Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

skew proficiency test

Posts

Re: skew proficiency test

#26

Re: skew video link- as soon as youtube passes it

Jim H

Thanks, looking forward to playing with it but would love to see it in action by someone who knows what they are doing. It will be awhile before I can get back into the shop to play as even with todays cold snap it was still 104 degrees >(

Re: skew proficiency test

#27

Brad Vietje

Re: Paying Your Dues

Brad Vietje

Hmmm,

I was going to make a photography analogy, as well. I used to teach 35 mm photography at the community college/adult learner level -- a range of topics from the technical to the creative & artistic -- probably John has, too. There are always students who can create some really interesting effects, but they are all-too-often just happy accidents. They can't explain how they did that, and can't figure out how to do it again, or start experimenting with a theme to create a whole set of images. Since they never really learned what the buttons and knobs do, nor how to predict the outcome of doing X, Y, or Z, they are just playing around. A similar thing has already been discussed with tuners, or beginners who want to take on a more advanced project without sufficient experience with the basics.

In turning, if someone thinks buying all the expensive toys will make them a great "artiste" in turned wooden forms, they could get lucky and find a wealthy patron who will buy their stuff, but it will be difficult for them to really get good at what they're doing. Getting back to Keith's skew exercise, if we develop proficiency with the basic cuts, scrapes and techniques, we are better able to take on a challenging turning job, or design something new and different.

I'm sure every creative endeavor has a similar issue of "learning curve jumpers", who want to push he limits a little before they're ready. That can be a great source of innovation and new ideas (occasionally), and often frustration. The same thing happens in a college English or creative writing class when some nubile budding writer wanna-be starts writing without punctuation, capitalization, and attempting diagramatic poems, claiming to be the next e e cummings (yeah, sure you are). I'd say master the rules before tossing them aside.

Experimentation and curve-breaking have their place (I'm sure many of us here were pushing the limits and getting ahead of our development a bit), but taking off in a creative direction without mastering the basic foundations of the sport, sure does make it harder to be successful in your pursuits. The "turner" who scrapes a spindle into submission, then sands the life out of something to get to a similar shape would have a hell of a time producing 12 of them, and finishing them in a reasonable time frame.

I'm no fan of black belt or name tag color identification of master, student, intermediate, etc... but I do support the idea of a basic skills mastery program, and while some subtle way of recognizing the master turners might be a good thing to pursue, I would want to be sure we didn't stigmatize the newbies and scare them away. In the astronomy & star-gazing world (no "L" in astronomy!), there are certificate levels for achievement of various observing programs, which are listed on a AAW-like membership web site. That might work well for the AAW, with mastery programs in architectural turning, production turning, bowls, hollow forms, sculptural turning, Ornamental turning, etc..., and besides achievement of certain skill levels, another certification for instructors and/or demonstrators, since there are people who are really good at doing something, and not at all skilled at teaching it.

There's my 3 cents on the matter -- and worth every penny you paid for it!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: skew proficiency test

#28

Re: John's practice video

Carol Reed, Strawberry, AZ

Wow! Asked and I received. John that was great! You are an extraordinary instructor. I think your proficiency 'exam' with the thinning of the disk from both sides trumps Keith's bead exercise though. :) His bead exercise is not without merit and it is what was taught me. Might have to try the thin disk exam. ;)

Re: skew proficiency test

#29

Keith Tompkins

Re: ouch!

Keith Tompkins

Re: skew proficiency test

#30

Ellis Walentine

Good one, John

Ellis Walentine

That was very instructive. Thanks for the WoodCentral plug, too!

Ellis

Re: skew proficiency test

#31

Re: Paying Your Dues

charlie belden

Keith:

I agree with the importance of knowledge being passed down from generation to generation - IF, and ONLY IF - it doesn't impede the creation and dissemination of NEW knowledge (see Copernicus, Galileo, The Inquisition). Carbide is and will make many of the Rules of the use of cutting tools less important or Not Applicable - "riding the bevel" for example - sharpening as another example.

I'm not sure how Germany's apprenticeship system and German scientists discoveries are related. Apprentices have teachers of existing knowledge, scientists have mentors who assist in the expansion of knowledge. The former preserves what's gone before, the latter's intent is to create concepts that don't exist yet.

