I use 1 1/4" concrete (Tapcon) screws
steven antonucci
They have the added benefit of countersinking into the face plates and leaving little piles of aluminum in every hole. If they can drill through concrete, they are going to be harder than the aluminum, no matter what grade it is. I run them in, then back them out, making sure that I haven't pulled the fibers up before redriving them.
If I look at the wood surface, you would imagine that it would leave a mark in the softer wood, but there never is one. I just tried a quick experiment with a piece that had a small ridge from a chainsaw cut, The far side was about 3/32" when I drove the opposite screw in, and I suspect that you are correct- the face plate probably didn't flex (I had some calipers and nothing changed dimensionally), but instead, the tapcon screw pulled so hard that it embedded the head of the opposite screw in even deeper.
Essentially, the screw used that little ridge as a leverage point to pull the high point down and since the low point couldn't move, the aluminum gave way in a game of rock, paper scissor (Steel screw beats aluminum by more than aluminum beats wood). I can post a picture of all of the aluminum shavings if you'd like to see them, but not tonight because I am sleepy.
If I tried this with a steel faceplate, it would snap the head off the screw if it didn't twist off first, since the screw wouldn't drill into the steel plate.
P.S. If you've never tried Tapcon screws, they are simply the best I've ever used. Nothing breaks them, the have a Robertson drive (square), and they are self drilling.
Steve




