Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Thoughts on negative rake scraper

Posts

Thoughts on negative rake scraper

#1

Thoughts on negative rake scraper

John Lucas

I know I opened my big mouth a few months ago and stated that I couldn't see any difference in a negative rake scraper and my flat scraper. I speculated that if they both had the same tip angle and it was presented to the wood at the same angle then they would give the same cut.

I have been experimenting and I'm still not sure about the quality of cut but here is what I think the difference is.

One, the tool is held closer to horizontal which is a more natural position. The negative rake keeps the tip lower which avoids catches.

two, the force of the cut is more straight down on the tool rest which should make it easier to take a light cut. Really clean cuts are possible with a scraper with a good sharp burr as long as the cuts are light.

As you can see in the drawing the wood would have a tendency to pull the non negative rake tool into itself or at least not put the same forces down on the tool rest. I use a very light touch when doing this cut with a flat scraper and in fact don't even have the tool on the tool rest. I support the tool with my fingers. The very high angle totally eliminates catches so there isn't any danger. consequently I get the same quality of cut with one exception. If the difference in densities tries to bounce the tool this steep angle won't prevent it. It truely requires a very light touch and is just used to clean the surface.

If you have to remove tool cuts larger than scratches it can be a problem. With the negative rake scraper this is less of a problem and you can take a larger cut without the bounce. Then put a fresh burr on and take fine cuts to clean up the surface.

I'm still experimenting and will let you know what I find out. I should have drawn in the tool rest but I think you can see the difference in the angle of the tools when the tip angle is presented at the same angle.


Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

#2

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

dgelnett

I tried making a negative rake scraper but must not have my angles correct. I don’t seem to be able to create the bur consistently. After looking at your drawing I need to increase the angle on both sides.

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

#3

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

Jim Pugh

I don't think that the angles John is showing are representative of scrapers and are just for quick illustration. To my limited knowledge, scrapers have a bottom angle just large enough to clear the wood - say up to 15°. To make a negative rake scraper, you simply turn a regular scraper over on your grinding platform and grind an angle on the top surface of about 15° give or take maybe 5°. The relief angle on top of the scraper doesn't need to be much wider than 3/16 - 1/4 inch. It isn't critical to make the negative rake scraper work.

As for my exerpertise on the subject, this is how I made mine and they work.

Completely OT: I notice on occasion that most of us do not know how to make the degree symbol '°'. Simply hold the alt key and type in the numbers 248. There are other symbols in this area and perhaps someone can reference a chart for them.

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

#4

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

John Lucas

Creating a burr is just a matter of using something like a diamond hone and rub up the bevel. I have had scrapers ground from about 80 degrees all the way back to 45 degrees. The bur seems to last a shorter time on the sharper angles but it doesn't last long on any of them. The finer angle seems to cut cleaner with the bur. Most of my scrapers are really more blunt than 45 degrees. It's just because I don't use them much and have been slowly grinding the angle more and more acute each time I go to the grinder.

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

#5

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

John Lucas

Jim you are right somewhat. The drawing was more to illustrate the angles the Stuart Batty is using. I have one ground that way. MOst of mine are done like you say. I simply grind off the top angle to give it a negative rake. I am still experimenting and some have a really blunt grind and one was a skew that had a 25 degree included angle and I just put a burr on it.

I do think the sharpen or more acute angle gives a better cut at least in my early experiments.

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

#6

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

Grant Wilkinson

I've not followed the negative rake discussion, so please excuse my ignorance. Looking at John's pics, is it fair to say that a negative rake scraper is nothing more than, or at least very much like, a skew presented to the wood flat on the tool rest?

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

#7

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

John Lucas

You are correct. The angles of top and bottom can change a lot. I have one flat scraper that is ground about 75 degrees or so on the bottom bevel. I just ground away the top bevel by eye at about 10 degrees. It is much more forgiving to catches when used flat on the tool rest.

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

#8

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

robo hippy

The negative rake scraper puzzles me. I have one, and never really use it. I have tried, but don't find that I get better results than I do with a standard scraper.

As to the 'it doesn't catch' idea, probably correct. What happens is the angle is pointing so far down, it will fall out of the wood before it catches. This is like putting your finger into the ceiling fans "in spite of Mom's warnings of "you will chop off/break your finger!" If you point into the rotation, you get extreme resistance like Mom said. If you point with the rotation, the more parallel to the spin your finger is, the less ticking you get.

I have tried every edge that I can think of with a NRS. Grinder burr, honed burr, burnished burr, and no burr. Thing to me is that it is still a scraper, and when used in a scraping mode, as in flat on the tool rest, it will tend to pull the fibers out before it cuts. Since the cuts are so light/fine, the tear out is very minimal. For sure, it works better on harder woods than on softer ones.

I have never understood the notion that the angles on a standard scraper will make it self feed into the wood. From my experience with them, it seems to be more of getting too much steel into the wood at one time (much bigger surface area than most gouges) which is why it feels like it is self feeding, when you should be taking smaller bites.