As for putting the responsibility for choosing the best teacher on the student, especially a new turner, that seems unreasonable. How do you pick the person with the best answer when you don't even know what question to ask? Hell, in turning, there's seldom just ONE answer to most turning questions. Take the Battys for example. One says scraping will work just fine for just about everything, the other espouses shear cutting for almost everything.

To naming woodworkers who break the mold and develop their own unique and successful style, you've set three vague criteria - woodworker, unique and successful style.

So here's my quick list for furniture

C.R.Mackintosh

Greene & Greene (and the Halls who actually MADE ,most the pieces they designed, though one of the brothers did MAKE some furniture)

Charles Eames (and his exploitation of steamed & therefore formable plywood)

Wharton Eshrick (and the german furniture maker who made the Ehserick Corner Desk)

James Krenov

George Nakashima

Sam Maloof

Ed Espenet Carpenter

Gary Knox Bennett

David Marks

That's TWO handsful. There are more, who are familiar to collectors, but not well known by the general public.

For turning it's a lot easier

Ellsworth

Hunter

Pho

Drozda

Priddle

Scoby

Jordan

Fisher

Hall, Alby (though he has developed so MANY "styles")

Lindquists (father and son)

Maltrhoups (sp?) - all three generations

Wolfe

Winton

and add

Barbara Dill as MultiAxes becomes more popular thanks to her

Re: skew proficiency test

#32

Keith Tompkins

Re: Paying Your Dues

Keith Tompkins

Hey Charlie, Where to start...

For new turners, it's not all that difficult. Join a club, find the best turner there, and learn all you can. From there, as you develop certain interests, the AAW has the POP program. Just ask on any online site who's recommended.

You may have overlooked two of my favorites: Wendell Castle and Hans Wegner. Bennett is most known for pounding a nail in a simply adequate piece of cabinetry, not for any ground-breaking design concepts. (Just my opinion)

I don't think history has sorted out the top turners yet, but don't forget John Jordan, Giles Gilson, Stony Lamar, Ron Fleming, too many others to even think about.

Do I think carbide will replace traditional turning skills? No. I can see most tools made of specialized steels and carbides, but the traditional gouge/skew will endure.

Re: skew proficiency test

#33

Re: Paying Your Dues

charlie belden

Brad:

The photography analogy is an appropriate one.

At one time you had only a rather large box camera, that required a tripod to hold it and a black piece of cloth you had to be under in order to see the upside down image cast on a ground glass plate at the back of the camera's box. When you saw what you wanted on the film, you loaded a "plate" into the camera, pulled a sliding plate out from in front of the film, removed the lens cover and started counting, guessing or ball park calculating the expsosure time. There weren't and "f stops", no shutters, no light meters, and if you needed more light you had to use Flash Powder. Because of the limited ASA, you needed fairly long exposures and your control of the depth of field was very limited. The limitations of photographic technology severyl limited what could be photographed well.

Even the revered SpeedGraflex had many of those limitations, as did the film of its time. Could you take excellent photographs of relatively still things and people with it? Certainly. But you couldn't take candid shots, or decent shots of anything that was moving quickly or work in very low light situations "on the fly"? But the negative size allowed for touching up flaws in the image - with pencils - and a good eye and steady hands.

Along came the Rollies (sp?) and the bulk of the camera was reduced significantly and that allowed shots to be taken that couldn't be taken before - without a LOT of control of the subject and its environment. But you still needed a separate light meter in certain situations.

When the Single Lense Reflex cameras came along things changed again - enabling more types of photos to be taken. The advancement in film technology was also key to these new capabilities. With the SLR, "in the camera composition" improved becuase the SLR was WYSIWYG (what you see is what you get) since what you were seeing was what the film would see when you triggered the shutter. With the earler Rollei (sp?) you weren't actually seeing exactly what the film would see - but rather a vantage point slightly above the lense.

As SLR techonology improved, several methods were developed to aid in focusing, so you didn't have to guess - or measure - the distance from lense to subject. And when "preview" was added to the SLR, you could push a button to open the apeture full open so you could see the "depth of field" of your lense. Before that you had to measure and use a look up table for your lense, or memorize the table. But you still had to take or guess at a light reading, the former requiring a separate light meter device.

