Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

Posts

MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#1

MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

Ed Moore in SW VA

Let's start with the picture.


Starting at the bottom:

1. 1/4" detail gouge, 5 1/4" handle, 9 1/2" overall, older Glaser tool

2, 3, 4. 3/4" SRG, 3/8" spindle gouge, 7/16" skew, all with 7" handle and 12 3/4" overall From the 2006 miniGlaser set

5. 3/4" skew, 12" handle, 19 1/4" overall

6. 1/2" English bedan, 10 1/4" tool, 24" overall (new)

Every tool shown is excellent. They take and hold a very sharp edge. This post is in response to Brian's question in an earlier thread.

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#2

Steven Antonucci

Can you explain the "mini-tool" thing to me?

steven antonucci

I don't get the idea of mini tools? I use regular, full sized tools to make things of all sizes. I have a 1/4" Sorby skew with a short handle, but that's it. Everything else is full size and I turn all kinds of fodder.

What's the attraction to a short tool?

S

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#3

Probably not, but I'll try.

Ed Moore in SW VA

Hi Steve,

The pro turners who do lots of traveling and demos need to keep weight down when they fly. I think that the new QR set weighs in at close to four pounds. That is a lot less than comparable full-size tools like I also pictured.

I like to make ornaments and will demo them here on Thursday. The 14" tools, 7" and 7", are just right for making them. Larger tools may work, but they would not be as easy to use.

If you were to use the miniGlaser 3/8" spindle gouge for a day making ornaments, I promise you that you would want one and that you would use it.

There may be other reasons for mini-tools, but if so, I have forgotten them.

Ed

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#4

Mike Stafford

Re: Can you explain the "mini-tool" thing to me?

Mike Stafford

I don't have any mini tools as described by Ed.

However what I have done to reduce my traveling tool weight is to use a couple of handles with adaptors for all of my tools. The overwhelming majority of the tools in my traveling tool kit have tool shafts that will fit in either 3/8" or 1/2" adaptors. I have handles with just such adaptors. About the only tools that I don't have unhandled are my parting tools and skews and when I can I plan on buying some unhandled versions of those tools.

Since I am primarily working on small items, e.g. boxes, ornaments, orts bowls etc. I don't need full sized handles to provide a lot of leverage. I seldom have a tool project more than 3 inches over the tool rest. With the shorter 8-9" handles I work with tool in front of me rather than to the side. I also work with both hands and switching hands is much easier and faster with the short handled tools. The adaptors allow me to vary the projection of my tools out of the handles. When I need more leverage I just allow more of the tool to stick out.

Frank Penta introduced me to this concept of working with shorter handled tools and it has been a boon to me as I believe my tool control has improved since switching.

As they say in the disclaimers, your results may vary....

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#5

Steven Antonucci

Reducing weight?

steven antonucci

Odd point to make, since I have to guess that lead shot filled aluminum handles weigh more than simple wooden one? Even if they aren't filled, I still think aluminum weighs more than wood.

When you turn, do you use the handles tight against your body or do you mostly turn with your arms? My knock isn't against the small steel... it's the short handles I can't wrap my head around. I make my long so thay always are against my side, but I also tend to drop the handle very low because I use a much sharper nose angle on most of my tools.

They're too pretty to use like a hammer on a spur center...

S

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#6

Steven Antonucci

How many tools do you travel with?

steven antonucci

Sort of a loaded question, since everyone is focused on travel weight. I've never flown with tools before, so I am not an expert, but I tend to travel very, very light (just enough t-shirts and underwear to make it home).

If I was packing tools, I would probably carry no more than 5 or 6, all in their own handles. I like the idea of shortening up the amount of steel in a handle (I have been known to just leave the T in Thompson sticking out because Doug makes his flutes too long :b). However, switching a tool out during a demo would be heresy.

How many handles do you carry?

S

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#7

Technique or crutch?

Ed Moore in SW VA

Steve,

Have you ever seen Stuart Batty make a finishing cut on the interior of a bowl? While there are times when the tool handle should be against the body, there are times when it should not. No matter what your opinion is of Stuart, he knows how to make a cut, and even his detractors will agree with that. His right hand is on the end of the handle, the tool is horizontal, and the arm is extended to allow the bevel of the tool to enter the wood near the rim at the correct angle. He swings the tool through the necessary arc and ends at the bottom of the bowl with virtually no tool marks discernible.

