Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

The Taming of the Skew

Posts

The Taming of the Skew

#1

The Taming of the Skew

Dave Paine

As a newbie, I have already had more "surprises" in using the skew than I want.

I have purchased the books and DVD's. One day all seems well, the next day "surprise".

Yesterday I was working on my first tool handle and got a "surprise". I did some internet searching and found a variety of opinions on the included angle of the bevel.

My skew happens to be a Henry Taylor which was ground to a 45 degree angle (25 deg on each side).

My searches showed a wide difference of opinion. some claimed the tool thickness should be 1.5 x the bevel depth, which equates to about 39 deg overall included angle.

I decided to try an adjustment and ground my skew to 40 deg overall, 20 deg on each side.

Either I am suffering from a mental link to my adjustment, or the sharper angle is much easier to control.

What say you of your own experience? Almost afraid to ask. Expecting a variety of opinions. Hope to avoid a "bar fight".

Re: The Taming of the Skew

#2

Re: The Taming of the Skew

Harry in Beautiful Downtown Kulpsville

Allen Batty recommends an included angle of 40 degrees, sharper wirh soft woods and steeper for harder woods. I use around 40 degrees. Most important is to "rub the bevel." If you are cutting unplanned spirals in your work, you are not rubbing the bevel!

Also keep both the long and short points away from the wood. Getting one of these too close will give you a dig-in.

The most important is practice. Every time something bad happens, stop and try to figure out what happened.

Good luck, the skew is a super tool once you become comfortable with it.

Re: The Taming of the Skew

#3

Re: The Taming of the Skew

Michael Mocho

A few things that may help in your explorations with the skew:

For shearing cuts, raise the tool rest to a point about halfway between centerline (lathe axis height) and the top of the cylinder you are cutting.

With the lathe off, hold the cutting edge at a 45 degree angle to the axis of the lathe (when viewed from above), and press the bevel onto the cylinder so that it contacts the rough cylinder of wood and only one side of the tool shank (the shorter edge) is in contact with the tool rest.

Using an overhand grip with your non-dominant hand, and with the other hand gripping the handle (thumb extended and on top of the handle pointing towards the ferrule) slide the tool along the tool rest parallel to the axis of the cylinder and adjust the angle and pressure until you can get the sharp edge to cut a shaving on the wood.

Try and distribute the pressure evenly between the tool rest and the surface of the spinning wood, moving from your knees rather than from your torso. ONLY shift your weight from one foot to the other, try not to rotate at the waist.

Once you have found that tool position where a thin shaving is cutting, try it again with the lathe on.

Once you find the �sweet spot� where it is cutting, use your legs to drive it along the tool rest, not your arms. Think of your self as a �human tool jig�, don�t muscle the cut.

Do this for about 10,000 hours and it will come quite naturally. :)

I sharpen my skews to about 35 degrees, and at about 65 degrees with a slight arc across the edge.

Good luck!

-M

Re: The Taming of the Skew

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: The Taming of the Skew

Keith Tompkins

HI Dave, I believe the sharper angle works better because the edge is more acute, therefore sharper, and you have longer bevels to ride on.

Re: The Taming of the Skew

#5

Jesper, Denmark

Re: A not very qualified opinion - and a question.

Jesper, Denmark

I am no expert with a skew, as mostly I turn bowls. However, the included angle is not nearly as important as is your skill level and amount of practise. You have good advice above.

The question relates to the grind: You would normally hollow gring on the grinder, and then hone - producing a small secondary bevel. With bowl and spindle gouges, easing the sharp point at the rear end of the bevel makes rubbing the bevel easier and makes less of a mark on the wood from the bevel.

Would this be appropriate with the skew as well??

Re: The Taming of the Skew

#6

Re: The Taming of the Skew

john lucas

I have skews ground from 25 degrees included angle to 60 degrees. I think about 35 to 40 is the easiest for beginners to use and the angle I use the most.

It's all about rubbing the bevel, not the length of the bevel or the angle. the shorter bevel lets me cut steeper coves. (yes you can cut a cove with a skew) The longer bevel usually means a sharper included angle. This is good for rolling beads because you don't have to move the handle as far to get a square sided bead. However I find this angle very grabby because a subtle move of the handle can pull you off the bevel if your not careful.

Re: The Taming of the Skew

#7

Re: A not very qualified opinion - and a question.

Doc Green

If you sharpen a skew on a grinder, which will produce a hollow grind, it's important to hone the bevel(s) so that a narrow flat surface surrounds the concave part, which shows up as a bright area in the picture below.

If the bevel is left concave (hollow-ground), the skew will be harder to control and will leave a rougher surface.

