Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Tree felling technique *LINK*

Posts

Tree felling technique *LINK*

#1

Steve Kubien

Tree felling technique *LINK*

Steve Kubien

Ok folks, I've never cut down a tree. I do not have one to take down but I was wasting time on youtube and saw this. He calls it the tongue and groove felling technique. I've never heard of it but it looks a lot easier than the regular ways I've seen.

Is this a standard technique or is this guy a nutter?


tree felling

Re: Tree felling technique *LINK*

#2

Re: Tree felling technique

Bill Howatt

Interesting. I've never seen that method before and at first I was wondering what the big deal was to go through the steps. Then I realized that the tenon that results makes the tree fall in the desired direction. I also wondered about sticking the nose of the chainsaw into the trunk (I've never done that) but it is a palm and I imagine that they are relatively soft (????).

AFAIK, the normal way to cut a tree is to make the notch as shown at the beginning and then make a cut behind and slightly above it. The tree should fall in the direction of the notch but sometimes due to the shape, tilt, etc they don't do as expected and the tenon method would help avoid that problem.

I'd say it is legit and after all, he does have his truck in the background.

Bill

Re: Tree felling technique *LINK*

#3

Re: Tree felling technique

Matt Birchfield

I've taken down lots of trees and that looks like an overly complicated way to take that little palm down, but it's a cool process! I helped a guy take down a 50" red oak a few weeks ago using a very similar method. If you need the tree to go against the direction it leans it seems to me that the method on the video would do great... I'm going to try it the next time I'm not near a building!

(The ONLY difference on the big oak was that instead of the wedge the guy used a 20 ton, low-profile hydraulic jack to "push" the tree over, but I think a wedge would have been just as effective -- in this case.)

Re: Tree felling technique *LINK*

#4

Chuck Jones - West TN

I think it would work

Chuck Jones - West TN

But, he could have pushed that little ole palm about anyway he wanted it to fall. I'd not try it in town the first time.

It is similar in some ways to a technique I learned (and use most of the time) from"Sawmill and Woodlot" magazine a few years ago.

I cut the notch as usual, then start a cut from the back about 4"-6" above the notch, cut about 1/4 to 1/2 way through the tree, then plunge cut the center all the way through. This leaves a substantial amount holding on each side. I then cut the remaining side pieces delaying the cut on one side if I want to pull the tree slightly in that direction. The main advantage is twofold; less chance of pulling the fibers in the main heart of the tree, and the ability to influence the direction of the fall. That is particularly good if it looks like the tree doesn't want to cooperate and fall the way I intended.

However, don't get the idea I'm a pro. If I'm in a yard or any close place and have a second person helping, I use my skid steer to make darned sure it falls where I want. :D

Some members of our disaster response team use a different technique. They notch the tree then start cutting from the back about 6" above the notch and cut down at an angle straight to the inside of the notch. I don't see any pro or con to this, except it does make the stump look cool.

Re: Tree felling technique *LINK*

#5

Re: Tree felling technique

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

I don't see anything wrong with it for a palm or other straight grained easy to split wood, but I have cut plenty of trees that have a lot of figure, where the grain winds one way or the other each year. This interlocking grain would try to wedge itself and bind tighter in the tongue and groove.

Then there are some woods like elm that probably would resist this method also.

Re: Tree felling technique *LINK*

#6

Steven Antonucci

First time I have seen this method

steven antonucci

But it looks pretty simple and effective. Now, I just have to remember it if I ever get into that situation. I've only dropped standing dead trees in the woods that were far, far from the house, but probably 50 or so...

Bag of tricks just got a new one.

S

Re: Tree felling technique *LINK*

#7

Re: Tree felling technique

Ralph Lindberg

I've seen this before, but I believe it really only works on smaller trees (yes, that is a smaller tree)

I'd really hate to try this on a 50 inch maple or 60 inch fir

Re: Tree felling technique *LINK*

#8

Re: Tree felling technique *LINK*

Bob Macgregor

That was kinda neat, but I think only really worth the extra steps in a special circumstance.

This got me sucked into YouTube videos on tree felling (another half-hour of my life gone forever!) and thought the stump vise video was a nifty idea...

Of course, if your chain is very dull, it might be frustrating to make the cuts for the stump vise.

