Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Bowl shape critic

Posts

Bowl shape critic

#1

Bowl shape critic

john lucas

Here are the last 3 bowls I've turned. they are not the same size but I tried to make them look like that in photo shop so we can better judge the shapes. I like the lift on the one on the left. I like the upper 1/2 of the middle one and I like the curve of the one on the right. If you look close you can see the curve flattens out on the middle one about 1/3 of the way up. I tried real hard not to do that. This is the largest of the 3 bowls and I guess it's just harder to really nail the shape on larger bowls. I like the diameter of the foot on the middle one but think it should have been taller.

Re: Bowl shape critic

#2

Re: Bowl shape critic

bob davis

no. one all the way

Re: Bowl shape critic

#3

Jerry Louden

Re: Bowl shape critic

Jerry Louden

John, I definately like the one on the left the best and the middle one the least. I think the foot on the right bowl could be a bit smaller and shorter. I like the wood on all three. Jerry

Re: Bowl shape critic

#4

Re: Bowl shape critic

dgelnett

It may be the angle of the camera but when I cover up the right half of the bowl and just look at the left half I see some flat spots, but when I switch the sides it looks better to me. (it could be the hit to my head with a flat object)

I like the first bowl.

I think the second would look better without the foot. The foot makes the bottom look heavey due to the shape. When I take a piece of paper and cover up the foot it looks better.

Re: Bowl shape critic

#5

Re: Bowl shape critic

Lan Brady

None of the them would end in the fireplace, but I like #1 and #3 very much.

The one in the middle just looks too square.

But , I would still put it on the mantle.

Good job, Lan

Re: Bowl shape critic

#6

Re: Bowl shape critic

Randy Gleckler

When you consider the curve or shape through the top of your decorative bead I think that's why #1 is so appealing. The 1st one straightens out through that portion of the Egg/sphere curve only slightly, but the 2nd one seems to elongate the line with less of a curve through that bead. The last one seems to flair out at the top.

As for the feet, I believe I like the first one best as well. I heard a discussion one time about watching where the natural curve goes even when you get to the foot. For some reason the middle one seems to just Stop and have a foot put on it, though the size is probably proportionately better. The 2nd one seems to still have a curve that floats above the table where with a smaller foot it might look better. As for the 3rd one I think the foot is phenomenal for it. it appears to be a more useful bowl and the larger foot flows with the design yet shows stability, if it was too small it would appear to be unstable and might inhibit it being used.

But that's just my 2 cents for this morning. :-D

Re: Bowl shape critic

#7

Re: Bowl shape critic

Bernie Weishapl

John have to say #3 is my favorite followed by #1 without the foot but that is just my personal preferance.

Re: Bowl shape critic

#8

Re: Bowl shape critic

Greg Haugen

Of those three, the first one is my favorite.

For my taste,

The middle bowl has too much "weight" in the bottom of the form and the beads are a little over powering. The right one has a little better curve but is still rather bottom heavy and fringes on a "square-ish" shape (flat across the bottom and vertical on the sides). I don't care for foots on bowls that have "weight" in the form (lower curves). The middle and right seem out of sync with the curve, foot, and bead/band.

The foot on the left is smaller, it has a nicer curve and the bead/band isn't right at the rim and doesn't blend in a bit with the spalting so it doesn't over power the bowl or wood itself but adds to it. And of the three, the bowl's elements are much more balanced.

Re: Bowl shape critic

#9

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Bowl shape critic

Lyle Jamieson

If you want to have some fun, take a sheet of paper and cut the tops off all the bowls at once. Where I found the most striking differences revealed is when the paper hood covered everything down to the middle bowls lower ring. At this point the center bowl jumps out at me as the best shape. The problem created by the hight VS the diameter of the center bowl stretches the line out of balance. This is a case for many beginners (which John is certainly not in this catagory) where the size of the block of wood dictates the shape, sometines in a negative way. Without the hood, if you look at these three with the catenary (the natural curve made by the draping of a chain) curve in mind the extra height of the center bowl stretches the shape to an un-natural line. The foot complicates the evaluations, but without a natural feeling curve the foot size will not help much.

Great exercise to look at a series and try to refine it in small increments. Every bowl teaches us something, we just have to look and keep evolving.

Re: Bowl shape critic

#10

Fat bottom bowls make the world go 'round

Barry Irby

I think the middle bowl is to fat bottomed and a little to tall. Looks like you got the most bowl you could out of that piece of wood.

No. Three, If it were a working bowl and about 12" in diameter would make a wonderful and stable salad bowl, but I doubt it's a working bowl. The foot is slightly too large, maybe half an inch.

No. One is my fav, but the foot might be a 1/4" smaller.

Actually, all are very nice and it's gorgeous wood.

Re: Bowl shape critic

#11

Re: Bowl shape critic

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

I prefer the wood in #1. #2 reminds me of a "tupperware" food container. #3 has the best shape, but the foot needs to be a smaller diameter. Usually I do not like very small foots, especially if it looks like it will fall over in the slighest breeze. None of them would end up in the fire.

Wife says that #3 foot is much too tall. She likes #1 the best.

Re: Bowl shape critic

#12

Re: Bowl shape critic

matt overton

Great exercise! I made a gut critique then read the above critiques, and have to say, most expressed my initial feel. All are very nice bowls, but no. 1 just feels right. I now know what I will do with that roughed cylinder of spalted maple that is waiting on my lathe. Thanks for the lesson and inspiration.

Re: Bowl shape critic

#13

Re: Bowl shape critic

Ian Jeffcock

I hardly feel qualified to comment. but I agree with most that #1 takes first place.

That being said, #3 would be close for me if the rim was a bit different.

It looks to me ( but it may be the photographs) that the rim on #3 flares out at the last minute. I like to have the rim follow the same curve as the rest of the bowl. Obviously there's a step, but the line of the rim should be parallel to the line of the bowl, ...for my taste. Hope that makes sense.

Re: Bowl shape critic

#14

Mike Stafford

Re: Bowl shape critic

Mike Stafford

I am not the best to critique anyone's work but I can give an opinion.

Bowl #1 (far left) has a form of which I am fond but I would prefer it without the foot. If the curve is continued right through the bottom it makes a very pleasant looking bowl. I don't care for the band at the top as it seems to cause an interruption of the beautiful grain of the wood. I don't care for footed bowls I must add as a disclaimer.

Bowl #2 (middle) If you take away the foot and the beads you are working on a pretty good calabash form which is a form that I find attractive. I think the beads are overly large and would look much better if more subtle/smaller.

Bowl #3 (far right) is my least favorite. I don't care for the large band at the top and the outward flair in appearance that it creates. The foot is too large for my liking as well. I would have preferred a bowl which curved inward more beginning aroud the middle and reduced in size all the way to the bottom.

But you know what opinions are like..... :D

Re: Bowl shape critic

#15

Keith Tompkins

Re: Bowl shape critic

Keith Tompkins

HI John, I agree with Lyle....the center bowl doesn't need the decorative beadwork...and if it were cut off at the lower bead, it would be a very attractive piece, similar to a Bill Luce bowl. I would still bring the rim diameter in a bit, just to see how it looks. I think it has the most potential of the three pieces. The curve in the third piece accelerates quickly, then flattens out before reversing direction...I must be at odds with most turners...I LIKE footed bowls; done well, they add a sense of lift that unfooted bowls just don't have. Just my opinion, of course.

Re: Bowl shape critic

#16

Re:Size Matters

mjonesrdg

When I look at these three forms and imagine them as 14" diameters, then look again and think they are some of John Lucas's mini-miniatures, then look again and think 7" max, my opinions change dramatically. I suggest that you send them all over to me and let me "fix" them for you. :D :D :b

Re: Bowl shape critic

#17

I'm with Lyle... I think

Jeff Willaford

If I block off the top of all three.... I like the curve of the middle bowl best but then it's more along the line of what I turn than the others.

Re: Bowl shape critic

#18

Very interesting discussions.  keep em coming.


Re: Bowl shape critic

#19

Re: Bowl shape critic

Don Orr

Nice bowls John. Great way to look at various shapes/styles. I am looking at the bowls in their entirety without blocking off this or that aspect. I am drawn to the leftmost bowl or #1. The shape is most fluid to me, the detail is subtle yet interesting, and the foot seems the most proportionate. . While I like deep bowls like the middle one, the detail throws me off and I think the foot is a little small to provide the lift the bowl needs due to the heavy-appearing bottom. The rightmost, #3, bowl would be better for me without a foot at all as a functional serving/salad bowl. I also don't prefer the curve from the bottom into the foot. Now this is all being said by someone who appreciates well made pieces like this but can't usually get any where near this level of quality work. Great wood too.

Re: Bowl shape critic

#20

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Bowl shape critic

Dennis in Southern Oregon



I did a bit of re-turning with Photoshop. What do you think? The bottom one is the original, and the top one is the result after playing with some of the curves of all three bowls and narrowing the foot of the third.

Dennis

Re: Bowl shape critic

#21

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Bowl shape critic

Jesper, Denmark

Hi John,

The spalted wood and the decorative beads makes it difficult to "see" the shape. So for a shape analysis project, plain wood and no decorations will make the analysis easier.

Having said that, the shape of the left one is the most interesting, as it seems to fairly closely folow the catenary curve shape. neither the middle nor the right one need feet. The middle one without the bead has a sorta nice homey feel to it and works in some contexts. The right one, again without the foot and as a fairly large bowl, says "utility" as a practical salad bowl, but the change in shape halfway up is not so good.

Re: Bowl shape critic

#22

BarbS

Well...

BarbS

I must have no good eye at all, because I was instantly drawn to the third bowl on the right. It seems much better to me than the other two, in the curvature, the wide top band and the perfectly proportioned foot. I've read the other opinions and I'm a bit startled by how many dismiss the third bowl as inferior. I guess I'll just keep turning for what I like to see, because I really, really do like that one on the right side!

Re: Bowl shape critic

#23

Just another opinion

Carole Valentine

Which ain't worth much. I would get rid of the "beads" on all three. To my eye they are out of proportion and very distracting. You have some pretty wood there, but it has enough busyness on it's own and doesn't need the competition from the beads. I would like the second bowl best without the bead, with the rim coming in slightly on a continuous curve so the top was just a little smaller than the bottom, and with a foot about half or less the height you have, or even better, no foot. I am not a fan of tall feet so I would lower the foot on all of them severely, but then different strokes for different folks....as I said, it's just one more opinion! ;)

Re: Bowl shape critic

#24

my 2¢

GaryG in MD

Hi John,

I would like to see a larger photo -- it's hard to judge such small images. (Ellis: I really preferred the old-style format where we could click on the smaller imbedded image and pop up a larger one -- as is done on WoW.)

I'm getting into this chain a little late, but I think it's important to reply to your honest request for input. I have not read any of the many comments (which I'm sure are at least as wise as mine), but I didn't want to bias my opinions -- so this is my totally independent review.

I prefer the one on the left. It has a nice flow to it and pretty good overall balance. I really can't fault it. And that's just the shape. What a great piece of wood!

I feel that the middle one has a heavy, fat feeling. Please pardon my language here, but, honestly, for me, it's like a "beginners" bowl in which the turner tried to use all the wood. I say this from personal experience.

I have several problems with the one on the right. It looks to me like the rim angle above the band is different from that of the band. I really don't like that. I would like to see continuity there. The size of a bowl foot certainly depends on usage, but let me say this. This one seems to be in no-mans land. I would make it much smaller in diameter for artistic or slightly larger in diameter for practical use. I am NOT one of the "no-foot" people -- I usually put one on my own bowls. I also like tall feet, � la Japanese and Stocksdale bowls -- but, again, I think this one is in no-mans land. I would make it either shorter or taller (and, of course, related to the diameter of your choice, should you agree with my comment above about the diameter).

Sorry to be critical -- we tend not to see much of that on WC, but I think we need more, and I know you well enough to know that you didn't want a pat on the back.

Hope this is meaningful to you.

Cheers, Gary

Re: Bowl shape critic

#25

Re: my 2¢

John Lucas

Gary It's not being critical. That's how we learn. Each person has something to offer just like selling to the public. Everyone thinks a little differently but when you get enough opinions there are things that stick out to everyone. I thought this would be a good exercise for everyone particularly those unwilling to ask for critics.

I take these to work and of course every one goes, man these are really great. I know they need work to be really top notch so it's fun to get opinions from turners who do take the shapes seriously.

For those of you who don't feel like you can give a good critic. It's just about learning the language and and trying to figure out why you do or don't like something. Your opinions are valued also.