Re: I think I agree with you?
Cindy Drozda
Stephen,
I do think the size of particle in the wheel has more to do with the perception of "sharpness". I have used (extensively in my own shop) 120 grit A/O, 80 A/O, 60 A/O, 120 ceramic, 50 ceramic, 120 diamond, and 180 diamond. Also several 60 - 120 grit "white" and "pink" wheels, even a good quality Norton "white" wheel; none of them compare with these latest generations of wheels that I'm going to talk about. I'm ignoring, for simplicity, my experiences with those older-tech wheels (white, pink).
Also for simplicity's sake, I'm mostly talking about sharpening gouges, of M2, M4, ASP 2060, A11/CPM10V.
Between the 120 A/O and 120 ceramic, I would say I didn't notice any difference in sharpness perception. The wheels act and perform differently, though. The A/O in question is a OneWay wheel. It cuts well, but wears out fast and "grooves" fast. The Ceramic is a Norton 3X, which also cuts well, and lasts longer. Both load up and need frequent dressing for best performance (just my opinion, of course).
Between 120 and 60 A/O, and 120 and 50 ceramic, my perception is that the edge felt "sharper" when sharpened with the fine wheels. Scrapers sharpened with the coarser wheel are more aggressive, but not as fine-cutting.
To compare the 180 diamond and 120 diamond, I can't really do a perfectly accurate comparison. My impression of the 180 diamond (not lubricated, worn out, 6" wheel) was that it was too slow and difficult to be worth using. I tended to prefer the 120 A/O wheel to it.
The 120 diamond wheel (8" brand new, lubricated) is slower to grind than the 120 A/O. It also gives a significantly brighter mirror-polish. Makes me wonder if the grit size is using the same scale for both...... The 120 diamond acts much "finer" in grit than the same 120 grit of A/O.
I did/do notice a difference in sharpness perception between the 120 A/O and 120 Diamond. But really only with the Thompson tools. They are the 10V tools that I use most at the moment. I do have one other A11/10V tool (an older pre-HiTech Glaser gouge) that I should use and sharpen for awhile and see what I think. The edge on the Thompson seems noticably sharper when sharpened with the diamond wheel than with the A/O of the "same" grit. Is this a composition rather than particle size difference? Maybe not, since the diamond wheel visually is grinding a smoother surface, even though it claims to be the same grit.
With the 2060, M4, M2 tools, I can't say that the diamond wheel really gets them obviously noticeably sharper-feeling. I can say that the diamond wheel doesn't "groove" or need dressing. It is always square across the face (actually the edge, where we put the tool to grind). For this reason, I prefer it for some of my precisely shaped scrapers. Being less aggressive and finer-cutting, it is easier to make a nice smooth shape to the tip of the gouge, which I believe makes for nicer shaped cuts. For that reason, I prefer the diamond wheel for gouges. Also because of being less aggressive, it removes less metal from the tool each time. Having the tools last longer is good. It sometimes feels a bit slower, though. When I have a need to remove more metal than a light renewing of the edge (for instance, changing the shape or bevel angle), I prefer the A/O 120 wheel. Ditto for relieving the heel (shortening the cutting bevel after sharpening it).
I'd have to say that, except for maybe the Thompson tools, particle size makes a lot more difference than wheel composition.
And I'd also say that there is more to wheel performance than the perception of sharpness (i.e. grooving, loading up, square face, fast cutting, less metal removed, etc)
Which edge(s) last longer? Hard to say. The 10V and 2060 edges last noticeably longer than M2 and M4. I don't see enough difference between good quality M2 and 2030, M4, or M42 to pay any extra for those last 3.
So that's my (further) $0.02.... more opinions.......
Can't wait to try those CBN wheels!
Cindy