Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

This is way to quiet.........

Posts

This is way to quiet.........

#1

This is way to quiet.........

jake Niedling

Well those that post the most must all be in Tampa. I am surprised that no one from Tampa has sent any pictures or sightings. I guess we will all have to wait until they get back to see the pictures and the comments. Looking forward to all the postings.

Re: This is way to quiet.........

#2

Rob Wallace

Re: This is way too quiet.........

Rob Wallace

Hi Jake!

We're all winding down from a very busy few days of excellent woodturning saturation. It was great to see so many friends and denizens of the WC Turning Messageboard. You'll probably see things start to appear when everyone finally arrives home. I still have one more de-briefing/planning meeting on Monday morning before I head home, but many firm handshakes and hugs were being shared this afternoon until next year in Phoenix. The local clubs here in Florida did an outstanding job of making sure the whole event went off smoothly, and we really appreciate all of their efforts. In short, this was a great symposium, with 1,200+ turners having a great time!!

More later.......!

Rob

Re: This is way to quiet.........

#3

Re: This is way too quiet.........

John lucas

I'm just not phone or computer literate enough to post photos from my phone. We are driving through our 3rd storm trying to get to Atlanta. I met so many wonderful people.

Re: This is way to quiet.........

#4

Steven Antonucci

where is the social media team at AAW?

Steven Antonucci

I think it's obvious that most turners have become a little bit technology savvy and are using more and more technology to educate themselves such as YouTube and Facebook and obviously Wood Central.

I know that individuals have taken some initiative but it would be great to see the AW also take the time to put together a social networking /social media plan for future events.

the technology is available to record video and live blog on the AAW website very inexpensively and without a lot of technical know-how.

Steven

P.s. this post was posted with voice to text no typing required

Re: This is way to quiet.........

#5

good points, and since we are trying to attract..

Dick Coers

....the younger people into woodturning, the national should look into this very quickly. There could be concerns that if it's too good, it may effect symposium attendance, but I would disagree with that kind of thinking.

Re: This is way to quiet.........

#6

Are you volunteering. That's all it takes

John lucas

Remember most of the AAW are volunteers and they work very hard. They also have a ton of local club volunteers who also worked their butts of to make this a really good symposium. They deserve a lot of credit. Maybe next year someone can step up and do the social media thing

Re: This is way to quiet.........

#7

Steven Antonucci

I would volunteer if I was an AAW member.

steven antonucci

My point is that social media is here to stay... and if the AAW's response to this is "hey, we'll take what we can get from whoever wants to do it...", they are missing the point. The concept of an "online" symposium for AAW members (or better yet, to attract new YOUNGER members) needs to be thought out and delivered in a professional manner.

Anyone that thinks putting an online version will lower the number of attendees because they can watch for free should talk to Justin Bieber ... who was discovered after posting on YouTube and is now worth far more money than the AAW will ever see. I heard that the attendance was about 1200, and membership is in the 15000 range... meaning the national symposium is "available" to about 8% of the membership.

Informally, less than half of my two clubs belong to AAW and we know that we do not have EVERY turner in the area as a member. What if the Symposium Online could be used to attract another 10% of the population to join the AAW?

It needs to be done, planned and professionally managed. If it is a "best effort" thing... they shouldn't even bother.

S

Re: This is way to quiet.........

#8

Alan Zenreich

Re: I would volunteer if I was an AAW member.

Alan Zenreich

Steve, options for extending the symposium to people who cannot attend in person are already being considered.

Re: This is way to quiet.........

#9

It is a top priority to the AAW

matt overton

Steve,

This was the top item of discussion at the chapter meeting with the board at the Symposium. They are working very hard to redesign the website to have the ability to reach many more of us with greater content thru webinars, virtual symposia, and social media. This all comes at a cost. The lowest quote to rebuild the website is $100,000. The sad reality is that if that 50% of the people in our clubs that are not AAW members were to join, the resources would be available to do these type of things. I understand the reasons why they are not members, and don't wish to rehash past transgressions, but I also believe it is largely because of the efforts of the AAW that we are able to enjoy this craft we love so.

Re: This is way to quiet.........

#10

The Bieb's Business Model

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

as the next teenybopper idol was well planned, packaged, and financed as a commercial enterprise. That sort of effort is not available to the AAW.

"Professionally Planned" means "paid for" with hard dollars, with no viable source for same. Aside from the in-person meet and greet, there are 5 components to the National gathering: Demonstrations, Instant Gallery, Juried Shows, Trade Show, and Dinner/Auction. So what parts on this effort lends itself to on-line extension?

Instant Galley and Juried Show photos are posted every year on the AAW website so that's already "done."

Trade Show vendor already work on line plus they would have to pay for what amounts to advertising. A touchy area tax-wise as well as cost/benefit analysis for them.

