Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

So tell me, what skew do you like and why

Posts

So tell me, what skew do you like and why

#1

So tell me, what skew do you like and why

john lucas

I've been collecting skews lately and building a few I don't have. I've been playing with shapes a grinds for a bunch of years now. I'm going to spend some time turning with all 12 that I have here shortly to try and learn why I like some over others. I thought I'd ask your opinions.

I probably should post a photo of them so you can see the differences but I'm at work and that won't happen until later tonight.

So far my opinion is that practice with whatever you have is more important than shape. However some shapes do offer advantages for certain types of cuts or situations. Anyway I would appreciate the opinions.

Also if you have a preferred grind angle. What I'm talking about is the angle measured from bevel to bevel so that we are talking the same lingo. Most of mine seem to end up around 35 degrees.

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

#2

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

Stuart Johnson

John, after you get the results from your tests this might make a good topic for our weekly turning chat.

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

#3

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

Chuck Engstrom

Hi John -- I have several skews but more typically use a 5/16 square tool, ground straight across with about 48° angle between the faces, for many of the cuts normally associated with a skew. I also have square tools of 1/4 and 3/16, and a couple of 3/16 rounds ground as skews for tiny details.

As to real skews, I have a 5/8 Lacer 2030 and a Doug Thompson 1/2, which is epoxied into a brass tube so I can put it in one of my multi-tool handles. I use these mostly for peeling and finishing cuts on straights or tapers of significant length.

MSC has 3/8 sq. x 8" M42 for $24 and 5/16 sq. x 8" M35 for $20, and Enco has similar as well, a bit cheaper, if you want to try this notion.

35° between faces I would expect to be much more catchy than my 48°. I do a fair amount of spindle turning and the square tool is just kind of what I got used to, though I realize that I seem to be using tools that are smaller than many might choose.

Best --

Chuck

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

#4

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

Curt Stivison

An idle one.

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

#5

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

john lucas

Chuck I did a test several years ago with a couple of other turners. We used skews ground from 25 to almost 90 degrees between the faces. To a point the blunter tools were less catchy but require a lot more movement of the handle to finish off a square sided bead. That made them less catchy for larger details more catchy at the bottom of the bead. They also required more forward pressure for planing which leads to more chatter on thin spindles.

The 25 degree cuts like butter and is great for planing cuts. It also requires less handle movement for turning beads. However it was a little more grabby as you round the corner on a bead.

35 degrees or thereabouts seems to be a good between setting. sharp enough to cut clean with very little pressure and blunt enough to be more controllable.

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

#6

Oh common Kurt, go for it.


Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

#7

I mean Curt 


Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

#8

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

Harry in Beautiful Downtown Kulpsville

I definitely do not like the skews with an oval cross section.

I like my large Doug Thompson skew with the curved cutting edge. Also like my 1/4" round skew made by Bob Rosand. Have about three others that are conventional configuration including a very old one made with high carbon steel. All work well. But, Doug's is the best!

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

#9

Mike Stafford

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

Mike Stafford

I am not a skew expert as I am still practicing and hope to master this tool eventually.

I like my 1/2" and 3/4" skews for general work. I have both ground with a slightly curved edge similar to the Lacer grind. I am using Alan Lacer's videos and exercises to improve my skew use.

I love my 1/4" round skew which I made during Ed Moore's class for ornaments. Easy to use and perfect for the small work involved.

I also have a couple of Craftsman 1/2" skews ground with extremely long bevels a la Ray Key, that I use for particular tasks.

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

#10

Haven't met one I didn't like....

Greg Haugen

I like them all. For ornament finials, etc. Bob Rosand's technique of a small round skew is ideal. If it was a "If I had to choose one tool on a island" type of question it would be Alan Lacer's 5/8" skew. I like it for roughing (peeling cuts) to fine precision work - it's very versatile. I've gone to Alan's a few times for one on one lessons when I was first starting out. Well worth it!!!! For skews to add to a tool arsenal, I like the rolled edge 1/2" and 1" size. It's a nice combination for small and medium sized work. The rolled edges are nice as well. I think there's a purpose to the radius grinds and straight grinds, both have optimal applications. I do prefer both, which one is used depends on the projects. I do like the oval skews as well. For Pens, I love my 1/2" rolled edge straight ground skew. Use it right side up, up side down (I like to use it with the toe down coming up to a bushing), and as a negative rake scraper.

If I were to recommend what to buy for a new turners, I'd stay with my 1/2" and 1" rolled edge skews. The prices won't break the bank and you can do anything with them. As far as straight or radius? Too much is made out of it. Learn either one, and you'll know the other as well and you'll also find applications where one is better than the other.

my 2 cents.

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

#11

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

NONE!

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

#12

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

Joe Dickason

I really like my 1/2-3/4". They are great for opening my 1 gallon cans of anchorseal

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

#13

Jim Evans

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

Jim Evans

I was scared to death of skews until I took a one day hands on with Alan Lacer. Now I'm not afraid to grab up a skew and use it.

I agree with Alan in that the oval skew is a bear to sharpen consistently.

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

#14

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

John Lucas

I agree that the oval skew is hard to sharpen. I did it by hand for many years and now use a jig that helps a lot. Still not as easy as a flat skew.

Personally I think the curved blades are hard to sharpen consistently as well which is one reason I prefer a straight edge.

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

#15

Tony Reynolds

lol That's what

Tony Reynolds

Stuart Batty said during the class I took from him. Seriously though, I like a modified grind 3/8" bedan. It's my go to tool for rolling beads.

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

#16

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

Jorge

I only have 7,down from 9, the 2" and the 1 3/4" found new homes.

