Well, I am a bad boy. I never use the face shield/mask. From years of turning sloppy wet wood (where are the windshield wipers), I learned to stay out of the line of fire. The face shield is always fogging up when I use it, and could never find a way to prevent that (yea, I know all the 'full of hot air jokes'). The dang thing just gets in the way for me. I have a powered one, very old and it was not comfortable either. With the fatal accidents that have happened recently, would the face masks have helped? I don't know. I guess the main risk with some people using them is that they think it makes them safe, and they don't use general precautions: sound wood with no defects, proper speeds, stand out of the line of fire. Learning how to figure out how sound the piece is you are turning is as much of an art as any other part of turning. Learning how to present the tools to the wood in a safe manor is another. Not a proper stance, I know. All of the face masks that are sold to the woodturning industry should have clearly marked impact ratings.
Our club meeting tonight is about shop safety. Hmm, I am one of the demonstrators, and the other demonstrator will talk about face masks/shields.
1 lb of wood, 500 rpm, distance 2' = hitting windshield at ~65mph.
Having rebuilt many frontal sinus fractures on those who survived the impact, the damage is severe and permanent no matter how gifted the surgeon. Furthermore, we have unsuccessfully fought to save the life of a patient from an injury at a lathe.
In my judgment, practicing your craft at the lathe without head protection is just not worth the risk no matter how skilled you think you are. Statistically, you are tempting fate.
And how can anyone promote an unsafe practice to others, especially while the earning money during the promotion?
.. and fatalities should be a new incentive for safe practices being emphasized among all turners. I remember during the Louisville Symposium that the safety demo started with slides of injury case illustrations, mostly chainsaw accidents, and by the time the 3rd or 4th slide hit the screen about half the audience had quickly left the room! Stuff does happen!
This is something that confuses me all of the time. I hear guys say "I took a class with XX at the Symposium"? Sitting in on a demonstration is not taking a class, nor do I treat a demo as instruction? I have no control over the viewer's ability to interpret what I am showing, nor their ability to replicate it with their hands or equipment.
If I had something in my demo that was particularly unsafe for a novice to do, I would point it out. Just because I show something doesn't mean that I am recommending that ANYONE in the audience should try it? Anyone that thinks watching a demo is some form of instruction is sadly mistaken.
Treat it like live entertainment, and know your own limitations.
I assume that you are aware of what a running chainsaw might do to you if you had an accident? Do you wear a faceshield and hardhat? Steel toed boots?
All that the AAW can do is recommend best practices. It has no authority over anyone to legislate how they work in a public setting. If you want to make demonstrators and vendors wear face shields, then the sanding guys better start wearing respirators and the wood vendors had better start wearing lumbar belts.
And anyone walking the floor had better have on a face shield too. I am always amazed that people will comment on the demonstrator, but not the 10 people 3 feet in front of the lathe...
For me, the face shields interfere with my ability to hear, see, and feel what the wood is doing. This is important to me. Common sense and the human species seem to be opposites much of the time. Your most effective safety tool in the shop is that thing that sits between your shoulders: common sense. When I teach, I do have the student wear the face shield. They always have the temptation to bend over for a closer look as they turn, which puts them directly in the line of fire.
For those of us who are at the production/professional level, we all have a lot of bad safety habits that are minimal risk for us, and would be suicidal for the beginner. Moving the tool rest while the wood is spinning, sticking hands inside a spinning bowl to feel for ridges and thickness, drop chainsaw starts, high rpm turning speeds, and a lot of cuts that we make. I always mention when I am showing a skill that a lot of what I do is 'professional driver on closed course, DO NOT ATTEMPT! This warning still will not keep some from trying it anyway. I also include that for trying new skills to SLOW THE LATHE DOWN. Probably the biggest safety step up for lathes is the variable speed lathe.
While I can't quote numbers, I do understand impact of pieces of wood. I have a 6 inch hole in the wall by my lathe from a piece that separated. Part stuck in the wall, and the other part bounced off my Baldor grinder. This further reinforced my standing out of the line of fire. If you look at the accidents, in retrospect, they all come from letting your guard down and not paying attention. I approach my turning like I do my car driving, Never let your guard down. Driving is not fun, too many idiots on the road. In the shop, I don't have to consider them, only myself, and some times I wonder about me.
The engineer's dilemma: you can never invent some thing that is idiot proof because as soon as you do, some one invents a better idiot.
The problem for demonstrators is how to reach those who are slow to learn.
Am I making excuses rather than reasons. Possibly.
I'm sorry I'm with Reed on this one. I have tried many times to wear a face shield. I simply find them uncomfortable and hard to see out of once they get dirty which they do quickly when turning green wood.
