Hi folks. Usually I make my own aesthetic decisions, but I'm wrestling with one right now and I thought it might make a good discussion for the group. Here's a piece I'm making for Charlie B's Pay-It-Forward challenge. I'm trying to decide how to complete the finial on this hollowform box. At this point, it still looks too thick to me. I'm wondering how you make your design decisions regarding finial dimensions and detailing. What, if any, are the universal principles involved? All thoughts welcome.
I looked at it long and hard, and perhaps the thing I find most "off" about it is that lack of any curve. It goes from the base to the finial just fine, but then it just tapers into a long straight line. I think that's your issue.
Steve
P.S. I looked at proportion, and it's OK if the shape was different, but that long taper seems to be the culprit! Perhaps that shape in a smaller proportion?
Ellis, The very top of the finial keeps throwing my eye off/up. I can't tell what that is. I think if the very top was removed where it comes the the thinnest point the whole piece would flow better. Beautiful wood and form in the HF.
I agree with Steve. I think there needs to be more taper as it goes toward the top. Usually I like the taper to end at the top details but I think in this case there seems to be a taper going down from the top details and another from the bottom up. I would accentuate that. Let the top taper go down and get thinner and then make the bottom taper flow into it. It will get delicate of course so good luck on that.
Good advice, John. That was one of the options I was considering, but I'm reluctant to take any chances. If it gets too thin, I can't put wood back on it.
Thanks, Dick. Actually, the piece is still on the lathe (I rotated the photo sideways to give a more realistic look at the forms), so that top part you mentioned is actually the stub where the tail center grabs it. I'll be tapering that last little onion bulb to a point when I part it off.
I'm also going to have to have another look at some of Cindy Drozda's finials. She has an amazing eye for this form.
I always turn finials with the tip unsupported by the tailstock. Pressure from the tailstock causes vibration, which limits the diameter you can achieve; I start from the tip, and work towards the base, taking advantage of the mass to support the cut. All single-axis turnings are symmetrical, so there are a few things we can do to break up the symmetry to add visual interest: vary the diameters, which creates a contrast between the largest and smallest sections. Avoid straight lines, which give a static appearance, it's better to mimic the form the finial supports. The rule of thirds works well with finials, each section can be divided up that way, and the finial overall as well. Beads and coves always work, but it's hard to make v-grooves fit into a design. Personally, I think the diameter should be 1/2 or less its current diameter, with a graceful curve from the base to the tip. I hope this helps.
This is from a turner who is terrible at the actual turning part of making finials. I think that the finial is WAY to tall. It should be half as high as the box.
particular term when describing finials during your class.....
I do think the finial is too tall and too straight. I like to see a gentle curve going from the largest diameter toward the tip feature if there is one.
IMO there's just too much finial. It tends to overpower the nice vessel. I think that the base of the finial could be thinned down a bit. Then just make the whole thing thinner using a gentle curve. I also think that it's too tall, but if you make it thinner it will look better. There doesn't really have to be a top feature.
Finials are quite tricky to get just right. Most folks who haven't done many tend to make them too heavy. It's mostly a matter of balance to make them look right.
I think you got a lot of good tips but I think you are already past the point of saving this one. I would take Keith's advice and turn an unsupported at the tailstock end finial. Start with a piece of wood that is big enough to give you a nice base and long enough to let you adjust the dimensions as you go. Also you will need to turn the tenon before parting off. Cindy Drozda likes to see a triangle or cone shape from the tip to the base in all the details. The long stem part can be very thin but the details should get progressively larger from the tip to the base. A lot of Cindy's finials are taller than the boxes she makes. I've included a pic of a finial I made that's taller than the HF and I think it works.
Thanks, Wally. Your advice is much appreciated. I think I'll start over and work from the tip back, taking your suggestions and the others into consideration. I guess you can tell that I haven't much experience with this type of turning. Maybe that's why I do the same hollowforms all the time. This is a challenge.
I remember seeing this piece of yours and really admiring everything about the proportions and detailing. I know good form when I see it, but it's hard to previsualize it and then make it happen. I'm wondering if you drew out the form very exactly on paper and then carefully gauged all the diameters prior to finish turning?
