Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

New chuck question part 2, a little long

Posts

New chuck question part 2, a little long

#1

New chuck question part 2, a little long

kellyanderson72

All right so I went to Woodcraft and checked out the chucks and left with the Supernova 2 and the insert for a 1x8 spindle, the lathe is a Powermatic 45 so that should be the correct size.

My problem is this - The lathe came with a face plate and it screws on the inboard side of the spindle but not the outboard side. The insert for the chuck screws on the outboard side but not the inboard side of the spindle. What am I missing? The insert seems like it wants to thread on inboard but just does not.

The label on the package says - Nova insert 1 x 8 L/R w/screw (item 153008). Is this the correct one? I assume that l/r means that it will screw on left and right hand threads?

This is the only insert Woodcraft sells for 1x8 thread but Amazon sells one that a reviewer says will only work on the inboard side, is this what I need? I don't care if it only screws on the inboard side as long as it does screw on the inboard side.

I appreciate any help you all can give me. I have no experience with lathes at all so I am kinda lost.

Thanks

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

#2

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

Harry in Beautiful Downtown Kulpsville

Kelly, this is a wild guess cause I don't know for sure, but I think you need a 1-1/4 x 8 adapter. This size thread is common on most of the larger lathes while 1 x 8 is generally used on the mini-lathes.

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

#3

Chuck Jones - West TN

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

Chuck Jones - West TN

I probably should stay out of this because I don't know what size spindle a PM 45 has. But one thing I do know is that the same insert will not work on both a LH and RH thread. If it screws on to the outboard side (which I assume is LH) then you have a LH insert which will not work on the inboard side. You will have to hustle on back to Woodcraft and get a RH.

Hopefully someone will confirm for you whether the PM 45 is 1" or 1 1/4" on the inboard side.

What puzzles me is that part number at Woodcraft seems to be a RH 1" x 8tpi. At least the picture is RH. I haven't a clue what the R&L means.

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

#4

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

kellyanderson72

Well the spindle is only 1" so that should be 1x8 rigtht?

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

#5

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

Clifton C

Kelly,

R/L means it has a right hand and a left hand thread cut in the adapter and it will thread on the inboard and outboard spindle. If you look inside the adapter you should see an area where the threads cross, it does not look like a normal thread pattern. The lead thread might be munged up (technical term) making it hard to thread on the spindle. My thoughts are, if it is not easy to spin on, take it back, you should not have to fight it.

c

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

#6

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

George Van Beynen

Kelly, Chuck is right. My PM45 is 1x8. You have to have the right threads for the inboard/outboard. Oneway makes a rh/lh combination insert.

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

#7

Chuck Jones - West TN

Okay! I'm not too old or too proud to learn...

Chuck Jones - West TN

... first I ever heard of an ambidextrous insert. :)

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

#8

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

kellyanderson72

The threads inside the insert are not normal looking threads but they are not damaged, it just seems weird that it will not thread on both ends of the spindle.

George, thank you for confirming that I am not crazy. Do you just have a regular 1x8 insert/chuck for your lathe?

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

#9

Re: Okay! I'm not too old or too proud to learn...

John Lucas

Chuck the Delta's made in the 60's came with an ambitextrous faceplate. When you look at the threads it looks like a bunch of X's. totally bizzarre. Maybe I'll try a threaded box like that one of these days.

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

#10

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

John Lucas

I have run into faceplates and inserts that won't go all the way on my spindle and all were new. It has to do with either tolerances or possibly burrs on the spindle threads. If it screws on at all but stops as it goes down then it's more than likely a tolerance thing. All threads have a certain amount of tolerance or slop if you will. Nuts and bolts on the space shuttle probably have an extremely small tolerance and nuts and bolts on your inexpensive chinese imports probably have huge amounts.