When you also figure that over 90 percent of all my turnings are small and injury is very unlikely I choose not to wear one. I did buy one of the Bionic shield face shields and it is the best I ever tried but it gives me a headache after wearing it for a while and if I loosen the head band any more it's just a floppy fit. Of course I don't even wear hats because I find them uncomfortable.
Of course I don't wear a bicycle helmut either. I find them uncomfortable and have ridden probably 35,ooo miles in the last 26 years without an accident. I also thoroughly enjoyed my ride through Kentucky on my motorcycle without my helmut. Felt great.
We are adults. we should read and study the necessary safety measures and then accept the ones we want to live with.
I will agree teaching is another matter and maybe we should set a good example there.
Actually, NO, I don't. I wear chaps made by Stihl. EVERY TIME.
I assume that you are aware of what a running chainsaw might do to you if you had an accident?
Absolutely. Back in the late 1970's I was a volunteer on our Rescue Squad unit back in New Jersey. Saw much more body damage and metal vs. body gore with torn flesh than most, with a few calls involving chain saw accidents. That provides enough psychological motivation to do things safely; a little fear is good.
Do you wear a faceshield and hardhat?
Integral face SCREEN, helmet, and noise-reducing ear muffs - Made by Stihl. Yes, EVERY TIME.
Steel toed boots?
When working in wooded environments or when felling trees, YES; every time - NO (my discretion).
I also wear gloves when using my chain saw, particularly a leather glove on the right hand. I have seen photos of back-of-the-hand cuts made by snapped chains, and I don't want to go there....
All that the AAW can do is recommend best practices.
No. That's not correct.... we can limit activities deemed unsafe at our own events....
It has no authority over anyone to legislate how they work in a public setting.
Correct - that is, in a PUBLIC setting. When demonstrators are not affiliated with a Symposium or other official AAW event, they can certainly do what they want - they have that right. (Some say they have the right to be stupid.) However you are wrong in saying that the AAW can not control its own Symposium activities. We not only have the right, but the responsibility to require safe practices at our events be done by demonstrators that we invite and subsidize. We certainly can do much more than recommend best practices.
If you want to make demonstrators and vendors wear face shields, then the sanding guys better start wearing respirators and the wood vendors had better start wearing lumbar belts.
That would be ideal, however those actions are not likely to result in insurance claims from participating in our events due to accidents brought about by, negligence, dangerous technique, or lack of personal protection. ( Vendors carry their own insurance and can torque-out their backs if they want.)
Chapters hosting turning demonstrators should also feel empowered to control the demonstrator's actions when they obviously are not following accepted safety procedures, or demonstrators who are not adequately protecting themselves with available safety equipment. If a demonstrator refuses to abide by the safety requirements of the chapter or club, including not using personal protection equipment, then it is the responsibility of the chapter to shut down the demo, or make appropriate corrections. Chapters should not incur additional potential liabilities because of poor or non-compliant demonstrators. If a demonstrator got injured, the chapter would bear the responsibility for that incident; (BTW - if the demonstrator was not a member of the AAW, he/she would not be covered under the blanket liability coverage. Chapters should be aware of that in advance.)
And anyone walking the floor had better have on a face shield too. I am always amazed that people will comment on the demonstrator, but not the 10 people 3 feet in front of the lathe...
If it is deemed that "the 10 people 3 feet in front of the lathe" are in an unsafe position, it is incumbent on the demonstrator to correct this safety situation before proceeding. Once in a while, common sense should come into play....
It IS the demonstrator whose technique is likely to be emulated by those turners watching - which is why the demonstrator is scrutinized more heavily. By accepting the role of demonstrator (and getting compensated for it, in many cases) that expertise brings responsibilities to show proper technique. This must become part of the culture of those that regularly do woodturning demonstrations, and those groups that host them.
I could point you at another 2 dozen examples from National Symposiums where AAW policy was being ignored. Not a single face shield in any of them, all well known turners... being paid... setting a bad example.
Pot. Kettle. Black.
If the AAW is serious about face shields, let's see them turn away a big name who doesn't wear one?
I'm guessing that Steve would consider college lecture halls simply demonstration arenas where the professors are entertaining their audience... not actually attempting to teach students.
In my opinion, teaching (what the instructor does) and learning (what the student absorbs) are two different things.
Just because the teacher has no control over what is absorbed does not make it simply entertainment.
When I demonstrate, I am only showing the audience how I do something. If they want to try it on their own, they are welcome to use the information I have shown the same way that they would use a DVD or Youtube video.
If you attended a demonstration given by Jeff Gordon (NASCAR) on how to drive fast, would you consider that teaching? Would you attempt to drive your car like a NASCAR driver because you saw Jeff Gordon do it?
