Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

You wanta be safer while turning?

Posts

You wanta be safer while turning?

#1

You wanta be safer while turning?

Doc Green

Then slow your derned lathe down!

Both the centrifugal force and the energy contained in the rotating mass increase with the Square of the RPM. What this means, for example, is that if you double the RPM, both the centrifugal force and the energy increase to four (4) times what they were before.

Centrifugal force is what causes the piece to fly apart. The energy contained in the piece may be viewed as its ability to inflict bodily harm.

As another example, but going in the opposite direction from the one above, if you reduce the RPM by roughly one third (29.3%), you will reduce both the centrifugal force and the contained energy to one half of the original values.

To give a numerical example, if you normally turn at 1,000 RPM, reduce it to 707 RPM and you will cut both the centrifugal force and the energy by one half.

The above is a simple fact of physics.

*******

May I add that I was deeply saddened by the news of the recent tragic accident. My sincere condolences go out to her family and many friends.

~Doc

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#2

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

Dick Wilson

Doc,

I couldn't agree with you more. There is a formula involving diameter, lathe RPM and a silver bullet number that is supposed to make you safer. Does it? I think there are tons of turners out there, beginners thru advanced thru professional, who shatter the speed limit every day on everything they turn. Yes, you can take wood off faster. My question is WHY? Are you in that big of a hurry? Are you trying to see how far you can shoot the wood strings behind you? I understand that on particular pieces the turner is turning air so the increased speed makes it easier to turn.....it also makes it a lot more dangerous.

I have a Jet 1442. I can crank it up to 3,000 RPM. I do not recall ever cranking it up to max speed for anything, certainly not turning. Since I first heard of Joan's tragedy I have looked at my speed setting several times while turning. My speed lever never went above 880 RPM!!! Guess what? There has been absolutely no slowing me down on turning pieces.!!! Good sharp tools cut like butter and I am turning SAFER!!!

Doc, what you say is so true regarding centrifugal force. It is a law of physics. Think about this folks. As you turn at faster and faster speeds the chunks of wood during a major blow up will be coming at you at a much faster speed.

I would hope that I am preaching to the choir, but sadly I am not. Think about it people. I, for one, do not want to see any more threads on the forums I visit discussing a fatality involving you.

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#3

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

john lucas

Well I guess I'm up there with the guys who turn too fast. I know you are right. However a bowl coming off the lathe at 500 rpm moves fast enough really hurt you. The piece that came off and dented my jonter cabinet was in the roughing stage and I'm usually turning quite slow at stage. If it had hit me in the head I would have had some serious damage.

What I've found is I can simply control the accuracy of the shape better at higher speeds. It's not so much the speed of the wood but the way you are controlling the gouge. For lack of a better description I can move my body in a smoother flow when the gouge is moving a little faster across the wood. I take lighter cuts and increase the speed. This lets me move in a more fluid movement.

Can I turn a slower speed. Yes. I do it in demos when discussing how not to force the cut. I slow the lathe way down and then show them how slowly the gouge has to move to get a really clean cut. I do discuss the safety issue and highly recommend not turning any faster than it takes to get a clean cut. When doing this slow cut it's almost impossible for me to get a form that doesn't have any undulations you can feel with your fingers and these are usually exaggerated when you sand. When turning at a higher speed I can get a shape that is perfectly rounded and in many cases can start sanding at 180 or 220 which doesn't cause dips in soft places of wood like 80 or 120 grit does.

On spindles, well mine are usually under an 2 inchs. For those I do turn at close to 3000 rpm. Again it's just a matter of getting a cleaner cut with a good flow to the lines of the piece. An I've never been hurt by a piece this small and I've broken several over the years.

I'm certainly not saying everyone should do this and in fact would prefer new turners stay in the low range. However I can easily understand why Jimmy Clewes and Stuart Batty turn at high speed.

I am going out today and dig my face shields out from under the dust and clean them up and try again. Can't make any promises, I've done that before.

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#4

Steven Antonucci

More physics

steven antonucci

The speed formula you posted is correct, but it is also a function of diameter and mass. The wider and heavier, the obvious worse the effect will be if it comes off the lathe and contacts you.