Also, as suggested above, raise the tool rest. And if you cut using the lower half or one third of the cutting edge, the bevel contacting the work will be longer in that region and will make it easier to control.

My $0.02. ~Doc


Re: The Taming of the Skew

#8

Re: The Taming of the Skew, below center

ronnyeelen

And always cut with the lower half of the edge. That sweet spot needs to be somewhere below center, not above.

Now, isn't that what Keith Tompkins' V Skew does automatically? since there is no top half on the edge..... maybe that is one of the reasons why it performs so well, as they say.

Re: The Taming of the Skew

#9

Steve Kubien

Nobody will ever...

Steve Kubien

...mistake me for a skew chisel expert but I will pass on an observation I have, well, observed... Get the thickest, heaviest, widest skew you can.

I have two skews within reach of my lathe...a 3/4" Thompson and a P&N which I think is 1-1/4". I far prefer the P&N for most work. I think the greater thickness and mass help with vibration and control. The Thompson comes to a finer point of the cutting edge relative to the long access of the tool. Maybe the shallower angle on the P&N helps. I don't know. Where I tend to use the Thompson most is for detail work like small beads and v-cuts. The P&N does all the planing cuts, peeling cuts and any bead over about 1/2".

YMMV

Re: The Taming of the Skew

#10

Re: The Taming of the Skew

Dave Gelnett

I like to have a flat bevel instead of a concave. It makes it easier to find the bevel to rub with less catches. In fact Eli puts a convex bevel on his skews. He said he did this for his son when he was learning.

Re: The Taming of the Skew

#11

Leo Cuellar

Another important point

Leo Cuellar

Dave, is to not pull the skew backwards while the cutting edge is in contact with the wood. A guaranteed spiral thrill ride. :D That used to trip me up quite a bit.

Re: The Taming of the Skew

#12

Re: The Taming of the Skew

John Lucas

I don't understand your reasoning on the concave vs flat. When you have a concave bevel you have 2 points that contact the wood. The cutting edge and the heel of the bevel. What's in the middle doesn't matter (ask the Japanese hand plane makers). If you have a flat bevel the cutting edge and the heel of the bevel still control the cut, the flat area inbetween doesn't do anything. I have tried both and can't tell a bit of difference other than the flat one takes longer to sharpen if you use diamond hones to refresh the edge.

With a convex bevel you just keep rocking the tool forward until you find the cutting edge. Personally I find this harder to use for beads but about the same for flat planing cuts.

Re: The Taming of the Skew

#13

Re: The Taming of the Skew

Dave Gelnett

John I don't think I can explain it but have tried it and it does seem easier. I have watched Eli go backward and forward with his skew. I have never tried to go backward.

Maybe it is more likely to hit the bevel when approaching the wood when the skew is convex and less likely to touch the edge. You got me.

Try it, you may like it.

Re: The Taming of the Skew

#14

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: The Taming of the Skew

Dennis in Southern Oregon

John, I think that you are correct when making slicing cuts and very steep shearing cuts and turning coves, but probably not when making planing cuts, low-angle shearing cuts and turning beads. My reasoning is that if the hollow grind is made using the common 8 inch grinding wheel and the work has a much smaller diameter, the skew can touch the work only at one point. Even if the axis of the circular tool grind were turned 45 degrees to the spindle, a 5 inch diameter spindle would touch the skew face at only one point.

Dennis

Re: The Taming of the Skew

#15

Keith Tompkins

Re: The Taming of the Skew, below center

Keith Tompkins

Actually, I can cut anywhere along the cutting edge...it doesn't matter..I can cut with the heel, or the toe, or anywhere in between. To demo, I start with the heel, begin to roll a bead, then end the cut at the base of the bead with the point.

Re: The Taming of the Skew

#16

Re: The Taming of the Skew

John Lucas

Dennis You are correct on the small diameter work, at least partly. You still have a very short bevel right behind the tip. In this case that is doing the same thing as the longer bevel on larger work. I have turned very small things with larger skews and thought about exactly what you mentioned. My conclusion when turning this way is that the skew still works the same. come off the bevel, even as short as it is and you either get kick back, or in my case it just breaks the wood because the spindle is too small.

Re: The Taming of the Skew

#17

Re: The Taming of the Skew

Fred Holder

Hello Dave,

You've gotten a lot of good advice before I got around to reading the post. I've been using the skew for many years, but like everyone I had a lot of trouble at first. I purchased a piece from someone in California, I can no longer remember the name, that has a slot to hold the skew. You slip the skew into it and tighten the set screw. The round piece needs to be on the tool rest when the tool is cutting. I used this for a couple of years and then discovered that i didn't need it anymore. It is a fine training tool, sorry I can't remember the name of the product or the company selling it. We're talking close to 20 years ago.

