Got my lathe today, and wore myself out cleaning and assembling it. It's the Jet 1642, and I'm glad I couldn't afford a Powermatic. This mid-range size pushed me to my limits.
Don't have a chuck, am convinced I'll need one, and am focusing on a Oneway Stronghold because the things I read about it mention runout amounts. Still, the Nova and Easy chucks look very good.
What are the criteria I should use to pick one?
And why are there so many options or variety in the jaws of chucks?
And what's that Reverse toggle for? Will that put wood back on if I make a mistake?
For me it boiled down to the Vicmarc and the Oneway. Both excellent chucks with good reputations and the price is right. I picked the Vicmarc mostly because of the chuck key. It is a standard 10mm hex key so if you lose it or damage it just grab one from the hardware store. No geared teeth to wear out either. I also like the selection of jaws that Vicmarc has.
I doubt you will wear out the teeth in our lifetimes. I have 5 Strongholds and 2 Vicmark 120s. Both good chucks, both have a good range of jaws available. But eventually, you decide you are tired of swapping jaws and want to buy chucks dedicated to specific jaws.
The strongholds are easy to field strip and clean, the Vicmarks I don't know about as I haven't tried. Look at what jaws are available for each or you could call Christiane at Woodworkers Emporium for the Vimarc and the folks at Crafts Supply on the Oneway and talk to them.
They are both solid, about the same to change jaws.
I also currently have a Jet 1642. There's nothing wrong with any chuck on the market. There are little things about each that people like or dislike. Novas, I don't care for the inserts since they don't have a set screw to them to lock them, they do have a nice selection of jaws-the only Nova that is big enough for me is the Titan and the new one has mixed reviews. Easy Chuck? It's brand new. No one knows the longevity of it and it's components. It's also the most expensive chuck. In my opinion, and you know what they say about opinons.........Oneway and Vicmarc are the best. With that said, I must mention Axminster. They have a long history of quality chucks and have recently introduced a new version of their top of the line chuck (Evolution). Even the mid level Axminsters, are good chucks. A couple of down falls, They're only offered in the USA currently by one place, Lee valley. If they stop caring them, the accessories are gone. Also, I'm not a big fan of the direct thread chucks. Even though you have a Jet 1642, if you turn on a club's lathe or travel it's nice to have the option to switch inserts. I personally have 2 Vicmarc 120's. One with the standard jaws, one with 5" dovetail. I like the threaded inserts, they're a breeze to swap out, and they have a set screw that locks them in place. Vicmarc has the selection of jaws that is top notch. I also like the Dovetail jaws over the oneway straight jaws.
The reverse toggle is to "reverse" the spin of the lathe, runs backwards. This is helpful in sanding bowls, sand one grit in forward, sand the next grit in reverse crisscross the sanding action. Also some hollowing system are designed to run in reverse and their claim is to be more ergonomic. To hollow more ergonomically, just slide the headstock down to the end. The high end of the belt is for small diameter work, and the low side is for larger. The larger the diameter the faster the outer surface is spinning compared to a smaller diameter at the same rpm. Also for bowl turning, the lower end slows the speed but increases the motor giving more torque.
Every one of my Novas that has an insert has a set screw to lock the insert into the chuck (I have 15). Each chuck or insert comes with a set screw and little leather pieces that go between the set screw and the insert so the threads are not damaged. The other thing I like about Novas is the fact that all the current jaw sets will fit every chuck up and down the line, the only difference was the old Titan that had Titan Power Grip jaws that only fit the Titan.
I believe that you can't go wrong with any of the major chuck suppliers and I agree about the Axminster from Lee Valley as they are good chucks at very reasonable prices (I'm turning in an article about them). I do have a Vicmarc as I like the Father Sing jaws but the Easy Chuck is priced out of this tool junkies budget.
I have Nova, Vicmarc and Axminster chucks. The vast majority of them I bought used through the classifieds here or on the AAW site. I am up to 10 chucks now but since Bill Blasic has 15 I feel inadequate.