F=ma

However, the piece will only travel in the plane that it was spinning unless it contacts something in a plastic collision. What does that mean? it will have to hit something else to change direction!

So when you set up your lathe, you should probably make sure that the line of fire behind the lathe doesn't contain anything that you'd want coming towards you after a dismount. All of my tools sit behind the lathe in a holder that is mounted a good foot out out the line of fire. The things that are there are pretty securely mounted and they absorb energy (empty pegboard).

It also stresses how important it is that you stay out of the line of fire in front of the lathe. Since the work piece is rotating clockwise, half of the piece is traveling toward you at any given moment, and the other half is traveling away. Newton's first law is that an object will stay in motion unless acted upon by an external force, so half of the wood is trying to fly towards you and the other half is trying to fly away.

So if you are demonstrating, not only is it important for you to be out of the line of fire, but make sure your audience is too!

S

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#5

Absolutely agree: Slow it down

Opelika Edro

I admittedly am a relatively inexperienced turner -- I've done some between-centers turning and then got enamored with bowl-turning -- I reckon I've turned several tens of bowls, not hundreds and thousands like folks on here. In that time, spread over the last six years, I've had a blank or two break and come careening off the lathe. The worst personal damage has been minor -- fat lip, tender eyebrow.

For me, every dismounting blank or shattered bowl has come down to one of two things: either I was running the lathe too fast, or I got careless with a tool. I understand that, when you turn a few thousand blanks, you're going to come across some pieces with inherent and undetectable flaws that might cause them to come apart -- but I think it's generally going to take aggressive action in terms of speed or cut to make that demon come out.

We prize wood for its individuality, but that will occasionally be a negative (hidden flaws). There will be accidents, but we try to reduce the risk to an acceptable level. In my case, the problems were my fault; but it certainly can be the case that a turner is unlucky with respect to a certain piece of stock. Sometimes terrible things just happen.

For me, the relative rookie, I always have safety glasses on when turning and grinding (and chopping, hammering, working under a car, using a string trimmer, cutting grass, and so forth). In turning, I have tried the face shield and cannot abide it. I only have a Jet 1442VS, so that limits to some degree the danger in terms of throw and horsepower -- nothing else.

I always return to slowest speed (~600RPM?) before starting a fresh piece. I check that everything is secure. I check that the piece can spin freely. I check that it's reasonably balanced. And, when I turn the lathe on, I get out of the line of action until I'm satisfied that all is well. I only bump up the speed if it feels safe. Oh, and since I'm obstinate about the face shield, sometimes I get a shaving or two up the nose. I reckon that goes with the territory. :-)

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#6

Re: Absolutely agree: Slow it down

Jon Garcia

This is from a Powermatic manual. I was told that the "General Cutting RPM" was plenty fast...


Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#7

Re: Absolutely agree: Slow it down

Jorge Casta�eda

Agree, the one case I go to higher speeds is when making natural edge bowls where there is air - wood, air - wood situation the higher speed feels a lot safer and the cuts are smoother.

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#8

Where Is The Line Of Fire?

Stuart Johnson

Through out the safety threads the term "line of fire" is used over and over along with the advice to not stand in it. How is the new turner suppose to know where this line is located? Is it different for spindle turning than bowl turning? What about when hollowing the inside? Is it the same when a piece blows up as when it is knocked out of the chuck? Neither the Nova or Robust owner's manual cover where one should stand and instinct is often wrong. No lathe manufacturer should need to go to extremes like "don't stick your hand in a spinning blade" type warnings but a couple diagrams and a safety shield included with every new lathe wouldn't cost that much.

BTW, I am lucky and have not had a piece blow up but I have had my share dismounted from the chuck. They have all hit the ways and then started their journey around the shop. I can't answer the questions about the difference in the line of fire.

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#9

Steve Kubien

Re: Where Is The Line Of Fire?

Steve Kubien

You are right, the lathe manuals don't cover line of fire however most of the books I have read, which have a beginners/how-to slant to them, do so. It all comes down to education, reading and teaching. These are no guarantee of safety but they will get you going in the right direction.

