Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

Posts

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#1

Ellis Walentine

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

Yes, folks, it's time again to register your opinions on yet another topic of importance to woodworkers. Six times a year, we post these "Ides" surveys and publish the results in our "News & Views" column in Woodworker West magazine.

This month's topic is a timely one. As most of you know, there is a major deliberation taking place at the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) regarding mandating the use of flesh-sensing technology on tablesaws sold in the US. The issue is now coming to a head, as the deadline for public comment is December 12, 2011. The full story can be found in the Federal Register.

We've had numerous discussions on this matter over the years, the most recent being this one back in October. Whether or not you participated in that discussion, I look forward to hearing your thoughts. Do you think that the government should mandate flesh-sensing technology on tablesaws? Would such a ruling be an unwelcome intrusion on woodworkers' freedom of choice, or would it be a justifiable regulation in the public interest, similar in scope and effect to mandatory seat belts and air bags in new vehicles in this country? Does the fact that Saw Stop owns the only patents on this technology as applied to tablesaws enter into the equation? What other pros and cons enter the equation?

If you'd like to register a formal comment to the CPSC, go to http://www.regulations.gov/#!submitComment;D=CPSC-2011-0074-0001 .

Thanks for participating!

Ellis Walentine, Host


Comment to the CPSC about Tablesaw Regulations

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#2

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

Absolutely not. The Federal Government is already far too intrusive in our lives. Whatever happened to Liberty? It should be an individuals choice.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#3

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

bill Crommett

Such things should be left up to the individual. As long as his actions do not impact the general public welfare, he should have a choice as to what risks he takes. If Nanny determines that the public welfare is impacted severely then the individual can be required to take a 20 hour safety course in how to keep his fingers out of the way of the saw blade. Does that fit ?

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#4

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

bill Crommett

Sorry, I forgot to sign the previous note properly. It should have been signed by " Nine fingered Bill ".

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#5

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

Carole Valentine

No. You cannot protect everyone from everything, especially their own stupidity. But that aside, just the fact that Stephen Gass (founder of Saw stop) is the petitioner for this ruling makes me angry. He wants to use federal regulations (and our tax money) to line his own pockets. If the rule is passed, then he should have to forfeit patent rights to the technology.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#6

Steven Antonucci

Safety is good, regulations are not

steven antonucci

Seems like he SawStop lobby has pushed this topic pretty hard, but I wonder why it is only being considered for tablesaws? Wouldn't a flesh sensing technology benefit us all in a bandsaw? A chop saw? A mitre saw? Why isn't the CPSC looking at all types of saws?

Oh, yeah... SawStop doesn't have the only patent and a compatible technology for these other types of saws.

I'd like to see the manufacturers have the technology in their products, but I have a huge issue with it being legislated in by a powerful lobbyist. Special interest groups with a huge stake in pushing their technology via legislation do not have public safety in mind.

It would be great if they manufacturers could stall SawStop until their patent ran out, and then copy it freely. Bullying industry into a monopoly is not the best business model.

Steve

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#7

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

robo hippy

It is a good idea to have around beginners. They simply don't have experience. It should not be necessary to have around people who have extensive shop time. We all make mistakes some times. For me, I cut a lot of wet wood, so the stop system would have to have an on/off button, then I would have to remember to turn it back on. It should be optional.

However, we all wear seat belts don't we?

You can never make anything 'idiot proof'. If you do, then some one else will invent a better idiot.

robo hippy

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#8

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

Scott Mckenzie

I hope this kind of legislation never comes to Canada. Build a technology ,lobby the government so everyone is forced to use it . Hmmm . We have a Saw Stop saw in our shop (45 employees) This came about because a dimwit was using his fingers for a push stick and got a kickback...messy. The safety dept. deemed that as our saws had no guards on them, we must get guarded . their choice was the Beismeyer saw guard.The guard was impractical for many operations so it was removed when required and replaced when done. BUT we had to log in a book the when,why, by who of removing the guard. Also signage was posted that use of saw guards was mandatory .The battle raged on for a couple of years until someone mentioned the Saw Stop. The Safety Dept was on the bandwagon, The Managers were on the bandwagon, The demo was shown ,the saw was purchased. All was well until the beancounters found that they could purchase two unisaws for the price of one Saw Stop saw . We said we have shown you the technology, supply it and we will use it. They have yet to get back to us.I should clarify that I work for the Federal Government in a Ship Repair unit. Only the Government could take something as simple as a push stick and turn it into a huge debacle. Good luck in fighting ridiculous legislation!

