Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Demonstrating without a faceshield

Posts

Demonstrating without a faceshield

#1

Demonstrating without a faceshield

J Byron

There are decades of turning videos and dvds where most of the demonstrators never wear a faceshield and some even without safety glasses. Most all of the demonstrators are men, and most are larger men who stand well over the spindle, for example, David Ellsworth, Allen Lacer, to name just two of many.

My daughters brought this observation to my attention as justification supporting their protest of wearing a faceshield or full-head respirator, which is required in my shop, as this safety equipment is apparently not 'cool' and uncomfortable. They site Ashley Harwood, someone they closely follow in our local area, as one who doesn't wear or need a faceshield, even while turning large pieces.

While it is encouraging that my daughters are enthusiastic about art, woodworking and woodturning, it is alarming that they have such cavalier attitudes about safety based on what they have seen from professionals, online, at club demonstrations and in the media.

After googling the number of deaths and serious injuries at the lathe and noting that most were women, I ask myself if the woodturning community is doing enough to educate and protect their newest members? And is there something specific that put women at the lathe in more danger than men?

How can safety be better addressed when today's demonstrators continue to present with yesterday's unsafe practices?

thanks for your consideration

jb

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#2

Steven Antonucci

a touchy subject

Steven Antonucci

There is a lot to deal with in being a professional demonstrator. If you were to watch a demonstration, odds are that you as the viewer are in more danger than the demonstrator. I have had people at craft fairs comment about face shields, even though they were only standing in the other side of the lathe from me.

While a face shield and eye/lung protection are always a good idea, you simply cannot make the assumption that a demo is also a safety course. If you see someone doing something that looks dangerous, you should have the common sense to know that you are personally responsible for your own safety. If I watch someone free climb El Capitan, it does not mean that they are teaching me to free climb nor advocating that it is without risk. I know that myself.

No matter what you see or learn... only you know your own ability and you have to make a value judgment as to what is personally safe. Teach your kids and the next generations accordingly.

Steve

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#3

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield *LINK*

Mike Brazeau

I totally agree with you and think it is high time the AAW stepped up to the plate and lead change. It is not only women that fall into this category. The three principal turning publications that are commonly read in North America are full of photos of turners without faceshields. I don't think it takes a rocket scientist to determine that insurance rates are climbing rapidly because of the recent and widely publicized major injuries to the heads of unprotected turners. We rewrote our guild bylaws last year to make faceshields mandatory for all members during Hands-0n sessions and for demonstrators. The excuse of not being able to speak to the audience with a faceshield is easily overcome with a good wireless lapel mcrophone system. Ours was about $700 three years ago.


The Joy of Wood

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#4

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

Jeff Rich

The key to that was a "good" wireless microphone system.

I always wear a face-shield, although it did not help when I walked into an AC Control electrical box that was hanging low....

I think a lot can be said for having protection while turning, even while sanding.

All it takes is one hairline split.......

On the other subject of Wireless Microphone systems, they have dropped in price and changed over the last few years.

BEWARE of used systems, especially if they are 700Mhz transmitting frequency.

Also, do not expect a $99 Radio SHack system to work as well as a $700.00 Shure SLX System. I would encourage most here to look at the PGX series.

I design and install audio and video system in my 9-5, so I know a tad bit but not everything.

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#5

Jeff, it would be a great service if....

JamieDonaldson

...you would post some specific info about mic systems, especially wireless systems that are available, and within reasonable price range. This lack of customer education is a big reason that more of these systems are not in use, especially at the chapter and symposium levels. I acknowledge the difficulty of doing demos with a faceshield, but there is absolutely no excuse for not wearing safety eye protection! >(

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#6

Speaking of Ellsworth

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

For any who was not at San Jose last year a/o didn't catch David's hollowform demo, he was pushing safety and face shield use and, as fate would have it, a sizable chunk of the demo blank flew off and hit him square in the face. For an SRO demo in a large room it was a very uf&p demonstration of safety equipment. In speaking with him afterwords he was obviously taken back a few steps and most grateful that he was wearing the shield as he clearly would have been seriously injured otherwise.

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#7

Alan Zenreich

Re: Jeff, it would be a great service if....

Alan Zenreich

Jamie,

When I demonstrate, I use a 3M AirStream respirator/helmet/shield (PAPR). So it's important for me to do good sound reinforcement.

Lauren and I use three wireless UHF mics when we demo. She and I each wear very lightweight headworn mics (these work very well with the PAPR), and we have a handheld mic that we give to the audience for questions. We bring our own small speaker/amp (because most clubs have no sound system), and can optionally patch into an existing sound system.

I've done a LOT of research tweaking demonstrator audio. I know most of the equipment on the market, from $20 to $900. Both wired and wireless. We've settled on systems that are very good, but don't break the bank.

I hooked Steve Antonucci up with one of my mics for his demo the other day... it worked beautifully... it was the first time I was in the audience to hear this particular setup.

Because of some judicious purchasing, I actually have an extra wireless mic setup, and a self contained speaker that I'm about to sell. If you're interested, drop me an email.

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#8

Re: Jeff, it would be a great service if....

Jeff Rich

That is the way to do it! I would gather to say the high end Sony or Lectrosonics microphone systems with a JBL Vertec Line array would suit a demonstration.

But this is beyond the price range of what most people would be willing to part.

There are much more affordable systems available. I do not like hearing stories about customers that get these elaborate systems and they do not use them because the system is too complex, or a hassle to use or it only work under a half full moon.

However a (Insert cheeeeeeeep microphone name) would not suit us as well and there is a lot of cheap junky stuff out there.

I will do a bit of research on some good but inexpensive voice lift systems for demonstrations. I know we have used Califone, Apollo, Anchor, Peavey and Fender for our customers. Anchor has some nice products with the wireless system built in and a very inexpensive, very small headset microphone.

This microphone is available separately from Point Source.

If anyone has specific questions, please email me: jwrich5151@gmail.com

Now if you want the full JBL rig.....just kidding!

By the way, I will start a new thread, as this is about faceshields and safety.

Always wear them, PLEASE.

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#9

Steven Antonucci

It is a good system

steven antonucci

within 10 seconds, you forget that you even have it on. Loud enough to hear me in the parking lot. Unobtrusive.

Works well with whatever head/eye protection you use.

Steve

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#10

Betty Scarpino

AAW * Demonstrating without a faceshield

Betty Scarpino

The AAW already IS leading a change in attitudes about safety for woodturners. Faceshields are required for demonstrators at their symposium and shields are in front of all of the lathes to protect the audience.

The journal has had an article on safety in many of the recent issues (the upcoming June issue will have a safety quiz). Safety is incorporated into each article where appropriate and that is done by ensuring that techniques and processes are safe. As editor, I have rejected numerous photos of demonstrators at local events who were not wearing a faceshield. I've also rejected images where young children are standing in front of lathe.

The AAW just published a book on safety. Buy two copies today, one for yourself, the other for a friend. In fact, I have an extra copy I will dontate to WoodCentral.

Mike ... your comment about it primarily being women who are injured: That's not actually true. Women are more willing to talk about their injuries, sharing their experience with others.

Maybe someone who makes safety gear could start a line of "cool" faceshields for the younger generation?!

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#11

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

Lyle Jamieson

Remind your daughters that the DVDs and articles they are referencing are OLD. Things have changed in the last 10-20 years. All of the well known turners I know stress safety and turn by example and wear face shields 100 percent of the time. Thanks AAW for leading the way.

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#12

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

Brad Thompson

Lyle: OLD??? perhaps you will contact Ashley Harwood to discuss being OLD :>)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cz5_8k6w_yY

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#13

Another interesting thread!

Don Orr

I get where you are coming from J ! It has been annoying to me as well to see so many photos and videos without adequate safety gear.

I just did a demo for one of my clubs last week and wore my faceshield to set a good example for the group. They have a small wireless sound system that works fairly well. Don't know make or model but I can find out. The audience said they had no trouble hearing me even with the shield down. I fully admit I am guilty of not always wearing it at home though. I work fairly small a lot. No excuse though.

I have experienced Alan Z.'s system 1st hand and it works very well, even with the fan on under the face mask.

I have had bark and other bits bounce of my shield more times than I can count so they do work. Nothing big yet though.

Glad to hear the AAW is being proactive on this issue. With the technology available today, hearing a demonstrator through a faceshield should actually improve the viewing experience for the audience.

And it's very nice to hear that your youngsters enjoy working with wood. Remind them that losing an eye or having a nasty scar on their pretty faces is not very "cool" either.

