WOOD ID HELP NEEDED
klowwn
Just trying to confirm - is this hickory or some other species?
Thanks
Ricc

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
WOOD ID HELP NEEDED
klowwn
Just trying to confirm - is this hickory or some other species?
Thanks
Ricc

Doesn't Look Like Hickory To Me
Brad Vietje
I'm at the very northern limit for the various Hickory species, so my exposure might be very different than others. I've seen about 4 different Hickories, and this doesn't look like any that grows in the Northeast.
Clearer photos would be helpful. Also, before anyone else jumps all over you, what is the approximate location where it grew? Information Like Alabama vs. Milwaukee, can make a LOT of difference. Other details about habitat like dark, wet, deep ravine, swamp, Arizona desert, or rocky mountain-top would be helpful, too.
Safe spinning,
Brad Vietje
Newbury, VT
Re: Doesn't Look Like Hickory To Me
Carole Valentine
Darned if the bark doesn't look like loblolly pine to me! Definitely not Hickory and not even sure it is hardwood. Does it have a smell?
More info
Ricc Havens
brad, it's from northern Indiana. On another forum I only had a response as possibly hickory
carole, not much of an odor at all. But then again I am fighting a cold so my smeller isn't working so good:):)
Thanks
ricc
Re: WOOD ID HELP NEEDED
Bernie Weishapl
Just a guess but it kinda looks like elm to me. Elm has a smell to it like a wet dog to me. Turns nicely though and finishes well.
Not easy to tell from the photo, but....
JamieDonaldson
...I would guess white walnut, also known as butternut. I don't know what it's northern most range is, but we have some here in KY.
Re: Not easy to tell from the photo, but....
jim miles - Charlotte
Walnut is my guess also- what is the prize if we get it right ?
( a bag of mulch from it ? )
Jim
Re: Not easy to tell from the photo, but....
JL
Maybe I'm just used to butternut lumber - but that looks a tad dark for butternut.
Re: Not easy to tell from the photo, but....
Mac Ray
My guess from the photo would also be a member of the walnut/butternut (Juglans) family,best guess would probably be a very poor quality hunk of near decay walnut....
Re: WOOD ID HELP NEEDED
Bill Turpin in WNC mountains
Bark and wood looks like black locust. Hard enough to spark a chain saw if truly dry. Is the lighter colored wood kind of yellow, are there any thorns embedded in the bark? Did you see the leaves?
Re: WOOD ID HELP NEEDED
R Henrickson
It looks a lot like some (black) locust I got from my brother-in-law's farm after a windstorm.
I'm guessing semi rotten cottonwood...
Dick Coers
what's the smell like?
Re: WOOD ID HELP NEEDED
Mike from St. Clair Shores
My guess would be Black Locust. Is it heavy and very hard. Dropped on cement does it sound louder than most domestic woods?
+1 for Black Locust
FACE GRAIN PICS
klowwn
I have a cold so I can't tell you about the smell. But here are two more pics of two pieces showing the facegrain. I would have included them earlier but my camera died and I borrowed one last night for these pics
Thanks
Ricc

Looks like yellow poplar to me
Ellis Walentine
I've seen that purple grain in yellow poplar quite often.
Ellis
I agree this looks like yellow poplar, but
Chuck Jones - West TN
It's hard to believe this is the same piece of wood as the first pictures.
Cottenwood.
Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas
The thinning bark on the sides of your first photos leads me to believe that the other half may have already been dead, leading to the dark staining of a normal cream colored wood.