Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Lathe accidents avoidance

Posts

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#26

Re: Sobering news

clay foster

I'll jump in here on the moderate speed bandwagon. I've been turning for 30 years, always at moderate speeds. I don't have any holes in my head, walls, or ceiling. The few times that something has come off the lathe, it fell to the ground, not the roof.

I agree with JJ that some of the horrible accidents we are seeing are a result of some demonstrators turning at speed 11 just for the showmanship. I demoed at a club once that the previous guest demonstrator was a very well known professional demonstrator that likes to crank the lathe up to take off speed for the same reason that lion tamers put their head in the lions mouth - it makes for a dramatic show. There was still a hole in the ceiling where he put a platter through it. Dramatic, stupid, and reckless. But several months later, that's still what the club members were talking about.

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#27

John Lawson

Re: Sobering news

John Lawson

I only turn small things, all spindle turning kiln-dried wood. I started wearing a face shield without exception when an inside-out turning I was doing (not at high speed) came apart with a bang. The four pieces landed in different places: two behind me in the garage, one lying on the ways, and one on the outboard side of the headstock. One of them destroyed my close-up light.

I don't want what happened to that light to happen to my face. You may fault my skills or my technique. I'm not much of a turner. But a face shield can convert a disaster into an adventure. I won't do without.

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#28

Re: Sobering news

Barry Irby

I had an accident in my shop years ago. I had a piece of wood I had roughed with a chainsaw and mounted in the spindle position. I was tired. (another item to add to the list of don't.) I usually reach for the face shield with my right hand and the switch for the lathe after that with my left. Some how got it backwards and the piece flew off quick as lightening and hit me right on the forehead. 27 stitches and $1300 later I was back from the emergency room. Fortunately, I had a neighbor who could drive me there. My Glasses had flown away in the impact. It took a while to find them and put the lens back in place. I am nearly certain if I had gotten the shield on first this would have been an embarrassing lesson and not a disaster. The piece of wood was roughly octagonal about 8" in diameter and 14" long. The lathe was set a 400 rpm and I think I had checked that the piece was free to turn and secure. (I still think about the I THINK part of that and double check it now.)

I addition, I know of two people killed by accidents with lathes. One was showing someone how to turn and had his right hand under the handle of the tool. He had a massive piece on the lathe, clumsily stabbed it with the tool and the handle came out of his hand hitting him under the chin, knocking him back so hard he fell and hit his head on the bed of his jointer, killing him. The fellow he was teaching, nearly forty years ago, decided turning was not for him.

The other fellow was turning a vase shape in a chunk of firewood that had an internal flaw and about half of it came off and hit on the head, leaving a horrible wound. He was found several days later. I knew him and know the fellow watching the one above.

Wear eye protection and a face shield. Turn at moderate speeds, don't turn crappy wood. Might be good to have a back up plan too. It took me several tries to get my neighbor on the phone. I had several nice chatty conversations with friends that were miles to far away to come help (I'm nearly blind without my glasses.)

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#29

Steven Antonucci

The Strawman argument

steven antonucci

If you have the lathe at the wrong speed, that is the turner's fault for not having a good working plan every time they step to the lathe. (When trying new things you may think you have a good working plan but it may not be)

So trying new things somehow makes you not accountable for the results? There are so many outlets for getting information these days, there is not excuse for bad planning. Yes, there are some knuckleheads posting things on YouTube that are "caveat emptor", but in the end, the guy who decides to mount up that block of wood on that lathe in his shop is responsible for his own action. Nobody else. You either plan to fail or fail to plan.

If you have "crappy wood", you put it there. (I rough turn a few thousand bowl blanks every year and can tell you from experience that not all defects/crappy wood can be seen prior to cutting into it. Stopping frequently to inspect is advisable but it may be to late in some cases)

I don't cut 1000s every year, but I cut hundreds and I also find a hidden defect, but that is the exception and not the norm. Most defects are there in plain sight, and people just don't know it. People need to know what is meant by "crappy wood". I turn vessels with voids ALL of the time because they are much easier to empty, but it is not crappy wood. In someone else's hands, it is risky...

