Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

skew proficiency test

Posts

skew proficiency test

#1

Keith Tompkins

skew proficiency test

Keith Tompkins

In my previous post, I mentioned a skew proficiency exercise/test from a 1946 woodworking training manual. Here is my version of it...I added the center section just for fun. There are other tests as well, v-grooves, coves, etc.. It should give a challenge!

Re: skew proficiency test

#2

Steven Antonucci

Similar effort...

steven antonucci

To build skew proficiency, I will often pick up a busted chair off the side of the road when people are discarding them.

I mount the legs and stretchers and recut them with only a skew... beads and coves...

Your bead only test is the beginner test...:D

S

Re: skew proficiency test

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: Similar effort...

Keith Tompkins

Hey Steve, this is just the warm-up for the final exam :D

Re: skew proficiency test

#4

Steven Antonucci

which is turning a hollowform with a skew

steven antonucci

Re: skew proficiency test

#5

Re: skew proficiency test

John Lucas

Keith My system is similar but I think for new turners it's better to start with a barrel shape and work your way toward beads. Turning the barrel gets you started rotating the tool you are not rotating the tool very far so it's easier to stay on the bevel.

Then move toward the ball shape. This makes you rotate the tool more but it's still a slow rotation so it inforces the need to rotate the tool as well as lift the handle.

Then gradually move on to straight sided beads which I think are the most difficult.

The photo you show is great for the experienced turner who hasn't been turning lately and needs to refresh their skills. I do just that. It's great practice.

Thanks for posting.

Re: skew proficiency test

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: skew proficiency test

Keith Tompkins

Hi John, I agree. This exercise was intended for students as a requirement to complete the lathe course, exhibiting their proficiency with the skew. They not only had to participate in the class, but also had to prove their ability before receiving a certificate.

I've thought about courses that could be offered through, or sponsored by, the AAW, where the turner had to show they had mastered the basics such as sharpening, spindle turning, bowl turning, etc. A certificate could be awarded at the completion of each course, and would count towards recognition as a journeyman or master turner. Sort of like earning a black belt in martial arts, or ASE certrfication for an auto technician. The title "master turner" would really mean something; for example, someone who had earned the title would be be accredited by the AAW to pass their knowledge on to the next generation of turners...ensuring the continuance of our craft.

Re: skew proficiency test

#7

Re: skew proficiency test

John Lucas

Keith Would we wear our smocks with belts of different colors. When I studied martial arts for a very short time I had a green belt. I was told that was just enough to get me hurt. I think I'm there in woodturning. :)

Re: skew proficiency test

#8

Keith Tompkins

Re: skew proficiency test

Keith Tompkins

You have much to learn, grasshopper. :O

Re: skew proficiency test

#9

Re: skew proficiency test

Mike from St. Clair Shores

Keith, I think this is a great idea. Many European countries seem to have similar programs. I'm all for the AAW doing this. As president of the Bluewater Area Woodturners, I started a program last year that members would have to participate in so many show & tells, President's challenges, club demos, etc. to earn different name tags that identify their turning abilities. Maybe a committee within the AAW could draw up a set of guidelines for earning different ranks with Master Woodturner being the ultimate goal.

Mike

Re: skew proficiency test

#10

Made a practice video this morning

John Lucas

Keith I did a short video showing how I tilt the skew up to get a cleaner cut. Since it was such a nasty piece of wood I also showed the cut with wax and lacquer soaking to try and get a cut worth salvaging.

Then I showed a sort of V cut exercise I do to learn how to control the cut and keep the pressure off the bevel.

I'll try to get it downloaded sometime today. It might be tomorrow before youtube lets it come up.

Re: skew proficiency test

#11

Tests & Certicifation vs Exercises

charlie belden

I see ads in the British turning magazine for turning instruction with the letters R.P.T. (Registered Professional woodTurner) after the instructors names. So it appears as though, at least in England, there is an official body that determines the qualifications for being "registered" and presumably some testing of competency requirements.