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#10

Steve Kubien

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

Steve Kubien

I recently had coffee with a friend and fellow turner and he was adamant that the teachers of high-speed turning are doing a great disservice to the turning community. I am not sure I can dispute this idea.

Slow down folks and learn better tool control. I know I will be putting extra effort into these concepts.

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#11

Steven Antonucci

The line of fire never moves (one exception*)

steven antonucci

Unless your headstock rotates, the line of fire never moves. It is perpendicular to the ways in the same plane that the wood spins in. If your headstock rotates, that plane rotates with it, moving the LOF. The LOF is defined as where will the wood go if it was suddenly NOT connected to the lathe (i.e. through a failure.)

The LOF and the projected direction of travel can be affected by objects that cause the wood to change direction, such as hitting the toolrest or the tailstock or a wall. This is the only way that the LOF changes. It's Netwon's third law in action. All of these things absorb some of the energy, but also act as a force to change the direction.

Remember that F=ma? The force is a function of both mass and acceleration, so as the object gets heavier, it also carries more momentum (mass x velocity). So something tethered to the lathe spinning at any RPM has some momentum, which is released during a failure. The force comes from Newton's third law and the sudden deceleeration of the object when it collides with another body (Newton #3: Objects exert equal and opposite reaction)

Even at 600 RPM (painfully slow for turning), a 12" bowl blank is spinning at about 20MPH. Imagine getting a 10 pound weight dropped on you from about 15 feet. Just about the same amount of force in both collisions.

So, your answer is that the line of fire is ANYwhere perpendicualr to the axis of rotation, regardless of length of the work piece or grain orientation. It makes a ton of sense to stand behind the cut, since the shaving will be directed away from you and anything that is faulty that you cut free will be in front of you out of harms way.

Steve

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#12

Re: The line of fire never moves (one exception*)

Stuart Johnson

Steve, doesn't that mean if a blank splits along a hidden bark inclusion the piece being flung off can go in any direction except parallel to the ways? So depending on where in the rotation it lets loose it can be back away from the turner, straight into him or anywhere around the rotation. To be safe when starting the lathe you should be standing past either the headstock or the tailstock. For example on my Nova 3k the start switch and VS are by the headstock so once I start it and bring it up to speed there is no way to get to the a proper position to start cutting because a piece can come off at anytime. Another fine feature on the Robust is the movable control I can take down to the tailstock.

I'm really not serious because at some point you need to get beyond just looking at the lathe and thinking about what we could do if it wasn't so dang dangerous. Safety should be taught and safe procedures shown but the things that might not be are thoses that are so routine they are second nature and we don't think about them.

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#13

Line of Fire for Spindles ???

Doc Green

I think the "line of fire" for relatively long spindles is not as clear cut as it is for bowls and similar items that are fairly short.

Suppose you're turning a leg for a chair; the blank is 18" long, held between centers. You're making a cut near the drive center and something goes sour. You get a bad catch and jerk the blank off the lathe.

The blank will leave the drive center first. Initially, it will pivot around the tail center until it flies away from it, but this very brief pivoting action will give the blank a rotation. It then becomes something like a rotor on a helicopter, without a pilot, and will cover a lot more area than an object flying away from a bowl.

Fortunately, because of the smaller diameter of spindles, the energy contained is much smaller, even at high RPM, so the whacking power is considerably less.

Just my $0.02 ... again. ~Doc

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#14

Chuck Jones - West TN

Avoid starting too fast

Chuck Jones - West TN

In my relatively limited turning experience I have notice that more than half of my "near miss's" have occurred at start-up. Where possible I always use the variable speed knob to start and stop the lathe (except in case of an unplanned occurrence when I whack the big red button).

I realize many good lathes don't have variable speed control. I have a Jet 1642VS that does and a Jet 1014 that does not. Most of my start-up surprises have been with the 1014 when I had a brain cramp and didn't think about where the belt was positioned.

Our club has a Delta Midi 46-460 which is a great lathe except for the fact the variable speed control does not completely stop the rotation. This messes up the safety advantage.

