Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

Posts

Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

#1

Steven Antonucci

Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

steven antonucci

A couple of years ago when I bought the cast iron leg set for my Nova, I built a small ballast box for it that holds a bunch of gravel. I left it raised from the floor so that I could sweep under it. About a year ago, I had an "A-ha" moment... if the box went to the floor, I wouldn't have to sweep under it because nothing could get under it!


Now, as you can see, the lathe's legs have a slant to them, and I can build the box to hold a lot more gravel, although the added weight is not the primary goal. (It's the clean-up). I am also debating a rollaround cart for storage of lathe items (a la John Lucas) to clean up the area around the lathe visually and painting the back wall white.

As you can see, it's a good solid weekend project...but I'm not sure if it will completely mess up my turning stance? Have any of you changed the way your lathe was mounted without fundamentally changing your stance?

Thoughts, comments...etc.

S

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

#2

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

Bill Howatt

You may find you need some "toe space" at the front which means the box can't come out as far as the current box.

Before going to a lot of trouble quickly mock up your idea with some scrap and see if it interferes with your stance.

When you decide on what you want to make and you just want to block shaving places you don't have to make a heavy duty box.

Bill

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

#3

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

Dale Miner

I put a cabinet with doors and a drawer under my 3520, and it is setting on the floor. The cabinet has a front to back dimension that is just about the same width as the spread of the legs near the bottom. In order to get the cabinet under the lathe bed and have room to clear the shavings off the top of the cabinet, the toe kick was removed from the cabinet. Originally, I positioned the cabinet even with the front of the legs, and in short order, I noticed my knees were hurting after turning. With the cabinet even with the front of the legs, I was turning my feet out to get closer to the lathe, and was putting a strain on my knees. I've since moved the cabinet back about 4 or 5 inches so that a normal stance is possible, and the strain on the knees is removed.

If you do build a box that sets on or near the floor, I think a toe kick or some other feature that allows for a normal stance should be considered.

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

#4

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

John Lucas

That was my thought also, toe space. Of course toe space fills up with shavings. I think what you have is the best deal unless you feel like you need more mass. If you do I would fill in the space above the box. Granted it won't lower the center of gravity but would give you more weight.

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

#5

Maybe a nudder idea

Dustmaker Mike

make the box all the way down and make a toe kick but, under the toe kick put in a dust collection port like a heater vent of some thing to just push the shaving into. just a passing thought

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

#6

Chuck Jones - West TN

What's the problem with shavings under the lathe?

Chuck Jones - West TN

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

#7

Dick Hines

Re: What's the problem with shavings under the lat

Dick Hines

Steven, I also questioned the lack of toe space. I have my lathe sitting on 4x4 blocks for the height and some time the blocks get in the way of my big feet. Having a box all the way to the floor could cause you some problem.

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

#8

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

Dick Wilson


Steve, I can see by your lathe that you are in the same boat that I was. I don't have my lathe bolted to the floor. The Jet 1442 is a medium size lathe and not a massive weight monster like some. I was concerned about putting stress on the legs and lathe bed. I decided to build a box in place using the lathe leg brackets. The box was lined with visquine (sp). I poured play sand to fill the box ( approx. 500 lbs.) and a lid screwed on. The added weight had a dramatic impact on the stability of the lathe. Yeh, there are times when I can walk it across the floor. I just have to prep the piece a little better. The down side: if it walks across the floor I am not strong enough to pull/push it back into position - I need help. I am thinking about adding wheels to each end so I don't have to bug anyone.

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

#9

Steven Antonucci

The space above it...

steven antonucci

Honestly, the space above it is probably a bigger issue for me than the cleanout below. I have been know to put my foot up on it whilst hollowing vessels. I debated enclosing it front and back to use it for storage for things like chucks and centers and such, but I could never get past losing my footrest...

I thought about the toes and being able to be tight to the lathe, and I may just clamp a temporary sheathing over the legs to see what it feels like. If I can live with it, I bet I can add another 400#'s to the box. Heck, I might do it for the top too!

Steve

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

#10

Steven Antonucci

Yours is bigger than mine.

steven antonucci

Mine doesn't really walk that terribly unless I am pushing the speed. The trick is to not start too high on the belt until the work is balanced, and I'm not always that patient. Over the course of the year, I probably end up a foot closer to the garage door than I start. I move it back when the door won't close...

Steve

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

#11

Re: The space above it...

Stuart Johnson

I read somewhere or saw a video about weight being more important up higher. If that is so building another box on top of the one you have might give you a bigger bang for your buck.

If I remember right this was part of a demonstration by someone that mounted a pole with weights on his head stock. I swear anymore my mind is like a great big Readers Digest, a whole lot of little article that are probably meaningless but you can never find again anyway. YouTube and Google aren't helping any either :b

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

#12

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

Steve Harder

I have the Nova 1624 with the steel legs.

My ballast box is located about 6" under the lathe bed - very easy to sweep under, no problems with foot room, makes a shelf for laying down toolrests that are in use - and gets the mass up close to the bed - where there is less chance for flex of legs to negate the effect of the ballast weight.

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

#13

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

Jorge Casta�eda

Steve, my goes all the way to the floor in my Nova, very often I wish my feet could get under it as I do on the Powermatic, a lot more flexible. How about a vacuum gate down there? a blast gate to keep it closed until needed.

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

#14

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

Bart Leetch

Just a thought...

How about mounting boxes made the same shape as the leg sections to the outside of the leg sections for ballast this would clear the center section completely. Then make a cabinet on casters with drawers to roll underneath for all your turning tools. You could even make actual turning tool racks by using bar magnets for the metal part of the tool & a board with sockets bored for the end of the handle to set into for the bottom & mount them to either side, & don't worry about the chips their a fact of life when it comes to turning. Chips are what a shop vac is for.

