Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Diamond Grinding Wheel Lubrication

Posts

Re: Diamond Grinding Wheel Lubrication

#26

Tormek and Powdered Metal Tools

David Walser

Up thread several posters have suggested that a Tormek cannot sharpen tools made with the newer powdered metal tools. I don't have any tools from Glaser Hitec or from D-Way, so I cannot comment on how well a Tormek sharpens tools made with the steel used in those tools. I do have a Thompson spindle gouge and I can report that my Tormek sharpens it very well. I haven't noticed ANY increase in the time it takes to sharpen the Thompson gouge compared to my HSS gouges of similar size. Not only that, the Tormek gets the Thompson just as sharp as it does my HSS tools. The ONLY difference is that the Thompson stays sharp longer.

As I said, I don't have any Glaser Hitec or D-Way tools, so I cannot report on how well the Tormek sharpens tools made with the steels used in those tools. (If anyone would like to send me a tool or two, I'd be happy to post my test results. :) )

Re: Diamond Grinding Wheel Lubrication

#27

Katherine Kowalski

PM Tool Composition

Katherine Kowalski

All,

Powdered metal tools are not optimally sharpened on aluminum oxide wheels because of the molecular structure of the steel. Because of the formation of carbides in the steel (usually tungsten or vanadium), aluminum oxide doesn't cut these carbides, it simply ends up chipping them out. Consequently you are left with a very ragged edge. (After years of experience using these tools, and also sometimes having to sharpen them at other's grinders, the difference is appreciable).

Norton 3x and SG wheels are a ceramic composite, and designed to cut through these hard carbides. (And, incidentally, designed to run at high speed). Please note that all "blue" wheels are not the same. Norton's 3x and SG, while costly, will get the job done. Of course, diamond and CBN will also sharpen powdered metal tools. Any of these gives a very fine edge to a PM tool.

Cindy's setup is an excellent one -- very clean and efficient.

On my grinder, I have a diamond wheel (Wood River brand) for sharpening, and a Norton 3x, 46 grit for grinding. (I also have a Norton 3x 120 grit that I loved to use before I found the diamond, which gives a mirror-like shine!)

Katherine

Re: Diamond Grinding Wheel Lubrication

#28

D-Way Tools

Greg Haugen

I just got a D-Way 1/2" bowl gouge with one of his nice handles and have been trying it out today on a piece of dried figured maple. It keeps an excellent edge and sharpened very easily. My sharpening setup is nothing special, most of you would laugh. It's the Woodcraft grinder (which I love-very quiet and smooth) and the white wheels that it came with (120 and 60). The gouge sharpened as easily as anything else does and keeps an excellent edge.

With all of this said, yes, I have white 120 and 60 wheels. I keep them true and clean and don't have any issues. I'll use these until I wear them out and then I'll probably get Norton 3X wheels or possibly diamonds. I just don't see a point in switching or buying new wheels when these work just fine.

Re: Diamond Grinding Wheel Lubrication

#29

Re: Tormek and Powdered Metal Tools

Cindy Drozda

David,

The Thompson tools are made from CPM10V, essentially the same alloy as the Glaser tools. Glaser calls it A11, which is the official designation. CPM10V is Crucible Steel's brand name for the same basic steel. So if Tormek will sharpen Thompson tools well, it should work well on the other powder-metal tools.

Theoretically, the Tormek shouldn't be good for sharpening Thompson tools or other powder-metal alloys. I believe it is an aluminum oxide wheel. Your experience says that it obviously works, so I believe you. Personal experience carries more weight than theory! I, also, used to sharpen my powder-metal tools on an aluminum oxide (120 grit) wheel, and I thought that they got just as sharp as any M2 tool.

My guess about why Tormek works is its super-fine grit. For the same reason, I was happy with the al-ox 120 grit wheel before I tried Norton 3X.

For a real scientific comparison, you need to get a diamond wheel (CBN, too, while you're at it) and compare the edge from it with the edge from the Tormek. Keeping the bevel angle the same, of course, and cutting the same kind of wood with the same tool.....

