Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Some kind of poison, by wood?

Posts

Some kind of poison, by wood?

#1

Some kind of poison, by wood?

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

I've heard that a person can become sensatized to any number of things over prolonged use or coming in contact with a substance. Laundry detergents, soaps, cleaners, fabrics, food. The list is endless I suppose.

I feel I may have fallen victim to something wood working related.

I was busy over the last few months working on the lathe making gifts for Christmas. I was turning Box Elder (hint for WC the Secret Santa), Spalted Dogwood, Cocobolo, Japanese Zelkova, Hard Maple, and Poplar. The wood I was in contact with the most was the Cocobolo. Second, the Dogwood. I've been to a dermatologist and I'm taking and applying medication to ease the itching and severe burning sensation from the inflamed areas. They took a biopsy on Dec. 29th and I'm awaiting the results.

The rash I have is in the crease of my arms at the elbow joint and all around my neck. I'm no doctor, but all things are pointing towards the wood debris and sawdust that landed on these areas. I tend to have my long sleeves pushed up at the elbows too. I wear a face shield.

Could the Cocobolo cause such a rash? How about the dark black streaks that run through the Dogwood?

Thanks,

Ray

Re: Some kind of poison, by wood?

#2

Mike Stafford

Re: Some kind of poison, by wood?

Mike Stafford

I would almost guarantee that cocobolo is the culprit. Many of the rosewoods, and cocobolo is a rosewood, contain oils that people can be allergic to. I have often read that there are two kinds of people- those that are allergic to cocobolo and those that will be.

I recommend that you discontinue turning cocobolo because of the potential for an allergic reaction that affects your breathing.

Re: Some kind of poison, by wood?

#3

Re: Some kind of poison, by wood?

Barry L Elder

Cocobol, as it is a rosewood. You should remove all rosewoods from your shop and premises to avoid progression of the allergic reaction. Preferably, ship everything to me and I will dispose of it for you at no charge! :D

Re: Some kind of poison, by wood?

#4

Re: Some kind of poison, by wood?

Kevin Stanbary in McHenry, IL

From www.wood-database.com:

"What is a Sensitizer?

You’ve probably already heard the term desensitized—usually in reference to violent movies or images—meaning that we start off as naturally being sensitive to something, and upon more and frequent exposure, we become less and less sensitive to its effects.

Well, with some woods that have been classified as being a sensitizer, the opposite is true: the more we are exposed to a wood’s sawdust or other fine particles, the more sensitive we get to its exposure, and the more severe and adverse the reactions become.

If you ever have an allergic reaction to any wood that has been identified as a sensitizer, use extreme caution in handling or using that species (and related species) in future instances. Some have reactions so severe that they simply have had to stop and discontinue using certain wood species altogether. (Cocobolo is notorious in this regard.)"

I'd be very careful with the rosewoods from here on out...

Re: Some kind of poison, by wood?

#5

Rob Wallace

Re: Some kind of poison, by wood?  *LINK*

Rob Wallace

Ray:

Given the species you list in your "possibilities" of wood contaminants, the cocobolo is certainly the most likely culprit. All Dalbergia species produce organic compounds known as quinones (and neoflavonoids) which contribute significantly to contact dermatitis in many (most?) individuals. The level of immune (or other dermal) response may be a combination of direct tissue damage through toxicity, or an accumulation of smaller insults over a period of time which results in an immune response generating rash, itch, and in some cases blistering or other dermal irritation/erythrema formation when even minor amounts of dust or wood-derived oils are applied to the skin (or worse - the respiratory tract!).

The link below summarizes some of the toxicity effects of dalbergiones, that class of compounds found in the rosewoods (Fabaceae: Dalbergia) which is implicated in most of the dermal irritation responses. Your dermatologist should be able to cross-reference these compounds and suggest a treatment based on this information.

