Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Unknown wood

Posts

Unknown wood

#1

Unknown wood

John Lucas

I found this over at the other house where I stored wood in the attic of my shed. I have no idea what it is. Any guess's. I have to head out to a club meeting. I'll dig in my books later tonight. It's very hard.

Re: Unknown wood

#3

Re: Unknown wood

marvin ewing

Looks like Cherry to Me

Re: Unknown wood

#4

Re: Unknown wood

R Henrickson

Perhaps cherry as has been suggested, but the bark looks a bit strange for that. The bark should decide the "cherry?" question. Perhaps a maple -- look sort of like some I've turned?

Re: Unknown wood

#5

Re: Unknown wood

Don Evans

Looks more like red Oak to me. The bark says it is definitely NOT cherry. Cherry has a smoother bark and it is light gray with darker gray spots in it.

don

Re: Unknown wood

#6

Chuck Jones - West TN

River birch?

Chuck Jones - West TN

If you rule cherry out I'd say there is a possibility it's birch. I turned a piece of river birch today and was amazed at how much it looks like cherry. However, I would not call it very hard. It turned like butter-- I guess, I've never actually turned butter.

Re: Unknown wood

#7

Re: Unknown wood

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN

Not cherry and not river birch (both of which turn easily). Without a better look, I am guessing red bud, possibly mulberry.

Re: Unknown wood

#8

Dale Jablonski

Re: Unknown wood

dale jablonski

The best way to determine what wood it is would be to send it to me. 8)

Re: Unknown wood

#9

Roadsideium


Re: Unknown wood

#10

soft maple

Dick Coers

I'm voting for soft maple, but not sure which one. Bark is wrong for cherry and birch.

Re: Unknown wood

#11

Jim Evans

Re: Could be Leverite

Jim Evans

NM

Re: Unknown wood

#12

Re: Unknown wood

John Veerkamp

The wood does look like cherry, but I'm also suspicious about the bark. Not redbud. when this large the park sheds much like locust but with much thinner pieces and also not as deeply furrows. Mulberry is bright yellow almost like its cousin osage orange when freshly cut. When aged it is a rich mahogany brown. The bark looks like ash.

Re: Unknown wood

#13

Mike Hunter

FOR wood ... found on rafters


Re: Unknown wood

#14

Re: Unknown wood

carl civitella

+ 1 on the Maple, looks like red maple. Carl

Re: Unknown wood

#15

I think Carl is correct.

John Lucas

I have been looking at Bruce Hoadley's book, the Audubon book , and Terry Porters book. It's not exactly like anything but is very close to Red Maple near as I can tell.

Re: Unknown wood

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: Unknown wood

Keith Tompkins

Hi John, I recently got some weeping Japanese cherry...very similar. Mine has streaks of color throughout. Could be a birch...how hard is it? Some birches are very hard.

Re: Unknown wood

#17

Jim Evans

Re: FOR wood ... found on rafters

Jim Evans

Yep, Leave er rite there.

Re: Unknown wood

#18

Re: FOR wood ... found on rafters

John Jordan

Red maple, no doubt.

John

Re: Unknown wood

#19

Rob Wallace

Need macros of end grain, if possible....

Rob Wallace

John:

While we can get some useful characters for a good identification from bark and side grain, I would MUCH prefer to have a look at the cell characters of the END GRAIN to determine if it is ring porous or diffuse porous, what the parenchymal rays are like, and if the image is "macro enough", to see if any tyloses are present, and maybe even count cell arrangements and/or determine relative cell sizes.

One of your excellent macro photographs of the end grain that has been freshly cut (or, better, shaved with a block plane or razor knife) will enable us to determine what woods it can and can't be quite easily. Without it, the answers are pretty much speculation and maybe educated guessing based on some folk's past experience - but not a real ID.

All the guessing and attempts at recognition are fine, but to do a real identification, you need a close-up of end grain characters. Hoadley's book (or others) and side grain pictures might get you close, but for a real ID, end grain characters are needed. With them we can eliminate or verify several of the species mentioned already, and might possibly suggest others not mentioned. I'd be glad to help if there is sufficient info from good macro images of end grain, side grain, (and even bark) available to see what the wood really looks like "up close and personal".

This was the topic of my AAW demonstration in St. Paul this past summer, and I made a clear distinction between wood recognition (which is what participants in this thread are attempting to do) and wood identification which is a process of examining characteristics of the wood, and following identification keys to really identify the wood by eliminating alternate possibilities. Those of you who have the AAW Symposium abstract book from the 2011 St. Paul symposium can have a look at my entry in it to get more information about this process.

I won't offer a guess because that's really what it would be at this point....!! :)

Rob Wallace

Re: Unknown wood

#20

Re: Need macros of end grain, if possible....

John Lucas

Rob Endgrain magnification is what I tried and scanned Hoadley's book but it really only narrows it down to a few. That's why I decided it might be red maple but still the grain and colors don't look that much like maple to me.

I don't have much bark to go from and it sort of looks like maple. Birch and Hickory were too other choices but the bark only looks sort of like one type of hickory. The photos I found of Birch wood look too even in color.

I got this wood from a guy who passed away and had made picture frames. He saved all sorts of wood and sawed it into 1" thicknesses. Most of what I have is roughly 3" across and 1 1/2 thick by about 28". I've had this stuff in my shed at the other house for 15 years and just started going through it to see what I can use. This stuff is the right size for mirrors. I don't know what I'll do with the smaller stuff. Hate to throw it out but it's gotta go somewhere. With any luck at all that house will actually sell some day.

Re: Unknown wood

#21

Whatever It Is...

Barbara Gill

It looks as if there is some powder post beetle damage.

Re: Unknown wood

#22

Re: Need macros of end grain, if possible....

Jorge

Jojhn,

That bark is no birch at all or red maple, my guess is if it is very hard, it may be hophornbeam, yes it's a mouthful, maybe Brad Vietje can take a look and let's hear what he says.

Re: Unknown wood

#23

Helifino


Re: Unknown wood

#24

Brad Vietje

HA!

Brad Vietje

Thanks for the vote of confidence Jorge, but I'm no expert on woods of Tennessee, and sometimes even get "stumped" by local species, too!

I'm with Rob Wallace -- sure would be nice to see the end grain; we're just taking pot shots without that, and I'd be firing pot-shots from 1,000 miles to the Northeast.

I use and like Eastern Hophornbeam, a.k.a. "Ironwood" (Ostrya virginiana, which is not at all the same as American Hornbeam (no hop), which is Carpinus caroliniana). While the wood looks about right, perhaps a little more like Cherry, the bark is not the same as any Hophornbeam that I have used.

I'm not inclined to guess about trees from so far away, and would defer to John Jordan who grew up in the area... I'm thinking the bark could be Plum, but the sapwood doesn't look right... I don't think of Red Maple or Black Cherry as very hard, as John described it, but how about Pin Cherry or Choke Cherry.....and since J.J. felt certain it was Maple, maybe that's as good as it gets without an end-grain shot.... Sorta like that.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Unknown wood

#25

jim miles

Re: Unknown wood

Jim Miles

I vote for Roadsideium- also known by its scientific name: Telephoniuspolem