Talking in circles, Mark...
steven antonucci
AAW cannot endorse ... unless it is a turner... who can profit ...
Who I am and what gives me the right to try to change things?
I'm just a woodturner.
S
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Talking in circles, Mark...
steven antonucci
AAW cannot endorse ... unless it is a turner... who can profit ...
Who I am and what gives me the right to try to change things?
I'm just a woodturner.
S
Politics aside
steven antonucci
You are correct that politics started my re-evaluation of the AAW, but the reality is that I think AAW is missing a huge opportunity. It runs like a print media, and we all know that print is dying. I like the journal, as it is a great publication, but I have officially cancelled every magazine subscription I own. If I need to read something, I can look at 10X the content online.
I am not trying to replace anything (except the wasteful print) that the AAW does. Almost everything I have suggested is additive, and mostly at no cost or reduced cost. A virtual demo "room" could be set up very easily with consumer grade technology (think someone's iPhone on a Skype session). Is it going to be perfect? No. Is it a replacement for being at the demo and the event? Absolutely not. Will it get better if someone tries it? I'd bet on it, and I never lose a bet.
Driving change is REALLY, REALLY hard. I don't claim to be any good at it, but at least I try.
Steve
Re: Talking in circles
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
Wrong again Steve.
AAW's mission statement is to endorse and promote woodturning. It can endorse all of its members and promote their work in any way it sees fit.
It cannot, however endorse/promote mere for-profit commercial businesses like tool companies.
If you can't tell the difference between a professional artist and the guy running the hardware store, I can't help you.
I do, however, have to question what you're all about. You started bashing the AAW over what you perceive as deficiencies in its safety education efforts. Now you're bashing them over how they choose to run their annual symposium which you won't go to anyway.
You walked away from the AAW after Hartford and the Lacer dismissal. As you've said on this forum, you want nothing to do with the AAW due to "too much drama."
What's next on your "The AAW Sucks" list and why do you even bother?
You're a wood turner. That's nice.
The AAW "belongs" to its members, which you've made it plain, you've no interest in joining. You therefore have no standing or say in how or why the AAW should or should not do anything whatsoever.
Rather than take potshots at the AAW, since you find it so objectionable, gather some friends and start a new wood turning organization. Scrape together the few kopecks you say it'll cost, and start up your free virtual demonstration site with streaming video from the round. You believe it? Do it rather than talk it. If it succeeds, others will follow. You change the world one mind at a time. Best get started. You might, however, consider some kind of dues or membership thing to raise your startup capitol. Most of AAW dues go to produce the Journal. Very little dues money finds it's way into the Symposium, which are usually self-funded unless, like last year in San Jose, the thing looses a small pantload of money due to a screwed up selection and contract provisions.
How about a symposium ap?
Dick Coers
Is there an ap for that? Is that in the planning stage also? There are many ways to collect fees for any on line content. I'd be really happy to pay for more content compared to spending a $1,000 flying and staying at an event. Why wait until a DVD is available? Make it available for download. I also agree with room layout issues. I went to one national at Louisville, and finally made the decision on day 2 to camp out in a chair for each half day. I would choose one major demo I wanted to see, find a good chair there early, and camp out for some demos I really didn't want to see until the demo I wanted to see was over. No effort to go to a national since.
Re: How about a symposium ap?
Mark Wollschlager
I saw one that James McClure had developed for the iPhone.
It had some nice features and was loaded with this years rotation info.
He thought it would be available by Phoenix, if things worked out.
He developed it as a personal project.
No stated plans for Android, other than that he might look into it.
No electronic interface can substitute...
JamieDonaldson
... for the face to face exchanges I enjoy about the many Symposia I've attended. The Instant Gallery is among my favorite activities, and there is no substitute for seeing the actual work in person.
So professional turners aren't commercial business
steven antonucci
Ok... yup... keep telling yourself that.
I suppose that none of them own insurance on their professional business or hire accountants (or at least bookkeeping of expenses for their business)... like turning schools, or demonstration fees? Because if they did, they wouldn't be able to demonstrate because they ran commercial enterprises and were no longer "artists"?
But selecting and paying them to demo isn't an endorsement... nope... nothing to see here.
I won't bother discussing safety with you. Your law degree is probably better suited than my engineering degree to talk about physics and such.
Nobody has to listen to me, but you seem to have taken an interest? As I recall, you joined after the Lacer incident?
Nothing to see here, move along...
S
Re: So professional turners aren't commercial busi
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
You're catching on, Steve. Keep going. . .
Opps, wrong again, I've been an AAW member since 2003, and you were doing so well . . .
Jamie nailed it- eyeball to eyball is the best way
John Lucas
There isn't any way you can get all that I get out of a symposium by viewing online. A brief conversation with a new friend gave me some info that may change how I do my cupcake icing. There's no way I would get that kind of info online.
