Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Oil finish shelf life?

Posts

Oil finish shelf life?

#1

Roger in MO

Oil finish shelf life?

Roger in Mo

Minwax oil finish has a tendency to turn to gel in the can after it has been opened. Does Mahoneys walnut oil have the same characteristic? Are there any other wipe on oils that will keep in the can after it has been opened?

Re: Oil finish shelf life?

#2

Dick Hines

Re: Oil finish shelf life?

Dick Hines

I am just finishing up a can of Watco I opened in Dec. Still good. I go through a lot of it.

Re: Oil finish shelf life?

#3

Re: Oil finish shelf life?

Dick Coers

I don't have any trouble with Minwax wipe on poly staying good of quite a while. I crush the can as I use it. That keeps the oil to the top of the can all the time. Air in the can is what causes the short shelf life

Re: Oil finish shelf life?

#4

Re: Oil finish shelf life?

john Veerkamp

I've never had Mahoney's go bad on me. I've used it for quite a few years. It is my go to finish. I always put a coat of micro crystalline wax on pieces that will be displayed or handled.

Re: Oil finish shelf life?

#5

Re: Oil finish shelf life?

donlennon

Old hint/trick seal tightly then turn upside down and support if needed and the jell will form on the bottom area and that next to opening

will be fluid. Others will place marbles etc in the can to force air out before being sealed tighly.

Re: Oil finish shelf life?

#6

Re: Oil finish shelf life?

Mike Brazeau

Watco lasts forever, for me at least. My garage normally sits at 47F in winter until I turn on my InfraRed heater.

Re: Oil finish shelf life?

#7

Roger in MO

Re: Oil finish shelf life?

Roger in Mo

Thanks for the tips.

Re: Oil finish shelf life?

#8

the fine print

GaryG in MD

In my experience, pure oils generally last a long time without problems.

Watco Danish isn't exactly pure, but it too lasts a long time with no storage tricks needed.

The problem is with oil "finishes".

An "Oil Finish" is a proprietary combination of an oil and a varnish and a thinner (and maybe a drier).

The most notorious for gelling is Waterlox.

For this type of finish, you have to use the various tricks like putting it in smaller containers, storing it upside down, filling it full of marbles, etc., to keep the air away from it.

...GG

Re: Oil finish shelf life?

#9

an ongoing experiment

John Lucas

I've had terrible problems with miniwax wipe on poly and other hardening oil type finishes. I tried the various sprays that displace the air in the can and maybe it helped but not enough. My finish still gelled.

Then I tried decanting it off into smaller containers but still had trouble removing all the air and it eventually went bad in the small jars.

I've tried eliminating the air using marbles to take up the space. That's a pain and you have to find something to do with the marbles each time you buy a new can.

I tried putting saran wrap on top of the finish before putting the lid on the containers. It seemed to work but is messy and the finish will still gel in the small containers when half used if you don't put the saran wrap on top every time.

I think I finally have the solution but haven't put it to a full test yet. I bought some Coghlan's Squeeze tubes for storing foods and stuff for camping. I I didn't know if the it would be compatible with the finish so I filled a tube partially. Squeezed all the air out and put it in a plastic bin just in case it leaks or eats up the tube. That was about 6 months ago and it's still working perfectly. I think it's time for a full test.

Mahoney's oil so far has not gelled on me. It just takes too many coats to get the look I want. Most of my bowls are show pieces not users so I prefer either lacquer or one of the wipe on hardening style oils like Minwax wipe on poly or waterlox.


Re: Oil finish shelf life?

#10

Re: an ongoing experiment

David Gilbert

I primarily use Minwax Antique Oil (MAO) for my bowls but have used Mahoney's Walnut Oil and I use Watco for my flatwork. The problem with all of these is that they react with oxygen and gel or harden up. Removing the oxygen is the problem and the solution.