If you are in the line of fire, move.(Some cuts will put some part of your body into the line of fire. Impossible to keep your entire self out of the line of fire 100% of the time. Your arm, hands, shoulder and yes even your head. Best to make sure the blank is sound and trued before making any of these line of fire cuts. ie:rough it first)

Agree, but I spend mere seconds in the line of fire, even on the most complex size and shape when the wood is in bowl orientation. Spindle work forces you to be in the LOF, but you can lower your risk by standing behind the gouge/cut. If you are cutting a bowl, you never need to be in the LOF.

If you are working beyond your ability, stop.(You're also not growing if you don't work beyond your ability. That is the only way to learn new techniques, cuts and etc. You certainly don't go from watching Ellsworth, Jordon, Mahoney and etc. to your shop and your an expert with the new technique you were shown. You must practice it which means working out of your comfort zone/beyond your current ability)

Did I say never stretch your ability or to not work beyond it? If I turned two candy dishes, should my next bowl be a salad bowl or a 22" natural edge monster? The way to learn is not to try to leapfrog ten steps, but progress in consumable gaps. The acid test should be "am I scared to do this?" If the answer is yes, you shouldn't be doing it. If the answer is no, but you are unsure exactly what you need to do, refer back to the work plan item.

The fact is that just like a motorcycle helmet, face shield will not make the wood better, the lathe slower, move you, or a better turner. It does not protect you from yourself and the mistakes you are making.(That is exactly why you where one. To protect you from a mistake/accident that you cannot foresee. Had a friend killed, one friend in hospital for six months and a brother laid up for three months do to motorcycle accidents. I am sure none could foresee a car pulling out in front of them. The helmet did not make them better cycle riders but guess which one wasn't wearing one.)

The same way that I wouldn't leap from suggesting that I can ride a bicycle, so I can ride a motorcycle is flawed...many turners make the mistake that because they have a tablesaw... they'll be OK. I used to race bicycles, and I never did anything on a bicycle differently because I had a helmet on. I knew that the penalty for violating a law of physics or exceeding my abilities would result in a lesson that I got an F- on. Crashing on a downhill section at 30 mph when you misjudge your ability to bunny hop a log across a trail is a tough way to learn, and I only needed the lesson one time. Do accidents happen at the lathe? Of course they do... but an accident is what you described... a circumstance beyond your control. It is not a lack of education, bad work habits, or an overestimation of what you are capable of. The penalties are too great.

Fix the mistakes.(Totally agree to change bad habits. But this is not a cure all for what can happen)

The main point here is to educate people that face shields are only effective against certain types of accidents, and not cure-alls. If you look at the number of reported SEVERE injuries over the past couple of years, it is pretty easy to say that there are certain types of impacts that having a face shield on does not change the outcome. If anything, I think MORE people are killed or severely hurt wearing face shields than not, because they have a false sense of security.

In the end, ANY dialogue about ways to keep turners thinking about their personal safety is a good dialogue. For my personal safety, I chose to use my knowledge of physics and body positioning as the MOST effective means to reduce risk at the lathe.

Steve

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#30

Steven Antonucci

And they keep getting promoted at Symposiums too

steven antonucci

With and without face shields...

Cut the platform for promotion if you want to see a behavior change.

Steve

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#31

Best statement

Dale Bonertz

"In the end, ANY dialogue about ways to keep turners thinking about their personal safety is a good dialogue. For my personal safety, I chose to use my knowledge of physics and body positioning as the MOST effective means to reduce risk at the lathe."

In your rebuttal this is the best statement of them all in my humble opinion.. We'll have to agree to disagree on the rest even though you have some good points. Not everything is so black and white in my view.

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#32

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

sergiov

Speed is just a dangerous substitute for a sharp tool unless one is turning a very small diameter piece which otherwise would be almost stationary. But a sharp tool is not dangerous and leaves a nicer surface.

Recently an important action house sold a turn burl bowl of 22 inch in diameter for $30,000. It was turned in the eighteen century. I just saw the picture and it was outstanding. A friend of mine went to the auction house and held the piece in his hands: he could not find words to describe me his feelings.

