The Strawman argument
steven antonucci
If you have the lathe at the wrong speed, that is the turner's fault for not having a good working plan every time they step to the lathe. (When trying new things you may think you have a good working plan but it may not be)
So trying new things somehow makes you not accountable for the results? There are so many outlets for getting information these days, there is not excuse for bad planning. Yes, there are some knuckleheads posting things on YouTube that are "caveat emptor", but in the end, the guy who decides to mount up that block of wood on that lathe in his shop is responsible for his own action. Nobody else. You either plan to fail or fail to plan.
If you have "crappy wood", you put it there. (I rough turn a few thousand bowl blanks every year and can tell you from experience that not all defects/crappy wood can be seen prior to cutting into it. Stopping frequently to inspect is advisable but it may be to late in some cases)
I don't cut 1000s every year, but I cut hundreds and I also find a hidden defect, but that is the exception and not the norm. Most defects are there in plain sight, and people just don't know it. People need to know what is meant by "crappy wood". I turn vessels with voids ALL of the time because they are much easier to empty, but it is not crappy wood. In someone else's hands, it is risky...
If you are in the line of fire, move.(Some cuts will put some part of your body into the line of fire. Impossible to keep your entire self out of the line of fire 100% of the time. Your arm, hands, shoulder and yes even your head. Best to make sure the blank is sound and trued before making any of these line of fire cuts. ie:rough it first)
Agree, but I spend mere seconds in the line of fire, even on the most complex size and shape when the wood is in bowl orientation. Spindle work forces you to be in the LOF, but you can lower your risk by standing behind the gouge/cut. If you are cutting a bowl, you never need to be in the LOF.
If you are working beyond your ability, stop.(You're also not growing if you don't work beyond your ability. That is the only way to learn new techniques, cuts and etc. You certainly don't go from watching Ellsworth, Jordon, Mahoney and etc. to your shop and your an expert with the new technique you were shown. You must practice it which means working out of your comfort zone/beyond your current ability)
Did I say never stretch your ability or to not work beyond it? If I turned two candy dishes, should my next bowl be a salad bowl or a 22" natural edge monster? The way to learn is not to try to leapfrog ten steps, but progress in consumable gaps. The acid test should be "am I scared to do this?" If the answer is yes, you shouldn't be doing it. If the answer is no, but you are unsure exactly what you need to do, refer back to the work plan item.
The fact is that just like a motorcycle helmet, face shield will not make the wood better, the lathe slower, move you, or a better turner. It does not protect you from yourself and the mistakes you are making.(That is exactly why you where one. To protect you from a mistake/accident that you cannot foresee. Had a friend killed, one friend in hospital for six months and a brother laid up for three months do to motorcycle accidents. I am sure none could foresee a car pulling out in front of them. The helmet did not make them better cycle riders but guess which one wasn't wearing one.)
The same way that I wouldn't leap from suggesting that I can ride a bicycle, so I can ride a motorcycle is flawed...many turners make the mistake that because they have a tablesaw... they'll be OK. I used to race bicycles, and I never did anything on a bicycle differently because I had a helmet on. I knew that the penalty for violating a law of physics or exceeding my abilities would result in a lesson that I got an F- on. Crashing on a downhill section at 30 mph when you misjudge your ability to bunny hop a log across a trail is a tough way to learn, and I only needed the lesson one time. Do accidents happen at the lathe? Of course they do... but an accident is what you described... a circumstance beyond your control. It is not a lack of education, bad work habits, or an overestimation of what you are capable of. The penalties are too great.
Fix the mistakes.(Totally agree to change bad habits. But this is not a cure all for what can happen)
The main point here is to educate people that face shields are only effective against certain types of accidents, and not cure-alls. If you look at the number of reported SEVERE injuries over the past couple of years, it is pretty easy to say that there are certain types of impacts that having a face shield on does not change the outcome. If anything, I think MORE people are killed or severely hurt wearing face shields than not, because they have a false sense of security.
In the end, ANY dialogue about ways to keep turners thinking about their personal safety is a good dialogue. For my personal safety, I chose to use my knowledge of physics and body positioning as the MOST effective means to reduce risk at the lathe.
Steve