This topic comes up so frequently that perhaps it would be good to write an article for American Woodturner with relevant references for turners and their care providers? Does anyone know if this has already been done somewhere?

Rob Wallace


Wood Hazards

Re: Some kind of poison, by wood?

#6

Re: Some kind of poison, by wood?

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Scrape a small amount of the suspect wood. Place the dust under a simple bandaid. Leave it on for a couple of days. If there is ANY rash under the guaze pad, then you are allergic!

Re: Some kind of poison, by wood?

#7

Re: Response from Kevin

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

Hey dude! What's happening? Good to hear from you.

Well, I think after reading your post and some of the others, I'm convinced that it was the Cocobolo. The kicker is that the projects I was working on all snapped when I got close to finishing the turning. So I'm really ticked that all the wood is sawdust and scrap. I have one small piece left, I'll send it your way. :D

Ray

p.s. I'm in misery.

Re: Some kind of poison, by wood?

#8

Re:response from Bob

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

Bob,

I've read articles before about the subject but I've never seen a really GOOD one. The LINKS and posts here by you all have really helped a lot.

Sounds like a plan to me. ;)

Ray

Re: Some kind of poison, by wood?

#9

Re: Band AID test

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

Good idea, but, after this misery, I'm not sure I want to expose myself again. And, my problem now is getting rid of the sawdust in and around the lathe, emptying the dust collector bag, etc. etc. etc.

Live and learn I guess.

Re: Some kind of poison, by wood?

#10

sorry "Rob" (not Bob) 


Re: Some kind of poison, by wood?

#11

Re: Response from Kevin

Kevin Stanbary in McHenry, IL

Haha Throw it and the family in the truck and bring it on out! :b

Seriously, hope ya feel better!

Re: Some kind of poison, by wood?

#12

Re: Band AID test

steve worcester

you can vacuum it up and throw it out, wear long sleeves, pants and rubber gloves. (As opposed to shorts)

I have the same issue, and just don't turn it anymore. It is worse in creases of the body or places where you sweat more.

Re: Some kind of poison, by wood?

#13

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Band AID test

Lyle Jamieson

In my case, I react to walnut. But as long as I wash up good or shower immediately, its not a problem for me. I just dont let it sit on my skin too long. If it was really bad you would have it all over your body, head, ears, wrists, etc, any exposed skin. So Id expect no problems from cleaning up the shop...with care and protection like a dust mask. But this is free advice and you get what you pay for. Dont risk your health, do the bandaid test to see what the cause was.

Re: Some kind of poison, by wood?

#14

Re: Band AID test

Roger Chandler

I read somewhere that there are two kinds of woodturners...........those that are allergic to cocobolo and those who will be.........

Re: Some kind of poison, by wood?

#15

Steven Antonucci

Have a roswood sale, Ray (I'm not a buyer)

steven antonucci

I had a similar reaction to the last piece of rosewood that I turned (african blackwood). I made a small top no bigger than an inch in either direction. The dust must have been on my hand and I wiped my eyelid.



These pictures do not convey how much pain is involved when you have the burning on your eyelid. It took a week to stop. I gave away all of my blackwood, and you should too - lest you try to make "one last piece" from it.

You should also familiarize yourself with the variety of rosewoods out there. Tulipwood is another one. I mentioned Blackwood (which I though was an ebony). The sensitizing alergy increases over time, and each outbreak has gotten worse.

I wouldn't turn it in body armor.

Steve

Re: Some kind of poison, by wood?

#16

Chuck Jones - West TN

I'm allergic to band aids... seriously

Chuck Jones - West TN

Cocobolo doesn't bother me, but this "newer" type of tape medical folks are using will blister my skin in minutes. Last couple times I've had any kind of bandaging have been miserable.

Where did all these allergies come from anyway????

Re: Some kind of poison, by wood?

#17

Re: Some kind of poison, by wood?

Jorge

Ray,

It is said that there are only two kinds of people, the ones that are allergic to cocobolo and the ones that will be allergic to cocobolo.

