Re: an ongoing experiment
David Gilbert
I primarily use Minwax Antique Oil (MAO) for my bowls but have used Mahoney's Walnut Oil and I use Watco for my flatwork. The problem with all of these is that they react with oxygen and gel or harden up. Removing the oxygen is the problem and the solution.
Here is how I use MAO and it works pretty well. I limit the number of times that I open a can of MAO. When I need some, I transfer it to a small glass bottle (50 ml) and then spray wine preservative gas back into the can. This gas is actually argon and is the same as bloxygen and pushes most of the oxygen out. I also spray the gas into the smaller bottle before I reseal it. By doing this if the small bottle sets up then I lose that but not the entire can. Once my bottle is used up I repeat the process. I have been able to keep a can of MAO around for up to six months and it does thicken as it ages but I usually can apply it before it cures in the can or bottle.
My experience is that Mahoney's oil cures very slowly. Watco is faster but still pretty slow. MAO can be pretty fast but is manageable. The worst that I have encountered is Behlen Rock Hard Table Top Finish. This stuff can gel in a weekend if it's left in the open mouth can they sell it in. I haven't used Waterlox in years so I can't comment on it.
Cheers,
David