My concerns about having something similar in the United States, run by AAW or some other body are

- that demonstrated competency with tools and techniques is wonderful, IF you're applying for a job - in say a factory

or "production" house. We don't have many woodturning factories or "production" houses

- one can have the competency with tools and techniques but not be a competent teacher / instructor

- standardization and certification tend to stifle innovation and creativity by "dictating" The Right Way, and rejecting any other way that works

It's that last one that we in the United States have avoided. And THAT may explain the explosion of new turning ideas and techniques. HOW and how efficiently one creates an interesting piece is less important than THAT one creates an interesting piece. Turning in the United States seems to be far more diverse than in Europe. Granted, it may just be that we in the U.S. aren't exposed to what's happening in Europe or other parts of the world. New Zealand does seem to have a disproportionate number of very creative and innovative turners, Alby Hall, Terry Scott and Greame Priddle to name just three.

Then there's the test of proficiency itself that I question. The example Keith provided is more an exercise in layout and turning to speciied diameters than the ability to use a skew - more of a machinist thing than a wood turning thing. The cuts to turn the beads once the start and stop points of the specified diameters have been turned - with a parting tool, skew, bedan or sharpened open end wrenches of the require diameter - requires only the ability to do a rolling cut with a skew. And there are several ways of doing a rolling cut with a skew.

And just because you COULD, at some point in the past, cut beads, coves, pommel cuts and V cuts with a skew, doesn't mean you could pick up a skew a week or month or year later - and do them again as well as you did after doing 4, 5 or 10.

I think that as soon as there's an "accepted" Right Way and Wrong Way, OTHER WAYS aren't pursued, or perfected. It's that tryng DIFFERENT ways of doing things that is responsible for many of the new turinng tools - and techniques.

Re: skew proficiency test

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: Tests & Certicifation vs Exercises

Keith Tompkins

HI Charlie, Being a bit of an anarchist myself, there is something to be said for structure; an established set of guidelines....after all, for every competent instructor, how many on you-tube are demonstrating, and advocating, very dangerous techniques? (or total lack of)

I've worked at two professions in my lifetime: a furniture maker/designer, and a auto technician. A bit odd, I know, but one's gotta feed the family. In both cases, I received training by european masters. In Germany, for example, a mechanic has to go through an extensive apprenticeship program. EVERY one of these guys I've ever met was a true professional, and were worthy of the title "master". On the other hand, I've witnessed "professionals" with little or no formal training...I shudder to think of the shoddy workmanship they sometimes produced. To think people's lives depended on their expertise and judgement.

I don't think mastering the basics, and being grounded in the fundamentals of a craft, necessarily stifles creativity. As a furniture maker, the fundamentals were pounded into me; and they were gospel. I can hand-cut a dovetail as well as anyone, or sharpen a bench chisel to perfection. I believe you must pay your dues, learn the traditional way, but that doesn't mean you cannot branch out from there. Like a jazz musician, learn the rules, and then break every one you can.

I agree, not all good turners are good teachers. Some things need to be left up to the student to find the right one for them...with things like WC, it's fairly easy to find out who's good, and who's not.

Re: skew proficiency test

#13

Paying Your Dues

charlie belden

I'm not one who puts much value on Paying Your Dues - if it isn't necessary to accomplish things I want to do. It's getting an idea out of my head and into reality that's the goal, not how that's accomplished. Efficiency is not a concern since I turn what I want to turn and have no deadlines to meet. If there's a tool that makes it easier to go from idea to piece - and I can afford it - I'll go for flattening the learning curve and not Paying My Dues.

I bought the MiniMonster for exactly that reason. It makes hollowing less risky for me - and I feel safer using it than using a swan neck totally hand controlled tool since this Captured Hollowing System constrains most of the tool's movement, leaving me to guide it only in only in one plane. Is it Idiot Proof? Not for this clever idiot. If I CAN screw up, I probably will. The MiniMonster merely reduces my opportunities to screw up ; ).

Now don't get me wrong. I'm not foolish enough to assume that a cool, new and improved, superduper EXPENSIVE tool will automatically and effortlessly enable me to crank out flawless beautiful pieces. That's a completely different Skills Set.

I'd have never tried snow skiing - if it required climbing to the top of a run in order to ski down it. Thankfully there are ski lifts. I like skiing. Not so fond of CLIMBING. If I could afford it, I'd probably be a Heli Skier.

