A couple of years ago, I bought one of those Wood River diamond grinding wheels from Woodcraft. My reason for buying a diamond wheel was to be able to sharpen those powder-metal tools properly. That diamond wheel did polish the edge of those hard tools, but it loaded up, heated the tools up, and there was no way to dress it, that I knew about. Couldn't very well use a diamond dresser. The Woodcraft/WoodRiver folks said that it "didn't need dressing".
I've finally found the solution to loving this diamond wheel: lubrication! As I was told, in industrial applications, diamond and CBN wheels are run with continuous lubrication so they will cut faster and last longer.
Check out the youtube video of my ultra-low-tech method of lubricating my diamond wheel!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bnvUraY7B78
Basically, I mounted a brush on the top of the wheel and drip chainsaw oil behind the brush to lube the wheel while grinding. The brush spreads out the oil and scrubs out the metal particles.
What a difference in performance, both of the diamond wheel and my powdermetal turning tools!
I used a wet sponge touching the underside of the wheel when doing lapidary with good sucess. This method is cheap, less messy, and efficiently cleans and cools. When the sponge dries out or starts to load up with swarf, just dip it in a bucket of water and rinse it out.
It works well -- but, just be careful using water around the grinders we all use. They are not meant to be used in damp locations. It could be a "shocking" experience. Water is usually the lubricant of choice for diamond grinding -- but, this is normally done on grinders specially built for the procedure -- and very expensive.
Cindy mentioned she bought the diamond stone to sharpen these. I have never had a single problem sharpening them on anything in my shop, from common sandpaper belts to white wheels and even the older gray wheels. The size of the grit has a remarkable difference but so far not the material I've been sharpening with.
I don't have any D way tools and read that they are harder but I don't know what kind of metal he uses.
Dave Schweitzer of D-Way uses M42 steel. It has a pretty good Rockwell hardness and sharpens up nicely.
I got one of the Norton Industrial grade SG wheels and it sharpens EVERYTHING very nicely. Yes, they cost about $105, but they are worth it because I can just touch the edge when resharpening and they are instantly sharp again. I don't wear much stone that way.
A good friend and I sharpened some tools on the Norton wheel that were hard to sharpen on a white wheel he had. He tested them immediately and was amazed at the difference in performance.
I recently got a 15V tool and I have sharpened it on the Norton and it was easy to sharpen. I am about to test drive the tool on a cherry bowl later this morning. If it is as sharp as I think it is, I am going to have a problem with a stupid grin on my face.
Ed I have one V15 tool. You don't notice the sharpening right away. It just stays sharp for a very long time. that's when the grin starts.
I purchased a Norton wheel when Woodcraft had a sale. I figured when my white wheel wears out I would replace it. My sharpening has reached the point that I remove so little steel and consequently so little of my stone that these last wheels may last forever. I may have to pass my Norton on in my will.
Are you suggesting that you can't sharpen 15V on a standard grinder wheel to the same edge sharpness? Or that it just takes more off the wheel to do it?
I am not doubting you, but I can't see a scientific reason why it would be true. I have an opinion that the newer harder steels do not get as sharp as some of my other tools, and I am wondering if it's the wheel on my Tormek?
It is my opinion that it would be virtually impossible to sharpen a 15V bowl gouge on a Tormek. Or, it might take a very long time.
The Norton SG wheel maintains its sharpness as it grinds and does not fill up with metal as quickly as other wheels. So, it seems to grind quicker than other wheels do.
I want a tool to take a good edge, no matter who makes it. It makes sense to me to have a wheel that will sharpen that tool to its best edge.
I sharpened a 15V tool and used it for the first time this morning. Don Riggs came over and we both used this tool. We shaped a natural-edged red oak bowl and were both extremely impressed.
Steve You can sharpen the V15 or V11 as sharp as any other tool. I have played with these tools vs my older Carbon steel tools and newer HSS tools. If I take the time I can get any of the tools sharp enough to make hair jump off your arm.
After I answer one question I always forget the other one.
If you are grinding a 15V tool on a standard wheel I think that certain problems occur. I think that standard wheels will fill up with metal quickly and not cut like an SG wheel will do. By not filling up with metal the SG wheel stays sharp and continues to cut. Or, the metal is too hard for the wheel and it destroys any sharpness that the wheel has.
Steve, these are opinions, but I believe them to have some validity.
Sharpening stones are way down below the bottom of the list of things I understand, but I have a couple observations on both my Norton SG wheel and the Woodcraft diamond wheel (I think it's the Wood River brand).
