Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Demonstrating without a faceshield

Posts

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#51

Steven Antonucci

Learning is not teaching either

steven antonucci

Remove woodturning from the equation for a second.

If you attended a Tae Kwon Do demonstration, would you expect to learn Tae Kwon Do from watching it? Would you suggest to someone that because you witness the demonstration, that you were now somehow qualified to do Tae Kwon Do?

I do learn at demos, but I do not consider the demonstrator a teacher. Just what's playing that night...

Steve

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#52

Number:

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

1. Possible but not to be relied upon.

2. Opinion stated was for the hypothetical of Steve Antonucci, a demonstrator who is NOT a member of the AAW. In that situation the AAW insurance policy will not cover either the demonstrator, the club/chapter, or any person present for damage loss or liability. Whether you agree with it or not, that is the limitation on the policy. Consequently, any chapter who employs a non-AAW member does so at its own risk. It is well to note that the AAW and its qualified chapters, being established 501c(3) charitable organizations, may be likely to be afforded some protection from claims of ordinary negligence under the Charitable Immunity Doctrine, but that immunity will not extend to a non-member demonstrator.

Your attempt to paraphrase what I said incorrectly posits an extreme case based upon absolutes that may be seriously overbroad. However, almost every demonstration I have seen or heard about always takes place in either an organized group situation, like a chapter/club meeting or officially sanctioned symposium with the demonstrator(s) receiving some compensation in some form, or in a commercial setting such as the traveling wood shows who use demonstrators as a name-draw to increase attendance for enhanced sales. Thus those demonstrators are "paid" for purposes of the question presented.

I will not comment on the burden of proof required except to state that while your simplistic description will be unlikely to suffice, just the litigation costs could easily bankrupt the average demonstrator who doesn't have insurance coverage.

This ends the pro bono [that's Latin for "free"] portion of this discussion. ;)

Caveat to all other readers: The foregoing opinion is effective in the State of New Jersey only. Readers in other States or countries should consult with competent legal counsel in their own area for advice or an opinion on the question presented.

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#53

Mike Stafford

Re: Number:

Mike Stafford

In my state the correct number is 12. That is the number of jurors it takes to decide a personal liability case and seldom if ever do jurors have sympathy for whatever deep pockets is being sued. In fact from my experience most jurors look at a lawsuit in the same light as hitting the lottery.

It doesn't take much anymore to convince people to take money from one person and give it someone else.

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#54

12 Angry Dudes

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Great flick notwithstanding.

Hi Mike,

When I was a puppy lawyer just getting my wings, my father, the finest trial lawyer I've ever had the privilege to have met, asked me the the following question:

"What is the obligation of the trial lawyer?"

I replied, "To win, of course."

To which he replied, "WRONG, WRONG . . DEAD WRONG! The obligation of a trial lawyer is to make a proper record for the appellate court that will sustain the trial verdict. You do anything less and you are guilty of malpractice!"

Mike, something less than 3% of the civil cases in our judicial system ever get to a trial; something less than 1% to a trial by jury. If matters are not settled, judges entertain and rule on motions for summary judgment because the facts involved in the case do not warrant being submitted to a jury and/or that no jury [in its right mind] could decide otherwise given the law that is applicable to the case.

It's a myth, a la Hollywood, etm, that silver-tongued money-grubbing "trial lawyers" have somehow subverted our judicial system.

:)

PS: And "dudettes" :D

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#55

What is not a myth is that "deep pockets"...

JamieDonaldson

...usually prevail in legal matters, because they can out-lawyer an individual that doesn't have the financial resources to continue and continue seeking legal relief, regardless of who is right or wrong. And don't ask me how I learned that lesson! >(

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#56

Re: Learning is not teaching either

robo hippy

Ah Grasshopper, you teach with out knowing it! Others learn from observation, and learning is the other end of teaching.....

robo hippy

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#57

Steven Antonucci

I repeat what I have learned

steven antonucci

So others may interpret it and learn.

In the same way that I would never blame you for teaching me how to core because I watched your video on YouTube (or Dale), I would not expect anyone that took what I have shown and blame me. Neither you nor I invented coring, and all we are doing is telling the stories in an oral tradition to our friends and fellow turners.

Unless you think that there is some kind of transitive property of teaching? If that's true, then it is all David Ellsworth's fault.

S

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#58

All Litigation is Expensive

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Some types, like your copyright case, other IP areas like patents, securities, fair trade, or toxic torts and such can be especially costly.

I work to keep my clients out of court and advise them to settle matters quickly because the costs of court proceedings will usually wipe out any advantage they might perceive they hold and then some. There are a large number of people and companies who know this full well and use it to their advantage knowing the other party will not or cannot afford to chase them.

A litigation attorney's dream client is the guy who wants to fight on the "principal of the thing" and has the disposable income to back his choice.

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#59

Faceshield & Safety Glasses

Steve Kniffen

Don't forget, according to ANSI Standard Z87.1, a faceshield does not provide eye protection. Safety glasses are required under the faceshield. The question is, which one will fog up first.

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#60

Leo Cuellar

Re: I repeat what I have learned

Leo Cuellar

I agree (surprise, surprise :D ) with you, Steve. While I personally have never been to a demo, time and again, on this forum and other sources, the overall success of the demo was rated in big part by how entertaining and engaging the demonstrator was. I personally would view a demonstration more as entertainment than education. If I signed up for a formal class I would have different expectations. No offense meant to anyone who does demonstrate and has a desire to teach, it is a noble aspiration. The unfortunate reality is that a distinction needs to be made between a demonstration and a formal class. Times have changed, we live in a society where people are looking at others to take responsibility for their own lack of reasoning ability. So, a lengthy legal disclaimer at the beginning of everything becomes necessary! No joke, I'd go back & edit any videos you may have posted on the net. If someone tries to copy what someone else has done, and their results vary, they then try to blame the originator. 'Tis sad, but true.