Personally, I like my Thompson tools a LOT more now that I'm using the diamond wheel (vs the 120 3X). The 10V/A11 seems to respond to the fine diamond polish better than it did to the 30% ceramic 120 grit grinding. The finish from the diamond wheel is much shinier, too. So it's prettier, that must mean something.

Cindy

Re: Diamond Grinding Wheel Lubrication

#30

Re: Cause and effect

Cindy Drozda

Steven,

Another thing to look at with the Thompson tools and how sharp they get is what kind of finish the inside of the flute has. A polished surface on the inside of the flute should result in a finer edge.

Like I said in another post, I like my Thompson tools a lot more now that I'm sharpening with a fine grit diamond.

Cindy

Re: Diamond Grinding Wheel Lubrication

#31

Re: Second answer

Cindy Drozda

Even if something appears to work just fine, it doesn't mean that something else might not just work better. And just because something "works" better, doesn't mean we will notice that difference in the context of cutting wood! Scientific theory is one thing, practical experience another.

Lots of turners seem to be happy with the edge they get on powder-metal tools grinding with aluminum oxide wheels. The edge appears to be sharp, and it does seem to last longer.

What I'd like to know is: Has anyone out there sharpened powder-metal tools with aluminum oxide, tried sharpening with ceramic, diamond, or CBN, and then preferred to use a "white" al/ox wheel given the choice?

My personal experience grinding tools includes a huge variety of different grinding wheels and set ups, and all of the tool alloys on the market within the past 10 or so years.

The most significant advantage that I have experienced is with a fine grit, balanced wheel. Composition of the wheel doesn't seem to give as much of an edge-creating advantage as fine grit does.

Just my opinion, and you know what they say about opinions......

Cindy

Re: Diamond Grinding Wheel Lubrication

#32

I agree, and...

Doug Trembath

I have used the Norton SG wheel I picked up when I first saw you, Cindy, at the 2000 Utah symposium. Mike Mahoney had shown me that you can dress the wheel anywhere from 60 grit to around 200 with the right approach with a good diamond dresser. I keep it very clean, and have it dressed as fine as I can get it. In doing this, I get a very sharp edge on all of the tools I have, from carbon steel to Jerry Glaser's tools, Dave's tools, and others. My opinion is that Cindy's point of using a higher grit does in fact make it easier to get a truly sharp edge, with almost no sparking, on any steel.

I have a Crown Pro PM gouge and skew, that are difficult to sharpen on anything else. That steel is HARD! The gouge is much easier to sharpen than the skew, believe me. I now use my hand tool diamond sharpening regimen to sharpen it. Both take and hold a very strong, sharp edge.

My white wheels are sitting in a drawer somewhere in the shop, probably will end up as trade bait. After using what I have, I wouldn't go back.

Like the lady says, though, you all know what they say about opinions, especially on a forum.

Doug Trembath

Re: Diamond Grinding Wheel Lubrication

#33

Steven Antonucci

I think I agree with you?

steven antonucci

I am wondering if the perception of "can't sharpen" these new steels isn't caused by hardness, but instead, by the particle size of the abrasive in the wheel?

Are people finding out that you get a better edge from a 600 grit diamond wheel than a 60 grit A-O wheel? Or is there some issue with a like to like comparison? (100 grit A-O vs. 100 grit diamond?)

Now I have to find someone with one of these wheel to test it out on my 10V and 15V tooling... if it turns out to be the case, I'll post the results.

S

Re: Diamond Grinding Wheel Lubrication

#34

Re: I agree, and...

Bill Neddow

I also agree. A finer grit gives a much better edge. In the "old days" there was a danger that a "scary edge" would just crumble off the end of a gouge as it was too fine to take the beating woodturners give it. But, with the new powdered metal tools, and with the M42 steel the D-Way uses, the steel is tough enough to take a bit of a battering and still hold a very sharp edge.

As for quality of cut -- which would you rather shave with? A regular razor blade or one sharpened with an 80-grit wheel?