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#15

Re: Where Is The Line Of Fire?

Dick Wilson

Steve, There are no safety instructions that come with the lathe and if you have noticed there are no safety how to turn with any tools either. I think there is a good reason why. Liability.

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#16

Steven Antonucci

The answer lies in the other collisions...

steven antonucci

If you put a piece on the lathe in between centers and cut it with a magic beam that didn't require a toolrest, the piece would only move in the plane it was travelling in- hence the line of fire is perpendicular to the ways because the axis of rotation and centripetal force acts in that plane. It will only leave that plan if something (a force) acts on it (like hitting it with a tool or a ricochet off the toolrest...)

It is easy to see in other areas of life. Take a small block tied to a string and spin it. Stick a sharp knife into the string and watch where the block goes. It will follow the path it was travelling at the precise moment it was cut. It may go straight up, or down, or right or left, but it will be in one plane.

As far as my Nova goes, I bought a switch that has a magnetic back to it. I plug the Nova into it, and it into the wall. It is attached to the tailstock end of the lathe, so I can shut the power off from either end without crossing through the line of fire. It comes in handy when you have something fail, and I can kick it with my knee if I am busy with my hands.

You are right about turning and an acceptable level of risk. I just lower my risks whenever I can by thinking about things that have happened, and then either ways to avoid reliving the experience or better ways to deal with it if I can't.

S

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#17

Re: Line of Fire for Spindles ???

john lucas

Doc I turned a lot of spindles before I got really serious about turning. The bigger ones almost always come off spinning toward you. I was a pretty bad turner early on and had a cheap lathe so things flew off. I think what happens is they either climb the tool rest, the tool or both.

I was doing demos on a club jet mini that had tailstock problems one time. The tailstock kept slipping. I threw some Dogwood limbs off the lathe too many times that day. Virtually everyone of them came over my shoulder. It was a long and frustrating day. I finally snuck off to the hardware store and bought a C clamp to put on the bed to stop the tailstock from slipping. We did have shields up for the audience and after the first time I slowed the lathe down.

In my experience it has been bowls and hollow vessels that are the danger. If we just quit turning them we wouldn't have these issues. :) I know it's not funny and it's a good thing we are discussing these things. Knowledge is a good thing.

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#18

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

robo hippy

I do not think that bowls exploding is caused by speed, or by speed alone. Main causes are bad wood and tool catches. If your piece of wood is good and sound, it will spin at high speeds with no problems. If you haven't developed good tool technique (as in how to avoid catches), then higher speeds get dangerous. If your wood has any flaws (as in punky, bark inclusions, any cracks, knots) then the danger level goes up again. These are pieces that you turn much slower than standard production pieces.

As to high rpms making the process go faster, it does, but almost as important is torque. I can stall my 3 hp Robust with an 1 1/4 inch scraper pretty easy. ("I'm on the Brute Squad". "You are the Brute Squad!" for Princess Bride fans). The main thing the higher speeds do for me is give me more cuts per inch. The lighter cuts are easier to do at high speeds, and more lighter cuts makes for a cleaner surface. I do make it a point when doing a demo to say that I am a pro, and like on the car commercials, "Professional driver on closed course, DO NOT ATTEMPT". Yes, I make it look easy, but it isn't. It takes years of experience to get to this level. You can work your way up to the higher speeds if you want to, but you do not have to.

As to finding the line of fire, turn some sloppy wet wood. Every where you have water going is the line of fire. My line of fire is a 2 ft. wide stripe on the wall and ceiling. You learn to stand out of the line of fire if you are turning some stinky or strong scented woods.

robo hippy

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#19

Steven Antonucci

Read my post above

steven antonucci

Actually the line of fire for a spindle is the exact same as it is for anything else on the lathe. The difference is how is something attached to the drive mechanism.

Spindles are typically supported on both ends. Without getting into to much mechanical engineering (most of which I forget anyway), the problem of spindles is that they flex away from the cut if you push too hard, and that force can deform them to the point where they are no longer engaged by the point in the drive center. You have the force of the tool acting on the system, but in general, the spindle really wants to spin towards you once it's not connected. Hitting the tool or toolrest will sometimes throw it up over your shoulder, or if you are taller, into your shoulder.