I did give away 3 oval skews, a pain in the nether regions to sharpen, I did replace them with 3 Thompson: ! 1/4", 1" and1/2", love all three!

The most used is the 1 1/4" followed closely by the 1/2". Now rarely use the non Thompson.

I don't grind them anymore, just sharpen them with a diamond file, Thanks Allan Lacer! They will last until my great, great grand children and beyond.

I grind mine to a 20 degree angle or is it a 70? I never knew what the convention is for talking about angles in skews and gouges, and the bevel is something like one and a half times as wide as the thickness of the stock.

It was the first turning tool I did learn to use and never had trouble using it, In the past I did experiment with curved skews, but besides being hard to sharpen consistently I saw no advantage using them, at the time I was tuning stairs parts mostly and had only 10 minutes or less to finish a spindle. My boss and mentor sold me a skew, a spindle gouge and a bedan, for the sum of $5.00, I still have all 3, since 1977! and in the year I did work for him never used the gouge or the bedan! It is easier just to keep going with what you have in the hand, touch up the edge with oil stones every 4 or 5 spindles. We used a parting tool for some details...

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

#17

Ellis Walentine

Glaser bowl skew *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

I don't have a picture of this skew handy, but here is a link to a long-forgotten article that is lurking in the attic of our articles department. If I can dig up a photo, I'll post it, or if any of you have this tool, how about posting a couple views of it?

Ellis


Glaser Bowl Skew Article

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

#18

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

john lucas

Jorge I use the term included angle which to me means that you measure from bevel to bevel by simply laying an angle gauge over the tool. for a skew that just makes more sense to me. I know some measure from the center of the shaft to the bevel and some tools are measured from the outside of the shaft to the bevel.

for measuring bowl and spindle gouges I measure from the flute down over the bevel, and for scrapers I measure from the top down over the bevel. don't know if that is accurate but it makes sense for me.

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

#19

Ken Vaughan

Do you mean "skew" to include skew like tasks?

Ken Vaughan

The discussion has included the classic skews as well as what P&N sells as a beading tool -- an English Bedan like tool.

There are also some 3 sided point type tools that do skew like tasks -- the Cindy D long for point tool (Vortex I think she calls it, and Taylor has a long form that Nick Agar called a "detailer" in his sales video.

I have come to like the bedan like beading tool -- there are options on sharpening that change the handle position when turning beads from the "V" in the middle to a classic bedan style grind -- difference seems to be what you get use to for handle movements.

So many things on can do with skews and the other tools that will do the same/similar tasks.

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

#20

The skew  task tools are a fine line

john lucas

The division between a skew and spindle gouge is just a flat top spindle gouge that some call a skewchigouge or other similar modifications.

The 3 point tool is only one step away from how my friend uses his V tool that I made the other day. Randy is coming over Friday to refresh my memory on how he uses that tool.

the Bedan is just one step away from a parting tool which I have used in the past to turn beads. I also remember a tool sold as a beading tool that was extremely similar to the Bedan.

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

#21

Skating Skews

mjonesrdg

All of my skews are "skating" skews, and they all are very easily skated to either side of the cut. My 1/2" oval, as well as my 1 1/4" standard skew are probably the best for creating the "X#@%&*##X" cut that I first began employing in my turning many years ago. That particular cut, (something like a "free-form" spiral), cannot be as readily or predictably created with any other tool in my arsenal.

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

#22

Keith Tompkins

Re: The skew  task tools are a fine line

Keith Tompkins

Hey John, Have him try the one I sent you....it would be interesting to see the results :D

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

#23

Sorby Spindlemaster  ?? *LINK*

Doc Green

From the description in the article, I think the bowl skew is shaped like a Sorby spindlemaster, or vice versa. Further, the directions on how to use the bowl skew applies to the spindlemaster.


Spindlemaster

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

#24

Tompkins V skew

Doc Green

After doing considerable experimenting with ordinary skews, the Sorby spindlemaster, and the Tompkins V skew, I've concluded that the V skew represents a significant step forward in a tool that will leave a skew-like surface and still be easy to control.

The V skew is similar to the spindlemaster but has a tip that comes to more of a point as opposed to being round. It is little if any more difficult to use than a spindle gouge.

Maybe Keith will post a picture. :)

Re: So tell me, what skew do you like and why

#25

Oval Skews hard to sharpen??

Greg Haugen

I must admit, I do find it mildly humorous when I hear that oval skews are difficult to sharpen even though many of us have round tools (skews, fluteless gouges, or shear scrapers) that are sharpened every time easily. Why does a subtle radius trip us more than a completely round shaft? It's not like it takes a large amount of pressure to sharpen a tool? Think of your platform as a "tool rest" not a "tool teeter totter". A light, finesse touch of the bevel, which is flat, to the grinding wheel while the tool rests on the platform. Radius grinds trip up some too, even though they have radiused scrapers in their arsenals. The only difference is that it's done on the top as well as the bottom. I think far too often we GRIND our tools instead of DRESSING the bevel. When I teach (I also talk about it during demos) after the student starts to get the technique I challenge them to see how light they can do it or how little they can take off. "Take a larger gouge and see how small of a cut you take with it." "Sharpen this tool but only dress, or clean, the bevel." Far too often I think we get caught up in the BIG lathe, BIG tool, BIG grinder but forget how much turning and sharpening is a delicate finesse.

Glenn Lucas' first DVD, Techniques, covers his technique for sharpening. It's mesmerizing to watch him sharpen. It's an art form in its self.

I'll get off of my soap box now......