As for staying with "traditional" furniture making methods, specifically mortise and tenon joinery - have you used the Festool Domino? The advantages of loose tenon joinery over the more traditional mortise and tenon, hand cut or with power tools is debatable in terms of strength is debatable, but in a 65 MPH world of every day driving, being ABLE to go 200 mph doesn't make any difference. The Domino enables even a novice at woodworking to do pieces that need mortise and tenon joinery - aprons to table legs as an example.. Won't turn out a well proportioned, nice to look at table - but it WILL make holding the parts together a LOT easier and quicker.

Learning The Rules first and THEN breaking them may be great for music done with traditional instruments - or doing things that have already been worked out. But in this rapidly changing world unprecidented opportunities to do things that couldn't be done before with tools and methods well established are popping up all over the place - to use HP's slogan for their first pocket calculators - A Solution Looking For Problems To Solve.

Give me easier safer ways to get to WHAT and let me spend the time and effort coming up with the idea for WHAT.

Re: skew proficiency test

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: Paying Your Dues

Keith Tompkins

Charlie, I teach a lot of woodturning classes. Biggest problems I encounter:

1. Student has not mastered the basics. Many have been turning for five years or more and still struggle. Most can afford the very best in tools, and, trust me here, own most of them. I am surprised how many turners in this category own a Oneway lathe.

2. Student has great ideas, but cannot create the piece they envision. Constantly frustrated. See #1.

3. How on earth does one teach a craft such as woodturning if there are no rules and no structure? There must be a baseline somewhere. Your approach works for you, but won't work in most cases.

Re: skew proficiency test

#15

Re: Paying Your Dues

charlie belden

I understand the need for Basics, however they're acquired. Understanding the concepts - of sharpening, the types of basic cuts (shear, scrape - pull cut, push cut, plunge cut etc.) which tools were designed to do which types of cuts (there are basically only fouro - concave, convex, straight and V) have to be understood. Ride The Bevel, methods of holding a piece are a foundation that's needed.

The good demonstrators/teachers emphasize that the tools they use, how they're sharpened, their bevel angles and they're use of their tools is JUST their way of doing things - and emphasize that there are many other ways of doing the job. They usually underline the point that what they are demonstrating is THEIR way - and there are several other or many other ways of accomplishing the same thing.

So yes - being taught ways of doing things by a good teacher can be invaluable - if by "good teacher" you mean one who can convey knowledge in a way students can understand and perhaps apply, as opposed to the ACHTUNG! Dis is DE VAY - und De ONLY WAY.

A student emulating the teacher - initially - is a good thing. But if the student is taught merely to be a clone of the teacher - that's not so good. I really respected and admired James Krenov. But I get tired of seeing his student's versions of his pieces, even if done very well.

Teach? Yes. Clone? No.

Re: skew proficiency test

#16

Re: Paying Your Dues

John Lucas

I have to agree with Charlie on this one, at least on some levels. We saw this in photography. It might be nice to have a certain level of competency and possibly have a certificate to show that. However I don't think you necessarily need that to create art, or to be able to sell it.

I think most important in art is the eye and mind of the person who creates it. A perfectly shaped bowl can be created using nothing but a scraper. It takes a good eye and gently touch to get the shape right but it can be done. Granted a skilled turner with a sharp bowl gouge and a good eye will do the same thing faster but both can end up with the same product. The same would be true with a spindle. I could take a skew and lay it on its side and scrape the whole spindle and end up with the same piece I would turn using the skew. Yes there might be some limitations as to shape but my point is, with patience and good eye both can be achieved.

We saw the licensing of photography go down this road. If a person had a really unusual style they were not accepted by the "guru's " of photography and would not be awarded a "master" of photography certificate. I'm changing the names of most of this so as not to offend anyone. The photographer with the unusual style still may find enough clients to make a good living but would not be classified as a certified photographer.

Re: skew proficiency test

#17

skew video link- as soon as youtube passes it  *LINK*

John Lucas


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tZVlhr9fLCM

Re: skew proficiency test

#18

Keith Tompkins

Re: skew video link- as soon as youtube passes it

Keith Tompkins

Hey John, that was great! Question...when you cut straight across end grain, do you arc the tool , or straight in? Does it make a difference? Anyway, awesome teaching video.

