Jim, it's Freewoodium- the best kind
Unknown wood
Posts
Re: Unknown wood
#27Hophornbeam is possible
John Lucas
I have not been able to find a photo of the wood itself. The bark looks very similar and the high magnifications from Hoadley's book look pretty similar. Anyone know where to find a photo of the wood. I've searched google but failed so far.
Re: Unknown wood
#28Re: Hophornbeam is possible
John Jordan
Its still red maple. The brown lines "flecks" are common, as is the pinkish hue and greenish color around the figure.

Re: Unknown wood
#29
Re: Hophornbeam is possible *LINK*
Rob Wallace
Try these John:
http://www.thewoodexplorer.com/maindata/we852.html
http://www.woodworkerssource.com/online_show_wood.php?wood=Ostrya%20virginiana
http://www.fs.fed.us/database/feis/plants/tree/ostvir/all.html
http://hobbithouseinc.com/personal/woodpics/hophornbeam.htm
Hope this helps!
Re: Unknown wood
#30
Re: Hophornbeam is possible
Rob Wallace
It still would be best to have a macro-image of the end grain to confirm an ID, or at least try to get some non-subjective characters to go on - colors can vary within a species and throughout a region, let alone between species.
Rob
Re: Unknown wood
#31E Hophohnbeam was my first guess.
Keith Newton
As a side note, the last time I looked, there was no National Champion for this tree. I happened to have a candidate ~ 7" dbh. ~40' T, which I located recently, and the largest I've ever noticed.
Re: Unknown wood
#32
Re: E Hophohnbeam was my first guess.
Brad Vietje
Keith,
That's a pretty nice specimin there, but you don't have the champ by a long shot. They are usually not very big, but I know of one that's about 22" diameter at the base, and probably 14 - 15" at chest height. There are certainly a few 8" or bigger on the hill above my house.
I made a bowl a few years back from a real whopper: the bowl is ~11" diameter and 5.5 - 6" tall, and all on one side of the pith. Most people think its dark-ish Rock Maple (local nickname for hard, dry Sugar Maple), or Yellow Birch, since people rarely see a Hophornbeam bowl, and never one that big. I left it thick, and it's really heavy. This one was just for me and not for sale -- I challenged myself to make the nicest bowl I could without using any abrasives. No photos right now -- new camera needed.
Tree must have grown in a pasture or an opening in the forest, since the growth rings are not quite as tight as usual for this species. I know its Eastern Hophornbeam because my dad and a local sawyer cut up the freshly felled tree about 2002, and I reduced the slabs and chunks to spindle and bowl blanks myself.
Safe spinning,
Brad Vietje
Newbury, VT
Re: Unknown wood
#33Brad, you should nominate it.
Keith Newton
If another is found, at least it would likely be a state champ.
Re: Unknown wood
#34Re: Brad, you should nominate it.
Jorge
Keith,
I saw an 18" recently in northen Maine, there is a whole hillside full of them, I just happen to notice that one, possibly there are bigger in that grove.
Re: Unknown wood
#35
Re: Hophornbeam is possible
Keith Tompkins
It should be fairly easy to tell just by the weight. Red maple up here is fairly soft, while hornbeam is very heavy and hard.
Re: Unknown wood
#36
Re: Brad, you should nominate it.
Brad Vietje
Ya -- for some reason it seems to grow pretty well up in higher places like hillsides, but in pretty decent-looking soils. I have found them in with Am. Beech, Sugar Maple and Yellow Birch, so the soils would tend to be a little sweeter (alkaline). Why it grows bigger here in the North is a bit of a mystery; seems like a lot of trees are much bigger down South with a longer growing season. Must be well acclimated to cold, snowy places like Northern New England. We sure do have some big Sugar Maples, so I suppose colder is better for some trees.
I'd like to start a photo file for trees, burls and such, so maybe I need to request a new camera for Christmas...
Safe spinning,
Brad Vietje
Newbury, VT
Re: Unknown wood
#37Well this is a tough one.
John Lucas
