
Quite a few pros have said the saws were "better" a few years ago, given some change to reduce emissions (Mike's comments are consistent with this), so I was advised to look for a used/rebuilt saw covered by a warranty. When I asked at my local dealer, he said he didn't have any used saws for sale at the moment, since he just cleared out a lot of stock to make room for the Husky line. When I said I was keeping an eye out for a rebuilt 346XP, he said he had 2 of them at home, that he's used in his property maintenance business, and since he would now get a few new saws with his Husqvarna dealership, he was planning to rebuild one and offer it for sale in the next 2 weeks ! I said, sign me up, and let me know when she's ready!
So -- unless the rebuilt saw is a dud, it would appear my search is over, though I still need to find a new bar for the Mac. First I gotta figure out exactly what model it really is.... I think it is too old to be the Pro Mac 610, so I have to go look...
Safe spinning & sawing, and Happy New Year to all,