Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Lathe accidents avoidance

Posts

Lathe accidents avoidance

#1

Lathe accidents avoidance

Don Evans

There are two things I would like to say that I've not seen anyone else mention on this or any other forum.

1. Adrien's post pushed me to this (glad you are on the mend Adrien). THERE IS NO NEED FOR SPEED IN TURNING! I've been working with metal and wood lathes for long time (35 at least years) and I only recall going over the 1200 rpm mark once and that was to see what all the talk was about. This was many years ago and people seems to state regularly that turning small stuff was ok at 3000 rpm. Well maybe a pen once it is rounded but there really isn't a need. You gain very little time between 1200 and 2500 rpm turning if any.

2. With all due respect to Robo, there is NO such things as line of rotation (that danger zone) a chunk of wood coming off a plate or chuck can hit the ways or more than likely the tool rest and go in ANY direction. I've been hurt only once with a lathe and that was due to using a home made holder similiar to a Longworth. It came from FWW magazine and it was over 30 years ago. There were no 4 jaw chucks then for wood turning unless you used one made for metal lathe (knuckle busters). Anyway, in my one experience the wood came loose, hit the tool rest, then me in the head. I did have on a faceshield but it still put me on the floor.

My point here is mostly, turning slower is in my opinion the most important one thing you can do. Slower moving objects do less damage! Second wear best safety equipment you can.

Regarding faceshields make sure it is at least rated Z87.1, this is printed on the shield in one of the corners. This is not 100 percent either, it will not stop a bullet so slow down.

I've never seen anything that must be turned faster in order to produce it.

Don

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#2

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

Doug Adams

Don

I agree completely with your speed argument , I have turned for at least 35 years and have never had a lathe on its higher speed ratings. I am now using a Powermatic 35020B and I have never had the belt in the upper range.

Doug

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#3

Ditto

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Don, I will echo your comments.

While I've met production turners who spin wood at 2-3000 RPM (the wood doesn't stand a chance) to produce 24-50 bowls a day, the rest of us have, IMHO, absolutely no use for that kind of speed. I have done pieces that required interrupted cuts, as in a winged bowl, but I never had to go above 1,000 rpm with a 26" diameter to get smooth cuts. Most of my turning is done at less than 800 rpm.

I will also add that serious examination of the blank can prevent a lot of injuries. Nobody has x-ray vision, but simply mounting a blank of the lathe, especially when dealing with the flashy figured wood so many love, is just asking to test whether your face shield is truly "good enough".

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#4

Re: Ditto

John Lucas

Well I do turn fast but 90 percent of what I turn is under 6". I have turned bowls very slow to show that it can be done but it's like driving 30mph in a 55 speed zone. Painfully slow. I can turn much cleaner and get much more graceful curves at higher speeds.

I will admit that for many many years I never turned above about 1200 rpm. Now I frequently find I am above that, but, and this is a big but, not on large items. I would not consider turning a 15" platter at 2000 rpm.

Rule #1 above all else should be to use sound wood mounted to the lathe properly. Proper speed, proper personal protection and proper tool use comes next.

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#5

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

walta

In my opinion the soundness of the wood is the biggest risk factor.

We are all drawn to the flawed wood with bark inclusions and or voids but we all need to see them as the siren’s song call us to the rocks.

I am not saying we can’t sail near the rocks but when we do we need to be very cautious

.

Speed is a big factor.

If 20 pounds of wood comes off the lathe at 2000 RPM and hit you squarely in the head no hat, shield or helmet will save your life.

If you are in the same room you are in the line of fire.

Walta

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#6

Sobering news

Joe shelton

I have not yet used a face shield except rarely when roughing.

Do I need one when turning spindles?

Joe

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#7

Rob Wallace

Re: Sobering news

Rob Wallace

Joe:

Do you use a seat belt every time you drive a car? If so, you are trying to provide a last line of personal defense should you have a car accident. Your driving skills, bumpers, crumple zones, roll bars, and other features of the vehicle provide the primary defense - the seat belt protects you in more severe impact accidents. The same concept applies to turning...

i.e. ......wearing a face shield when turning. Using a face shield does NOT provide the the actual first lines of safety at lathe - that comes from using good technique and making good judgements about speed, selecting sound turning stock, and using correct methods and tools. The face shield is the last line of defense and should not be relied upon alone to protect you from fragmenting blanks, etc. It is "the turner's seat belt", and has been recently demonstrated, can make the difference between "living to tell about it", or having your woodturning friends need to turn an urn for your ashes....

Why would you NOT wear one? It really doesn't matter whether it is for spindles, bowls, platters, vessels, etc. - You should still wear personal protection any time the lathe is under power and wood is moving. Exceptions might be when turning especially small turnings, pens, etc. but at the very least, eye protection MUST be in place regardless of what you are doing, even when the fragmentation risk is small. Why not just get used to wearing a face shield whenever you turn? This should become as automatic as clicking one's seat belt when getting in the car.

