Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Bowl shape critic

Posts

Re: Bowl shape critic

#26

Lyle Jamieson

Re: my 2¢

Lyle Jamieson

Great point, John. Its about learning the language. The bottom line is to follow the path of the fun and refine what looks good to YOUR OWN creative eye. Its not to adjust to others likes or dislikes. We all have a piece of the truth.

Re: Bowl shape critic

#27

Steven Antonucci

Agree with Mike

steven antonucci

I am not terribly fond of any of them, and largely for the reasons that Mike stated. I think each one has something that could be subtracted to make it a better bowl.

A footed bowl is probably one of the most difficult things to do when it comes to a bowl. If you can cut the outside, you can make a matching inside, but marrying a foot to that upper form is something that I think is very difficult to pull off. I think that the lines are all disturbed by the bead/rim treatments, and it's a case of Meatloaf (Two out of three ain't bad-but three out of three is!)

If you remove the bead or the foot in each of the bowls, I think you end up in a better place. It's not that either is poorly done, but just that the form is so recognizable that adding to it actually takes something away...

Steve

Re: Bowl shape critic

#28

Chuck Jones - West TN

Never met a bowl I didn't like, but...

Chuck Jones - West TN

...knowing that you have been turning for a hundred years I doubt you posted these for someone to brag on. I'm late to the party and all the good ideas have been taken and mine are not original, but:

Lose all, or most of the band on the first bowl.

Saw off the top one third of the second bowl, or eliminate the band and reshape it into more of a calabash.

Reduce the height of the foot on the third bowl by half or more. Eliminate or reduce the band to a small bead or two. In the process smooth out the curve a little.

(These bowls look familiar. You didn't get them from my shop, did you?)

Very good exercise. Thanks for setting it up.

Re: Bowl shape critic

#29

Re: Never met a bowl I didn't like, but...

john lucas

Chuck I found them in the corner when you weren't looking. I think they were going in the woodstove. :)

Re: Bowl shape critic

#30

AMEN


Re: Bowl shape critic

#31

Brad Vietje

Re: Bowl shape critic

Brad Vietje

Interesting comparison, Dennis. Thanks, John for the interesting discussion.

I find the middle bowl the most interesting, and bringing in the rim makes a nice improvement. I'd go a little further than Dennis did in Photoshop -- I'd make the beads smaller, but as some have commented, with such figured wood, the adornment isn't as effective.

The third bowl doesn't appeal to me much, and its all in the rim treatment -- too big, and I don't like the break in the curve with a conical shape.

The first bowl is in-between for me, but I'm still bothered by the rim. Maybe a little shorter. I respect all sorts of feet -- or none, and I might eliminate the foot on the squatter bowl in the middle. I make artsy bowls with teensy feet that become purely decorative, a bigger foot for a bowl that needs one to do its work, and I love round-bottom bowls with a full curve.

I'm convinced that lumpy bowls result from good lighting. When getting to the final form, switch off all the lights except one -- preferably un-frosted for a near point-source experience -- and look at the shadows on a spinning bowl as the light is moved around -- a little mini mag light works well for this, too.

Fun exercise, and I agree that with larger images it would be easier. My 3 cents...

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT