Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Work holding survey-

Posts

Work holding survey-

#1

Steven Antonucci

Work holding survey-

steven antonucci

How often do you use a faceplate vs a chuck? How many of each do you own?

Are there specific things that you would never use one instead of the other?

Inquiring minds have too much time on their hands...

Steve

Re: Work holding survey-

#2

JL

Re: Work holding survey-

JL

I rarely use a face plate. I have two of them.

I usually use a chuck. I have two of them.

I don't count though - as I do mostly spindle work. For those, I turn between centers. I've got four Sorby Steb centres (live and drive, two different sizes), a live cone center and a four prong drive center. I also have two jam chucks - I guess those qualify as face plates.

Re: Work holding survey-

#3

Chuck Jones - West TN

Re: Work holding survey-

Chuck Jones - West TN

I use a face plate often, not instead of a chuck, but instead of between centers. I'll use a face plate to rough the outside of a large, out of balance blank or for a platter. I have 3-4 face plates and 3 SuperNova2 chucks.

Inquiring minds want to know, and bored people want to answer. I'm bored today because my wife is away at a craft symposium (imagine that!) and I'm mostly baby-sitting all her numerous critters.

Re: Work holding survey-

#4

Re: Work holding survey-

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

I do not use a faceplate very often. Chucks are much faster. I use a faceplate only when size dictates it.

6 chucks -2 lathes

3 faceplates

2 steb drive

2 steb free

Joyner offset drive

Re: Work holding survey-

#5

Leo Cuellar

Re: Work holding survey-

Leo Cuellar

I have a bunch of face plates that I bought with the intention of making quick change disk sanders. Even with a lathe it is difficult to spin enough round tuits though. I'll be re-purposing some of those for new jigs for off center turning.

I have several different chucks of various sizes & jaw configurations for different kinds of work. I have in a pinch used my lathe to turn small steel & UHMW parts for the day job 'cause the boss is too cheap to outfit a proper shop.

I also have a whole slew of live & dead centers, steb, spur, cup, bullnose, collet, etc.

You aren't going to make us choose again are you? Because I still don't have everything that I need, and I'm still learning what works best for what. Slippery slope indeed :D

Re: Work holding survey-

#6

Richard Allen

Re: Work holding survey-

Richard Allen

How many faceplates? >15

How many chucks? >10

I primarily use a chuck. My faceplate usage is currently limited to stave rings. Most all other work holding I do is a chuck or between centers.

Re: Work holding survey-

#7

Re: Work holding survey-

Norm Smith

Hi Steven,

I have about a dozen face plates and use them on all larger hollow forms. I also use them when turning large uneven pieces, etc.

I also have 3 chucks.

Norm

Re: Work holding survey-

#8

Dick Hines

Re: Work holding survey-

Dick Hines

Five chucks and 3 face plates. The chucks are on a rack and I could not tell where the face plates are.

I start everything between centers. That way I can adjust the piece to get it centered just the way I want it. I try to grt the side grain of a piece centered in the bottom of all my bowls.

Re: Work holding survey-

#9

Re: Work holding survey-

Reed Gray

For bowls, unless they are in the 20 inch range, which is almost never, I use a chuck. Drill a recess to mount for turning the bottom and bottom recess, then reverse, core, finish turn, remount core in drilled recess, and continue. I have 4 chucks, half dozen face plates.

When turning between centers, I will use spur drive, or steb centers to start, turn a tenon, and then mount in a chuck.

For hollow forms, I start between centers, and then turn a tenon for mounting in a chuck. I seldom turn them, and have big jaws for larger (8 to 10 inches) pieces.

Just got tired of screws and screw gun, and the chuck mostly never comes off the lathe.

robo hippy

Re: Work holding survey-

#10

Re: Work holding survey-

John Lucas

I have 5 chucks and maybe a 8 or 10 faceplates. I grew up with faceplates and used them exclusively for a long time. Even after I got a chuck I still used the faceplates for anything larger than about 5". Now that I have the Vicmarc chucks and lots of jaws I use them almost exclusively and rarely use a faceplate.

I do use a faceplate on larger work because It is more stable and I can turn a rebate that fits the faceplate for perfect alignment when reversing things.

Re: Work holding survey-

#11

Steven Antonucci

The reason I asked...

steven antonucci

I used to think that all face plates were created equally, but after using some Oneway's a few days back, I am in love with the face plate again! I have some cheap, blue aluminum ones and was amazed at how much more rigid and securely they held the small hat that I turned.