I have known Alan Z online. Would have never met his wife if not there in person. Same with Keith Thompkins. Had a great conversation with he and his wife. I've talked to John Beaver online but when we met in person we found out we have much more in common.
Re: Jamie nailed it- eyeball to eyball is the best
Alan Zenreich
John, in person is 'better'. However the fact of life is that most people on the planet simply can not attend any particular event in person. Whether this is because of geographic, scheduling, or financial restriction, doesn't matter.
My company has its annual conference that gets 17,000 attendees in person. That's a lot of people in one room to view the keynote presentations (the rear projection screens were over 300 feet wide!). These sessions are incredibly important, often introducing new products.
Of the attendees, 3,000 are employees...the rest are customers, prospects, analysts, press, etc. but that means that ther are still close to 60,000 employees that cannot attend the conference!. I can't guess how many customers and prospects can't attend in person.
So we now stream all of the keynotes online in real time, and make them available via our online community (managed by this humble narrator). So at the minimum we now make 14 hours of material available online. We also do live Q&A online... there's lots to share with the world.
By the way, I never watched the keynotes by sitting in the 'big' room with all those people. I decided to sit in one of the venue's restaurants, and watch the sessions on my tablet while leisurely having breakfast... Little earphones are a fine thing.
It's tricky serving multiple masters.
One school of thought is 'this information is very important, so we will only share it with those who pay to come to the conference'.
The flip side is 'this information is very important, so we will shout it from the rooftops to everyone who can possibly hear us'
Sales versus education.... they are conflicting agendas.
One solution is making a portfolio of information from the event. Some of it available to everyone, some available only as part of your membership dues, and perhaps some only available for a separate fee (in person or online).
As previously mentioned, I have a lot of experience with this topic, and look forward to continuing the discussion with the folks who are planning the next Symposium.
Have you attended all the national symposiums?
Dick Coers
You've never missed a symposium since you joined John? Must have been at least one where you couldn't go and would have liked to see more of it real time. I'm also considering all the international members. Now I bet a lot of them would appreciate on line content!
Videos
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
As most of the hands-on demos are run with video augmentation, power point etc., it shouldn't be too hard to set up a list of videos in the members only area of the AAW website where members who could not attend a Symposium could access them at their leisure after the fact. Assuming the AAW servers have the capacity, I would think it would be far cheaper than trying to live-stream 3 days' of demonstrations and presentations, thus forcing the potential viewers to adjust their viewing to the Symposium's live schedules. Time zones and the international date line being what they are, I'd have to wonder at the level of participation in a live-stream set up at 2am in Sydney, Berlin, or even Hawaii.
An additional "benefit" would be that it wouldn't tend to diminish live attendance at the Symposium which requires a certain number of warm bodies in order to meet expenses, even with local club volunteer participation.
What a great idea! LOL
steven antonucci
I say tongue in cheek, since it was my idea in the first place 
Pretty much spot on with every point. If you have something great, shout it from the rooftops. If you have the community, they will pay for it if they can, but why would you want to punish your "customers" if there are reasons that they cannot attend?
Open works and is inclusive. 92% of the AAW got nothing from the Symposium (1200 reported attendees out of 15000 members).
Wouldn't it be great if you could flip it to 92% inclusive...
(I'm willing to work with you Alan to make this happen)
Steve
Re: Videos
Alan Zenreich
Mark, agreed about the recordings being made available. A first step for live streaming might be the panel discussions. At our launches, we regularly take questions from around the world as the announcements are being made. We also set up Ask The Expert discussion threads in our online communities where the questions and answers continue after the event (useful for those who missed the live event as well as giving folks time to digest the information and formulate questions based on what they saw)
Questions
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
To get that kind of Q&A going outside of say the current AAW Forum, you're going to be asking for a whole lot of free overtime contributions by your proposed "experts". I anticipate that some may, but some won't, and the amount of such cooperation will be limited. After all, this whole this is not a commercial venture like your company's effort. The spur of the personal profit motive is mostly lacking in the AAW situation. Moreover, questions posed in other than a live feed become defacto one-on-one exercises since they can't be shared with the Symposium's live attendees. Perhaps setting up that Q&A on the AAW forum site would give a greater opportunity for that sharing.
The AAW used to produce a DVD of.....
JamieDonaldson
...several featured demonstrations at each Symposium, making that info available to members who were not in attendance. I don't know if this activity has been done in a few of the recent Symposia, but it really made a nice addition to a turners info collecting.
Re: Questions
Alan Zenreich
Mark, I am simply tossing out some ideas for consideration. I know the upside and downside of all the ideas I bring to the table. This is just a cursory discussion. The key is finding things that can be done, not spending much time on things that can't of shouldn't be done.