When I have students in a learning environment like Peters Valley, I can actually teach them. It gives me the chance to go over the 800 subtle things it takes to get them to pick up a technique. They wear face shields because they are in a working environment where they have not been exposed to the risks. I have a chance to explain the risks to them so that they can make their own decisions later on.
You may attend a demo to learn things, but it is not teaching. Would you fault Jimmy Clewes for running the lathe so fast as being a reckless thing to teach? Or do you view it as more of a window into the way he works? We all know what the answer is.
We will continue to disagree on this point (as we have on so many other points).
In a club demonstration, the demonstrator is teaching how he/she does things.
There is a difference between lecture format and hands on workshops, but they are both methods of teaching.
If it was just entertainment, why would the demonstrator bother to solicit and answer questions from the audience?
I think the 'I am only a demonstrator' attitude is simply an excuse to be able to not be accountable for the contents and possible consequences of the session.
I enjoyed a very recent club 'demonstration' where the turner was being very careful to teach good technique and how to avoid poor technique while turning bowls. Call it a demo if you will, but the session was titled "Bowl Turning 101" (implying an introductory "course"), not a performance of "A Midsummer Night's Turning".
The audience will likely try many of the things shown. I did bite my tongue a bit when I saw that the demonstrator only wore safety glasses during most of the turning, but I as glad that he at least took that minimal step.
Oh, and yes, I have had long one on one conversations with many demonstrators, including Jimmy Clewes about demonstrator turning style and its effect on the audience. They have all been very gracious to entertain such discussions and brought a lot to the conversation.
While I am glad you refrained from the overwhelming urge to remind me when I forgot to flip my goggles down, I would still refer to my demo as nothing more than a demo. My personal demonstration style is very technique focused to introduce the ideas for efficient, safe work. No matter what I call my demo, it is still just a demo. Gil and Tony needed something for the newsletter, so I said "Bowl Turning 101".
If anyone left that demo and said "I just took a bowl class with Steve", would you agree that would be a vast overstatement? The only thing that I would say is "I just watched Steve's Bowl demo. He explains a lot of things in it."
Notice how I refrain from the word teaching?
In teaching, you have "tests" to check for retention and knowledge transfer. Teaching is also iterative. In a demo, if you missed it, it's gone. Why do demonstrators interact with their audience (not students..)? It is not to test retention, but to gauge interest. I want to know if I am boring the audience to death.
If you want to test whether or not I am trying to teach you something, don't see if I am wearing a face shield. See if you are. If you aren't, enjoy the show.
Re: Everyone is personally accountable for themsel
Alan Zenreich
As I said, we will have to agree to disagree... your view of teaching is much much more narrow than mine (for example, I don't think teaching requires testing)
Fortunately neither of us have a problem with the other one being "wrong".
Do you think if someone was injured as a result of attending a demo and trying something in their own shop, with their own tools, and their own hands- they could sue the demonstrator for "negligent teaching"?
Do you think any jury could be put together that a guilty verdict wouldn't be overthrown?
"Um... yeah, I saw this guy do this and I blame him for teaching me wrong"
Since you are a New Jersey resident and I am admitted to practice law in that State I can tell you, based upon your posed hypothetical, that you had best get some serious insurance that will specifically protect you against such situations, including the cost of legal counsel, to protect both yourself and the Chapter who employs you. Even the ubiquitous "Don't Try This At Home" will be no shield if a member of your audience attempts to emulate the technique you demonstrated to him or her, especially since they, through their club/chapter dues, paid you for your show 'n tell.
From what I have seen of the AAW insurance policy, I doubt that it would cover the situation even if you were an AAW member. Since you are not, even the club will not be covered if something happens during the demonstration, let alone afterwards.
Case will NOT be dismissed. Woodturning has been established as an inherently dangerous activity. The demonstration of a technique invites application and copying by members of the group. Knowingly demonstrating an unsafe technique to persons unqualified to use it might well constitute gross negligence as a willful disregard of the risk inherent in the use of the method by unqualified persons.
You asked.
Caveat to all other readers: The foregoing opinion is effective in the State of New Jersey only. Readers in other States or countries should consult with competent legal counsel in their own area for advice or an opinion on the question presented.
#1 If you are not paid for your demonstration, are you still liable because you showed it?
#2 If the AAW policy doesn't protect the club, the demonstrator or the person viewing the demo (regardless of their membership in AAW), what is the purpose?
It sounds like you are saying that anyone can blame a demonstrator they saw at any event for any accident that they have (in NJ), regardless of what they were doing. All they need to prove is that the demonstrator showed it and that they were "doing the same thing" at the time of the accident?
If that was the case, woodturning should not be demonstrated.
When I attend a demonstration, I expect to learn. It doesn't have to be hands on to learn new ideas to go home and attempt to put to use. The planting of ideas is teaching, and absorbing them is learning.