Certainly that bowl was not turned at high speed but probably with a very sharp hook tool made of high carbon steel (horror in these times of super hard steel!) and nicely honed every few minutes (horror in these times of dry grinding and no honing!). $30,000!

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#33

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

Geoff Whaling

I agree & disagree with both Dale and Steve. Both arguments assume a degree of knowledge and experience of the processes we use.

Why do we call these events accidents?? They are not accidents! They may be unplanned but they are not accidents – they are predictable and preventable if we posses the knowledge. Turners have known for centuries how to reduce risk. Some simple do not know any better, forget or deliberately choose to ignore sound well learned practices that have served turners well. Sure we have plenty of turners now and in the past who were pioneers and they became very skilled at managing risk and create incredible turnings on the lathe. They also realise that what they do/did carries a significant amount of risk so they learned to plan to manage hazards and risk or how to create certainty. Or they may just have been incredibly lucky. The wider turning community learn from their experience, knowledge and example.

Unfortunately we do have demonstrators who promote turning at high speed, or turning blanks that are high risk or have a significant amount of fresh air. Often their response is more speed to get a cleaner or “uninterrupted” cut. They set (good/bad?) examples to other turners who may not have the skill, experience or knowledge to understand the hazards and risks but they still choose to pursue that style of turning or type of project. An already high risk situation is often made ridiculously risky with unnecessarily high lathe speeds, with almost no hazard controls in place and little or no margin what so ever for error. It is up to us and the promoters of symposia, our leading clubs, the wider wood turning community and organisations like the AAW to say enough is enough when we see unacceptably risky practices!

I certainly am one to accept challenges, promote personal growth, promote pioneering turners and a range of views and skills in wood turning. Some tasks we choose to undertake carry higher risk than it should and in almost all circumstances that risk can often be very easily eliminated, reduced or the consequences mitigated. Some of those hazards and risks present potentially severe outcomes - even life threatening outcomes. Are those risks worth it? Do we understand that those tasks carry that level of risk or what the potential outcomes for us may be?

Why do we promote face shields as the answer? They are NOT the answer. Most face shields I have seen in use by turners in home shops, at symposia and in articles in our magazines are mere splash shields that offer almost no impact protection from objects with any mass. Most only offer a measure of protection from nuisance low energy particles that are a risk to eyes. Still better than none at all. Hazard identification / Risk minimisation is the answer and is has to be appropriate to the level of risk! PPE including a face shield and safety spectacles is one small part of the complete hazard management / risk minimisation strategy. Do not be fooled that spindle turning is “safer” - it is not. Larger spindle projects, multi axis spindle turning or even a typical baluster can generate objects with significant mass being ejected from the lathe that pose as much risk as a bowl blank. Medium impact rated face shields should be the minimum mandatory protection for any hand lathe turning – bowl or spindle! They at least mitigate the severity of some of the most common head injuries, but they are not the solution, just one control mechanism and a small part of the complete solution – education, hazard identification, risk management assessment, control implementation, assessment of severity of outcomes etc.

IF these head injuries were to occur in a work place the work place would be shut down until a satisfactory complying hazard identification, control and risk management system was put in place. IF there were a severe injury or death then there would most certainly be prosecutions. Why do we accept a lesser standard for our own personal safety when we control the environment we choose to “work” in?

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#34

Steven Antonucci

Spot on

steven antonucci

You bring out the best of my argument "against" face shields perfectly... most turners have splash guards that will do almost nothing against the types of projectiles that are causing damages. We hear accidents being reported where the turner "had a face shield" that "saved his/her life". Most of these items are repurposed from other applications and not meant to be used at the lathe.

John Lucas mentions that "even a catcher's mask" wouldn't work...and he's right because it was designed to stop a baseball, not a flying piece of wood. Think about the number of times that you've seen someone take a foul ball off of their catcher's mask and you know that it WORKS PERFECTLY for the activity it was designed for. I've never heard of someone being killed where a catcher's mask failed, and that is out of a much larger pool of people than woodturners.

