Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Has a face shield prevented an injury??

Posts

Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#1

Has a face shield prevented an injury??

Ed Larson

In light of the injury to Lynne Yamaguchi I thought "Have face shields prevented injuries??" We usually only hear of the accidents and not the near misses so I would like to get some sense of how often a face shield has prevented an injury. Please describe the incident with as much information (size of work piece, lathe speed, body part affected, what the consequences might have been without the face shield, etc.) as possible.

To my knowledge, there is not a large data base as to the effectiveness of the face shield, hopefully your replies will help in that regard.

I will start. I try to always use a face shield and do so probably 98% of the time. I have had no serious near misses but many time have had pieces of bark or large wood chips his the face shield. Certainly these could have caused cuts to the face and in the worst case a possible eye injury.

At our meeting last Wednesday a club member related the following: He was turning a bowl wearing a face shield respirator when the bowl (8-10") came apart. He had no warning and had just touched the work piece with the gouge. A piece hit the face shield and knocked it off his head. A second piece hit him in the chest and produced a laceration. He was thankful for the face shield and believed he would have suffered a major head injury had he not been using a face shield.

What is your experience??

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#2

Steven Antonucci

Once

steven antonucci

I had a situation where I had a platter split in half and it punched a hole in the ceiling 10' above my lathe. Half hit the face shield and blew it off of my head. I suffered no injury at all. Without a face shield, I would have had significant issues. It was 15" in diameter, and probably 3/8" thick. It likely only weighed a few ounces. If it had been more massive, the faceshield would not have done much.

Getting out of the line of fire is still the best means of defense.

Steve

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#3

Mike Stafford

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

Mike Stafford

I can only speak for myself and on two occasions I was glad I was wearing a face shield.

The first time I turned a chunk of manzanita burl I was merrily turning the inside of the bowl shape when suddenly the burl started disintegrating a piece at a time. No less than a dozen pieces hit my face shield and undoubtedly would have damaged my eyes and perhaps my lovely face if not for the protection.

The second time was more serious because of a stupid mistake on my part. I was rounding up a box blank. I always wear my face shield when I am rounding up a box blank because the spindle roughing gouge can knock off some large corner pieces that like to fly up into your face. Well in this instance I turned on the lathe and put the spindle roughing gouge to the wood and the blank came loose from the centers, bounced off of something and ended up hitting me on the end of my nose. My nose was reddened but I was okay. I had forgotten to tighten down my tailstock and it could have cost me some blood.

Always wear eye protection and a full face shield is a good idea. And remember to always check how securely mounted your work is before turning on the lathe. Let me tell you I learned two lessons that day about faceshields and tightening down things on the lathe.

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#4

Chuck Jones - West TN

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

Chuck Jones - West TN

I've had a few pieces large pieces of bark hit my face shield. Probably would not have caused serious injury, but I'm glad the shield was in place. It's the big one that's going to come off some day, or the small piece that will aim for my eye that keeps me wearing a face shield and safety glasses.

One day I walked to the grinder to sharpen a bowl gouge. I didn't use to always keep my shield on when I was sharpening, but for some reason that day I did. I was distracted and let the gouge slip off the edge of the grinding stone. It caught between the Norton SG stone and a useless shield that used to be on the end of the grinder. It busted the stone up pretty good and a large piece smacked the face shield right in line with my mouth. It scratch the shield up but I did not get a fat lip from it. I said some dirty words about ruining that $100+ stone.

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#5

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

boxxmaker

Yes,more than once,the worst was a 15" ambrosia bowl blow up a few yrs ago and all I got was a nasty bruise on my chest,I forgot to check the lathe speed and it was set at about 2800,00 rpms.

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#6

At least once that I remember

David Walser

The reason that I remember this incident is because it cost me one of the prettiest bowls I've ever (almost) made. I was parting the bowl off a faceplate when the toolrest pivoted into the spinning bowl. The bowl exploded. One of the largest pieces ricocheted off the wall and straight into my face. Fortunately, the bulbous shape of my Triton Powered Respirator's face shield protected the bulbous shape of my nose. The impact knocked me back half a step, but the only things hurt were my bowl and my pride. The bowl was irreparable. My pride has more than recovered.