Re: Diamond Grinding Wheel Lubrication

#35

Steven Antonucci

I spend a lot of time polishing flutes

steven antonucci

but only about the first 1/2" or so... since it will last me 2 years!

S

Re: Diamond Grinding Wheel Lubrication

#36

Re: Second answer

john lucas

Cindy I agree. The grit of the wheel seems to make the most difference. Early on I only used course grits because my sharpening skills were mixed and using fine grit wheels made it hard to get a really good edge.

I remember taking a class with Frank Sudol. he used a 1" best sander with a worn out 400 grit belt. He said it sharpened like 600 grit. (don't know if I agree with that). I could not get my tools sharp on that thing. I think it was because I rounded over the edge. I have used a strip sander at home to play with and I don't have any trouble sharpening with a 220 grit belt on that. Probably a learned skill thing.

My skills have improved a great deal and with the help of the Oneway sharpening system I believe I could use an extremely fine grit wheel and still sharpen with minimal fuss.

Re: Diamond Grinding Wheel Lubrication

#37

Re: Tormek and Powdered Metal Tools

john lucas

I have a Sheppac wet wheel grinder. It's a copy of the Tormek, or maybe vice/versa, I don't know which one came first. The tormek is definitely a better machine. Anyway, I have sharpened my Thompson skew on it with out any problems. I wanted to see if it would work. I dont' do that very often because I don't have water in my shop and it's too much hassle.

Re: Diamond Grinding Wheel Lubrication

#38

Re: I think I agree with you?

Cindy Drozda

Stephen,

I do think the size of particle in the wheel has more to do with the perception of "sharpness". I have used (extensively in my own shop) 120 grit A/O, 80 A/O, 60 A/O, 120 ceramic, 50 ceramic, 120 diamond, and 180 diamond. Also several 60 - 120 grit "white" and "pink" wheels, even a good quality Norton "white" wheel; none of them compare with these latest generations of wheels that I'm going to talk about. I'm ignoring, for simplicity, my experiences with those older-tech wheels (white, pink).

Also for simplicity's sake, I'm mostly talking about sharpening gouges, of M2, M4, ASP 2060, A11/CPM10V.

Between the 120 A/O and 120 ceramic, I would say I didn't notice any difference in sharpness perception. The wheels act and perform differently, though. The A/O in question is a OneWay wheel. It cuts well, but wears out fast and "grooves" fast. The Ceramic is a Norton 3X, which also cuts well, and lasts longer. Both load up and need frequent dressing for best performance (just my opinion, of course).

Between 120 and 60 A/O, and 120 and 50 ceramic, my perception is that the edge felt "sharper" when sharpened with the fine wheels. Scrapers sharpened with the coarser wheel are more aggressive, but not as fine-cutting.

To compare the 180 diamond and 120 diamond, I can't really do a perfectly accurate comparison. My impression of the 180 diamond (not lubricated, worn out, 6" wheel) was that it was too slow and difficult to be worth using. I tended to prefer the 120 A/O wheel to it.

The 120 diamond wheel (8" brand new, lubricated) is slower to grind than the 120 A/O. It also gives a significantly brighter mirror-polish. Makes me wonder if the grit size is using the same scale for both...... The 120 diamond acts much "finer" in grit than the same 120 grit of A/O.

I did/do notice a difference in sharpness perception between the 120 A/O and 120 Diamond. But really only with the Thompson tools. They are the 10V tools that I use most at the moment. I do have one other A11/10V tool (an older pre-HiTech Glaser gouge) that I should use and sharpen for awhile and see what I think. The edge on the Thompson seems noticably sharper when sharpened with the diamond wheel than with the A/O of the "same" grit. Is this a composition rather than particle size difference? Maybe not, since the diamond wheel visually is grinding a smoother surface, even though it claims to be the same grit.

