Thoughts on negative rake scraper
John Lucas
I know I opened my big mouth a few months ago and stated that I couldn't see any difference in a negative rake scraper and my flat scraper. I speculated that if they both had the same tip angle and it was presented to the wood at the same angle then they would give the same cut.
I have been experimenting and I'm still not sure about the quality of cut but here is what I think the difference is.
One, the tool is held closer to horizontal which is a more natural position. The negative rake keeps the tip lower which avoids catches.
two, the force of the cut is more straight down on the tool rest which should make it easier to take a light cut. Really clean cuts are possible with a scraper with a good sharp burr as long as the cuts are light.
As you can see in the drawing the wood would have a tendency to pull the non negative rake tool into itself or at least not put the same forces down on the tool rest. I use a very light touch when doing this cut with a flat scraper and in fact don't even have the tool on the tool rest. I support the tool with my fingers. The very high angle totally eliminates catches so there isn't any danger. consequently I get the same quality of cut with one exception. If the difference in densities tries to bounce the tool this steep angle won't prevent it. It truely requires a very light touch and is just used to clean the surface.
If you have to remove tool cuts larger than scratches it can be a problem. With the negative rake scraper this is less of a problem and you can take a larger cut without the bounce. Then put a fresh burr on and take fine cuts to clean up the surface.
I'm still experimenting and will let you know what I find out. I should have drawn in the tool rest but I think you can see the difference in the angle of the tools when the tip angle is presented at the same angle.

Robo, I think if the tool is presented above center (and I've seen turners use a scraper WAY above the centerline) there is a lot of wood under the tool edge. A catch in this position will cause the tool to "self-feed" as the tool is now trying to remove a too-large amount of wood. Having the tool on the centerline will avoid this, the tool will simply drop into air.