BOB


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CoNDVKdQX_A

Re: Tree felling technique *LINK*

#9

Re: Tree felling technique - bad idea

Larry Litwin

It's generally a bad idea to cut with the tip of the bar. Too much chance of kickback and too hard to control in any hardwood. The plunge cut front to back also looks like a good way to get the bar stuck. All it would take is a slight swelling or tipping forward and you are screwed. Wouldn't take that chance with any of my Sthils. Also, the tennon is too small to have much effect on a heavy tree that wants to go in a different direction. A palm is straight with little top mass. Hardwoods have extensive branch systems that can take the center of mass far out from the trunk. Just my 2 cents.

Re: Tree felling technique *LINK*

#10

Steve Kubien

Thanks everyone

Steve Kubien

I appreciate the feedback. As I say, I'm cutting anything down anytime soon but I thought this was interesting. I hadn't thought about the straight-grain nature of the palm tree.

Cheers.

Re: Tree felling technique *LINK*

#11

Re: Thanks everyone

Barry Irby

Steve, I know almost nothing about palm, except that my son brought some back from Florida. Don't know what kind it is or what kind is in the video, but what he has has a layer of tough fibrous outer layer about an inch thick and all of the center or heart is soft, more the consistency of Styrofoam than wood. You can crumble it easily with your fingers. So a plunge cut through the heart of palm would be very easy compared to the stuff that is native around here.

And, I agree about the cutting with the tip of the bar. Very dangerous and not for us amateurs.

Re: Tree felling technique *LINK*

#12

Steven Antonucci

Cutting on the tip of the bar

steven antonucci

I agree that it is certainly not a beginner cut, but what he did is not dangerous if you truly understand how to use a chainsaw. I did the exact same thing last night at my woodturning club (much to the amazement of the club!)

If you watch closely when he starts the cut, the saw is cutting on the lower section of the round tip. This is the key. He makes a small entry cut, then straightens the saw to the plunge cut. That small entry cut traps the bar, and virtually eliminates any chance of it kicking back. The only direction that the bar can move is straight back, and the upper teeth are pulling the bar in while the lower teeth are pushing backwards- a net of 'zero' backwards force.

Lastly, since the saw is horizontal, any kickback would be directed in the same plane as the bar, which is trapped by the tree on either side. I've seen folks do this type of cut on very large trees , and it's very controlled compared to cutting the hinge. They often leave the saw in the stump while the tree falls in the videos I've seen.

Hope that helps.

Steve

Re: Tree felling technique *LINK*

#13

I'd have to disagree with you Larry

Mike Foster

I have taken a course of felling trees that is taught all over the world called the Game of Logging. This is a series of courses that are taught to allow trees to be taken down safely and effectively, with emphasis on safety. The program was started by a Swedish logger, but if you look, I would bet that someone around you will offer the courses. I took it just to learn how to safely manage the patch of forest that we inherited. I took the course with a bunch of loggers.

These folks teach the plunge cut, and really stress that it is actually a safe cut and necessary to be able to take a tree down safely, with control. Their technique closely matches the description by Matt. Heres a link to a some photos showing the technique. Nothing beats a hands on course, though.

http://www.celebratebig.com/pacific-northwest/oakville-game-of-logging-chainsaw-tree-felling-yarding-bucking-course/

Mike

Re: Tree felling technique *LINK*

#14

Rob Wallace

Maybe on a palm, but not on a tree with real wood

Rob Wallace

Steve:

I would heartily suggest that you do NOT use this clip as a source of information on how to learn to fell a standing tree. The "wood" of palms is considered 'anomalous' (essentially a collection of closely-packed, parallel vascular bundles) and does not represent the more normal true wood deposition in "rings" formed from lateral (cambial) growth found in both softwoods and hardwoods. It is very atypical, and does not represent the same kind of behavior one would see in various types of true wood.

As has been already mentioned, there is considerable danger in making a plunge cut using the tip of the bar (sorry Steve, but I don't agree with your your 'zero force' analysis). This type of cut adds considerable unnecessary safety risk to the whole operation. First, the density (and thus mass) of normal wood is considerably higher than one would find in palms, and the grain in most trees can be interlocked (particularly in hardwoods) making the apparent simplicity of finishing the job with a wedge and hammer much less likely to work. Might be OK in palms, but I would not bet on that working as easily in other 'real' woods.

Before you head toward trying the more bizarre methods of dropping standing timber, my suggestion would be that you first master the widely recommended "notch and hinge" method. If you do head into the more bizarre forms of tree felling, I also suggest you buy a second saw to be ready to free the first saw from getting bound in all the special cuts you'll need to make! ;)

Above all, be safe.

Rob

Re: Tree felling technique *LINK*

#15

Re: Maybe on a palm, but not on a tree with real w

Russ Fairfield

I agree with everything that Rob Wallace said, but I will be more blunt so that anyone can understand what I am saying.

