Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

Posts

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#26

Mike prefers a front-end loader ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

when he eats ice cream. It helps reduce his tool envy.

Ed

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#27

Re: New thread?

Mike from St. Clair Shores

There was a lot of talk about why use mini tools and some of the turners were questioning that they didn't understand the need for them. I remembered seeing a link at Totally Turning about Nano tools. When I visited the site I saw they were small tools. I was not trying to hijack your thread just showing a link to another small set of tools that I thought would show that yes indeed small tools do have a place in turning. Maybe it's the heat but it sure seems like there have been some passive aggressive responses on this board lately.

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#28

Mike Stafford

I use a grain scoop.....

Mike Stafford

less spillage that way! :b

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#29

Mike Stafford

Re: New thread?

Mike Stafford

I'm sorry Ed, I am the one who hijacked the thread. I completely lost sight of the fact that we were talking about a specific set of tools and I wandered off into shorter, smaller tools in general.

I guess we should have had a discussion about smaller tools and folks such as myself could have talked about their small tools.

(I can't get over how much hair you have. You were bald as an onion when we last saw each other.)

Stay cool, Elvis! :b

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#30

Steve Kubien

I think you are right...

Steve Kubien

...about the passive aggressive tone at times. Personally, I am upset about it becoming a booster site for Glaser-Hitec. Maybe I will just go and turn a bowl using my non-Glasers. Actually, I'm not even sure if that's possible?

(now THAT'S passive aggressive. :) )

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#31

No problem

Ed Moore in SW VA

I'm not into "blame" at the moment.

I think a new thread talking about small or mini tools would be a good idea.

As to hair, if I don't get it cut soon I'll look like Einstein. (Albert, not Frank!)

I am hoping that a miniGlaser round-nosed scraper arrives by tomorrow. I am really into doing an all-miniGlaser demo tomorrow evening.

Ed

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#32

Actually, it should be a booster ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

site for all woodturning tools. New items usually get a short boost and we move on. It is getting so that making nice comments about any tool brings out snarky comments from those who like other tools. I find that to be unnecessary and unpleasant.

Ed

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#33

Re: I don't get it

Philip Duffy

I am with you on this one Steve! I am still wondering why I spent the money on one of those carbide cutter fancy tools when it works not a speck better than my scraper made out of a planer blade. Phil

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#34

Steven Antonucci

Actually, I didn't ignore the hypothesis

steven antonucci

I turn with all kinds of tools. There is nothing I can't do with the tools I already own and use, so the hypothesis that I would have to have one is completely flawed. I wouldn't, even if it was the best tool in the world, simply because the turner is what matters, not the tool.

As far as using a short handle, which was my original question, I see a lot of beginners struggle simply because they turn with their arms. If the handle is short, and it becomes more and more difficult to lock your arms and your body together.

But you have answered my original question. Having a small set of tools, regardless of names on them, the steel they are made of, or the weight is only a personal choice you've made.

S

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#35

As a former math prof, ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

I assure you that you confused the hypothesis with the conclusion. The hypothesis was that you use the 3/8" MiniGlaser spindle gouge for a day of turning. If you did that then the conclusion was that, you would want to have that tool.

You stated "But you have answered my original question. Having a small set of tools, regardless of names on them, the steel they are made of, or the weight is only a personal choice you've made. "

What gave you the right to trivialize my decision-making process and misrepresent it? This violates all the known rules of polite discourse.

Ed

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#36

Re: As a former art prof, ...

Phil Powell

What are you fellows smokin'? Ed you and Paulo must be from the future. I

looked up the tools on the Hitech web site and those tools are SEVEN HUNDRED

DOLLARS for the set and aren't available one at a time! I payed less then

that for my first divorce and that was all about freedom. So I could purchase 7 or 8 sets of Nano Tools, throw most of them away and still be ahead. I have several Glaser tools and never payed anywhere that much for any of them. ( i love them!)

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#37

Phil, I don't remember ever ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

commenting on price. I have said that I like the tools and that is based on them being of good steel and holding an edge very well, despite what a personal attacker said.

I have far too much hair to work for Paulo Marin. I have chatted with him some as a result of compliments I paid Jerry Glaser several years ago. It would be presumptive of me to discuss his pricing policies and I don't go there. He runs a successful aerospace business and doesn't need me to mess him up with bad pricing advice. You can take what I know about running a business, put it in a thimble, and still have room for your finger.