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#9

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

Sam Scalzo

I am with the rest of the coments. Keep the governament out of it. I agree with Carol let the manufacture give up his patent rights.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#11

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

Hi Ellis,

I think the technology is great and I hope lots of other saw manufacturers offer it in the future, maybe even as an option on saws.

However, I do not think it should be mandated on saws. What about older saws like mine? Would it now be illegal? Would that mean that I can not resale my saw, thus making its value on the market 0?

Interesting analogy with seat belts. I think that people under 18 should be required to wear seat belts (and motorcycle helmets), but I think adults should be able to make their own decisions with regards to personal safety and what risks they are willing to take.

Like others have said, if it *IS* mandated, then I think any patents on the device should be shared, at no costs, to all other manufacturers of saws. If it is optional, then the manufacturers can pay to use the patent, if they so choose.

Sorry to ramble on, like others, I have strong feelings about "big brother" intruding into my life under the guise of "safety".

Mike

Running with scissors and ok with the risk in Apex, NC :)

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#12

Mike Stafford

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

Mike Stafford

The folks at the CPSC have no idea how to make anyone safe. You cannot protect people from their own stupidity and the folks on the CPSC are about as dumb as people can get. Not one of them has any idea how to operate any item they choose to regulate.

The entire law suit upon which all the excitement was generated was caused by a person who was too dumb to operate a table saw. 12 ignorant jurors can be convinced of anything.

You must remember these are the same people who once proposed that all 5 gallon buckets should be manufactured with a hole in the bottom so that the bucket could not hold water in which a baby might drown if the baby should fall head first into the bucket.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#13

Steven Antonucci

Sweet


Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#14

Walt Bennett

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

Walt Bennett

What many of you can't seem to understand that the greedy clown that holds the patent is the one trying to get this enacted. This has NOTHING to do with big government, just capitalism run amok.

I've a decent (not high-end) table saw that I paid $400 for - but would have had to pay $1,100 for a Saw-Stop brand equivalent. I'm a woodturner, not a cabinet maker, so I couldn't possibly justify that much money for a tool I use just a few times a year. An individual who works for one of the major tool manufacturers told me they'd tried working out a deal with Saw-Stop, but couldn't get the royalty below $500 per saw even though they were going to make all the parts, so they've opted not to go that way.

When a technology is available that can save lives, limbs or whatever, and it's cheap and relatively inobtrusive, it makes sense to incorporate it in my mind. Saw-Stop's is not cheap, nor is it inobtrusive (if it trips, it's trow-away and needs to be replaced). I'd be perfectly happy to spend a couple hundred to upgrade my saw BUT ONLY IF it could just be reset any time it tripped and I wouldn't have to spend another $200 to buy a new one.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#15

Dick Hines

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

dick hines

It looks to me like Saw Stop has talked our Rich Uncle into makeing them a wealthy company.

To me it gets back to the old saying" When your stupid you are supposed to suffer."

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#16

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

Harry in beautiful downtown Kulpsville

"You can never make anything 'idiot proof'. If you do, then some one else will invent a better idiot."

Hey Robo!

That better idiot has already been invented. It is the people on the CPSB.

Let them keep their collective noses out of my business and apply their energies to something that helps the public in general .

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#17

Mike Stafford

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

Mike Stafford

Walt, I think everyone understands that the greedy clown is behind getting the regulations enacted. However the greedy clown is not the idiot who will be enacting the regulations- big government will.

I believe we are all on the same page.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#18

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

robo hippy

I liked the John Wayne version of that one, "Life is tough. It is tougher if you are stupid"

Or one from Robert Heinlein, "Stupidity is a fatal disease."

robo hippy

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#19

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

John Lucas

I have probably made myself clear before. I don't think we need regulation of this sort. If everyone wanted the sawstop then they would be selling out of their saws. Let the public decide. If we want to buy a saw without the device we should be able to. We have the option of buying their saw. Shouldn't that be enough.