Until the "replicator" is actually invented, we won't be sharing rubber chicken on-line so the Dinner gets left out. The Auction could, however, be done as a podcast with remote participants bidding on the items, but financial prequalifications would have to be carefully done and pretty strict rules such as absolute bidding implemented. In a fast moving see-it-now-but-it-right-now context (rather than an E-bay, QuiBids scenario) pod-cast bidding would be likely to create a lag that could overwhelm the effort.

That leaves the Demonstrations. Those could certainly be done via pod-cast in real time. Let us remember, however, that the Symposium is not free. So the pod-cast would also have to carry an admission charge. As people view You-Tube for free including lots of how-to-turn-wood videos, some serious consideration will need to be done as to how to create enough demand to justify the added production costs.

Re: This is way to quiet.........

#11

Steven Antonucci

That is the kind of thinking that will kill it...

steven antonucci

Appreciate you illustrating the kind of old world thinking that will absolutely kill a new idea. It can't be done because of these 10 reasons...

Has YouTube killed the DVD market for instructional content? Has eBay/Amazon/iTunes killed the "buy it" market because they compete with traditional retail? Or have they GROWN the market and catered to people who will not be served in traditional models?

Whether it is free or charged (whatever "it" is), the AAW needs to be willing to try something new and potentially, gasp... FAIL. Everyone focuses on the cost of new, the risk, blah blah blah... but the leadership needs to think about the long term viability of the organization. Unless there is new membership... with LIFE EXPECTANCY...it will not last. Kids today do not value hand crafts or take shop because the society has become "disposable" (I'll stop here... another rant is coming on...)

There is a complete lack of technology understanding if the AAW management thinks that this is $100,000 problem. While it would be great to be in real-time streaming, near-time is probably fine for demos (which should be free to members ... and possibly anyone else as a recruiting tool). If the AAW centrally managed the vendor area with "show specials", perhaps the vendors wouldn't have been complaining about how poorly attended the vendor area was... and perhaps smaller vendors could participate "virtually"?

Do you do everything in Phoenix? No... it would be chaos, but any one thing to extend the event... they have the WHOLE YEAR to figure it out...

Re: This is way to quiet.........

#12

Alan Zenreich

Re: That is the kind of thinking that will kill it

Alan Zenreich

I have a weeeeee bit of experience with providing an online presence, both live and recorded, having instigated and implemented these kinds of things for our product launches and annual conference.

I have discussed some possible approaches with a few of those involved in the planning process. They know that I would be happy to help out, and look forward to continue exploring the options.

Re: This is way to quiet.........

#13

Re: That is the kind of thinking that will kill it

Dale Gillaspy

Steven,

You sound like a great Monday morning quarterback.

You said "if you were a member." Your reason's for not being a member are yours and that is fine. We all have choices. However, you had some great ideas and seem to be certain the website can be re-vamped much cheaper than the estimates that are currently out there. If you have those professional qualifications or contacts, I can introduce you personally to the right people. That would leave plenty of money to implement some of your ideas.

You said the demo's should be free to AAW members. I think that is a great socialist view of it all. While that sounds great in theory, who exactly is going to pay for it all? Demonstrators get paid for what they do. Videographers get paid for what they do. Equipment costs, facility rental costs, and the list goes on.

(And yes, the proliferation of i-tunes and the like has greatly diminished the physical music/DVD market. Just ask Blockbuster and Best Buy)

Re: This is way to quiet.........

#14

Steven Antonucci

The right people...

steven antonucci

I know the right people. Problem is that they are the wrong people...they keep thinking "how do I do the thing that has always been done the same way it has always been done?"

My Monday morning argument is simple. Every year, the AAW throws the same event (and it is a good event), and every year, it gets the same result (+/-). Every year a percentage of the membership dies, or leaves for their own reasons... and the AAW accepts this as "OK"? Every year, the AAW decides that it needs to go after the youth market at the Symposium with a turning area and instructors (arguably, expensive?)... and how many of them join? Or ever turn again? Does anyone measure the effectiveness of this program?

Here are some a dumb questions:

Why is the AAW paying demonstrators? Does it have to? (I would demo for free... just travel costs)

If there was an online component of the Symposium, would they retain some of the folks that leave (without dying...those loses are unavoidable)?

Instead of a long narrow or ridiculously wide room where 10 people sitting in the line of fire can see, why not theater in the round?

Is it socialist to think that someone attending and paying is getting more than someone watching online? Half of the people in the room are looking at screens anyway (since they can't see anyhow) Is the AAW only interested in serving those members who can afford to travel?

