Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Has a face shield prevented an injury??

Posts

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#26

Keith Tompkins

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

Keith Tompkins

Dale, If you read back through my posts, I never advocated nor suggested, NOT wearing a faceshield...Just look at all the threads, comments, and suggestions concerning face shields, and how to prevent the wood from hitting you in the first place! I teach woodturning to hundreds of turners, and believe me...there are people out there doing a LOT of stupid stuff! A LOT of people. Look at the damage a two pound piece of wood did to Lynn.....imagine what a 40 pound piece would do! (or more) Now, I made suggestions, for example, to use a faceplate with appropriate screws to mount a large or out of balanced blank....not a chuck. Does that mean I suggest NOT wearing a face shield? What I'm trying to do is save some poor soul from a catastrophic accident, caused by their own ignorance. I really wish you would at least make an attempt to read what I'm trying to say for exactly what it is..without any misinterpretation. It's no different than driving your car...do you drive on bald tires? Do you drink and drive? Does your car have a low brake pedal that has to be pumped several times to stop? No brake lights? Would you let your wife and kids ride in vehicle like that? NO, because they are all the absolute requirements for a 'safe" car. No different than operating a lathe. The things I listed are minimum safety requirements! Before you start the lathe, before you install the face shield...

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#27

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

adrien

Got a nasty catch. I still can't figure how the #%$@! handle was suddenly slammed into my face shield. Would've broken something more than my glasses without the face shield on the respirator.

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#28

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

Ed Larson

Thanks for all your informative and helpful replays. Please keep them coming. I plan to share this information with my club.

I think this data certainly shows that face shields prevent injuries. In no way did I mean to imply that using a face shield was all one needs to do to be safe. It is just one level of protection. Thanks John for your post above that describes good wood turning practices that emphasize prevention of wood leaving the lathe.

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#29

Wow Keith

Dale Bonertz

I reread my post and don't see your name anywhere. I reread all the posts you have made in regards to the current spree of face shield threads. The only thing I can see that would remotely tie my post to you is the line "the last line of defense." I have been reading posts from several forums and for several years from people who have a recurring saying that face shields are a "last line of defense." That is/was an assumption on your part that I was referencing you. All I can say to that is get over yourself. Most recommend using face shields (notice I say most not all) yet come across as having no faith in them. Too each their own but I feel they are wrong. I did not single you out and really don't appreciate you singling me out.

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#30

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

Barry Irby

I have been wondering about my turning smock. It is light weight nylon. Wouldn't it be better if the chest were padded?

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#31

Keith Tompkins

Re: Wow Keith

Keith Tompkins

Dale, It did seem that you were referring to my comments...I've received several private emails directly about the subject , so I'm a bit touchy at this point. If I'm wrong on my assumption, I apologize, but I've never read anywhere of someone suggesting not to wear a faceshield, or that it wasn't important.

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#32

Re: Wow Keith

Dale Bonertz

Apology accepted. I was not referring to anything you said. My comment was aimed at reading things over the years of some putting more emphases on safety glasses rather than a face shield - both are important. A few years ago one responder actually said he would rather see someone with safety glasses and no face shield than a face shield and no safety glasses. I emphatically disagree with such comments. Have a great day and safe turning.

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#33

Keith Tompkins

Re: Wow Keith

Keith Tompkins

Thanks for understanding, Dale...I appreciate that. It's pretty easy to get me wound up on some topics...

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#34

Yes!

Carole Valentine

More than once. Most recently a "solid" very dense piece of Rosewood about 5" x 3". It had a ring check that could not be seen and just as I was finishing shaping the outside, half of it flew off and smacked me very solidly. The face shield prevented what would have been significant facial injuries.

As for staying out of the line of fire? That trajectory is not always predictable!!! I know that from personal experience.

Wear a good shield...ALWAYS!

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#35

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

Jim H

Jen,

Glad you had it on. Seems like most of the demos I see, the demonstrator says something to the effect of "normally I wear a face shield, but not now so you can hear me. Please Don't take this wrong, I know you are a wonderful demonstrator from SWAT, but that one moment, hopefully taught the best lesson of the class.

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#36

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

Dale Bonertz

Jim,

The first time I demonstrated I said the same thing mainly because I heard so many other professional turners say it so it must be true - right. :\ I felt so uncomfortable without it that I have never done a demonstration without one since.

What concerns me is that when turners are passing through an area to demonstrate they depend on someone bringing a block of wood. They may give it a quick look over but they don't know or have time to study the log it came from or the block itself. Trusting souls these demonstrators are - that the person who cut it new what he/she was doing.

