Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

You wanta be safer while turning?

Posts

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#26

Richard Allen

Re: Robo, I disagree!

Richard Allen

What are you trying to say. Should be get lathes that can turn at 20,000 rpm?

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#27

Re: Robo, I disagree!

Ed Moore in SW VA

I am saying that each piece of wood/bowl has a shatter speed. Since wood is not perfect the shatter speed may well be within the limits of our lathes. The implication was that for a bowl to shatter there must be operator error and that speed alone would not do it. Well, speed alone will do it. There may well be other factors, but sufficient speed will shatter a bowl.

Ed

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#28

Re: Robo, I disagree!

robo hippy

Ed,

Well, point well taken, and I agree kind of. I am not a physics master, but I think a bowl does have a shatter point. The bowl most likely will not shatter if it stays concentric, and with our speed ranges, this is hard to approach. I saw a thing about computer discs being spun up to speeds in the 20,000 plus range. What happened was that the discs started wobbling, like the bowl rim will if you apply a scraper near the rim. The resulting oscillations increased till the discs shattered. I would think that the same thing can happen with woodturnings, but we don't approach those speeds to cause that deforming, unless it is very large diameter, and/or very thin. The difference between end grain and side grain will generate some oscillation. Very light tool pressure can make enough differentiation to start oscillation. A lot of things factor in.

robo hippy

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#29

Robo, I agree!

Ed Moore in SW VA

Let's go back to the hypothetical bowl I described. Assuming normal orientation which presents alternating side grain and end grain, I think there is little chance that the rim will be a perfect circle when the bowl is complete. As the internal stresses are released when the interior is removed there will certainly be movement. Something close to an ellipse will result at the rim.

Jimmy Clewes warns folks not to clean up the interior of a bowl with a shear scrape. Due to the elliptical nature of things at that point a terrible catch is almost a certainty if one attempts a shear scrape. Even if the speed is not close to the bowl's shatter speed, when such a catch occurs shattering becomes a real possibility.

My point was not that speed is always the culprit, but that sufficient speed will always cause a bowl to shatter. Sufficient in this case may be extreme.

Ed

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#30

Shear scrapes

robo hippy

Shear scrapes are a term that is very confusing to me. There are many interpretations of it. If you have a scraper flat on the tool rest, that is a scraping cut. NEVER EVER USE THIS CUT ANY WHERE NEAR THE RIM ON THE INSIDE OF A BOWL, OR ON THE OUTSIDE OF THE BOWL IF THE INSIDE HAS BEEN REMOVED!!!!!!! This will start oscillations which at least will leave nice alternating dig ins, and eventual blow ups, even with the lightest touch. When you hear the screeching and howling, this oscillation is what is causing it. If you hold your gouge on its side, level, and make a light cut that way, with the flutes pointing at the wood, it is still a scraping cut. Some call a shear scrape, but there is no shear angle. If you drop the handle, then it becomes a shear cut. If you have a scraper up on its edge at a 45 or higher degree angle, with a fresh burr, and make very light pulling cuts, this is a shear cut, and is very gentle on the wood. It puts very little pressure on the wood, and there is a small chance of starting the oscillations. If you use your left hand as a steady rest on the outside of the bowl (make sure the rim edge has been rounded over or it will slice your hand very neatly, and blood on the wood doesn't look good), where tool pressure = hand pressure, you keep it in balance, and can make a smooth, steady, even cut, which almost totally eliminated any oscillation. On smaller bowls, this can be done at any time. On bigger bowls, you have to do it in stages, just like turning, because the bowl starts to adjust to having wood removed. The difference between a scraping cut and a shear cut is the angle at which the cutting edge is presented to the spinning wood, not the tool. In my opinion, the bevel has nothing to do with it. A scraping cut pulls at the fiber, and will tend to tear more. A shear cut does a much better job of lifting and slicing the fibers.

Personal rant done with for now.

robo hippy

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#31

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Centrifugal Force....

Jesper, Denmark

Centrifugal force increases with the square of the increase in speed. So a small reduction in speed is a larger reduction in the centrifugal force.

The hoop stress increases with the cube of the increase in speed, so the forces tearing a bowl apart is much more reduced than the centrifugal force by reducing the speed.

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#32

Steve Kubien

Re: Where Is The Line Of Fire?

Steve Kubien

You are correct there.

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#33

Re: Where Is The Line Of Fire?

Bob Macgregor

If your lathe is always in the same position, there is a fairly quick way to mark the "line of fire". Turn a bowl from a porous wood like red oak or beech, then put a pool of finish inside it and crank up the RPM. This will give you a nice line across the whole shop perpendicular to the ways, clearly marking the most likely trajectory of a turning that explodes. All you have to do then, is strive to keep your body (especially your head!) out of that path as much as you can.

BOB

Re: You wanta be safer while turning?

#34

Alan Zenreich

Re: Where Is The Line Of Fire?

Alan Zenreich

Bob,

Your technique will mark the initial trajectory.

However, it is then compounded/complicated by the ricochet trajectories of any shattered projectiles interacting with the environment (fixtures, other tools, glass lighting lamps, etc.)

Comedian Ron White talks of people who refuse to evacuate during hurricanes, because it's 'just wind'. He points out "It's not THAT the wind is blowing, it's WHAT the wind is blowing" that will kill you.

It's hard to know where "out of the line of fire" will be. Therefore ATGATT for me.