If you want to use a scraper as a finish tool, it works far better in a shear cut mode, as in up on its edge at a 45 or higher degree angle, than it ever will flat on the tool rest. It makes little difference in which edge you put on it, shear cuts are cleaner than scraping cuts.

robo hippy

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

Keith Tompkins

If nothing else, a skew makes a pretty good negative rake scraper :D

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

Keith Tompkins

Robo, I think if the tool is presented above center (and I've seen turners use a scraper WAY above the centerline) there is a lot of wood under the tool edge. A catch in this position will cause the tool to "self-feed" as the tool is now trying to remove a too-large amount of wood. Having the tool on the centerline will avoid this, the tool will simply drop into air.

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

#11

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

robo hippy

Having the cutting edge at the proper height matters a lot. On the outside of the bowl, you have the scraper at or slightly below center, and on the inside of the bowl, you have the scraper at or slightly above center. This does give the tool room to 'fall out' of the cut, rather than digging in deeper.

robo hippy

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

#12

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

robo hippy

Having the cutting edge at the proper height matters a lot. On the outside of the bowl, you have the scraper at or slightly below center, and on the inside of the bowl, you have the scraper at or slightly above center. This does give the tool room to 'fall out' of the cut, rather than digging in deeper. In both situations, the scraper should angle down, or at minimum be level, never pointing up.

robo hippy

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

#13

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

Wally Dickerman

The NR scraper is at it's best on very hard woods and on endgrain. The tool should be level, it must have a burr to work well, and it must be used with a light touch. It's not meant to hog off wood.

Years ago I ground a scraper as a NR. I wasn't very impressed with it. I was turning a platter of very dense quilted maple. Because the quilt grain is constantly changing direction I was having a hard time with small chip-outs using either a gouge or a scraper. I decided to use the NR. No more chip-outs.

So my conclusions is that the NR scraper has a special use. It doesn't replace a regular scraper in general use.

I grind all of my scrapers at 60 deg. Works for me.

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

#14

Mike Stafford

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

Mike Stafford

Having just spent two weeks in August and three days at the N.C. Woodturning Symposium watching Richard Raffan use scrapers of nearly every shape for a variety of operations on bowls and boxes I saw not one negative rake scraper in his arsenal. As a matter of a fact he made much the same point as John is making; that if the cutting edge is presented properly the angle is the same as what "the negative rake scraper advocates" are doing.

If you study the various ways he moves a scraper through and across the wood as he uses it becomes apparent the result that he achieves cannot be duplicated by a negative rake scraper.

But he is Richard Raffan and he is truly a master with the scraper and with most other woodturning tools as well.

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

#15

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

bob davis

in raffins early "turning wood" he puts a buur on a skew and uses it as a scraper..the master of all masters does it all

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

#16

Roger in MO

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

ROGER IN MO

Thanks John and all for the illustrations and discussion. I'd often wondered what a negative rake on a scraper looked like. I'll have to try it for myself. I've a rather dry piece of ash that is not co-operating.

Roger

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

#17

Mike Stafford

Now that you've reminded me....

Mike Stafford

Richard used his skew as a scraper in one of his demos while cleaning up the inside corner of a cross grain box.

He even quipped, "A negative rake scraper at work....."

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

#18

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

John Lucas

I didn't mean to imply that the negative rake was a cure all. Shear scraping is better than flat scraping and that is true if the tool is a negative rake scraper as well. Cutting clean is still better than scraping. Scraping does help solve some problems.

Wally is right. Scraping is at it's best with really hard woods, bone or ivory.

The negative rake scraper is just another tool in your arsenal. I was just trying to understand it better.

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

#19

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

Bill Noce in Northeast Ohio

John, Quite a few years bacK I had the opportunity to take a hands on class with Stuart Batty when he demoed at Northcoast Woodturners in Cleveland, Ohio and the luck of the draw sharing the same lathe with him. This was when he had that NRS made with the big grind and wide and thick. I got to use it with Stuart showing me how to properly use a NRS. Its was unbelievable at the time on how smooth the inside of the bowl I was turning was.

In Craft Supplies Catalog there is a picture of a NRS and a explanation of how to sharpen it I think it is in the pages of pens.

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

#20

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

Jesper, Denmark

The various signs, not on the keyboard are shown in Windows system tools.

The correct degree sign is alt 0176 °.

The alt 248 is an Ø - Scandinavian version of the German O -umlaut and also used to designate diameters.

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

#21

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

Grant Wilkinson

Tks, John.

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

#22

Re: Thoughts on negative rake scraper

Bernie Weishapl

Thanks John and all for the pictures and info. I took a scraper I got from Penn State and ground it like your second picture John. I ground it to a combined angle of 42 deg. I was having some problems with some chinaberry I had and in this instants it took care of the problem.