1. I've had the SG for 2-3 years and there are many things I like about it, such as mentioned here already. But I did notice a couple days ago that my 8" wheel is now a 7" wheel. I'm grinding HSS and occasionally a carbon steel. Earlier in the life of this wheel I was probably more heavy handed than someone more experienced would have been.
2. About 1-2 years ago I bought the diamond wheel. A few weeks ago after reading a discussion on diamond wheels I examined mine closely and found that it is worn unevenly. It has a very slight groove right down the center where I had been doing most of the grinding of gouge tips. I have not been aware of any need to clean the diamond wheel. Could be ignorance on my part.
If I could have only one of these two wheels it would be the Norton SG. I love the honed edge that the diamond wheel leaves, especially on spindle gouges, etc. But I think if I had it to do over I would just use the SG and my home-made power honing strop for the final polish where desired.
Here is another confession and part of the story that may be useful to someone.
The reason I measured my Norton SG is I had a dumb-a$$ed accident with it. I had a momentary distraction while I was sharpening a 3/8" Thompson bowl gouge in the Wolverine jig. "Apparently" I let the gouge tip wander too far off to the right and it caught in the narrow space between the wheel and the wheel cover/guard on the right end. A couple chunks of the wheel smacked my face shield like a rock from a lawnmower.
Luckily I was wearing both my Uvex shield and my safety glasses. The shield was hardly scratched.
As soon as I changed my skivvies I took the shields off both ends and threw them into the scrap-iron pile. After thinking about it I can't see that they are worth two cents and without them this would have only been an "Awe-Oh" moment. I've re-dressed the wheel to where I can continue to use it by avoiding about 1/8" on one side. Lost about another 1/8" so the wheel is actually 6 7/8" now.
BTW that jam up stopped the grinder so fast the diamond wheel on the left spindle spun the nut loose and it almost came off.
I believe too many warnings are harmful, but I am glad I've paid attention to the many times I've read warnings on the forum about grinders. Stuff can happen and one had better have the old face protected.
My sharpest tools are my Oneway bowl gouge and my Sorby skew. I am not sure why, but they take a better edge than my Thompsons. The Thompson edge lasts substantially longer than the Oneways and Sorbys.
Now that you've brought the topic to discussion, I am wondering if I am getting an inferior edge on the Thompsons because of the Tormek? I'm going to have to experiment to see if I can figure this out. It's been a crazy couple of days, so I could use some shop time!
Did I understand you to say you removed the metal shroud that surrounds the grinding wheel (or would surround the grinding wheel had you not removed it)? If so, I'd recommend you get all the bits and pieces back out of the dust bin and reinstall the shroud. Friable grinding wheels (like the gray wheels that come with most grinders, the white A/O wheels, and the ceramic Norton wheels) can develop unseen cracks that will allow the wheel to suddenly fly apart. The wheels basically explode. The shrouds are designed to contain such an event.
The new diamond and CBN wheels that are solid metal with a relatively thin diamond or CBN matrix applied to the edge of the wheel don't have this problem and can be safely run without the shroud.
I did try to true my favorite skew, 1 1/4", From Doug Thompson and after a couple hours it was just starting to have a full width cut, I figure at that rate it would take a couple days, sp I finishe going back to hand work on a diamond file.
Steve as I mentioned to Ed I sharpen on a white wheel. I have not sharpened my bowl gouges or skews on my Shepac wet wheel grinder so i can't say how that will work. I don't have any problem getting my thompsons as sharp as my other tools using my white wheel. Granted I don't have a D way or Glasser to test against but I do have Henry Taylor, sorby and a few no names.
I have talked to a few people in the grinding industry who feel that the Tormec style water wheel is just about at its limit of capability with the Powdered Metal steels. I have no proof -- and I think their comments were based on personal observation and not scientific testing. But, this might be the answer to your problem. The Tormec is not really working at its best.
Aluminum Oxide stones (white, blue, red, grey or whatever) will sharpen the Powdered Metal or M42 steel tools just fine.
Ed You could be right although I have used a norton stone when teaching at other shops and I don't see the difference in cut. I believe there is a difference in wear of the stone, especially grooving, but then grooving has only been a very slight problem with my white stone. I'm not sure I would even call it a problem. When I clean the stone with my T diamond it usually gets rid of any groove. If not I use the Gieger wheel trueing jig. Still I've only used about an inch in the 5 years since I put the stone on the grinder.
I'm certainly not dissing the Norton wheels, or diamond or CBN. I just don't think I need them today. When this wheel wears out I have the norton I bought I bought.
I agree with Bill as I had no problem refreshing the edge of my Thompson 15 V with the white stone that came with the Woodcraft slow speed grinder. Worked fine.