I hear lots of discussion about run out on chucks and have yet to see any of the name brand chucks have enough run out to matter when you consider that the material we are turning can contract and expand due to humidity changes more than the run out being discussed.
I got tired of changing jaws so I bought more chucks to allow me to have the jaws I most frequently use mounted and ready to go. It is a luxury but at the same time it does save you time. When I am turning a lot of boxes it helps to be able to leave a piece in the chuck and move on to the next one to perform the same operation.
I like the Nova chucks because all of their jaws will fit their chucks with just a few exceptions. Nova chucks can be had a pretty good price when on sale. The Vicmarc chucks are quality chucks but the jaws that fit the 100 do not fit the 120 and vice versa. As far as I know all of the jaws are interchangeable on the various Axminster chucks. The Axminsters are heavy and the gears seem to take longer to close and open than on other chucks but once you get them locked the wood isn't going anywhere.
Thanks for the info on the Novas. A few years ago I bought a couple of Supernova 2's and the inserts were plain-no set screws for a positive lock. They were also 1X8 spindles. What are yours? Maybe their are slight differences in spindle size. I like the idea of a Made in the USA chuck, but at the price of the Easy Chuck, you can buy 3 novas or 2 vicmarc 120's. Great idea, steep price tag.
Like the rest of us you are just one tool away from greatness. I cannot tell you which tool that is as I have not found it yet myself but I continue to search....
Just my 2 cents worth ... I'd go for the Vicmarc or the Axminster, with a slight preference for the Ax. Why? Axminster sells jaw slides! Get a set for each set of jaws. Changing from one jaw set up to another is now so simple. Wind the old set out, wind the new set in. Plus, they have the Mick O'donnell jaws, and, as was stated earlier, once the Ax gets a hold of the wood, it isn't going anywhere. Now, to be fair, I have only turned using a friends Axminster ... and he also has the Vicmarc 120 with just about every jaw set they make. I did like them both but as I said, that concept of having a slide set already with the jaws is a REAL time saver.
Joe, I have one chuck-the Oneway Stronghold. I have NEVER changed jaws, or had a need for anything else. Some of the folks here have multiple jaws/chucks etc.-some have a need and use for all that, some just like having a lot of tools.
Start with just the one chuck, and if you find the things you like to do would be easier with another chuck/jaws etc, then that is money well spent. I've just never had a need for anything other than gripping a two inch tenon. Other folks make things of more variety.
Get a full sized chuck like the Stronghold or the comparable sized Vicmarc. Dick says the Axminster is good-not very common, though-I don't recall ever using one in my travels. If I was buying a chuck today, I would probably be inclined toward the Vicmark because of the hex key like John Lucas said. But it really doesn't matter much. FWIW, I've never seen a Nova chuck that didn't wobble, although I'm sure there are some.
I have 4 SuperNova 2 chucks and 1 SuperNova.......and a wide assortment of jaws for them.
I just recently got the new Hurricane HTC 125 chuck ........by far the best value in a chuck on the market..........a quality chuck that looks like the Vicmarc 120 and I even took the back off to inspect the internals........needless to say, that I am truly impressed with the quality and especially the value.......$149 for the thing and it is slightly bigger than the Vicmarc 120.......I wanted a big chuck and got the 5" serrated jaws extra.
They also have the HTC 100 4" chuck which is more comparable to the Stronghold by oneway or the SuperNova2...........if I were new to turning and had not yet made a large investment in other chucks........hands down this is the way I would go!
Do a google search........view the youtube videos on it.........these are the real deal at a super value.........1/3rd the cost of a Vicmarc, and no I do not have any affiliation with the vendor or manufacturer.........just a very satisfied customer!!!
There is another option. A chuck is not the best way to hold wood. Especially with a mid range lathe like yours you want all the support and stability possible. A faceplate and/or glue blocks are much more efficient. It is not the chuck that fails but you are grabbing a sponge...that wood fibers compress and the result is a vibration problem. You can turn faster, bigger, and safer without chucks. Chucks have limitations and I want to increase my capabilities and not limit them. I can buy a half a dozen faceplates for each chuck cost.