Eventually technology came to the rescue again - building light meters right into SLRs. Not long after, "spot metering" was added to the SLRs' capabilities. In bright back lit situations, you didn't have to get a light meter reading by placing it very close to your subject. And, as before, film technology kept up with the advancements being made with the camera. Higher ASA/DIN films, with finer and finer grain, exteneded the capabilities of photography.

For photgraphing things that changes quickly - motor drives got added to the camera's capabilities, making Getting THE Shot much more likely than before.

Then there was the post camera requirements of film photography. There were ways of developing color film to compensate for using Outdoor Film with Indoor Lighting and visa versa. And to make prints from the developed negatives you had to be in a Dark Room, and work under red or "safe" lights, work with an enlarger and photo sensitive paper which required special chemicals to develop the print. And even when you had the developed print, you had to rinse all of the developer and "stop" off the paper - then dry the paper - flat - since paper once wet tends to curl as it dries.

If you wanted to make copies of a print you had to go through the whole "print, develop, rinse, dry and flatten process.

My father was a portrait photographer on the side, an accounty in his other life. I spent a lot of time on both sides of the lense, and even more time in the darkroom with him. That turned me off to still photography, until just before my son was born. Thankfully, camera and film technogology had come a long ways by the time I bought my Olympus OM1.

By the time my son was old enough to get into photography, still cameras and film had gotten even better and easier to use, and with affordable fish eye lenses, macro lenses and telephoto lenses, he could take the shots he wanted to take - without a lot of futzing and figuring. But he still had to rely on, and pay for, someone else to develop the film and print his images. NOW he has a Nikon Digital and several lenses for it. He can see a much large version of what the lense is seeing, in color - before he snaps the shutter - and then see, albeit in a small digital display, what the detectors in the camera actually got. If he has his laptop or iPad with him he can see a much larger version - in color. And when he selects the image files he likes, he doesn't have to have a darkroom to begin playing with the image data to get the look he wants. Instead he can open PhotoShop and tweek the image data until he gets exactly what he was after -and still keep the original image data intact.

Now some would feel that he SHOULD have spent months, years or decades learning the fundamentals of film photography and develop a thorough understanding of optics and film chemistry. But the fact of the matter is that he'd probably have lost interest in photography long before completing that apprenticeship program. And a lot of really nice images would never have been taken, and the memories that accompany them would likely have been lost.

Are there turners here, who, if they were photographers, aspire to be as good or better than Ansel Adams? Sure. Are there some who would be quite happy with Brownie box camera snap shot equivalents in their turning? Sure. Are there turners who if they were into photography would insist on owning and using a Hasselblad and still take photos a Brownie could have done? Sure.

The turning community is, thankfully, a Large Tent community, with room for all. If you want to scrape and sand - terrific. If you want to master the use of a particular turning tool - that's terrific. If you aspire to be a Master Turner, what ever THAT means, good on you guy.

Me, I just want to get ideas out of my head and into wood. If I find ways to do that more easily or quickly - NOW - I'm going to do that - if I can afford it - in time, patience and/or money. And the fact that the doing is part of the fun of turning is a bonus.

Will I ever be a recognized and highly respected turner? No. If I can make what I want to make, perhaps help some other turner with getting an idea out of his or her head into a turned piece of wood, or make things a little easier for another turner - that's good enough for me.

YOUR mileage may vary.

Re: skew proficiency test

#34

Re: Paying Your Dues

bill Crommett

Charlie: Your epistle on the history of photography is a classic that should not be lost in cyberspace. Can you tell me how to get it off the forum and onto a printed page ?

Bill

Re: skew proficiency test

#35

Re: Paying Your Dues

charlie belden

Uh - cut and paste into a text document?

To illustrate the photography to turning analogy, here's a shot I caught with a $150 digital camera - ten years ago - while walking from the Rue Monge metro station back to Hotel Tim where I was staying There are five modes of transportation in the shot - pedestrian, horseback, metro, motor bikes and cars. In almost the center of the image, note that it's only a bit past 9:30 in the morning, the rest of the day still to come.

Saber and Suzuki coexisting.


Turning is a Big Tent thing - with room for all sorts of ways to get from Here to There.