Now, when I turn, I start to evaluate which one gives me more options for the long term. A chuck is great for taking the piece on and off the lathe, but most of what I turn is done in a single session. If I screw in a faceplate, I don't have to worry about recentering.

I like small face plates for hats because I can thin the tops of them around the inner transition without having a lightbulb stuck inside all of that time. (less time, less risk) If I had it in a chuck, I could probably do the same thing, but the slightest loosening of the jaws now moves my 50/1000ths probably 50/1000ths and I cannot get it back to perfect.

I have to say that I normally would use a chuck for bowls and vessels just because I became "chuck dependent" after I first got one. I am working on unlearning that behavior as I start to teach and realize that a lot of people just don't own a chuck!

Steven

Re: Work holding survey-

#12

Re: Work holding survey-

Matt Overton

I will use a chuck most of the time. I use faceplates for larger pieces, or when an odd piece just looks difficult. Most of what I turn is under 10 in. so the chuck works well for me.

Re: Work holding survey-

#13

Re: The reason I asked...

John Lucas

Steve I haven't worked with my faceplates side by side as a comparison. Particularly aluminum vs steel. I do notice a difference in how the faceplates are made. For example I counter sink the wood side holes on all my faceplates. I found that the wood sits flatter when you do this. Of course I also drill more holes. I use a minumun of six holes in all of them. I think this could make a difference in how much vibration you get out of a faceplate. I would think that a heavy cast iron faceplate would probably give less vibration on larger pieces than aluminum but it might be nitpicking. I don't know since I haven't actually tested them side by side.

Re: Work holding survey-

#14

Re: Work holding survey-

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

I have 5 chucks, 5 faceplates and 2 screw centers which count as faceplates I guess.

I usually use a chuck and a tenon, either on the blank or on a glue block. When turning a deep HF that has soft or even punky wood I use a faceplate along with inserted dowels to add the needed strength.

When teaching a beginning class in bowl turning we use a glue block and a faceplate or screwchuck. First, I want the students to know that they can turn bowls without a chuck. If they have a lathe they no doubt have a faceplate. I also want then to know about glue blocks. I do demonstrate the use of a chuck however.

Wally

Re: Work holding survey-

#15

Steven Antonucci

Unscientific to say the least

steven antonucci

My observations were based upon changing my lathe, the size of the wood mounted, the size of the faceplates (marginally), and the manufacturer. I guess what I am saying is that it is an opinion for now that steel face plates are worth the extra few bucks if you use them a lot.

If you don't use them a lot, it may be because of the vibrations. I noticed that my blue faceplates tend to "bend" to flat if they aren't on a perfectly flat surface. If they bend from screw tension, what happens under a rotational load with a suspended mass?

At some point, I will probably dedicate them to small jigs and such. I just need to find a free $100 to buy some Oneways now.

Steven

Re: Work holding survey-

#16

Steven Antonucci

Do you do the glue blocks "live"?

steven antonucci

Or do you have a bunch of blanks with glue blocks prepared? I hate CA glue (ever since I got some in my eye) and I'd be gunshy with a bunch of newbies, since CA isn't very good against shock forces.

Working on a few new ideas for next years class at Peters Valley...

S

Re: Work holding survey-

#17

Re: Do you do the glue blocks "live"?

John Lucas

Steve The last bowl class I taught I used glue blocks and faceplates as well because the school didn't have all the chucks and I also believe in faceplates. I had a CA problem teaching mirrors one time. It was bad CA. Rather than risk that I used 5 minute epoxy. Before I got really into the demo we all made glue blocks and glued them with the epoxy. By the time the demo was done the epoxy was well cured.

Re: Work holding survey-

#18

Re: Do you do the glue blocks "live"?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

Part of learning the use of a glue block is installing it. I do a couple with the class watching as I explain the do's and don't's of installing and using a glue block. When the student installs one I'm looking over his/her shoulder. Properly installed, a glue block joint is stronger than the wood itself. We use med CA. They very seldom have a failure. If one happens we examine the piece to explain why. Part of their leaning experience. Been doing it that way for over 20 years.

