my 2¢
GaryG in MD
Hi John,
I would like to see a larger photo -- it's hard to judge such small images. (Ellis: I really preferred the old-style format where we could click on the smaller imbedded image and pop up a larger one -- as is done on WoW.)
I'm getting into this chain a little late, but I think it's important to reply to your honest request for input. I have not read any of the many comments (which I'm sure are at least as wise as mine), but I didn't want to bias my opinions -- so this is my totally independent review.
I prefer the one on the left. It has a nice flow to it and pretty good overall balance. I really can't fault it. And that's just the shape. What a great piece of wood!
I feel that the middle one has a heavy, fat feeling. Please pardon my language here, but, honestly, for me, it's like a "beginners" bowl in which the turner tried to use all the wood. I say this from personal experience.
I have several problems with the one on the right. It looks to me like the rim angle above the band is different from that of the band. I really don't like that. I would like to see continuity there. The size of a bowl foot certainly depends on usage, but let me say this. This one seems to be in no-mans land. I would make it much smaller in diameter for artistic or slightly larger in diameter for practical use. I am NOT one of the "no-foot" people -- I usually put one on my own bowls. I also like tall feet, � la Japanese and Stocksdale bowls -- but, again, I think this one is in no-mans land. I would make it either shorter or taller (and, of course, related to the diameter of your choice, should you agree with my comment above about the diameter).
Sorry to be critical -- we tend not to see much of that on WC, but I think we need more, and I know you well enough to know that you didn't want a pat on the back.
Hope this is meaningful to you.
Cheers, Gary