Note: I was out of the line of fire. I just wasn't out of the line of ricochet.

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#7

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

Roger Chandler

In January of this year, I was turning a piece of white oak log........got a catch and it flew out of the chuck.........was turning at 1250 rpm, and the piece of white oak at that time weighed about 2.5 to 3 lbs. I really got whacked! It sounded like a gun shot.

It hit me in the faceshield....a Uvex Bionic faceshield, and hit partially on the frame in the chin area and partially in the clear lens...........knocked me back a couple of steps and really gave me some pause.........

I believe that faceshield saved me a trip to the emergency room that day! I wrote something about it on the SMC forum if anyone is interested in reading about the event.........a thread of comments ensued and is interesting as it relates to safety while at the lathe

http://www.sawmillcreek.org/showthread.php?180412-My-Uvex-Bionic-faceshield-saved-me-a-trip-to-the-emergency-room-today!&highlight=

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#8

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

Steve Kniffen

I use a UVEX Bionic too: http://www.uvex.us/uploadedFiles/ProductConfiguration/ProductLiterature/Uvex_Bionic_DS_3pg.pdf. I was turning a travel mug when I had a catch and the whole thing bounced off the bar at the top of the shield then off the garage door. I'd been using a less rigid, cheaper shield up until a couple of weeks before. Was glad I had the stouter shield on that day.

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#9

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

ihmserv

twice in 8 years.

first was when I first got a lathe and was learning spindle turning. who knew that a big knot thru the middle of a 4" square by 18 inch long piece of oak would snap before I even got the piece round. 12" piece came right up and hit the face shield, 6 inch piece hit my right wrist. sat down and thought about that one for about 20 minutes. no damage to wrist or face.

second was a 400+ segmented piece. had rounded the outside and was working the inside with a 1/2 bowl gouge, didn't push the tail stock back far enough the handle hit the tailstock, causing me to get a catch on the inside. luckily the piece shattered, so no piece was over 3x 3 x 1 still scarry having rapid fire pieces hitting me the faceshied and every wall in the shop.

both times I class it as operator error and a learning experience, without serious injury.

IAN

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#10

Joe Bradshaw

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

Joe Bradshaw

Lovely face???

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#11

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

Nick Todd

When I was just beginning, I mounted a 4x4 of laminated pine between centers on an inexpensive mini lathe. Everything was fine until I decided to turn up the speed. As soon as I increased the speed, the piece came off the lathe and hit me across the safety glasses and a cross the bridge of my nose. I had a few minor cuts & bumps of my face. The safety glasses had area of 1/2" square that grooves from the rotation of the work. That would have been my eye ball. I saved the safety glasses and the wood as a reminder.

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#12

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Yes! My old Airlite prevented me from suffering similar injuries many years ago.

A piece of timber disintegrated, not from speed or misuse of my tools, but hidden inclusions of bark that had made the whole piece unstable.

When it flew apart the visor was smashed from my face taking with it my glasses, something, possibly the timber hit my nose and an horrendous nose bleed ensued. The visor, my glasses and some of the timber left the shop through a closed window and landed a good ten feet from my shop.

IF (a big if) I had not been wearing the visor there is a strong possibility that I would not be turning today! I did have two Black eyes a very sore nose but it didn't put me off turning!

Everyone who thinks that NOT wearing face protection should think again!

Regards Peter.

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#13

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

Barry L Elder

In my case, my face shield has prevented at least two facial impacts, maybe more. In one case an 8" bowl blank had some unseen worm tunnels that caused it to split off the tenon, bounce off the tool rest and then into the shield before deflecting elsewhere. Also happened with a blank with a hidden crack that I turned beyond its' ability to hold together.