Wally

Re: Work holding survey-

#19

Steve Kubien

Re: Work holding survey-

Steve Kubien

2 aluminum faceplates, 1 steel

2 Supernova2 chucks and a Nova midi

I use the faceplates for roughing out any bowl over 8" (I'll use a spur drive if under 8") and roughing all hollowforms unless they are really small (4" tall or less). When blank thickness allows, I will use a faceplate for finish turning as well. Glue blocks have their place and I use them fairly frequently.

Whenever I get another chuck, it will be a big one like a Titan.

Steve

Re: Work holding survey-

#20

Don Pencil

I HAVE LOTS OF THEM

Don Pencil

:b

Use both.

Mostly faceplate.

Re: Work holding survey-

#21

Re: Work holding survey-

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

I have 4 faceplates for the big lathe, and one 4 jaw chuck, which I have never used. But I normally allow for extra wood when roughing out my blanks for screwing into, and then almost always carve feet, rather than a turned foot.

For the smaller PM, I am down to one small 2" plate. I broke the last two 6" ones, before building the big lathe. The middle part with the threads broke out of the plate, so I know I was getting a bit of flex - vibration in the work before they broke out.

On the big lathe, my 2 - 6.5" faceplates are 1" thick, and the 10" are 1.5" thick. I can work off either end CW or CCW. These were bought from MSC, and were stock backer plates that jaw chucks can be mounted on for the machine shop industry. The import ones were pretty reasonable, ~ $70 ea. I am satisfied that they are not flexing, and with 2" threads on an arbor reduced from 3.5" out 4" then, from a 4.5" arbor through the headstock and bearings. I'm not too worried about these breaking out.

Re: Work holding survey-

#22

Re: Work holding survey-

Gil Jones

10- Scroll chucks.

6-face plates� (Don Pencil makes very nice faceplates!!!)

Don't much like scroll chucks on relatively soft wood, otherwise they are fine.

Sometimes start between centers to get the alignment where I want it, but mostly I use a 3" to 3 1/2" Forstner bit to create a flat spot, and glue on a waste block with PVA glue.

I am OK with the longer wait time of PVA for the waste block mostly because CA seems too easy to shear, at least for me (Different strokes). Possibly the CA I use is not strong enough??

Then I generally use a faceplate for large / heavy wood, and a scroll chuck or screw chuck for smaller / lighter wood.

My vacuum chuck system is still in the experimental stages, but my reason for building it is for finishing bases, and I am not so sure it exerts a strong enough hold for heavy / hi-torque work (I could be wrong).

Gil

Re: Work holding survey-

#23

Don Pencil

Re: Unscientific to say the least

Don Pencil

Steve,

What screws are you using to attach the faceplate to the wood?

The "blue" faceplates are 1/2" thick on the flange and the distance from the edge of the hub to the O. D. of the flange is 3/4". I have never been able to find a screw that could apply enough pressure to the faceplate to bend it if the surface of the wood were not even. The wood is much weaker than the aluminum. The fibers of the wood would give up and pull out or break long before the faceplate could possibly bend. The idea that the faceplate would flex as the wood rotates on the lathe spindle makes me wonder what screws one might use to hold the wood and not rip out under the tremendous pressures needed to flex the grade of aluminum in question?

As to vibration.

The molecular structure of aluminum, specifcally 6061 T6511, has a greater resistance to the transfer of vibration that steel or stainless steel. The molecular structure of aluminum dampens the vibration where the steels transfers it to the lathe and beyond. This vibration is hard on the lathe parts such as bearings and contributes to the metal fatigue of other lathe components. Not good.



This is a picture of me turning a 22" dia. x 14" deep green wet maple bowl. The faceplate on the back is a 1.25" x 8 tpi x 3.50" faceplate. It blue and known as a FP14835. The wood attached to the faceplate with 1-5/8" #6 dry wall screws from Home Depot. The wood is a maple crotch and very out of balance. NO FLEX.

In addition, the lathe RPM's are low when a very large piece of out-of-balance wood is being turned. As soon as the bulk of the wood has been removed the balance issues go away and the RPM's can be increased.

Back to the screws. What kind to you use that will hold a piece of wood securely to the lathe, not rip out of the wood, and flex the faceplate? I would like to have such a screw.

Be well,

Don

Re: Work holding survey-

#24

Re: Work holding survey-

Malcolm Tibbetts

For segmented work, faceplates with hardwood waste blocks ( I rarely do other types of work).

Re: Work holding survey-

#25

Don Pencil

Re: Work holding survey-

Don Pencil

Thank you for your kind comment.