When I am making the icicle for this ornament, I can't make the cuts with the tool against my body. I need a tool that is sharp and will allow me to make the cuts.


A boxmaker rarely has the tool near his body. When Mike makes the final cut on the body of his signature boxes he needs control that long tools cannot give him and they can't be next to his body.

I guess my point is that spindle turners must have excellent tool control and the tool probably won't be next to their body.

Ed

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#8

Mike Stafford

Re: How many tools do you travel with?

Mike Stafford

A roughing gouge, two Thompson gouges, two Hunter tools, two parting tools, a square scraper, a skew and a partridge in a pear tree. That is how many fit in Lee Valley Tool roll. I usually carry three handles.

Oh, I guess the last one I leave at home....

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#9

Richard Allen

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

Richard Allen

Packard sold a line of 3/8" Glaser tools which look a like the bottom tool in the picture. 3/8" spindle gouge, 3/8" bowl gouge, 3/8" round nose scraper. There was also a 1/4" round skew.

These tools get into places easily where longer tools would be impossible to use.

The handles are solid, there is no lead shot.

When working in tight spaces or working details that need a wide range of motion to stay on the bevel this little tools are real gems.

I wouldn't consider these tools to make a bowl larger than 3" across but for small details where I want the bevel to stay in contact thorough a 90 degree change in direction...

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#10

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

steve worcester

I think it is mostly about a small tool can make smaller details. I have a Glaser small detail as shown at the bootom of the pic. It is an Ellsworth design that would be sharpened with a rolling sweeping bevel into a tiny point used for the last parting off of a spigot on the bottom of a piece. But small tools for small work or small details.

As for what I travel with, 6 gouges (5/8" & 1/2" swept bowl and a few detail) and a few handles. Come see me in St. Paul at my demos and you can see. In that case it may be a little over the top, cause no one wants to see me sharpen when they paid money to be there.

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#11

Steve Kubien

I don't get it

Steve Kubien

I am really missing two things here... The "mini" tool thing is a mystery to me. I turn pens, stoppers, some ornaments...the usual small stuff. I don't own a single mini tool and see no reason why I would.

The other thing I don't "get" is why I would even consider a tool which is more expensive than what I use now, is made from the same steel I use now, lead-shot fillable, aluminum handles like I have now without the nasty, gritty feel of the older Glaser handles plus my handles have a more important name (to me) engraved on them (my own)? Are these things guaranteed to never make the inside of a bowl bigger than the outside or something? I am comparing apples to apples and in some cases, the savings is around 30% in favour of the tools I am using now, which I love.

So, what gives?

Respectfully,

Me

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#12

Re: I don't get it

brian.mcinturff

It's a preference thing. Personally I can't see how anyone doesn't understand. Some cuts are easier with a smaller tool. Big handles do get in the way at times. Price? when I break the price down for what I'll pay for the MiniGlaser complete set of 12 it's no more than what I would pay for individual tooling of similar matals. As for the handles, they are actually my favorite handles. I just like the feel of them. I'm not a fan of wooden handles. So it really does boil down to personal preference. And for finials they sure are handy...

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#13

Steven Antonucci

Have you taught the partridge how to turn?

steven antonucci

If you did, he probably can use the pear tree...

S

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#14

Steven Antonucci

I'd cut that with a 1" skew in a 16" handle.

steven antonucci

I have watched Jean Francois Escoulen make a trembleur with a full sized bedan. His turning skills are second to none. The trembleur was 30" long and didn't need any sanding.

It's the same question I would have for a mini-lathe. A lot of people ask me how I turn small things on my Nova. They can't get their minds around using big tools and a big lathe to make small things.

Not a convert, sorry.

S

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#15

Re: I'd cut that with a 1" skew in a 16" handle.

BillTurpin in WNC mountains

My wife turns things in the range of Christmas ornaments to pens. She has had five carpal tunnel releases over the last 25 years. She does not have the strength to hold large tools. ALL her tools are mini tools. When she turns something a little bigger (up to six inches) she still uses her mini tools. Any new tool over 14" gets its handle shortened. I would own a Bill Grumbine monster gouge if I could afford one.