Re: Questions
Dick Coers
I would propose that it would be considered good marketing for a demostrator. Many consider their "touring demos" at clubs as a vital part of their yearly income. Do a good presentation with Q&A, show it around the world, and they get more students and more booked dates for club presentations. Not all of them of course, but those that are saavy marketers of themselves will. Consider what a printed article, book, or dvd has done for them in the past. Here is the current replacement. In fact, pay for view, would generate more income than dvd's that get placed in libraries or passed around internet forums do currently. Now also consider a Kickstarter program to generate funds for such an endeavor. Rock bands, movie directors, you name it are all doing this to fund new entertainment. Why not the AAW? 15,000 members (minus the 1,200 who go to see old buddies) kick in $10 each and get a of dvd. Kick in $50 and get a box set. Now we are talking enough money, right?
Re: The AAW used to produce a DVD of.....
Mark Wollschlager
I am pretty sure that the case of the San Jose symposium it was very cost prohibitive to create a DVD of the demos or instant gallery.
At that venue ALL recorded video had to be done by the union staff.
Pretty much anything had to be done by their people ( plug in power, adjust sound and projection equipment )
IG DVD's are available for almost all BUT San Jose.
http://www.woodturner.org/Shop/ProductShopItem.asp?PID=39
There were several video cameras circulating around the events in Tampa, but I don't know if they were official, 'freelance', or part of another project.
Understood, Alan
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
I'm not playing spoiler here, only trying to flesh out ideas and how to apply them. I think it's very worthwhile to extend the reach of the Symposium to people who can't travel each year. But I've also seen ample evidence that a sizable percentage of AAW members are basically magazine subscribers who care very little about the organization beyond getting their Journal on time every other month. Those folks are very unlikely to spend the time or money going to a Symposium in the first place, so comparing 1,200 attendees to 15,000 members is an illusory effort. Based on what I've seen of member involvement over the past 10 years, I suspect you'd be doing fantastically well to get more than 2,500 people, live and digital, involved in a Symposium.
I'm also aware that the AAW's actual operating budget is pretty limited (the EOG and POP activities are self-funded through auctions and dedicated endowments, so they don't impact the budget or membership dues) so every outreach effort, like you are describing, has to be carefully considered in light of costs, actual results, and the alternative paths available to get the same or nearly the same results. The AAW can't afford to spend money and volunteer time only to get minimal (or no) participation; that's a prescription to burn out your volunteers.
This may ask for a "build it and they will come" response, but the AAW doesn't have the resources to gamble like that. I'm well aware of the technical ability to conduct web-based meetings and such; that's not all that new, and getting better all the time. But there needs to be some level of demonstrated willingness, if not commitment, by the "target group" to use the service before the AAW can initiate that kind of effort. An example was the effort to get more people involved in the annual elections by moving the whole process to electronic voting. The hope was for higher participation and interest by the membership. There was a small improvement but far below what was expected. Another was the effort that allowed Members to call in, toll free, and listen to Board meetings. The idea was dropped for a total lack of member participation.
All that said, there is now a mechanism for you to make direct proposals to the board, including the ability to poll all 15,000 members and assess their interest in your proposal through an issue of the Journal. Seems to me that a detailed proposal that can be used to gauge actual membership participation should be your best course rather than me and Antonucci getting into arguments over who's the older thinker.
Of course, that could just be old thinking as well . . .
you lose 100% of the bets you never make
Steven Antonucci
I think that it can be done so many different ways if you can get someone to listen. However, I suspect that some industrious Turner could probably figure out how to deliver the DVD on their own and completely cut the AAW out of the picture. Certainly the IG... but a handful of demos too. Pretty sure you have the right to record in a public space...
Kick starter funding ...underground DVD market... where is my cloak and dagger?
S
Your "pretty sure" is most likely
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
very wrong.
While the IG is a free-for-all, you must pay to register in order to attend the Symposium demonstrations. Those demos are not, therefore, in a "public space" and bootlegging a video should get you sued for infringement of the AAW copyright which, IIRC, is granted to the AAW, exclusively, by every demonstrator (keep that in mind if you ever want to demo at an AAW Symposium). That along with whatever else some litigator could latch onto, would be an easy case, and stealing something from a public charity ain't too likely to get much sympathy from a jury. Consider also that because your enterprising bootlegger pulled his little theft in the State where the Symposium was held, he gets sued right there. That could be several thousand miles from his home making things pretty expensive to defend.
Stick to physics and engineering, Steve. You're not qualified to give legal advice.
just record the emerging artists and vendor demos
Vendors Will Love You
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
For the free advertising!
As far as the emerging folks, I think I'd do the courteous thing and ask permission to film and sell. Some people get a little touchy about being "used" to make money without also being compensated. Putting them into a free video library is one thing that might well be flattering enough to get cooperation; selling DVDs of their presentation for profit would be quite another.
Re: Vendors Will Love You
John Jordan
I would like to participate in this interesting conversation, but I have to run. There's a big concert at the arena tonight, I've never heard of the band, Donnie and the Big Note Guitar Kings, but they must be worth seeing. Can't believe I got front row seats, cause I'm sure it must be sold out. 
John