Make smart decisions. Concentrate on what you are doing.

TURN SAFELY!

Rob Wallace

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#8

Re: Sobering news

John Jordan

Several people have pointed to speed as the problem and Don got it right. While it may not cause the initial problem, it is the contributing factor that has caused the serious injuries we continue to read about here. As the old 70's bit of wisdom said, SPEED KILLS!

Speed, crappy wood, speed, crappy wood, speed, crappy wood. Avoid those things and use the common sense safety precautions that have been pointed out and we won't read about your accident here. :)

There are a few people who demonstrate turning at uber speeds, and I think that's al that some folks leave the demo with............yeah, that's the ticket.

John

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#9

Steven Antonucci

kinetic energy is mass x velocity squared

Steven Antonucci

Velocity is a square multiplier to the amount of potential energy in a piece. Double the speed is the equivalent of 4 times the mass. Kinetic energy is when the piece comes loose. You need to think about how hard you want to get hit, and set your speed accordingly.

I literally watched a science program tonight where the shot a 1/4" ball bearing at 15,000 mph into a granite block. The block exploded into a million pieces. A perfect example of kinetic energy. High mass or high speed...high potential energy. Bad things can happen...

Steven

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#10

Re: Sobering news

John Lucas

Joe That's my argument also. I turn small things. In my shop in the summer face shields are very uncomfortable and simply not necessary for the work I turn.

If I turn a 15" bowl with bark inclusions, yes I'll wear one.

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#11

Won't argue one second about eye protection

John Lucas

Safety glasses are a must. They aren't hot and uncomfortable in 100 degree high humidity environments like my shop in summer. They also keep you from squinting when your using certain tools and angles that throw the shavings back in your face.

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#12

i'm also a slow turner

Mike Foster

I do not really see an advantage to turning at high speed. Much of my latest work has some pretty wonky mountings that are scary enough. I always stand out of the line of fire and turn at slow speeds. My Beauty does not have a RPM readout, but I would guess that I turn quite consistently less than 1000, probably quite a lot less. On those wonky mountings I may be cutting air more than half the time but I dont crank it up. Requires a lot of patience and concentration to not take too big of a bite. I will turn at faster RPMs on something small to get a better cut, but even that is not at the lathe's fastest. I can't remember when I last had the belt on the fastest pulley.

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#13

Alan Zenreich

Re: Won't argue one second about eye protection

Alan Zenreich

John,

A powered respirator helmet, with it's airflow keeps me much more comfortable in warm/hot conditions than without it.

So for me, there are no excuses for not wearing high quality eye/lung protection.

Oh, and in the "we can fix" that spirit, there are ways of cooling the body too if the shop can't be easily cooled. As a motorcycle rider, I have found cooling solutions that work for me riding with full protective gear, on the hottest of days.

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#14

Betty Scarpino

FACESHIELD RATING Z87+

Betty Scarpino

The correct rating notation for a safe faceshield is Z87+ (Don mentioned 87Z-1 in his email).

Andy Chen wrote an excellent article for American Woodturner on faceshields. If you do not have access to that article (April 2013 issue), send me an email and I will send you a PDF of it. editorscarpino@gmail.com

Yes, faceshields are the last line of defense (unless you are really, really, REALLY fast at dodgeball).

Don, I totally agree with you that high speeds are (usually) not necessary and in fact are dangerous. Thank you for your post.

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#15

Re: Won't argue one second about eye protection

John lucas

Im sorry but im not wearing a chilled jacket in my shop. :). I do have air conditioning but its not big enough and just sort of takes the edge off basically we all do what we feel comfortable with. Its good to hear what others do and to listen to the safety lessons. Then we do what we think is necessary.

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#16

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

Philip Duffy

Don is Absolutely correct in all respects. In my 23 years of turning I have had one bad accident when a big cherry platter separated and one piece caught me in the upper arm. In reflection, the speed should have been much slower, and it sure is these days!! I was out of commission for 3 months! Speed may be necessary in pen turning applications but not in regular lathe work.

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#17

Alan Zenreich

Re: Won't argue one second about eye protection

Alan Zenreich

John,

I was thinking more along the line of the phase change neck coolers (not the evaporative types)

I have several of these and find them VERY useful when doing many things in hot humid weather.

http://www.blackicecooling.com/

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#18

Steven Antonucci

assume the face shield really helped your arm?

Steven Antonucci

If you are wearing a face shield as a last line of defense it is akin to assuming that a bullet proof vest will save you against a .50 cal round. As you pointed out, the platter hit you some where else than the 1 sf a face shield covers.

As Adrien pointed out, so did his.