I got started with OneWay chucks when I first started turning, got too many to change horses now. A few years ago I picked up a set of jaws that OneWay made for the Stronghold chuck that was drilled for Vicmark 120 jaws. They called them Versa-slides, got them on a closeout at Craft Supplies. Really seemed like a good idea - I wish someone else would pick up on it. There are a couple of jaw sets that Vicmark makes that I prefer over what's available for the Stronghold, with the slides, I've got a Stronghold dedicated to the two sets of Vicmark jaws I like.
I also picked up a set of Vicmark 105mm jaws drilled for the Stronghold at the Craft Supplies Super Wednesday garage (before the Utah symposium every year) sale a few years ago. They're my favorites for roughing and for bowls over 12"
Seems like there used to be a lot of options that aren't available today...what happened?
Joe - Like most of the others commenting, I have several chucks. I like them and use them regularly. However, I wish I had been taught in the art of using faceplates before I started buying chucks. For most projects, faceplates are superior to chucks. As Lyle Jamieson write above, chucks introduce vibration -- vibration that can be avoided by using a faceplate. This issue of vibration is of more importance to new turners. As you gain experience, you will learn to more accurately cut the tenon (or recess) used to mount the project in the chuck, which will reduce (but not eliminate) vibration. As Lyle also points out, faceplates are far less expensive than are chucks.
In addition, I often have several projects going at once. It might take me months to complete a project given that my shop time is so infrequent (the new job's a hassle and the kids have the flu). Faceplates are great for setting a project aside and remounting it back onto the lathe. Since the faceplate has never been removed from the project, everything centers perfectly. That's not the case when a project is taken off and then is remounted on a chuck. Usually, a couple of cuts is all it takes to get the project running true again, but that can waste away wood that you'd prefer to keep.
So, why do I use chucks when I find faceplates to be superior in so many ways? Chucks save time and I'm aware of their limitations. So, when, on balance, I feel I can turn the project using a chuck, I'll do that if I plan on completing the project within a reasonable time (so I can avoid a remounting issue if the wood moves). But, since I know how to use faceplates, my choice to use a chuck is an informed one.
I wish as a new turner I'd not bought a chuck for a year or so. I now realize that, too often, a lot of the difficult I was having getting a good cut was due, in part, because the wood was moving within the chuck because of a poorly cut tenon. Using a faceplate would have made it easier for me to learn how to use my other (cutting) tools properly. Starting out with faceplates would have made it easier for me to learn the other aspects of woodturning.
There has been so much comment on this subject that i wonder if I should add my 2 cents in. I turned for two or three years without a chuck, but in about 1990 the first Nova chuck came on the market. I purchased one and used it for about a year and then bought a second one. At that time, all of my lathes has 3/4" 16 tpi spindles. When the Super Nova came on the market, I purchased one and then later a couple of more. When the SuperNova 2 came on the Market I purchased two of them. I also have two of the Nova Chucks for four and five inch grips. After we went to Australia in 2006 and visited Vicmarc, I purchased two of the smaller Vicmarc Chucks. We also visited Vermic and I was impressed with their chucks and purchased one of those. Why so many chucks, because my wife and I both turn wood and we have four lathes set up in the shop. The Nova chucks are very good and have a wide selection of jaws. The Vicmarc chucks are excellent and is the Vermic chuck.
There have been a couple of comments about using a faceplate until you learn to turn. That is good advice, because it is more difficult to tear a chunk of wood off of a faceplate that out of chuck jaws. But as you get better it is nice to have chuck jaws to use instead of a faceplate.
Virtually all of the chucks on the market will serve you well, but I personally like Nova and Vicmarc and Vermec chucks. For what its worth in your making a decision.
With all the comments given, there is little more to add. I have a few nova chucks and a Vic but recently added a administer so I could make my own jaws out of hard maple. Great for scoops or odd shaped ornaments. Most popular chucks have flat jaws for making your own jaws except Nova.