And there are many other woods, that sensitize people

I was carving a handle for a crocked knife last week, could not finish it, african snake wood, my upper lip went stiff, went to wash immediately and next day still not back to normal.

Re: Some kind of poison, by wood?

#18

Harry Robinette

Re: Some kind of poison, by wood?

harry robinette

Please wear a good mask if your allergic on the outside even just a little your inside well be more allergic.

My lung Doc told me that cause of COPD, but it makes sense so wear a GOOD mask when cleaning.

Re: Some kind of poison, by wood?

#19

Here's a document... *LINK*

GaryG in MD

http://montgomerycountywoodturners.org/Documents/Safety%20-%20Wood%20Toxicity.pdf

This pdf has three separate, independent lists of toxic woods, including what forms, how toxic, potential effects on the human body, etc.

Cocobolo is one of the most notorious!


http://montgomerycountywoodturners.org/Documents/Safety%20-%20Wood%20Toxicity.pdf

Re: Some kind of poison, by wood?

#20

Thanks everyone for their input.

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

Unfortunately this rash is spreading like wild fire which doesn't make sense. A call is in to both my regular Doc and the Dermatologist. I can take a lot of pain but I've had enough.

Ray

Re: Some kind of poison, by wood?

#21

Re: Thanks everyone for their input.

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN

Relative to the spreading like crazy -- contact irritants will elicit dermatitis first on the thinner and more sensitive skin areas, then the dermatitis will appear on thicker skin -- it appears to be spreading, but more likely a delayed response is taking place. If the irritant has been removed, and no infection is involved, the dermatitis will not "spread."

Re: Some kind of poison, by wood?

#22

Rob Wallace

Re: Thanks everyone for their input.

Rob Wallace

Ray:

I hope this condition subsides soon. Emmett is correct about delayed response in less-sensitive areas - this is common - exactly the same response with poison ivy and presence of the irritating urushiol getting into sweat ducts in "tougher" skin areas, which 'break-out' or "spread" even after the offending materials apparently have been removed from skin contact.

I assume that the docs have you on some form of antihistamine, and that they are suggesting some sort of topical application on the affected areas to reduce pain and itch.

Unfortunately, these kind of conditions have to "run their course" and allow the body to respond and recover - there's probably not much that can be done except to manage the symptoms for comfort and safety.

There's a big lesson here for everyone!

Rob

Re: Some kind of poison, by wood?

#23

Re: Thanks everyone for their input.

bill Crommett

There used to be a protective hand cream in two different formulations, one water soluble and one oil soluble. I forgot the name of the stuff, but it won't do any good if you are going to blow your nose or rub your eyes while the skin of your hand is contaminated.

Re: Some kind of poison, by wood?

#24

Rash

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

I wasn't going to post this because I feel like an idiot. I'm not looking for sympathy either. I just thought it would help somehow.

I don't know what caused this BUT I saw the Doc last night and I'm on Prednisone and a prescription antihistamine.

Both arms look like this and I have a 3 inch wide band of the rash around my entire neck. I'm 98% convinced it was the Cocobolo.


Re: Some kind of poison, by wood?

#25

Re: Rash

GaryG in MD

Ray,

Sorry you have to go through this, but it's a good reminder to us all.

I'm going to use this photo in my Safety Minute at our next club meeting (you will, of course, remain anonymous). We have some new beginners so I'm going to go over the "list" with them. All of our Clubs should post these things on the wall somewhere for all to see BEFORE they end up in your situation.

Two things:

1) You are now allergic to cocobolo for the rest of your life. Every time you come into contact with it, it will get WORSE. You don't want to go there.

2) Look at the 3 lists I posted and consider avoiding the other noxious species as well. There are plenty of "safe" woods to turn. If you HAVE to turn one of the questionable ones, you should look like an astronaut when you do it.

Hope it clears up soon, Gary