Here are three EASY things that the AAW can do next year that cost nothing:

1.) Ask for volunteer demos... nothing but a plane ticket and a room paid for anyone who wants to demo. (I bet that there are many people like me who would do it... and that would force some of the people who want to get paid to demo to rethink the purpose of the event)

2.) Stream something. Anything. For free. The folks that live near the event can walk through the vendor area and IG without being AAW members. Why can't AAW members get it for free?

3.) Have purpose built rooms in the round so more people can see. Don't schedule demos that put people in the line of fire, but burning and decorating, or small lathe projects...

With the money I saved AAW in #1, you can pay for #2...#3 costs nothing.

Steven

Re: This is way to quiet.........

#15

Re: It is a top priority to the AAW

Harry in Beautiful Downtown Kulpsville

Well said Matt. I have said it before, the AAW is responsible for much of the growth of woodturning. It has pulled people with like interests together and made things like Woodcentral possible.

Also, no one is forced to join AAW. But if they don't, they shouldn't expect their criticisms to be taken seriously. Sort of like not voting and then crying about what our elected officials are doing.

Re: This is way to quiet.........

#16

Old Thinking

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Theater in the round? Great idea for Beckett, even Ol' William. All we need is to locate the facilities around the country that could handle such an effort as the 18-ring circus of the simultaneously on-going demonstrations. Seems like an easy putt. I'd like to see what the production costs, including site fees, would be like. With your New Thinking, Steve, maybe you could work that up? At no charge, of course. See this Old Thinker is pretty sure that the old rule still applies: Money talks, BS walks.

Demonstrators "doing it for free"? Are you seriously expecting professionals who make at least part of their living from this to what, use they vacation time for the good of the AAW? Seriously?

An then there's the real in-person social aspect of the Symposium that, until human society becomes totally digital, will hopefully never be replaced by those data-mining operations so often referred to as Social Media.

If you actually read my comment, you seem to have missed the points that most of what you propose, the internet sharing of work on display, is already being done each year. You proposal with regard to the trade show vendors would, if I remember, be prohibited by IRS rules. AAW can make and sell products to promote itself and raise money. It can sell advertising space in its magazine. It CANNOT endorse vendors or engage in a for-profit operation as you suggest. The must be left to the vendors to run their own "show specials" etc., which they may do by purchasing ads etc. in the Symposium handbook.

Re: This is way to quiet.........

#17

Rob Wallace

Re: That is the kind of thinking that will kill it

Rob Wallace

Steve:

I am sitting here in Detroit airport making my connection flight home after the symposium , and just read your response to this thread. Once again you appear absolutely clueless about what the AAW is doing and has done at recent symposia. Unfortunately, your frequent lack of accurate facts and that you not being a member of the associationgives you pretty much ZERO credibility to make pronouncements about the AAW should or should not be doing. Had youknowledge of thecurrent situation, and the real costs involved with running the organization, publishing a high-quality journal, and putting-on an annual national symposium, you would soon see that what you are proposing has costs involved with each and every aspect, regardless of what you think is "free" an easy. .

Sorry, but you are fundamentally wrong about much of what you have posted here. You need facts first before trying to steer an organization from the outside.

Rob Wallace

Disregard following text - Smartphone currently not acting very smart:

the proposals, in general, are intractable projects you propose. Though

Re: This is way to quiet.........

#18

What Rob said.


Re: This is way to quiet.........

#19

Steven Antonucci

You really can't figure out how to arrange chairs?

steven antonucci

Must be the way that I am saying it... so I will try again using different words.

Having been to my share of "turning things", the number one complaint is always the same. "I got there late and It was packed, so I couldn't see anything" (so I left...)

If I look at the Symposium sessions, there are probably a dozen sessions where the lathe wasn't even turned on. In each one of those cookie cutter rooms, there was a long rectangle with someone sitting at the front of it. All I am suggesting is that for sessions where coloring is the topic, hold that session in a room where the chairs encircle the demonstrator? More people will be able to see, and it costs nothing to arrange the chairs that way. I'm also willing to be that it will be a more intimate experience that drives more attendance for these sessions.

If you make your living as a professional turner, and the AAW "hires" you, isn't that an endorsement? Why should the "professionals" get paid when the local members who volunteer do not? Are the professionals somehow worth more to the organization than the uncompensated, unendorsed rank and file? Should they (we, as I am sort of a professional) volunteer to demo for just travel costs (since they are giving up their time in the interest of the organization)? I know I do... and I've never charged my club anything...

I do not for one second refute the social aspects of being onsite at the event (it is the only thing that I go for). However, since the vast majority of the membership will not attend the event, shouldn't there be some aspect of their AAW membership that is covered by their dues? Why can't they download and print their own copies of the book? (better question: why is the AAW still incurring that cost at all? make the book available to all membership to print on their own and never print another one again)

Is the "free for everyone" a socialist point of view (as has been pointed out?) Who is going to pay for this? (You've asked multiple times) A better question is "Where is the money going?"