Re: skew proficiency test

#19

Keith Tompkins

Re: Paying Your Dues

Keith Tompkins

Charlie, you bring up some valid points, but you may be overlooking a few important details. All of civilization is based on knowledge passed down from previous generations, a foundation, if you will. Otherwise, we would be constantly re-inventing the wheel. All new engeneering feats are based on what we already know, we just add, and add, and add to our knowledge. While European societies still use an apprentice system, they are responsible for many scientific advances...we stole the A-bomb from the Germans. Similarly, in woodturning, why spend years learning a craft by trial and error methods when it could be taught by a competent teacher in a few weeks? Yet, it happens all the time...especially with the design aspect.

Are all teachers created equally? No, but it's up to the student to choose the best one for them. James Krenov was a great teacher at what he did; students left his classes with a good understanding of materials and hand-tool technique. Although a great craftsman, Krenov, in my opinion, didn't push the evelope concerning design, he sort of got into a groove and stayed there. The fact that his student's work resembles his bears out this fact...he didn't push them to explore past a certain point. That doesn't make him a bad teacher; after all, there are well-known woodworkers who only work in one style. Shaker, Chippendale, Arts and Crafts, Greene and Greene, etc.. Some work exclusively with Windsor chairs, and only teach their specialty. It's very rare for a woodworker to break the mold and develop their own unique and successful style. Try to name more than a handful that have.

An important thing is that people like Krenov kept a craft alive; without teachers like him, many secrets would eventually fade away.

I tell my students...take the ideas presented in my class; use the ones that work for you, and disregard the rest. Do the same with every instructor you study with. Eventually, you will have many different techniques to fall back on, and you will have begun to develop your own style.

Re: skew proficiency test

#20

Keith Tompkins

Re: Tests & Certicifation vs Exercises

Keith Tompkins

Charlie, I didn't clarify this...the exercise is to be done with the skew only, so planing cut, end-grain cuts, peeling cuts are all used, as well as cutting beads.

Re: skew proficiency test

#21

Re: skew video link- as soon as youtube passes it

John Lucas

Keith Cutting straight across the grain like that I think it's more important to try and get the angle of the skew cutting edge as steep as you can by raising the handle. Some woods don't cut as well with the edge almost 90 degrees to the direction of travel but most respond well if the cutting edge is between 45 and 90. By 90 degrees I mean 12 oclock to 6 oclock angle. In the video I am cutting at about 10 to 4 or maybe steeper.

I can't really arc the tool in although I have done a sort of reverse arc where I actually start the cut from the bottom and arc the handle down which brings the point up. I do this because the tool cuts very slow when the edge is straight up and down, and much faster as the edge gets to the 3 to 9 oclock position. So arcing the tool from the bottom up means that the tool will cut faster where the wood is moving slowest, in the middle. This helps keep me from forcing the cut which leads to a rougher finish.

Re: skew proficiency test

#22

Re: skew video link- as soon as youtube passes it

charlie belden

Great videography and the the narrator made his script sound spontaneous and sincere. The guy handling the skew wasn't too shabby either. The punky wood choice added a High Wire Act tension to the performance. The only thing lacking was a split screen showing the side and top view simultaneously as the cuts were made because it's the entry part of the cut where things can go to hell in a hand basket - quicker than the blink of an eye..

What I particularly appreciated was that you showed THREE different ways of making that cut with a skew.

Most excellent demo video of a skew application that's difficult to understand with just still pictures and accompanying text.

Re: skew proficiency test

#23

Re: skew video link- as soon as youtube passes it

Jim H

That was very informative, thank you. Now we need a video showing How to use my new Tompkins skew :)

Re: skew proficiency test

#24

Re: skew video link- as soon as youtube passes it

John Lucas

Charlie I wish I was knowledgeable enough about video to do something like split screen. I do plan on learning to at least add still photos and drawings. Our medium is very difficult to teach by video and extremely difficult typewritten.

Re: skew proficiency test

#25

Keith Tompkins

Re: skew video link- as soon as youtube passes it

Keith Tompkins

Hi Jim, I'm working on it! If you need help, call or e-mail...Keith