You can substantially reduce the amount of flex in a spindle if you hold it in a chuck. It also overcomes the issue where you accidentally disengage a point at the headstock. A rigid connection actually moves the defelction point further way from the headstock, as illustrated by anyone who has ever seen a long thin stemmed goblet being turned.

I can see a physics for turners book forthcoming...

S

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#20

Steven Antonucci

Great point on the line of fire!

steven antonucci

An easy way to understand it!

Take a bowl and turn it. Soak it in water for a few minutes and then continue turning. If you are getting wet, you are in the line of fire!

S

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#21

Brad Vietje

...And a bit MORE Physics...

Brad Vietje

In addition to F=ma, consider that the energy of a piece in motion, its kinetic energy, is proportional to 1/2 the mass times the velocity squared.

KE=1/2mv^2 Now, this usually describes elastic collisions like a bat hitting a baseball, but the take-home message is this:

The faster she moovin', the mo' she gonna hurt !. BIG time.

So maybe we can all slow down, smell the roses, and keep on turnin'.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#22

Dick Hines

Re: Great point on the line of fire!

Dick Hines

Bowls blowing up is why I like turning hollow forms so much. Standing at the end of my PM just feels safer to me.

I also turn big deep bowls from the end of the lathe.

I am not saying that I will not get hit just that it is less likely to be hit turning form the end of the bed.

"THINK" before you turn your lathe on. If the blank looks like it not quite safe more than likely is's not.

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#23

Lyle Jamieson

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

Lyle Jamieson

Thank you John for starting the "other" side of this issue. Speed will not hurt you. A piece of solid wood is not going to explode when the speed is turned up. It will only come apart when a error is made. If you do something wrong like a poor chucking method or poor tool control, even slow speed will still hurt you. If you are using Crappy wood then a slow speed will not protect you from getting hurt. I turn fast. It is actually much safer to turn fast then tunka-tunka beating the wood into round. I am sorry to be the person to burst your rationalization bubble that slowing down is safer, screw up and you will still get hurt.

The real answer is to learn all the safety issues being taught and turn safely. This is no joking matter. Those of us that have been turning for a long time have developed a process that is safe. Not because we want to sell tools but because we have done all the stupid things you can imagine already and learned from them. We were lucky to survive our errors, dont press your luck, get some help.

How many stories have we heard in the last couple weeks here on Wood Central, (Just the tip of the iceburg) about close calls or actual injuries. Find out why "stuff" happened and dont do it again!! Slowing the speed down wont stop stuff from happening.

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#24

Keith Tompkins

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

keith tompkins

A couple of other things...your bowl blank becomes a gyroscope, even at low speeds. If dismounted, it wants to remain in the same plane in which it's spinning. The blank wants to hit either the tool rest or bed of the lathe, and propel itself right at you. The higher the rpm, the more stored energy it has. Think of a yo-yo. Spin the thing slowly, then let go of the string...see how far it travels. Then, spin it as fast as you can, and let go. BIG difference.

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#25

Robo, I disagree!

Ed Moore in SW VA

Let's take a sound piece of wood and turn a normal salad bowl 5 or 6 inches high and 15 inches in diameter. For this size 1/2" thickness is quite reasonable. Let's assume further that we have not yet removed the tenon. Secure the bowl in the chuck or keep it on the faceplate if that method of mounting was used.

Now, let's start turning up the speed while we are standing well out of the line of fire. Keep increasing the speed. Assume that this lathe has no upper bound on rotational speed. Keep increasing the speed. You see where I am going with this. At some speed, possibly quite high, our bowl will explode and shatter. It is quite possible that the "shatter speed" is beyond the speed limit of most lathes. It is also quite possible that it is not. Whether you are a professional or a rank amateur has nothing to do with a bowl's shatter speed. No matter how confident a professional might be, they lack the ability to repeal the laws of physics.

Every bowl has a rotational shatter speed.

Ed