As the woman who was killed unfortunately learned, a face shield does nothing to stop a large, energetic mass. You also found that out. The human body just isn't built to absorb that much energy.

Of the number of accidents we hear about, a face shield probably helps in less than 10%. I think that there is a valid case for wearing one, but it needs to be put in proper context. If I told you that you had a choice between being shot with a vest on and not being shot, most people would opt for the latter.

There is no safe way to be in the line of fire. If you are turning or watching, take a simple Newtonian physics class and stop arguing with science.

And wear eye protection.

Steve

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#19

Alan Zenreich

Re: assume the face shield really helped your arm?

Alan Zenreich

I have no way of telling how many bits of gravel, debris or insects were deflected by my full face motorcycle helmet. This kind of thing is not reported.

When a motorcyclist collides head on with a truck, it gets reported (and someone always mentions that the helmet didn't protect the splattered guy from injury).

We rarely hear of lathe accidents where the face shield prevented or minimized injury.

I suspect that these are the majority, and in many cases the user may not know the event happened.

In these cases it's no big deal to the user, and it's not newsworthy. It's usually the catastrophic cases that make the news.

I've seen a few of these "Thank heavens I was wearing my face shield" posts on other sites, but they don't get much attention.

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#20

Steven Antonucci

100 percent of accidents are the turner's fault

Steven Antonucci

If you have the lathe at the wrong speed, that is the turner's fault for not having a good working plan every time they step to the lathe.

If you have "crappy wood", you put it there.

If you are in the line of fire, move.

If you are working beyond your ability, stop.

The fact is that just like a motorcycle helmet, face shield will not make the wood better, the lathe slower, move you, or a better turner. It does not protect you from yourself and the mistakes you are making.

Fix the mistakes.

S

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#21

I Agree 100%

Barbara Gill

Just this week I was roughing out a Cherry blank. When I turned the lathe off to check things I discovered a crack going through the blank. If I had been turning at an excessive speed and/or not checked the piece, it probably would have probably come apart.

There was no sign of the crack to start with. Dan got another chunk of cherry for cooking at the restaurant.

I never have understood the rational for cranking the lathe to top speed.

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#22

Alan Zenreich

Re: 100 percent of accidents are the turner's faul

Alan Zenreich

I strongly agree with "Fix the mistakes".

Avoiding problems is the best approach. Protective gear is not a substitute for safe practices.

Protective gear is for when accidents (things you may not have much control over) happen.

Eyes, lungs, face, skin, are among the body parts that I don't want damaged, regardless of event.

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#23

Rationale

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Subconscious death wish.

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#24

Disagree!! 100 % of accidents - turner's fault

Dale Bonertz

If you have the lathe at the wrong speed, that is the turner's fault for not having a good working plan every time they step to the lathe. (When trying new things you may think you have a good working plan but it may not be)

If you have "crappy wood", you put it there. (I rough turn a few thousand bowl blanks every year and can tell you from experience that not all defects/crappy wood can be seen prior to cutting into it. Stopping frequently to inspect is advisable but it may be to late in some cases)

If you are in the line of fire, move.(Some cuts will put some part of your body into the line of fire. Impossible to keep your entire self out of the line of fire 100% of the time. Your arm, hands, shoulder and yes even your head. Best to make sure the blank is sound and trued before making any of these line of fire cuts. ie:rough it first)

If you are working beyond your ability, stop.(You're also not growing if you don't work beyond your ability. That is the only way to learn new techniques, cuts and etc. You certainly don't go from watching Ellsworth, Jordon, Mahoney and etc. to your shop and your an expert with the new technique you were shown. You must practice it which means working out of your comfort zone/beyond your current ability)

The fact is that just like a motorcycle helmet, face shield will not make the wood better, the lathe slower, move you, or a better turner. It does not protect you from yourself and the mistakes you are making.(That is exactly why you where one. To protect you from a mistake/accident that you cannot foresee. Had a friend killed, one friend in hospital for six months and a brother laid up for three months do to motorcycle accidents. I am sure none could foresee a car pulling out in front of them. The helmet did not make them better cycle riders but guess which one wasn't wearing one.)

Fix the mistakes.(Totally agree to change bad habits. But this is not a cure all for what can happen)

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#25

Re: Sobering news

John Altberg

I have taken to wearing my face shield for ALL turning. The reason?: Even small spindles can come apart AND you may typically be turning them at higher speeds as mentioned. The game changer for me was when a bottle stopper blank spontaneously flew apart on an unseen defect in the wood while making a perfectly fine, catch free cut. The jagged piece hit squarely on the lens of my Uvex safety glasses and my eye was spared. Had that piece hit any flesh I would have been severely cut for sure. Has it happened since?, no. Will it happen in the future?, perhaps BUT I will be wearing my shield AND safety glasses!