What this means is if you get a spindle that is on the fat side of the tolerance and a faceplate that is on the small side you can easily have issues with fit. I put chalk on my spindle and screwed on the faceplate that had problems. Then filed on the spindle with a triangular file or scraped on the faceplate threads (I have a thread repair tool that reached into the faceplate) until I got it to fit.

If you have a tap you could run that through the insert. Or you might try contacting the place that made the insert and see if they would swap. Another insert may have a slightly different fit, again due to the tolerance when they are made.

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

#11

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

Stuart Johnson

Seven or eight years ago Powermatic had an issue with a batch of spindles not being machined properly. They sent dies to those with the problem. I don't remember if it was a 3520 A or B issue but it didn't take them long to correct it.

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

#12

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

Don Evans

Just to confirm, what you have been told, an insert can be threaded for left and right threading. What I will debate though is any atempt for you to trying to repair it. It is brand NEW, take it back and make them give you another to try.

By the way, my first lathe back in 1970's was a 1956 Delta 10" x 36"(think that was lenght it will do) anyway, the faceplate that came with it was a X threaded one so it could be put on inboard or outboard. Still got that lathe (in storage) and it still looks new, sandblasted and painted before storing.

My Delta was 1"x8tpi also.....

Don

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

#13

Tony Reynolds

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

Tony Reynolds

The A version had a problem with not enough thread so a faceplate or a chuck would run out of thread before seating on the shoulder of the spindle. They sent me a nice spacer or collar that fixed the problem.

Tony

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

#14

Mike Mills

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

Mike Mills

Here is a description for the insert from Woodcraft #153008.

1" - 8 TPI R&L Insert w/Set Screw for Nova Chucks

This is not an insert BY Nova; it is an insert FOR Nova chucks.

You will note at the bottom of the Woodcraft page other insert start with "Nova" in the description.

If you go here…..

http://www.teknatool.com/products/Lathe_Accessories/adaptor_page.htm

You will see that the dual threaded insert made BY Nova is Insert T not D.

It may still not work but I would order a Real Nova insert from their service center in Fl. Cost less also I believe.

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

#15

Several brands of older lathes had....

JamieDonaldson

...double threaded faceplates, such as my old General 160. And several brands also had different diameters of spindle threads on the inboard vs outboard as well.

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

#16

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

walta

Please don’t take this the wrong way. The out board threads at Left handed. This means that they are backward from normal. So you must turn the chuck to the left to put it on the spindle. Even when I know that the part in front of my is left hand threaded it takes every fiber of my being to move the shaft in the correct direction. So let’s try it in baby steps.

1 Clear the lathes spindle.

2 Turn on the lathe.

3 Turn off the lathe as it slows note the direction the spindle is turning.

4 Take a sharpie marker and make an arrow over the spindle on the outboard side pointing in the direction the spindle was turning in step 3

5 Install a face plate on the inboard spindle.

6 Hold the chuck against the outboard spindle with light pressure threw steps 7 and 8

7 Turn the face plate the onside direction if the arrow for 3 full revolutions. You should feel the threads bounce against each other.

8 Now turn the face plate the same direction as the arrow for 10 full revolutions. With any luck the chuck is now on the spindle.

9 If not repeat 6,7and 8 3 times.

Be careful the L-R thread insert can be easily cross threaded.

Walta

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

#17

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

kellyanderson72

Yes sir, it is going back.

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

#18

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

kellyanderson72

That is what I get for being a beginner. It will go back. I did not realize that I could order directly from the factory but that is where the next one is coming from. Thanks

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

#19

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

kellyanderson72

Thanks for the help but after searching around on-line last night I figured out that this is not a OEM insert and found several others having similar problems. It is going back and I will get one from the manufacturer.

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

#20

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

Nelson

Please let us know if the one from Nova works better, i think you will find the same problem, but us posted.

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

#21

Re: New chuck question part 2, a little long

kellyanderson72

I will get the regular, single thread insert from Nova, that should solve the problem. The only reason I bought the one that I did is that it was the only one that they had for 1x8 thread.