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#37

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

Mike Brazeau

With a quality lapel microphone there is absolutely no problem with a faceshield and voice pickup. After using two different cheap systems our Golden Horseshoe Woodturners Guild invested in a quality system and it made a world of difference.

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#38

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

phillip medghalchi

Very good point and I was wondering how come no one mentioned anything about it? I think somewhere I mentioned that I got hit on the left shoulder at the very top by half of a 12" mesquite bowl that flew off the lathe and I was lucky to dodge it, however, it got me and we side swiped with a big gash on my shoulder that i found out when I went into shower. It huts and later on I got a bad brown skin and scar form it. Now, it got me thinking that if it hit just a little further in or had I not been able to dodge it, it could brake my collar bone or possibly crack some ribs. I think that a padded apron or smock would have definitely taken some of that impact and at least would have been bruised instead of that gash. what say you?

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#39

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Yes a face shield has prevented injury for me several times. Anything spinning, including a pen, has the chance to break free and become a progectile. Size is not as important as what potential damage it can cause, from a sliver in your eye to a knock out punch to the jaw, from wood to even tooling it all has less of a chance if you wear a shied. I am not sure a list of my own events is really required, but I also have this confidence as a goalie, the mask I wear bears witness marks to its purpose and success,

Take care,

Jim

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#40

Steven Antonucci

Floor hockey goalie

steven antonucci

I used to play goalie during my fraternity days. I had no stick skills per se, and I had never played goalie before, but I did own a first baseman's glove. Before game #1, I put on a Jason Friday the Thirteenth mask and realize that you can't see anything out of them. I debated foregoing the mask, but in the end, wore it.

About 10 minutes into the game, with the world's smallest and most imcompetent defense in front of me, a guy wound up a slapshot that I saw for a second, and then it disappeared... briefly. In an instant, it must have hit me right between the eyes, and it felt like being slapped in the face by a big hand. A little while later, it happened a second time (when I realized the other team was trying to do it... which I responded to by slashing them a la Billy Smith style, and they lost the urge)

I went back to the frat house and found a lacrosse helmet with a cage. It provided me with two things: visibility and air space between my face and the thing that was hitting me. I think Keith has the right idea when it comes to what a good helmet really looks like. It probably needs to look more like a football helmet than a flip down mask if you are concerned about being truly protected. You always stand the risk of being hit hard enough to knock you down, and a concrete floor to the back of the head can kill you.

I equate a face shield to the old school goalie mask. I wouldn't want to take a hit to the face wearing one, and consider it only a fraction better than just wearing goggles.

Steve

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#41

Re: Floor hockey goalie

Dale Bonertz

Steven,

(I wouldn't want to take a hit to the face wearing one) I agree with what you said here. (consider it only a fraction better than just wearing goggles) I respectfully disagree with this comment. I will give you one example out many that I could give you. I worked in a wood window and door manufacturing facility for many years. Some people wore face shields (25 to 30 years ago they were all cheap) and others safety glasses/goggles. At one station people would cut aluminum for our clad line. One day a fellow had a piece hit him in the face when he was cutting and he was only wearing safety goggles. Hit him below the eye and tore up his cheek to the point that he had lifelong scars. About 1 1/2 years later another fellow had a similar accident on the same piece of equipment. He was wearing a face shield, it broke the face shield and knocked it off of his head at which the impact appeared to be in the same location as the first guy (obviously no way to prove this for sure). He only ended up with some bruising and no life long face disfiguring. That to me is more than a fraction better than goggles. I hope you don't feel like I am picking on you for that is not my intent. I just want people to hear that there is more to saving eyes at stake with the face shield versus safety goggles debate.

I am reading with interest the comments on people wanting to run and armor up with helmets with face guards and polycarbonate masks. Baseball catcher type chest protectors and we probably should be wearing genital cup protectors also. I know I may get slapped with making lite of some of these ideas or thoughts but please hear me out. If we (experienced turners) swing the pendulum to far the other way on safety then we will most likely see a decline in our new turner participation and we may even scare off some of the current hobbyist turners. Not many are going to want to armor up for their hobby that they have limited time and cash for in the first place. Some may even feel this is way to dangerous of a hobby by the way people armor up. I just want to caution everyone to not swing the pendulum to far over like our government does on issues. There is a happy medium of a good face shield with eye protection, learning to stand out of the line of fire and safe practices around equipment ie: speed, anchoring and etc. Accidents will still happen whether we are armored up or not. Let's get the message out for safe practices without scaring the heck out of folks and yet keep them excited about our sport.

Thanks,

Dale

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#42

Steven Antonucci

Categories of injuries...

steven antonucci

I understand your point of view, and I agree that a face shield protects against what I refer to as a Level II threat.

Level I is a nuisance threat. Dust and small debris hitting you in the eye, or small pieces that may sting, but do not cause damage. Goggles and face shields are mostly equivalent.