Have you noticed how the competitive juices are flowing now in the woodturning tool business? This is great for the woodturner. I predict that new and better tools will emerge and at prices we can justify.

Ed

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#38

Re: Phil, I don't remember ever ...

Brian McInturff

I always chuckle when I hear someone complain about pricing. I guess we all should just buy our tools from Harbor Freight, including our lathes. 700 sounds high, until you break it down. You get 9 tools, a handle, and the casing roll. I just watched a video on the tool and the handle is truly unique. Forget about any set screws or Allen wrenches. You can change from 1 tool to the next in about 2 seconds. And the fit is better than any military tool or NASA tooling I've seen. I was skeptical because of all the bad publicity that has been out there on the Glaser Hitec line but I've done a little research, talked to a few people including Paulo, and am truly convinced that this is a win win for woodturners. And, what if the handle was made so you could add on to it. Then you are looking at one of the most versatile tools on the market. As for the tooling not being available separately, how do you know? Have you asked Paulo? It's just a hunch but I bet if you were to ask him...

I'm anxious to get mine and put it to the test. I'll post pics and if I can get my son to help, maybe even a video.

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#39

Steven Antonucci

I'll restate my original question:

steven antonucci

Being a math professor, you should be able to understand a proof. You take the hypothesis and test it. If your hypothesis is correct you should be able to prove it.

So to date, here is what I've seen:

Big tools are too heavy to turn with or transport. That's crap.

Mini tools can do things that you can't do with big tools. Also crap.

Somehow, if I had access to a Glaser spindle gouge, I would want one. Crap again.

I have every tool I need. I probably have twice as many as I need, and I like make 50x as many things as you do. Not just finials, which I turn with a skew because I can.

So you have yet to prove in any way that a mini tool makes any sense to add to an arsenal. If you WANT to spend your money buying things that you don't need, I am not going to stand in your way. Perhaps you should buy them in pairs so you have a back-up?

But for me, I think PT Barnum said it best...

S

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#40

Re: Phil, I don't remember ever ...

Phil Powell

Ed, you're right competition is a good thing. I was just taken back when I

saw just how much I would have to spend to get a set of mini Glasers. I'm

thinking there must be some Scots blood in me somewhere.

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#41

Mis-stating and confusing ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

what I have said does not make any of your points valid.

Why do you find it necessary to attack people personally? This is why people are complaining about the tone of WoodCentral.

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#42

Re: I'll restate my original question:

Brian McInturff

Wow! Just Wow! Comments like telling someone they are spending money on things they don't need. None of us really "NEED" anything. It's a matter of want and being able to buy it without remorse. You seem like a bitter man with those comments. Are you ok?

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#43

Steven Antonucci

I am fine.  Thanks for asking.

steven antonucci

Not bitter at all. With the proliferation of "choice" available today, it's about educating the new turners coming into the market about NEED vs. WANT.

I had a conversation at a club meeting last night with a new turner. He's older and living on a budget, and he plainly told me that he needs to get some new tools. I assumed that he had done some things that were difficult and had a reason, so I asked him why he thought that way.

He explained that he had been hollowing bowls with spindle gouge, and that he planned on making more bowls so he wanted to buy a 3/4" bowl gouge and a 1/2" bowl gouge.

Screeching halt.

I asked him what he turned on. A Sears monotube lathe.

I had one years ago, and I guess that you could stop it with your hand if you tried. I asked him what the rest of his wish list looked like, and crossed a bunch of other things off for him.

The problem with the turning MARKETING right now is that all companies are vying for the same dollars. You can go to any catalog and see tools that have NO value, or are so horrifically overpriced for what they are that some people feel like they cannot afford to turn because they will have to buy the crappy Packard tools (which is how our conversation actually started- are these any good?)

It's a free market, and anyone that want to buy any brand at any price can and will do that. Buying a Glaser or a Doug Thompson doesn't make me a better turner. Practice does.

When new club members are asking me if they have to spend $100 per tools, something has to be said.

S

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#44

Re: Mike prefers a front-end loader ...

Dale Miner

Man o' man, I got a belly laugh out of that one.

Front end loader, that is a good one. Might have to give it a try next time we make homemade.