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#14

Re: AAW * Demonstrating without a faceshield

Randy gleckler

Betty, Did I recall you were at the Nashville Symposium this year? Regardless, during the Sat portion of the symposium the Hotel also had a Baseball/Softball Event going on. One of their booths right besides what the Woodturning Symposium had going on was for Catchers helmets with wild colors and styles. I kept thinking to myself, man if they put a Face sheild on that, they might have twice the customers as they were some very comfortable and good looking helmets.

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#15

Re: AAW * Demonstrating without a faceshield

Craig Daymon

Demoing this weekend. I'll keep this in mind. My demo doesn't put me in the line of fire, so I was planning to only use safety glasses, but I was thinking of the shield (which I think I've seen used maybe once in the past year). Making a Saueracker Shell.

-Craig

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#16

Betty Scarpino

Re: AAW * Demonstrating without a faceshield

Betty Scarpino

Randy, no I had to back out of going to he Nashville symposium at the last minute (moved my 88-year-old mother into my home). I hope to attend the next one!

Yes, let's have some forward-thinking manufacturer step up to the plate (lathe?) to make really cool faceshields and other safety gear for woodturners!

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#17

Re: AAW * Demonstrating without a faceshield

Brad Thompson

Betty: Do the AAW safety requirements also apply to the Vendor's demonstrations?

Because at the past Symposiums I've attended, at the largest and most attended vendor demonstrations with Stuart Batty & Mike Mahoney face-shields were NOT EVER used -- by any of the folks at the lathe; reviewing the online videos confirms this.

Has the Symposium changed for vendors also?

Wonder if vendors even consider how much influence they have on those new to the craft?

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#18

Betty Scarpino

Re: AAW * Demonstrating without a faceshield

Betty Scarpino

I was going to mention the vendor area because the Board and ED have discussed safety requirements for vendors, but I don't know enought about what's currently in place to comment intelligently. You are correct, though ... vendors play a significant role in the promotion (or lack thereof) of safety. I'll ask Phil McDonald, AAW's executive director, and let you know.

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#19

Steven Antonucci

Why doesn't the AAW have a "safety" area at events

steven antonucci

Or safety focus demos? If it is so important, why isn't there more visibility and focus on the topic at the national level?

Why limit it to just the standing at the lathe turning part? A large number of turners could also benefit from chainsaw safety, OSHA training on VOCs and dust, bandsaw safety, tablesaw safety (for segmented work).

Trying to legislate one specific item while ignoring the rest of them makes no sense to me...

Steve

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#20

Alan Zenreich

Re: Why doesn't the AAW have a "safety" area at ev

Alan Zenreich

According to the schedule, Ron Gerton is doing a couple of sessions at the symposium titled:

"Safety Doesn't Have To Be Learned The Hard Way"

One of the sessions is on at the same time as one of my demos, I'll try to catch his repeat session.

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#21

Rob Wallace

The AAW and SAFETY *LINK*

Rob Wallace

Sorry I am jumping-in to this thread only now - I couldn't get on to WC yesterday, since I am in the process of grading term papers and a mid-term exam right now.....a big time crunch for me, given that the semester ends in about another week!

The AAW has made it clear that promoting and educating the woodturning community about safe turning practices will continue to be a high priority for the organization. I currently chair the AAW's Safety Committee, and we will continue to develop programs and policies that improve on demonstrating safe methods for woodturners, not just at the lathe, but also in sanding methods (including respiratory protection), sharpening, noise protection, chemical safety, and ergonomics.

At the demonstrators' meeting at last year's AAW Symposium in San Jose, all demonstrators were admonished to clearly demonstrate and promote safe woodturning practices, use appropriate personal protection equipment, and to include explanations and examples of how techniques should be done safely. We have already planned the same topics to be discussed on the afternoon of June 27th at the demonstrator gathering where use of full face shields will be discussed, as will the importance of including some discussion of safety in the individual demonstrations. Prior to the Tampa Symposium, all vendors will be contacted to make them aware that the AAW will be insisting on use of appropriate personal protection equipment in the Trade Show area. (Those of you who attended the symposium last year probably know that we were required to have polycarbonate shields in place for ALL activities involving any power machinery to be able to do demonstrations.)

For those demonstrators that disregard use of appropriate personal protection equipment while they demonstrate at the Symposium, the likelihood of them being asked to demonstrate again in the future will be near zero. Demonstrators MUST teach by example, and that includes use of appropriate personal protection equipment.