If this were the real world, we'd look at the budget and we'd measure effectiveness of spend. Seeing as I am not a member, I probably cannot do that...but I know enough to know that as a non-profit, you can either raise more money so you can spend it or cut costs. AAW raises money by attracting members, which is done numerous ways. Reducing costs (by eliminating printing of Symposium materials e.g. or having "volunteer demonstrators") would free up the AAW to do "more of something" (because there would be more free capital)

Do I expect a professional turner to "give up a part of his/her income"? No, but I am sure trying to force it...The AAW shouldn't be a source of income for a professional turner.

Steven

Re: This is way to quiet.........

#20

Steven Antonucci

same as when I was a member (why I left)


Re: This is way to quiet.........

#21

Steven Antonucci

(The dismissive/u don't know/we got this attitude


Re: This is way to quiet.........

#22

Agree with Rob

John Lucas

Don't want to run this in the ground and you know I like you, but you are wrong or guessing about much of what you propose. Non professional turners are paid also, so it's not just a professional turner promotion.

Do you really think people would travel across the country to see non paid turners who probably aren't the caliber of Eli Avisera, Mike Mahoney, Stephen Hogbin etc. The regional symposiums do this but still use the paid big names to promote the symposium.

It sounds to me like your just wanting something for free and the complaining when we ask you to help out. Support the AAW and volunteer and you will get so much more. I have and so have the many many people who were there this weekend.

Re: This is way to quiet.........

#23

Steven Antonucci

I asked for nothing?

Steven Antonucci

I volunteered to demo for travel cost.

I told them to keep my book. (I am asking for other AAW members...I gave my Hartford book away to the first guy who wanted it...paper isn't my thing)

Anything that it appears that I am asking for myself is actually for the membership that cannot attend. I typically do not attend demos at turning events (unless I know the demonstrator)... so I personally don't care if the room is crowded or people can see. When I demo, I want people to get the full benefit of my experience as part of giving back to the community. I usually try to demo 2x per year, and my reward is the new friendships I get to make when I travel.

I treat the extended community like a large virtual club. Keep the DVDs. Keep the print materials and demonstrator fees. Keep the mileage charges to and from the airport. I don't want anything free.

S

Re: This is way to quiet.........

#24

Why??

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Do I expect a professional turner to "give up a part of his/her income"? No, but I am sure trying to force it.

A - You'll "force" nothing as a non-member.

B - What gives you the right to do so?

Here's and Idea, Steve. Join the AAW. :\ Submit your application to demonstrate in Phoenix next year, and include in your application that you will waive your fees and costs to do so. Maybe you'll get something going.

The AAW shouldn't be a source of income for a professional turner.

Really? The AAW was founded and created by professional turners. The POP and Collectors of Wood Art specifically benefit professional turners as well as up & coming professional turners.

It is the professionals who have moved the art/craft out of the shadows and have developed the innovations in tools and techniques you seem to take for granted.

Re: This is way to quiet.........

#25

Re: I asked for nothing?

Jerry Klug

I live on the "Left Coast" so it is unlikely we will meet. I attend events closer to home and I doubt you travel this far. I respect your support of Woodcentral and the information you share. You have frequently been a voice of good turning practices and comments useful to other turners. That said, I think you are on a toot about the AAW. You said they loose members every year. Not more than they gain. The AAW is growing every year. The clubs I am associated with are experiencing the same thing. The loss or members has so many reasons that you cannot in good faith claim that you know the reason. As the editor of my club's newsletter I have tried to quantify what the reason we gain or loose members. It can be as complicated as competing events that the individual has interest insuch as multiple hobbies and only time for one. I have had people tell me that it was too far to travel to the events/meetings. I drive over 120 miles to every meeting. Why? I am giving back. I enjoy seeing my friends. I am learning more about turning and hope to become a better turner. The ones that complained about the driving distance live across town from our meeting place.

You need to re-join the AAW and spend you efforts assisting and contributing realistic approaches to the organization. I suspect your leaving after Hartford indicates you have some political bent for your negative attitude toward the AAW. The organization is only as good as it's members make it and by not being a member makes one sound like they really don't care.

I don't text and I have not got onto Facebook. I know I will have to someday as it is becoming a popular communication tool used by many that I now e-mail with. I enjoy watching good instruction and have improved my turning by it. A virtual demo would be impossible if every watcher asked the demonstrator one question. The demonstrators at the AAW either accept questions during the demo or are available after. Free electronic demos cannot accomplish this. I am old enough to enjoy communicating by "talking" and "listening". I have a concern that the electronic communication our younger people are making mainstream will handicap them very soon. I thing the current AAW practices are doing well. I also see enough change in the AAW over recent years that I have faith that the leaders will adapt and continue to grow.