This type of decoration has such tremendous possibilities for adding dimensions to a piece. I think the "style" of the finial imparts a feeling to the piece, by suggesting or mimicking a shape or style characteristic of another era or tradition. Often we don't articulate this sort of thing, but the impression is made just the same. It is the job of the maker to perceive this feeling in advance and then bring it to life in the finial.
Thanks for your excellent advice and knockout example.
Curves are far more pleasing than straight lines. Women have known this FOREVER. And curves that flow one into another smoothly and continuously are even more pleasing. So where two curves meet, they should meet at their common tangent point (think "S").
The neck of your finial is a straight taper , everything else in the piece are blended curves. The straight line in the finial "neck" interrupts the flow of the rest of the piece.
If you put the minimum diameter of the neck of the finial up about 2/3rds or 3/5ths or maybe 3/4rds of the neck's height and turn two curves, one coming up form the base and another coming down from the top of the "neck" - you MIGHT be able to squeeze in two curves.
Hi Ellis, Here's a page from my "Art of the Finial" class. Like Cindy, I use a triangle to visualize the shape of the finial. I've highlighted some basic ideas I strive to create
I really appreciate the good advice I've received on this question. Here's how I've resolved this particular finial -- by cutting it down by about half and adding some curves and details. I didn't exactly apply the formulas that Charlie and Keith illustrated, but I tried to address the appearance with those proportions in mind.
It's been an instructive exercise for me. Among other things, I've learned that Indian rosewood is really too porous to hold the kind of precious detail that these finials demand. But, I'm still not comfortable with my tools, chucks, abrasives and methods for making these things.
One of my concerns is that the finial needs to be integrated visually with the vessel that it adorns, so that curves are congruent or parallel or whatever they need to be, and so that the visual weight and proportions of the finial are in keeping with the size and shape of the vessel below. I'm unclear as to how to do that if you turn the finial as a separate piece and then marry it up to the vessel later. My instinct is to turn the spigot/tenon of the finial and then mate the two for finish shaping.
I'm also as confused as ever about the lexicon of finial detailing and styles. Clearly, more research is in order. How do finial designers decide which elements to combine, in which order? A quirk here, an undercut there, a bulb, a sweeping cove, a little acorn tip... it's an art and a mystery.
Anyhow, I'd like to get some more discussions going about the tools and techniques of this very interesting style. Maybe we can get Cindy to join us at some point.
That was really strange, Carol. I'm almost afraid to find out why or how that photo was substituted for the one I uploaded originally. Anyhow, it should be fixed now. If it doesn't show up, flush your browser cache.
Hi Ellis, Big, big, improvement. I think part of the secret of turning good finials is having the ability to self-critique your work....some turners have a lot of trouble doing that. You obviously saw something wasn't quite right, and were willing to try something else....some turners who've attended my classes just seem to have a hard time letting go of their familiar forms and shapes....and become stuck at a certain level. Now, you can see you're heading in the right direction, so I would suggest turning a few more, experimenting with the proportions, focusing on the effect even the smallest detail has on the overall appearance. Sometimes if I struggle with a piece, I'll turn several samples from common wood, just to compare their overall appearance when sitting atop the form. (Like the image of several finials I posted recently, each with small changes)Then, duplicate the best one in the "show" wood. If I were to critique your newest version, I would suggest reducing the diameter of the tip by 1/2, and reducing the diameter underneath the main bulb form. The idea is to highlight, or showcase, the main element, the large bulb form; the easiest way is to create the contrast of large/small. (Since the shape was already turned, I understand the lower bulb form couldn't be enlarged, but it would add if that were possible) Here is the grind I use on my detail/spindle gouges, which allows me to skim across the turning with the long grind; the flute is 90 degrees to the turning. I don't cut with the flute up, nose cutting if at all possible...that adds pressure to the turning, and therefore, vibration. The skew, long point down, works well for details...such as the base of bead shapes. I've found that the skew works great on finials, almost never a catch, probably due to such small diameters involved. I don't use a parting tool on the finial body at all, the surface it leaves is too rough; I turn fillets with the skew. With good technique, almost no sanding is needed, but I don't sand sharp details at all. I hope this helps, I'm out of ammo.