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#14

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

Bruce Markwardt

A few years back I was turning a top for a small shaker style candle stand. It was about a 16 inch piece of walnut, spinning at around 600 rpm. Somehow it fractured as I was finishing the rim and the largest piece hit me directly in the face shield. Scared the heck our of me. I became a believer in face shields at that time.

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#15

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

Dale Bonertz

What a great thread Ed. Thanks to all who have responded. I hope those who poo poo face shields read this and take away from it how good face shields really are in protecting us.

Even though I understand what people are trying to say when they say face shields are "the last line of defense". I feel this is minimizes the face shield and its importance since it is one of the first things we should be putting on before starting the lathe. Then stand out of the line of fire and start the lathe and your cut. I don't believe at all that face shields give me/us a false sense of security. They are important and they work better than what many want to give them credit for.

Again thanks to all for sharing your experiences. I hope more people come forward with their stories.

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#16

Don Leydens

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

Don Leydens

LOVELY FACE (2) ?????

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#17

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

Charles Yawn

Once, I filled a void with CA glue and did not wait long enough for it to cure thoroughly. When I turned the lathe on, a lot of the CA glue flew out and spattered on my face shield and the window on the other side of the lathe. I believe if I had not been wearing my face shield, I could have had CA glue curing on my face and eyeballs.

Charles

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#18

Re: belts and suspenders

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

I do generally use a face shield, and like John in another thread am looking for a shield with more lower face (jaw area) protection.

I NEVER do anything in the shop without safety glasses (having previously had a lab (not a shop) incident that resulted in long term eye injury).

I am picky about glasses fit, wanting particularly to ensure a close fit to my face on the sides and lower portion (important for turning). So in the case mentioned here of "CA spray", I would hope that even if I had not flipped my face shield down that my safety glasses would have prevented the CA spray from reaching my eyes.

So for me it is a multi-pronged approach - belts and suspenders!

Eye protection always - face shield too! (actively seeking a better face shield)

Prevention - check out the piece carefully, and check lathe speed.

Dust collection - always tweaking to improve.

Henry

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#19

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

Nick Todd

Also if you are talking injuries that are reduced by the face shield: getting dust in the eye.

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#20

Re: Once

RCH

"It was 15" in diameter, and probably 3/8" thick. It likely only weighed a few ounces. If it had been more massive, the faceshield would not have done much."

Exactly the point I made in another thread. Mass, not just diameter, is crucial.

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#21

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

Barry Irby

I can attest that one would have reduced or eliminated an injury I got about ten years ago. I had a blank on the lathe about 14" long a seven in diameter that had been hacked to size with a chain saw and had about six sides. Normally, I put the face shield on with my right hand and turn the lathe on with my left. That night I got it backwards and turned the lathe on first. I have no idea how or why, but the piece launched itself right into my forehead. 9:00 Sunday night. A friend took me to the emergency room. 27 stitches later and $1300 I was back home. I am absolutely sure the face shield would have done me a lot of good.

On several other occasions I have received hard blows to the shield that I am sure would have injured me. Yes, they absolutely work and probably could be better. and they do keep dust out of your eyes and off your face.

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#22

Mike Stafford

You guys are just jealous!!!!


Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#23

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

Don Orr

I've been lucky or careful or both so far. I've had small pieces bounce of my shield many times but nothing big enough to cause damage if I had not been wearing it. I have had pieces come apart and go flying but I was out of the line of fire. Not a big fan of unsound wood or trips to the ER.

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#24

Steven Antonucci

Chemical burns on eyes from CA are the worst...

steven antonucci

pain I have ever felt. Period.

Wear goggle with CA glue.

Steve

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#25

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

Jennifer Indy.USA

Two weeks ago while demonstrating to a class I had a hunk of a bowl come off and smack me in the face shield. It was green wood with what appeared to be ring shake. Had I not been wearing it I certainly would have had at the very least a good stinger on my face and at the worst...who knows. Yes, they prevent injuries.

Jen