A few have touched on keeping the cut below center of the cutting edge and I highly agree with this. The tool is more stable when cutting in this position. Also, I find that the tool performs best when the shaft is perpendicular to the wood being cut. The skewed edge gives you the angled cutting edge you need.

On final thought, when making beads: 1) make sure the tool shaft is perpendicular to the wood, 2) start the cut just to the left or right of center of the planned bead, 3) do not move the skew yourself, but rotate the handle in the direction of the cut. The tool will run down the side of the bead and into to V-groove. Repeat on the other side. With practice, on smaller beads, you can make the bead in two cuts.

Finally, always have the tool rest so that the tool is cutting above center of the wood. Have the tool handle so that the tool is perpendicular to the wood, rub the bevel, and cut below center line of the cutting edge.

Use the points for making V-Cuts not not for normal cutting.

Fred Holder

Re: The Taming of the Skew

#18

I have one of those stashed away ......

JamieDonaldson

...somewhere Fred, probably way back in the old toolbox with the old skews!

Re: The Taming of the Skew

#19

Keith Tompkins

Re: The Taming of the Skew

Keith Tompkins

Anybody use a skew to turn beads this way?

Long point down, riding the bevel. Tool level, swing an arc with your body. I'm cutting at the centerline of the turning. Cuts cleanly, I find very little tendency to catch.

Yes, I know it's not the "correct" way. :D

Re: The Taming of the Skew

#20

Re: The Taming of the Skew

john lucas

Keith I will often finish up a straight sided bead with the toe down. I have turned whole beads but I guess I just have more experience with the heel down so it's more comfortable. I usually turn the whole bead heel down but sometimes when I haven't been turning on a regular basis I will turn the straight edges with the toe down because it's safer for me. I can't turn the top of the bead as easily with the toe down.

Re: The Taming of the Skew

#21

Re: The Taming of the Skew

Michael Mocho

Sure Keith, I use the point-down cut all the time. I think it works best when the handle is raised continuously while the bead is being cut, and it cuts particularly clean towards the ends of the cut at the smaller diameter. I agree with John Lucas that the heel down seems to cut slightly better at the larger diameter of the bead- I often suggest that students try heel down to start the bead, and then point down if they are nervous about catching in the smaller diameter section of the bead.

It is essential to keep bevel contact all the way through the cut- with slight pressure perpendicular to the surface of the bead at the point of edge engagement.

Re: The Taming of the Skew

#22

Re: A not very qualified opinion - and a question.

john lucas

Doc I respectfully disagree about your assertion that a hollow grind bevel will leave a courser surface. As I've stated before I have tried both hollow grind and flat grind as well as convex. I cannot see a difference in the quality of cut. With a good piece of wood and slow cut I can actually get a cut so smooth that I sometimes have to sand it to dull it down to match the cuts done with a spindle gouge on coves. I'm working on my cove cutting techniques to get them that burnished. On an oily wood like some pines I can get a surface that looks like it came from the Beal system and that's with a hollow grind chisel. All woods won't produce a surface that clean and some actually tearout more with the skew than with a smaller spindle gouge. I'm guessing the smaller circular tip has something to do with that. Anyway back to the skew. It's the area right behind the cutting tip that matters.

The Japanese hand planes have a flat area at the tip,the tail and right where the blade comes out. The rest is concave. They do this to reduce the friction of pushing the plane and also to make it faster to flatten the wooden plane which has to be done periodically. It does not affect the quality of the cut. A concave grind skew is the same thing.

Re: The Taming of the Skew

#23

Re: The Taming of the Skew

john lucas

Keith toe down is how I cut the bottoms of my goblets. You can get a really concave area this way. I often include a bead with a concave bottom in my lamps because this is a cut that is difficult to cut with a machine or duplicator and separates my lamps from production lamps.

My best friend uses an old V tool, with the top flat and 2 bevels on the bottom. He cuts his goblet and candlestick bottoms by putting the flat side against the wood which acts as the bevel and then cuts the concave portion. It would be like using your tool with the flat side as the bevel.

Re: The Taming of the Skew

#24

Re: The Taming of the Skew, below center

ronnyeelen

Ok, but are you then talking about using the V skew?

Because if you are, you will always be below center of the tool... which is what I meant.

If you can also do that with a normal skew, good on you. I can't.

Re: The Taming of the Skew

#25

Re: The Taming of the Skew

Terry Scott

Keith is right on the button

Remember to rub that bevel as well and the Skew will become your friend

The best negative rake scraper I own as well

Some would say( no doubt) that you shouldn't listen to me as I put a skew into places were no man has gone l.o.l