I agree that newer turners would be better off to start with faceplates. I have some that I had a local welder attach a 1/4"plate to a heavy hex nut and drilled a bolting pattern in the plate. I had to relieve the threads so that the faceplate could bottom out on the spindle.
Good turning but be aware that the vortex. It will always maintain a vacuum on your wallet.
Great question, and many good responses. You even have responses here from world famous turners, exceptionally talented turners, teachers, authors, equipment inventors, and the whole shebang, but BY FAR the best response was from Greg Haugen, which you did not answer yet: What do you intend to turn?
I'll add two more: 1) What is your level of experience? 2) Where do you live? (READ: what AAW chapter club should you join?).
Asking wood turners which chuck you should get is sorta like asking a group of hunters which rifle, or asking anglers which rod & reel.... what are you trying to turn, shoot, or catch? There's no one-size-fits-all answer here. If your passion is hunting, and you intend to turn mostly game calls, pens and craft show projects you won't need the same chuck as someone turning 16" hollow forms, or someone turning pool cues and period furniture.
If you don't feel experienced enough to make the choice, I have 3 pieces of helpful advice:
1. As David Walser and Lyle Jamieson stated, master the faceplate first. There is almost nothing you can do with a chuck that can't be done just as well (or better) with a faceplate, and many would tell you the faceplate may be 5% slower, but in most situations gives a better hold. By forcing yourself to master the basics first, you will learn a lot of valuable lessons that will help you grow and evolve as a turner.
2. Join a local club, and attend the meetings and demos. You will probably learn more in 2 or 3 club (AAW Chapter) meetings than you could learn in a whole year of figuring it out yourself with books or videos. You won't regret investing the time and effort to seek out a group of experienced turners. Find a mentor who's work you admire, and with whom you can communicate well. If possible, someone who lives near enough that you can go turn in their shop. When you're ready for a chuck (basic skills in the bag and you know what you really want to turn), try their chuck. Try different makes and models at club meetings. Then you'll know which model(s) you like best, and you won't need to ask us :~)
3. Practice. Don't make things, at first, just make shavings. Examine those shavings. Learn the difference when a tool is sharp and cutting cleanly -- almost effortlessly. Learn what good and bad cuts sound like. Throw away the music and headphones, and listen to the wood cut -- it's important. I can sit in the back row at a demo with a blindfold on, and can tell who knows how to cut wood and who is struggling. I know how smooth that wood feels just by listening. It's a thrill to watch someone like John Jordan turn a form, and a real treat to hear what it sounds like. Learn that part, and when your turning sounds like that, you'll be well on your way!
Safe spinning, and best wishes,
Brad Vietje
Newbury, VT
(1 Oneway Stronghold and 1 older style Supernova -- not as good as the newer S-N II, BTW))
First, thanks very much for the detailed and informative answers and recommendations. It will take me a while to assimilate everything you've sent me.
In the meantime, I'm going to get to know the lathe and the accessories I have now. That probably means that I'll focus on getting sharp edges on tools, and getting those edges into wood (point taken, Brad).
Greg, when I know what I want to turn, I'll be back for more tutelage.
Thanks, everyone, for pausing so graciously to get me rolling.
After about 8 years or so I finally took the back off my Vicmarcs to clean them. All were clean and really didn't need it. The GRizzlly copy of the Vicmarc was dirty inside so the fit of the back and other parts must let in more dirt.
I'm not sure if I misunderstood your original post. Each chuck that takes an insert comes with a grub screw to hold the insert into the chuck. The inserts with a "L" designation have a grub screw to lock the chuck to the lathe (no unscrewing while reverse turning). The only 1" X 8 chuck that has the grub screw to hold the chuck to the lathe is the G3-D (made specifically for the Delta 46-460) and that is a non insert chuck. To the best of my knowledge there are no "L" inserts for the 1" X 8 (guess I'll have to find out).
Multiple chucks (no changing jaws) and multiple lathes are definitely a luxury but a nice luxury