Here is how I use MAO and it works pretty well. I limit the number of times that I open a can of MAO. When I need some, I transfer it to a small glass bottle (50 ml) and then spray wine preservative gas back into the can. This gas is actually argon and is the same as bloxygen and pushes most of the oxygen out. I also spray the gas into the smaller bottle before I reseal it. By doing this if the small bottle sets up then I lose that but not the entire can. Once my bottle is used up I repeat the process. I have been able to keep a can of MAO around for up to six months and it does thicken as it ages but I usually can apply it before it cures in the can or bottle.

My experience is that Mahoney's oil cures very slowly. Watco is faster but still pretty slow. MAO can be pretty fast but is manageable. The worst that I have encountered is Behlen Rock Hard Table Top Finish. This stuff can gel in a weekend if it's left in the open mouth can they sell it in. I haven't used Waterlox in years so I can't comment on it.

Cheers,

David

Re: Oil finish shelf life?

#11

Re: an ongoing experiment

david

Looks like John's method has some promise. Waterlox is my finish of choice. After several quarts of Waterlox had jelled on me, I started actively looking for a remedy. What works well is displacing the air with water. The oil finish will float over the water level. First I decant the Waterlox into 3-4 small Mason jars. Fill each with water until the oil level comes to the rim, and seal with the gasketed cover. I use up one jar at a time and refill the jar after use each time. I keep a plastic bottle of water handy and fill up the space vacated by the use. This can be 1/16" on small projects, or up to 1/4" or more. Fill the water and the oil will rise; stop when the oil reaches the rim of the jar. The surface tension will cause the oil to curve up at the rim so there is a small amount of air trapped when the lid is on, but not much. Since using this method, have never had Waterlox jell on me. Sometimes refilling causes overflow when putting on the lid. Only issue is difficult removal of the lid of the jar use, especially when there is an extended period between uses. If the lids don't seal up completely, the jars can be used over and over.

Re: Oil finish shelf life?

#12

Re: Oil finish shelf life?

RPE1

I use marbles on my Waterlox. I've had some in storage for three years in Texas. It is still good. I don't see the big hassle with marbles. I got them at Hobby Lobby. They use them for floral arrangements. I use mason jars and put marbles in until it the level is up to the top. I clean the marbles with paint thinner when they are not needed. I clean the marbles in the jar with the thinner by just shaking them in paint thinner.

I do like the water solution much better however. I think I will go with that in the future.

Re: Oil finish shelf life?

#13

my solution: a year and counting

mjonesrdg

It was just an experiment to see if I could keep my Waterlox (and other oil/varnishes) from gelling. Now, a year into the experiment, and I have found other advantages associated with using these syringes. I can dispense just the amount I need without spilling, so less messy. I haven't had a drop go bad. they are cheap a reusable. I put a push pin through the protective cap and dispense through that tiny opening, and the push pin makes a seal in the plastic. About 2 bucks each. Many distributors online.


Re: Oil finish shelf life?

#14

i do same,,works

bob davis

keep oil to top and lasts til used up

Re: Oil finish shelf life?

#15

Re: an ongoing experiment

Lloyd in Mississauga

It seems like we need to come up with a way to keep the finish in a sealed container and have a spout to get it out.

Would you be able to reuse one of those bag-oh-wine boxes or something similar?

Clean it out and pour in the finish and then pump in some of the gas to displace much of the air and then have the spout at the bottom. The gas should sit on top of the finish to keep the left over air away. You could decant the portion you need into a small container for use.

Bit of pia to initially fill, but it may save the finish longer than in the can and cleaner than marbles or adding suran each time.

http://www.instructables.com/id/How-To%3A-Reuse-Franzia-or-any-other-%22Wine-In-A-Box/

Lloyd

Re: Oil finish shelf life?

#16

Re: Oil finish shelf life?

Dennis Bilevich

Ex hail into the can, work for me

Re: Oil finish shelf life?

#17

Bush Oil *LINK*

Don Orr

I use Bush Oil almost exclusively and it NEVER gels in the can. Not sure how widely it is available since it is a locally made product. Absolutely fantastic product.


Bush Oil