The problem with the Internet is that people who don't know any better do stupid things because they see a film clip of something they shouldn't be doing. I am waiting to hear from someone who is foolish enough to use this method on a real tree (large Pine, Fir, Walnut or Oak) with a real chainsaw and lives to tell about it.

Re: Tree felling technique *LINK*

#16

Steve Kubien

Re: Maybe on a palm, but not on a tree with real w

Steve Kubien

No worries Rob. I have no plans to take down any trees. Let's of tree-guys around here to do that so all I have to do is process what I gather. As I said, I found it interesting, having never seen this technique before. A bunch of folks have commented on the nature of palm trees and their structure, which I hadn't thought of. Makes sense that this may not work on most other types of hardwoods.

As for plunge cuts...never made one and do not plan to until I've got someone experienced with me to guide me through it. No way am I going to "learn" this off youtube or read about it or the like. Nope, I want an experienced hand with me. I am very cautious with my chainsaw. I know what I know (limited) and equally important, I knoiw there is LOTS I do not know. The second group is what keeps me making a cut, stopping, thinking, deciding and only then making the next cut. It is not uncommon for me to make a cut, shut off the saw and restart it in 2 minutes after I've thought things through. Not very efficient but no trips to the ER either. I'll take slow and safe any day.

Cheers!

Re: Tree felling technique *LINK*

#17

Steve Kubien

Won't be me.

Steve Kubien

I'll be using my lightsabre before I try this sort of thing. I was just curious.

Re: Tree felling technique *LINK*

#18

Steven Antonucci

Try it

steven antonucci

Stand up a small section of log, and follow the steps. Tell me if you feel anything. :-)

I'm pretty good with a chainsaw, so maybe it's just me?

S

Re: Tree felling technique *LINK*

#20

Re: Try it

John Lucas

I've used a plunge cut quite a bit for cutting smaller blanks out of large logs. It seems very easy to control for me. It's trying to cut and carve with the end where it's easy for it to try and run on you. I start a plunge cut with the saw tilted a little so the bottom of the bar is the first area to contact. As the cut moves in I simply lift the saw up so it plunges straight in.

Re: Tree felling technique *LINK*

#21

The hinge . . .

Doc Green

In the comments above, I don't see anyone emphasizing the importance of the hinge, the part of the trunk that is left uncut. The hinge guides the tree as it falls.

If you screw up and cut the trunk completely through, . . . all bets are off. The tree can then go where it pleases. ~Doc

Re: Tree felling technique *LINK*

#22

Re: The hinge . . .

John Lucas

I have always used the hinge method but have on occasion had a tree twist. The tenon idea seems like it might prevent this but I'll bet the mass of the tree would just snap it off. That's one reason I won't cut a tree on a windy day if there's any danger of it falling where I don't want. Wind and offcenter branches can make a tree do almost unpredicatable things.

Re: Tree felling technique *LINK*

#23

Re: The hinge . . .

bill crommett from Seneca

And even fall over backwards.

Re: Tree felling technique *LINK*

#24

Ditto Mike Foster

George Van Beynen

I also have taken the Game of Logging course here in Wisconsin with Ken Lallemont. I am a FISTA certified logger. The plunge cut is necessary for tree control in many cases. Essential in some deadly situations with heavy leaning forces that produce �Barber Chairs�. It is surprising that people take courses to safely operate a table or band saw so they do not loose a finger but grab a chain saw and head to the woods without any previous training from an experienced operator.

Re: Tree felling technique *LINK*

#25

Steven Antonucci

Or worse- hop off the hinge and not fall at all!

steven antonucci

I had the privelege of learning to fell trees the hard way-with standing dead hemlock that were at a point of serious decay. Looking back at it, I should have known better, but I didn't. Experience is what you get right after you needed it...

I had this one hemlock that was severely decayed, and probably 18" in diameter with a 14" bar on my saw. Nowhere to cut a hinge, as the outer wood could be kicked off of the tree 4" deep. This 30" tree was probably being held up by a 6"x6" center post that I couldn't see through all of the punky outer wood.

Well, I cut it and it twisted off the stump and landed right next to it, but didn't fall. I ended up cutting it 3 more times to get it all on the ground, and each cut was an adventure. If I was going to do it today, I would have cleared off the punky wood, and taken it down properly (wedges, ropes, etc...)

I highly recommend that folks talk to "tree guys" whenever you get a chance and observe what they do. I've learned tons from them, and they are a great resource.