Betty noted that in the AAW's new "Journals to Books" publication project, the first book, released earlier this month, is entitled "Safety for Woodturners" and is a compilation of 18 relevant articles on safety from American Woodturner that deal specifically with identifying and working with safety issues in the use of the lathe, using turning tools, the band saw, chain saw, and first aid. This is meant to allow newcomers to woodturning, as well as more experienced woodturners, an opportunity to read a range of resources directly relevant to learning safe woodturning, as well as how to continue to remain safe while gaining experience. There will be at least 4 or 5 other "JTB" books being produced over the next year or two on topics related to learning different aspects of woodturning, but it was decided that safety was the topic that should be considered first in this series. You can have a look at amazon.com (link below) to purchase one of these brand new 64 page "mini-books" (about $ 15.00) for you, for your club, or for a new woodturner you are mentoring as a gift that "will keep on giving"!! Since $15 is a FRACTION of any hospital emergency room fee alone that might need to be paid if you are NOT turning safely, the new book is a really inexpensive investment in learning about what things need to be done to be able to work safely.

I can assure you that the AAW will continue to take its role in providing education and safety awareness very seriously, and that the topics of safety and minimizing risk will remain high priorities now and into the future. Mike, "we have already stepped up to the plate!"

Rob Wallace, Chair

AAW Safety Committee

Member, AAW Board of Directors


"Safety for Woodturners" at Amazon.com

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#22

Thank you Betty & Rob

Mike Brazeau

It was J. The original poster that drew attention to women. Overjoyed to see these actions happening.

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#23

Rob Wallace

Re: Why doesn't the AAW have a "safety" area at ev

Rob Wallace

Steve:

Have you been to a recent AAW Symposium? There have been a number of demonstrations that do focus on turning safely, as to methods as well as environment. Many of our demonstrators include a brief discussion of safety when they begin their demonstration, or at critical steps within the progression of the demo.

My demonstrations last year in San Jose were specifically focused on developing safe turning environments, using methods that minimize risk, and reducing negative health effects related to turning. To be able to have these kind of demonstrations included in the Symposium, we need people willing to present them. If you are an AAW member and want to contribute to future safety presentations, we'd love to have you!

Please see my other post in this thread which reviews recent developments and plans for the future related to developing more education and awareness of safety issues.

Rob

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#24

Re: Why doesn't the AAW have a "safety" area at ev

Brad Thompson

Perhaps, Steve, since the first visual attraction for a new turner is AT THE LATHE, teaching through example AT the lathe might be the most EFFECTIVE method to start with.

Having taught drivers-ed for years, I would never have required student's seatbelt use without using mine. Furthermore, in the early days of seatbelt laws, there were plenty of old coots howling at being required to use one...but today, how many of us would ever consider starting up a vehicle without one, let alone allowing our children to drive without buckling up, or racing on a course without a full harness? In vehicles, we have learned about the physical laws of force -- why are we so slow to learn it in front of a lathe, which is defined by the same laws?

Anyone who demonstrates must consider their influence on their audience -- wouldn't it be heartbreaking to know that someone who followed your methods injured or killed themselves because of your influence.

No ... anyone who conducts public demonstrations, especially those who make money from demos, has a moral (and legal?) obligation to teach through example; working without a shield to head is irresponsible and unprofessional.

Chuckling to myself as the words of Norm Abrams keep reverberating : "Before we use any power tools, let's take a moment to talk about shop safety. ..."

Safety should be the first AAW educational goal.

AAW mission statement: "Our purpose is to foster a wider understanding and appreciation of lathe-turning as a traditional and contemporary craft and a form of art among the general public and amateur, part-time, and professional woodturners. This will be accomplished by providing education, information, organization, technical assistance, and publications related to woodturning."

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

#25

Rob Wallace

Re: Demonstrating without a faceshield

Rob Wallace

Brad:

I'm pretty sure Lyle was referring to the VIDEOS and ARTICLES being old.....

.....we can agree that Ashley isn't old; she may still need some encouragement to demonstrate publicly with a full face shield if this is how she is being viewed.

It is a false impression that someone "doesn't need" a face shield..... these young ladies following that logic should be put back on the right track that NO ONE is that much of an expert to not need personal protection equipment!

Rob