My worst injury was with a hand held carving knife. Will the government start regulating those?

I currently own a car I can no longer work on or doing it myself takes an entire day thanks to all the crap the government made the car industries install. They can't possible protect us from everything and somewhere along the line there should be common sense.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#20

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

Royce Wallace

I own a saw stop. I decided it was a good insurence policy. Do I believe the govt. should regulate to cause all to use it__no. However it is complicated due to the fact of govt. medical insurance questions. Would save the money used to repaire the injuries that do occur. The injury statics are interesting when the details are reviewed. I suspect we must now begin to understand that with regulated health care via govt., regulations of our life will become even more pronunced. Reading the committee reports I do not believe the public will be listened to in this instance.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#21

Joe Fleming

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

Joe Fleming

I agree with the majority. This rule is wrong. I will add that I think SawStop is acting legally, but unethically. Their products are extremely expensive and, as I understand it, their licensing fees amount to extortion. Now, with a government mandate, they will attempt to gouge professionals and hobbyists alike. This is patently clear when you read the transcript of the CPSC.

Having said that, the gauntlet has been thrown down by them and they have been pretty open with this challenge. If someone else can develop a reasonably priced technology as an alternative, go for it. I personally believe SawStop will be out of business in a year if this happens. At their prices, they will only thrive with government mandated sales.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#22

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

Mark

Yes--it's a matter of safety--I know we have freedom in this country--but technology to keep us safe should be used by all. The only reason why it's only on one brand is because they hold the patent. As soon as that patent is gone you'll see it everywhere. Look at the explosion of multi-tools. There was only one on the market--patent expires and there are at least 10 different ones now at one quarter the cost. This would save fingers, hands and a whole lot of stress. It's just good old common sense--let's all be safe out there, but if there's technology to keep us safer I'm all for it. I think my hand or finger is worth an extra $200 don't you? If not, walk around in a cast for a month and see how well you can get along without that finger or hand.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#23

Walt Bennett

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

Walt Bennett

Problem is that it's more like $500 and that's for each time it's needed. This isn't a seat belt. It isn't a motorcycle helmet. Those save a heck of a lot more than a finger or two and cost a whole heck of a lot less. Air bags are the closest equivalent to a Saw-Stop mechanism, but that's more due to the cosmetic stuff that gets destroyed when they deploy - but an air bag will keep you from getting killed. Don't know how many actual deaths have been attributed to table saws, but I really doubt there's anything near the same potential as a car.

(And after 40 years riding, I personally believe that any biker opting to not wear a helmet should be refused medical attention after an accident, but that's another topic.)

I still say the root of this whole issue isn't big government trying to be intrusive. It's one person's company trying to take advantage of it for pure profit.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#24

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

Barry Irby

I have mixed feelings about this. I don't think the government should mandate this. The technology is available for those who want it and I would buy a SawStop if I were in the market.

That's what I think for those of us buying the equipment for ourselves. How about those who have little or no choice? What do those of you who work for companies that provide the equipment for you? Wouldn't it be better if they bought you a SawStop type saw? I know it might make financial sense for them but perhaps they already have a saw and are not in a position to replace it. If your only choice was to work with an older saw or lose your very important job, what would you do?

Also, this technology has been around for what, ten years? Surely others could have come up with equally impressive but different versions that could be patented on their own. Are we not dragging the American saw industry kicking and screaming into the 20th century? (Next we will drag them into this century) It took what might turn out to be the game changing invention for table saws to get us a riving knife.

Somehow if you invent a better mousetrap the world should beat a path to your door and you should become rich. Right? But that is not happening here. So if the world does not beat a path to your door the government should make us buy your stuff?

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#25

Lets hear from those using the Boss's Saw

Barry Irby

How do you feel about the accident after you find out the company could have bought the entire saw and the replacement cartridge and blade for less than the cost of your trip to the ER? Did they let you build a little coffin for the severed digits?