With the 2060, M4, M2 tools, I can't say that the diamond wheel really gets them obviously noticeably sharper-feeling. I can say that the diamond wheel doesn't "groove" or need dressing. It is always square across the face (actually the edge, where we put the tool to grind). For this reason, I prefer it for some of my precisely shaped scrapers. Being less aggressive and finer-cutting, it is easier to make a nice smooth shape to the tip of the gouge, which I believe makes for nicer shaped cuts. For that reason, I prefer the diamond wheel for gouges. Also because of being less aggressive, it removes less metal from the tool each time. Having the tools last longer is good. It sometimes feels a bit slower, though. When I have a need to remove more metal than a light renewing of the edge (for instance, changing the shape or bevel angle), I prefer the A/O 120 wheel. Ditto for relieving the heel (shortening the cutting bevel after sharpening it).

I'd have to say that, except for maybe the Thompson tools, particle size makes a lot more difference than wheel composition.

And I'd also say that there is more to wheel performance than the perception of sharpness (i.e. grooving, loading up, square face, fast cutting, less metal removed, etc)

Which edge(s) last longer? Hard to say. The 10V and 2060 edges last noticeably longer than M2 and M4. I don't see enough difference between good quality M2 and 2030, M4, or M42 to pay any extra for those last 3.

So that's my (further) $0.02.... more opinions.......

Can't wait to try those CBN wheels!

Cindy

Re: Diamond Grinding Wheel Lubrication

#39

Re: Tormek and Powdered Metal Tools

brian.mcinturff

I sharpen my Glaser tools on the Tormek and have not noticed any problems. Matter of fact I only sharpen my 15v on the Tormek. For touchups during turning I was using my Woodcraft grinder with stock wheels and noticed the Thompsons and Glasers didn't seem quite as sharp as when I sharpen with the Tormek. So, any more I tend to use the Tormek for touchups. I haven't tried the CBN wheels yet, Guess I need to add those to my list.

Re: Diamond Grinding Wheel Lubrication

#40

Re: Tormek and Powdered Metal Tools

bill Crommett

I would like to pose a summary: How long can one cut with a "dull" tool ?

Re: Diamond Grinding Wheel Lubrication

#41

Re: Tormek and Powdered Metal Tools

JerryW

IMHO, you can cut as long as you like with a dull tool - until the surface you are producing causes you concerns (tearing). My experience is that if you hone at nearly the first sign of surface degradation, then you need only a very light touch-up. If you continue until you are really dull, you will need the grinder. I prefer to stay off the grinder as long as possible. Tool manufacturers love grinders, my shop budget does not! :)

Re: Diamond Grinding Wheel Lubrication

#42

Re: Tormek and Powdered Metal Tools

Bill Neddow

I think part of the confusion on this lies with the fact there are different wheels for the Tormek. I believe the wheel supplied now is an aluminum oxide mix. This should work just fine on the powdered metal tools. However, there are (or were) some softer "water wheels" out there more like the composition of the Japanese water stones. These might be too soft.

Re: Diamond Grinding Wheel Lubrication

#43

Re: Tormek and Powdered Metal Tools

David Walser

Bill,

You are correct in that there are several wheels available for use on a Tormek. The wheel that comes with the Tormek is a very light gray and is a 220 grit alumina oxide wheel. A few years ago, Tormek introduced two additional wheels, a "blackstone silicon" wheel and a 4000 grit Japanese waterstone. In addition to these wheels from Tormek, there are wheels available from third parties. Most of these are super-fine grit Japanese waterstones.

The blackstone silicon wheel was specifically developed for sharpening tools made from today's harder steels. Tormek claims the original wheel will sharpen tools made with the new steels, but the blackstone wheel will do it quicker and with less wear of the wheel. The wheel can be used to refresh, but not shape, the edge on carbide tools.

Both 220 grit wheels are designed to let the user change their effective grit level to 1000 by "grading" the stone with Tormek's stone grader. Using both grit levels produces a highly polished bevel and a very sharp edge.

Re: Diamond Grinding Wheel Lubrication

#44

Ken Vaughan

Tormek Wheel Explanation - Thanks Dave

Ken Vaughan

Appreciate the explanation -- Makes good sense.