Bill on my 94� mountaintop

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#16

You ignored the hypothesis!

Ed Moore in SW VA

Steve,

I wrote "If you were to use the miniGlaser 3/8" spindle gouge for a day making ornaments, I promise you that you would want one and that you would use it. "

Your conclusion is that you are not a convert. So what, you ignored the hypothesis of my statement, which makes your conclusion irrelevant. Your mind is made up and is not open to further thought on the matter.

Jean-Francois Escoulen is an exceptional turner with whom I would love to take a course. He does things that neither Steve nor Ed can do. I have turned a top with an axe - but I don't recommend it for good tops. I'll bet that J-FE can turn an excellent icicle using a spindle gouge as well because he is flexible.

Ed

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#17

Re: Technique or crutch?

john lucas

Ed I still sort of use my body. What I do is lock my arm in one position and then move my body to make the cut. Not quite as good as making the cut with the tool against my body but better than just wagging my arm out in the air.

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#18

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions *LINK*

Mike from St. Clair Shores

Anybody out there ever try the Nano Tools from Warren Cutlery?


Nano Revolution

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#19

Alan Zenreich

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

Alan Zenreich

Yes, I have, and rather like the Nano tools. In fact, the very first thing I did when my Monster articulated rig came in was to insert Nano tools shafts/cutters into the Monster because I was working on a small hollow form when the Monster was delivered.

As for conventional use of the Nano tools, I find the handles very comfortable. and I especially like the tiny beaders for adding details to some jewelry we turn.

Nice tools.

Watching Steve Sherman use them in the vendor area of Totally Turning was a treat.

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#20

Bill Blasic

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

Bill Blasic

I use the 1/4" Thompson Spindle and Detail gouges with 8" handles that my friend Bill Noce makes. I use them for making finials and icicles and they just work great for tool control. It is just so much easier than using a long handled tool for these projects. I had a 1/4 English made gouge and it had number one a longer handle and number two it got dull real fast, the Thompson stays sharp for a long time. It is all about what feels good to your mind and hand.

Bill

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#21

Mike Stafford

Warren Nano Tools

Mike Stafford

Wow, those Warren Nano tools look right up John Lucas' alley with all the small stuff he turns. But he is able to turn the small stuff with the tools he currently has. Nevertheless, really cool looking little tools.

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#22

Mike Stafford

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

Mike Stafford

I think you summed it up perfectly Bill. It is what feels good in your hand and in your mind.

It took some practice for me to get used to using the short handled tools but now I love using them. They are not for every situation. I still pull out long handled bowl gouges etc. when I am doing bowl and platter work.

If you want to use long handled tools use long handled tools. If you want to try the short handled alternative by all means do so. You might like the feel.

Like my dear departed father-in-law used to say, "That is why they make chocolate and vanilla."

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#23

New thread?

Ed Moore in SW VA

Start a new thread rather than hijack this one.

Ed

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#24

Re: Can you explain the "mini-tool" thing to me?

john lucas

Althought I use regular size tools for 90 percent of my work I do have a set of mini tools. I find them very useful for turning Christmas ornament finials. Your doing a lot of movement in a short space and I can simply do it quicker with the small tools. I can't sell my ornaments around here for very much money so I have to make them as quick as possible.

I don't invest much in them because they are used really for this one thing. I have Sorby mini roughing gouge that I reground to look like their continental gouge. That is my spindle gouge. I have a Harbour freight mini roughing gouge that I bought in a set for $5. The other 2 tools that came in the set weren't very useful but this thing holds a good edge and I love roughing the small spindles with it.

I have a 3/8" skew that I made from a 3/8" spade or paddle bit. This is close to my favorite tool. It has a 1/4" round shank so it acts like a round skew but the cutting edge is longer. Then I have a short 1/4" parting tool that I bought at the flea mkt for $2.50. I love this thing and use it for other projects.

so I have about $40 invested in my mini kit. Paid for that on the first 2 ornaments sold.

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

#25

Re: MiniGlaser tools and dimensions

Dale Miner

Regardless the flavor,

I prefer to eat my ice cream with a medium length handled table spoon. Of course, most any spoon fork or even if need be, a roughing gouge would work.