Rather than repurposing a riot helmet next, or an arborist chainsawing helmet, football helmet, hockey helmet....why doesn't someone assemble a woodturner's helmet? Purpose built for someone standing at the lathe.

Steve

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#35

Re: Spot on

Geoff Whaling

Steve I personally wear an "Armadillo" Face shield & I am rather pedantic about my safety.

It is "Suitable for high impact, splash protection and outdoor use. Ideal protection against high velocity particles, splashing materials, molten metal and hot solids. Approved to AS/NZS 1337:1992 "

The robust browguard, harness, visual acuity of the thick curved (both vertically & horizontally) polycarbonate visor and its versatility for most typically encountered hazards for wood turners makes it the best of what is available here in Australia for wood turners.

We recently had a workplace incident where subcontractors were not complying with accepted work place safety standards for high risk rigging elevated platform work. A leatherman was accidentally dislodged from a belt pouch and struck another worker below on his safety helmet. Fortunately only minor mouth injuries when a dental plate shattered. Helmet & harness are automatic write offs under our legislation. The contractor has lost two weeks production with down time while the work place investigtion has taken place approx cost so far $50k and he may loose his "High Risk" work certifications. All because his employees chose to "speed things up" and clean up down below while another rigger was above in an EWP taking photos for audit purposes. What could possibly go wrong? Knowing some of the individuals involved they would not do that if they were actually rigging - or would they?

Often "low risk" is not as low risk as we would like to believe.

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#36

Lots of factors

Bill Howatt

There are lots of factors to be considered in being safe while turning but from reading this thread and various other threads the injury causing factor was bad wood likely coupled with too high a speed - certainly too high for the bad workpiece at any rate.

I would say most times if a blank comes out of a chuck or off a faceplate including the tenon snapping off, it usually falls on the floor or takes a bounce off the tool-rest and goes down to the floor. Notice, I said usually, not always.

The dreadful incidents that cause the injury are usually caused by bad wood flying apart such that there is a direction component that aims a chunk at the turners head and of course, if the speed is high, the kinetic energy of the flying pieces is high.

IMO, slow speed and very frequent examination of suspect wood like burls is a necessity. All wood even if it initially appears sound needs to be examined as it is peeled away. A lot of cherry I see is bad for shakes but I'll bet most of the "bad" can be seen from the start and it is probably the "bad" that makes them desirable to turn.

Regardless of the pros and cons of face-shields they should be worn for eye protection and a degree of face protection. I'd say that even though shields have failed to totally protect in many cases, they may well have made the difference in life and death.

I have gotten into the habit of using a lighter faceshield because of convenience but this thread has convinced me to go back to my heavier-duty one. Convenience is the enemy of safety in so many cases.

Bill

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#37

Safety ears

clay foster

It's obvious that injuries don't have a single cause, but are a combination of events, some a result of ignorance, some a result of premeditated carelessness. We need to use every safety device and practice at our disposal.

One that I would like to include is our ears. Okay, some of us older guys don't have certain upper ranges of hearing any more (such as a wife's voice,) but what is left is very valuable. Whenever I hear a change in the sound of the tool on the wood, I stop and check what caused it. It could be a hidden crack or bark inclusion, a piece of bark getting loose, or maybe something not dangerous except to tool edges, such as barbed wire. Anyway, this practice has prevented a lot of unscheduled events for me at the lathe. Your ears can also tell you if the tool is sharp or dull.

On a side note, I think some of the recent injuries and near misses are caused by the capabilities of current lathes and ignorance of new turners on what that means. When I started turning 30 years ago, about the only thing available were Powermatics and Generals with 10" diameter capacity and maybe one horsepower motor and a Reeves pulley drive. Now someone with no experience at all can buy a lathe with 24" capacity and a 3 hp motor. Maybe manufacturers and the AAW could work together on providing a safety DVD with every lathe purchase.

Re: Lathe accidents avoidance

#38

Re: Safety ears

Geoff Whaling

Amen! Couldn't agree more.