From John J. description of the wood it sure sounds like Red Maple and the bark sure looks similar. It is extremely hard and heavy. So hard that it's difficult to get a clean enough cut on the end grain to really see the pores. A razor blade is too thin and it's hard to get much of a cut. My low angle block plane was freshly sharpened and it cuts but tends to close the pores. I used a freshly sharpened gouge and took a clean sliver. I can now see the pores but it still looks like 2 or 3 woods in Bruce Hoadley's book.
It seems to be a lighter colored wood than the pictures of Hop Hornbeam I can find. I still haven't found a really good photo of Red Maple.
I'm going to make mirrors out of this and don't usually write the species on those but it's nice to know to tell customers what they are.
Re: Unknown wood
#38Re: Unknown wood
Dale Stansbery
I haven't cut any for a long time, but I think the grain looks a lot like a Hawthorne that I once cut. It was hard, dense and heavy.
Re: Unknown wood
#39Re: link to photos *LINK*
http://hobbithouseinc.com/personal/woodpics/hawthorn.htmhttp://
Re: Unknown wood
#40Re: link to photos
Dale Stansbery
I think the one I cut was a Scarlet Hawthorne which is the third set of photos. They have the bright red fruit in the fall.
Re: Unknown wood
#41
Re: link to photos
Keith Tompkins
Hi Dale, Hawthorne trees are one of my favorites...beautiful in the spring!
Re: Unknown wood
#42Re: link to photos
Dale Stansbery
Yep, beautiful clusters of flowers. They're also good for wildlife food in the fall with the fruit. However, they're not so great if you run a thorn into the top of your foot. They have a poison that stays localized (so the ER Dr. told me), but will hurt like nothing you've ever experienced before.
Re: Unknown wood
#43Re: Brad, you should nominate it.
Jorge
Yes, colder is better for trees like hackmatack, fir, spruce, some of the pines and the birches.
That hill has beech, hophornbeam, red maple, moosewood and a dusting of hemlocks...
Re: Unknown wood
#44
Re: Well this is a tough one.
Rob Wallace
John Lucas wrote:
From John J. description of the wood it sure sounds like Red Maple and the bark sure looks similar. It is extremely hard and heavy. So hard that it's difficult to get a clean enough cut on the end grain to really see the pores. A razor blade is too thin and it's hard to get much of a cut. My low angle block plane was freshly sharpened and it cuts but tends to close the pores. I used a freshly sharpened gouge and took a clean sliver. I can now see the pores but it still looks like 2 or 3 woods in Bruce Hoadley's book.
John:
One of the hints I give during my Wood Identification demonstration is to use a brand new heavy duty razor knife blade (I use one in a retractable blade razor knife) to make the end grain slice, using an angled cut running in the same direction (or following) the growth rings. it also helps to wet or briefly soak the end of the wood sample in water (3-5 min.; hot/warm water is better; having it wet will help cut the wood to see the cell structure, as it reduces the crushing of the cell walls because the blade can get through them easier). When I travel and am doing the Wood ID demo, I have a small spray bottle for wetting the wood that is part of my "Wood ID kit" of blades, magnifiers, etc. that I take with me.
Good luck with the ID - when you're cutting your blanks for the mirrors, send me a decent sized scrap piece (w/ bark helpful), and I'll see if I can confirm what the wood is.... - address in the AAW directory.
Also, rely mostly on structure for identification, and less on color. (One of my former professors suggested that only black and white images should be used for identifying wood). It is mostly the arrangement, size, and distribution of cells that helps determine what the wood is.
Rob
Re: Unknown wood
#45Red Maple
Jorge
John,
The fact that is hard and heavy means it is not red maple, which is rather soft and not that heavy. Here are two pictures of a chunk of firewood I put in the lathe and cleaned one end of it, one is dry and the other wet, I see more detail in the dry one.

Hopefully you can read it, is the best I could do, I have no macro lens, on my wish list, but has not materialized yet. I used a normal 50mm lens.
Here goes the wet one:

I forgot to go in the woods and make a shot of bark..