The head of the Vega 2600 is filled with concrete. You can read about it here http://www.vegawoodworking.com/ good information.

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

#15

Steven Antonucci

I know the video...

steven antonucci

and the science stuff behind it...:)

My primary goals aren't about stability. I'm OK with what I have right now. It's the clean-up after a long winter and the storage/workspace organization that has me considering doing this.

Painting the wall white/light grey behind it would give me a better backdrop to visualize form. The tools would have to move because they are visually distracting. A rolling cabinet is an easy answer and could be pulled out anywhere while turning.

The center of mass being closer to the area of out of balance rotating mass would dampen the vibration. Ideally, the box would also be mechanically attached to the legs to provide torsional stiffness, but I am guessing that this isn't the last lathe I will ever own, so I am working on the basic premise that "good enough" will do.

Now if I drilled a hole through the top of the headstock and ran a big bolt up through it, I could add some free weights... :)

Steve

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

#16

Re: I know the video...

Bart Leetch

Well I tried to work tool storage into the deal for you Steven this would also give you a top to set thing on while your turning.

Here is the one I made for my Unisaw it also holds router bits & tools & some turning tools & bits & pieces.

I will some day make one just for turning stuff.


img

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

#17

Sandbox Alternative *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Hi Steve,

If you thinking of putting your tools in a cart anyway, but want to stabilize your lathe, you should consider John Williams "system" and his reasons at the link. I went the way of the 300 lb sand box under my old 1236, but tried this, and can tell you it really works. You'd have to do a bit of fabricating to attach to your DVR, but then you'd have the entire area underneath your lathe clear.


Lathe Leverage

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

#18

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Possibility?

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

May I suggest a weighted curtain (Lead weights sewn into the hem) of heavy material that would allow for toe space by being flexible but exclude a lot of the shavings?

Regards Peter.

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

#19

Steven Antonucci

Immediately SHOT DOWN!

steven antonucci

I had thought about using clamps to temporarily get a feel for how it might affect my stance, but then I decided to just lay a scrap of plywood against the lathe. The effects are stunning.

For starters, , when I stand at the lathe, I have the ability to actually put my feet under the existing box by almost 4". The slant is at least another 2", meaning that I am almost 6" further back from the center of the lathe. I'd have two choices- reach for it, or lean in 6" over my own center of gravity.

Neither of those ideas are even remotely palatable.

If I decide to rebuild my box, I may build it lower, still leaving room for the "toe kick". I may also try Peter's curtain idea, as I think it has merit (remembering that my goal is to avoid sweeping under the lathe!)

Good ideas all round. Thanks

Steve

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

#20

Just a suggestion to think about.

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

When I was building my big lathe, I had welded up some 1.5" thick steel, but still could feel some vibration from resonance. I ended up pouring if full of concrete with big thick plugs of steel thrown in to boot.

If you were to use the legs for the inside corners of a form screw on from the outside. Screw on the outside of the ends also. After screwing on the back. I would lay it down on its back to make the pour from the front.

You could have it sweep back in the middle, with a thick mix, and could either push in some removable plugs for your step, or have a steel protrusion wherever you wanted it.

Of course tying in some re-bar or mesh wire would make it tougher as well.

A big solid block of concrete tying all four legs together, does a lot to resist the torsional / dynamic forces from out of balance pieces.

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

#21

Steve Kubien

Re: Just a suggestion to think about.

Steve Kubien

Have you got pictures of your lathe Keith?

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

#22

Steve Kubien

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

Steve Kubien

No way I could handle standing that far away from the lathe bed. I will follow this thread because I am thinking of beefing up the stand on my 1624.

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

#23

Mark's idea has merit!

Doug Trembath

Jerry Glaser marketed a device to counterbalance the lathe, much like the idea in the link, at one time, and those who used it liked it a lot. I believe it had a sliding weight? Foggy memory along with a bad case of

CRS. A discussion about it should be in the archives somewhere, but I wasn't able to combine words well enough, it seems.

Doug Trembath

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

#24

Re: Not Mark's idea, but

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

I did rig up an 4x18" post and a 40 lb bag of sand that I bolted to that little outboard bed stub on the JET. Made a huge difference in that 12" swing machine. Looked funky, but I could swing the lathe's limit and the thing would not dance until I got it way over any reasonable turning speed. You do need a rigid connection with the bed. If you've got a sliding headstock and are willing to loose 5" of bed, you're in good shape. Has to be attached as close to the headstock as possible; NFG on the tailstock end.

Perhaps it hasn't caught on because it's not nearly as sexy as a very nice tool chest parked under the lathe

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

#25

Re: Debating a fundamental change around the lathe

Barry Irby

I have a DVR. I made a cabinet for it. The top is a 2" thick "cutting board of oak. Under the right (Ways) there are six drawers on full extension runners. Those have some fairly heavy stuff in the them. Under the headstock is a "column" of sand, something like 350 lbs. The toe kick is only about 2" deep and three inches tall. That space is filled with sand. Above the drawers is a tray under the top and that is filled with sand. The cabinet is about 18" deep front to back, but the lathe is mounted right on the front edge. As I recall, the cabinet has four or five hundred pounds of sand.

The only thing I don't like about the cabinet it the drawer runners. they are full extension runners and it seems they like to collect sawdust. They get a little crunchy. Its easy enough to blow them out with compressed air, but another of those little shop chores.

I think what makes mine pleasant is the fact hat the front is vertical and not flared forward like your legs. Even though the toe kick is not deep, it is OK because the lathe is right at the front and you don't rally need a toe kick.

Perhaps you could build a column under the head stock and fill it with heavy stuff. I have read that something like sand or gravel works better that the same weight of a solid material. The theory is that the material absorbs the vibrations internally.