Level II is a moderate injury (non-life threatening). A face shield is a major upgrade to this type of damage up to a certain point, and can protect up to a certain mass/speed combination.

Level III is when you have a mass/speed combination that exceeds the capabilities of a face shield to protect you against a catastrophe. In this case, it probably doesn't matter if you have either a face shield or goggles on, and you'd be better off wearing a "helmet" of some sort.

The problem as I see it is that everyone here is assuming that you need to have a one size fits all solution. If I am turning finger tops, I can probably get away with basic Level I eye protection. If I am turning the interior of a large vessel, I am off the end of the lathe and out of the line of fire. I can probably get away with goggles again. However, if I am shaping a large vessel, and I have no choice but to stand in the line of fire, I am probably better off using at least Level II protection or some kind of Level II protection (helmet+ goggles?).

The key to being protected is understanding the risk and taking the appropriate precautions to minimize your exposure. No one thing will make you safe at the lathe. The material, how it is mounted, where you stand, what too you use, and your level of proficiency all matter more than what you wear on your head as a last line of defense.

As Master Lee (9th degree Tae Kwon Do teacher) used to tell my son, the best way to absorb a punch is to never get into a situation where you have to absorb a punch... walking away from the fight is better than winning it.

Steve

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#43

Well said


Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#44

Dale Jablonski

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

Dale Jablonski

I had a Trend respirator and shield which was like a goalie mask and I loved it. The one problem with something like this is the weight factor. I found that even at the advertised 2 pounds I could not have the apparatus on my head for long. It was too heavy and I had to sell it. Any face protection would have to be light as possible yet functional.

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#45

Weight of powered respirators

David Walser

I think that a greater factor in comfort than the weight itself is the distribution of the weight. I've not used the Trend, but when I tried it on at the store, it felt "weight forward" and I thought it would be uncomfortable to wear bending over a lathe. (I understand the Trend Pro is better in this regard.) In contrast, the 3M Airstream and the Triton seem to distribute the weight more over the top of the spine. Even when leaning forward, the respirator’s weight doesn’t feel like it’s trying to pull your head down and doesn’t put a strain on the back of the neck. Another thing I like about the Trend’s design is that the fan and battery are carried on a belt strapped to your waist, so your neck isn’t carrying that weight. (The Airstream’s battery is also carried on your belt.)

Some turners do away with the belt pack by using 3M’s Breathe Easy (similar to the Airstream except the fan and battery are carried on the belt) and pump filtered air to the helmet via a hose that’s suspended from the ceiling. If you’re really sensitive to weight, you might want to take this approach. All you’d be carrying would be the weight of a hardhat and a face mask.

Obviously, these are matters of personal preference. I find my Trend very comfortable and soon forget that I’ve got it on. YMMV.

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#46

Re: Weight of powered respirators- confused

Dale Bonertz

I am confused David, the Trend that I had the battery pack was in the helmet - did they change this? I understand what Dale is saying because I had to sell my Trend also because my neck would not allow me to wear it. Better that someone got a use out of it rather than collect dust on the hook in my shop. I now use the old style non powered respirator which my neck still thanks me.

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#47

Re: Weight of powered respirators- confused

David Walser

Dale - I'm sorry for the confusion. I made a typo in the last paragraph of my response to the other Dale. I wrote: I find my Trend very comfortable and soon forget that I’ve got it on. I meant Triton, not Trend. Sorry.

The Trend does have both it's battery and fan in the helmet. The 3M Airstream has the fan in the helmet; it's battery is on your belt. In addition, the 3M's fan is in the back of the helmet, which I think makes for a better weight distribution. If someone in your area has an Airstream, see if you can borrow it for a day. You might be pleasantly surprised.

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#48

Dale Jablonski

Re: Weight of powered respirators

Dale Jablonski

The Trend (might have been the Pro model ??) did feel like it was weight forward. What makes matters worse for me is I have some neck issues so it made matters worse. Can't tolerate much so I use a face shield and a dust respirator when I turn. Even then after prolonged use my body exacts it's revenge.

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#49

Re: Weight of powered respirators- confused

Dale Bonertz

Thanks for the clarification. I liked my trend except for the weight issue. I, as Mr. Joblonski, have neck/back problems. I was kinda hoping they (trend) changed that which would have made it inviting to try again. I'll check on the airstream. Thanks

Re: Has a face shield prevented an injury??

#50

Steven Antonucci

See Alan Zenreich's battery hack...

steven antonucci

I don't recall the specifics, but he swapped out the heavy batteries for much smaller, lighter and more efficient ones. He posted a video on YouTube I think too that describes how to do it.

Steve